13 ms·
Curt Schilling’s dream died quite quickly at 38 Studios
- imcqueen 14y agopretty crazy to think that Rhode Island could have financed over 3,000 YC seed investments with this one failure.
- Drbble 14y agoSeems more like intentional corruption than failure. Did Curtis have any bona tides or anything to offer besides photo ops with starstruck officials? The failure was in electing or appointing the bureaucrats who spent public funds for personal entertainment.
- mkramlich 14y agoMy bet is a mix of incompetence (on the part of 38 Studios leadership, and government side), plus maybe some under-the-table kickbacks. They could have just started the company the obvious and healthy way, by making a product then selling it, then iterating and scaling up using organic revenue that came from customers. When customers buy your shit, they're voting with your wallet to say, "I want your shit. Take my money", so it solves or derisks the whole "Is there a market for this? Will we burn through this investor cash and ever fail to make payroll?" problem rather neatly. But instead they tried to juice it with investor crash. Which at times is a bit like trying to finish your semester project early by snorting a lot of cocaine so can skip sleeping. It just might work out ok and come to a gentle landing. But all kinds of forces pushing against that happening, and far more risky.
- stephengillie 14y agoWhy was Rhode Island trying "to jump start a video game industry in Rhode Island" by investing in only one company? Why not fund 3000 smaller videogame companies? They could have given $250,000 to 300 videogame companies, or $2.5 million each to 30 companies.
- thedaveoflife 14y agothe sad answer is because 38 studios had a famous CEO
- VonGuard 14y agoMMO's are fucking money sinks. Investors see the insane profits from selling virtual items and figure "No inventory! No warehouses! Yet they're selling product!" and figure they can just throw money at a game until it's profitable. Also, after Schilling started, free-to-play became the model. A genuinely doomed company from day one.
- jmduke 14y agoMMOs aren't money sinks. Look at World of Warcraft, look at Lineage. Bad MMOs are money sinks. Bad anythings are money sinks.
- patio11 14y agoUS-based AAA MMORPGs have development budgets in the $X00 million range, and only end up profitable if they're World of Warcraft or launched before 2004. They take, minimally, three years to launch. The primary customer acquisition method is a nationwide media buy which costs as much as the development costs do, and if you don't totally saturate the retail channel and then sell all your boxes, you lose. By comparison, you can launch a social game for five/six figures in two months, your primary acquisition method will be virality backed up by cross-promotions and FB ads, if it doesn't work you shoot it in the head and do another one, and if it does work you double-down on development and quintuple-down on advertising and then print money hats.
- robryan 14y agoIn app development terms it is akin to having to say hit #1 on the app store and hold it for months to get a decent return. I think Age Of Conan was an interesting case, launched with big publicity and was quiet good. Things outside the introductory areas though weren't fully fleshed out and there were some big bugs. In the first couple of months they lost most of the user base, one you start a decline in an MMO network effects take hold. They have put an extraordinary amount of work into the game since this point, building a great game, and had success with the free to play model. Still though, the biggest impact on where they are now was these first few weeks.
- jakejake 14y agoIt's hard for me to even understand burning through 75 million, but from what I read I guess that's the cost of making a blockbuster game these days.
- frou_dh 14y agoSee the MMO game APB and its Scottish developer Realtime Worlds for another debacle. Mad cash was burned, it just managed to get released, then bombed spectacularly, taking the 300+ employee company with it. http://lukehalliwell.wordpress.com/category/realtime-worlds/ http://lukehalliwell.wordpress.com/category/realtime-worlds/
- jakejake 14y agothat's crazy, it's hard to even understand where all of the cash goes.
- maybird 14y agoThat same day 38 Studios employees were told their health insurance would expire in two days. It's in times like these that you realize the importance of universal health care. (I'm not talking about COBRA.)
- trimbo 14y ago> I'm not talking about COBRA Public service announcement: you can't COBRA on companies that go bankrupt. COBRA allows you to keep your group plan from your former employer. If that plan goes away, since the company goes away, you will be unable to COBRA. May have changed with Obamacare but this is how it was in the past.
- joe_the_user 14y agoNot sure how that takes away from COBRA not being enough...
- rcthompson 14y agoIt doesn't. It's just that original comment implied that COBRA might be of at least some limited help in this case.
