4 ms·
> It seems like AWS' entire business model is making the pricing so confusing that you don't know what it will cost until after you've used it. It feels weirdly
by ryandrake 3y ago
> It seems like AWS' entire business model is making the pricing so confusing that you don't know what it will cost until after you've used it. It feels weirdly similar to the US healthcare/insurance situation.
Not just the healthcare situation, but everything. There's nothing much more stereotypically American than "not knowing what you're going to pay for something until you're billed." Dozens of little fees on your cable or ISP bill, resort fees in hotels, service charges on your restaurant bill, fees on car rentals, fees from your bank when you so much as breathe on your account, and of course sales taxes which for some reason are never listed on the tag in any store.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoPeople complain about this relentlessly, but never change. Additionally, every single business owner I know complains that whatever it is they're selling, (1) it isn't worth the brain damage to sell to customers looking for the lowest price, (2) as long as people comparison shop in a harebrained way, hook pricing (aka up front pricing that looks low and turns out high) is only rational. It's not like they're providing a bad service for the cost.
- pixl97 3y agoI mean this is why a lot of first world countries have consumer protections that demands the retailer/service publishes prices up front. Course in the US there is quite a counter lobbyist group that prevents just that from happening.
- thfuran 3y ago>hook pricing (aka up front pricing that looks low and turns out high) is only rational. Yes, many deceptive business practices are rational acts on the part of the businesses. That doesn't mean they should be tolerated.
- thaumaturgy 3y agoI have begun to think of this as a "large population error", and I'm noticing it in a lot of different markets. At small scales, annoying your customers is bad business. You only need to lose a few before it begins to hurt. Customer complaints are more likely to be a consideration in business decisions. At larger scales, a business can begin to preferentially adopt practices intended to drive away some customers. Perhaps you don't want the "pathological" customers, to borrow one of Patrick McKenzie's terms. You can make more money with less effort by being more selective about your customers. At extremely large scales, you largely stop thinking about groups of customers altogether. All of your decisions are driven by aggregates -- did all sales go up this quarter, or down? The effort required to do a deep dive into the behaviors and preferences of any individual market segment may not make sense anymore on a quarterly basis. At this scale, you might be able to afford to annoy tens of thousands of customers and still have a very nice graph next quarter. So, when someone says a business practice shouldn't be "tolerated", that's a perfectly reasonable position, except it doesn't actually work for businesses operating at extremely large scales. It's too difficult for customers to organize a protest in a way that will influence that business's decision-making. So much business has moved online in the last 20 years, while the US has leveled off at 80% urbanization over the same time period, along with more and more businesses congealing into BigCos, combined with the recent domination of private equity: lots and lots of things are now operating at a scale where customer concerns just aren't a part of the business model anymore. Coffee shops, fast food, big-box retail, online retail, SaaS, PaaS: all of these can thrive while running on exorbitant pricing and abusive customer policies, because their volume of customers is so large that it's nearly impossible to be so bad that you'll piss off enough customers to impact your decision-making. (Unless you're Sony.)
- staunton 3y ago> It's too difficult for customers to organize a protest in a way that will influence that business's decision-making. It's actually very easy (in theory). You (vote for someone who will) ban fraudulent and anti-competitive behavior, sue the offenders and have them pay huge fines. The fact that this very rarely works out is a failure of the political system.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago
- wongarsu 3y agoWhich is exactly why they should be banned to keep the market overall healthy. Preventing deceptive practices in a market economy this is a prime example of useful government "intervention", just like supporting contract enforcement or preventing theft
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey can always justify it as not knowing the price. The sales tax rate is different in different places. It costs a different amount to ship to Florida than Alaska and picking it up at the factory is free (even if nobody does). The advertised price is if you have your own modem, renting one from the cable company is more. None of these are inherently wrong. You should be paying more if you're having it shipped to a remote location with high shipping costs, and the cost of that shouldn't be dumped on every other customer. But it's kind of a loophole if you want the advertised price to be lower than what people are actually going to be paying in practice.
- wongarsu 3y agoThere are some cases where not knowing the price is reasonable. As you say, shipping can often only be calculated if you know all items and their destination. If you advertise on national TV you can't name a price that includes sales price (unless the company eats the difference). But these could be treated as tightly regulated necessary evils, not as a justification that showing final prices is always impossible. There is no reason you can't show final price including tax on the label in a physical shop. There is no reason why a restaurant should be able to charge a 20% service charge instead of increasing regular prices by 20%. If you are buying a concert ticket or airline ticket the displayed price should include all mandatory fees. They can upsell you on additional services, but they can't suddenly notice in the last checkout step that your price is higher because the website you are using is charging a fee; that fee was known to them at the beginning of the transaction and should have to be disclosed at that point in time at the latest. If you want to go even further you can also dictate that shipping and handling fees are only allowed to include reasonable costs of actual shipping and handling. All of these are normal common-sense regulations in most first-world countries.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThis argument reminds me of pre-ordering games. People are simply too dumb to stop doing so, even if it's in their best interest. But those that do are often rewarded for not pre-ordering in the form of lower prices and more content, hen the game eventually goes on sale. It doesn't mean that pre-ordering should be banned, however.
- duxup 3y ago> it isn't worth the brain damage to sell to customers looking for the lowest price The cheapest customers are always the most expensive to work with. It’s a sad reality. I worked at several companies who for some foolish reason saw the cheapo customers as some untapped market and when they raced to the bottom they lost every time.
- antisthenes 3y ago> It's not like they're providing a bad service for the cost. When it comes to healthcare, they absolutely are. The US spends more than double for the same outcomes as other developed countries. And no, this isn't because of the cost to develop new and novel drugs (which aren't used in 99.9% of routine health care)
- jonahhorowitz 3y agoCalifornia gets a lot of flack for having too much regulation, but this change is very welcome for consumers. No more junk fees in CA. - https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/sf-restaurants-junk-fees-law-19436419.php https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/sf-restaurants-junk-fees...
- autoexecbat 3y agoIs this just restaurants?
- justinc8687 3y agoNo, it’s everything. Restaurants somehow thought they’d be exempt and the article is referencing recent explicit guidance that they will not be.
- theoldlove 3y agoToo bad DoorDash is exempt
- krisoft