- bhb916 14y agoSomeone losing a benefit on short notice does not constitute an argument for tax-payer subsidization of that benefit. There are other options for these people, like individual plans that aren't provided by their employer. If such plans aren't available to these people in the state they live in it's most likely due to the regulatory environment of that state. In the states I'm familiar with (CA, WA, AZ) individual health insurance plans are cheap and readily available. (People with serious, chronic pre-existing conditions are another matter entirely) The people who will be adversely affected by this layoff in this domain will be those who get catastrophically ill, requiring huge hospital bills, who aren't otherwise individually covered and who don't find employment before they get sick. I expect that number to be really, really low. Insuring this entire population against that event seems silly. Ultimately, relying on your employer for these things is a ticking time bomb.
- DamnYuppie 14y agoI find this to be quite sad. I really enjoyed the game and was looking forward to their follow up. I also don't approve of companies keeping employees in the dark when things are going wrong. I understand why they do it, keeping bad news quite is all the rage apparently, but I can't endorse it.
- rsanchez1 14y agoIt's a delusion on the part of everyone involve. Management can't see past the next quarter and hopes beyond hope their company won't collapse. Employees don't see the warning signs and just accept what management is feeding them. Management has bad news but isn't willing to share with employees for fear that the employees will leave, even if that bad news means collapse is imminent and all employees will leave anyway.
- ZenPsycho 14y agoI wonder if this is another example of Gall's Law at work.
- mcav 14y agofor those wondering, Gall's Law is: > "A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked. The inverse proposition also appears to be true: A complex system designed from scratch never works and cannot be made to work. You have to start over, beginning with a working simple system." — Wikipedia
- bluedanieru 14y agoGood. These are the same assholes who allowed me to preorder KoA in Japan on Steam, saying "it will be released internationally a few days after the US release". It still isn't unlocked.
- soapdog 14y agoAs a foreigner, I can't understand why the U.S. has no public free healthcare for all. Its one of the basic rights and one of the first obligations of a government. All governments should provide free and public healthcare and education. Here in Brazil we have a pretty bad government and yet we have those. And if you're seriously injured and it is an emergency, you can go to any private hospital and they are forced by law to treat you and payment is decided later. Sometimes U.S. policies scares me...
- learc83 14y ago>And if you're seriously injured and it is an emergency, you can go to any private hospital and they are forced by law to treat you and payment is decided later. That works exactly the same in the U.S. You can't be denied emergency treatment.
- hasker 14y agoThe same is true of most if not all hospitals in the US to my understanding. They cannot turn away patients in the emergency room for ability to pay. Still, the hospital can try to bill excessive amounts. Also, this does not guarantee the highest level of care to everyone, but neither private insurance nor most nationalized healthcare programs provide this.
- jfb 14y agoWhere was Schilling's principled libertarianism when he went begging for taxpayer cash? /crickets
- rsanchez1 14y agoHe fell for the lie that the government "invests" when it spends taxpayer dollars on projects doomed to fail.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zdgman 14y agoFunny that this degenerated into a discussion about healthcare. I can almost guarantee this will be a business school case study in the very near future. The thing is, companies are still putting out MMOs. Guild Wars 2 - Not out yet but looks to be an awesome followup to Guild Wars. Tera, just released in North America and getting some praise (was previously in South Korea). Star Wars The Old Republic also just released and had a pretty successful launch even though now it is seeing it's user base decline. I would be very interested in seeing how these three titles perform over the next 5 years but it's safe to say that you can still produce an MMO as long as you (a Have actual experience in the game industry (b Have some successful titles under your belt or a publisher willing to bankroll your talented studio. Also, really great followup article that goes over some of the failures: http://kotaku.com/5913492/curt-schillings-big-huge-38-studios-debacle http://kotaku.com/5913492/curt-schillings-big-huge-38-studio...
- mkramlich 14y agoIt sucks that Curt is going to have this failed thing associated with his name now. Because his prior big splash in the game industry is/was with the board wargame Advanced Squad Leader at his company Multi-Man Publishing. They did a stellar job at bringing ASL back to market and back from the dead, especially with the Starter Kit series -- brilliant design, just what ASL needed to bypass the complexity hairball of the full system, which was so intimidating to potential newbies. So perhaps this was a case of a mortal biting off more than he could chew. I also strongly hope that this doesn't somehow indirectly hurt MMP or ASL and they keep on kicking ass.
- ilamont 14y agoOne thing that has amazed me since the story first broke a few weeks ago is how little attention has been paid to the actions of 38 Studio's CEO Jennifer MacLean, the CFO, and board of directors. This was an all-star team (see http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/lamont/2012/05/18/38-studios-board-of-directors/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/lamont/2012/05/18/38-studios-bo... ). The media attention has been on Schilling, but the senior management and board of directors have some responsibility for this debacle as well.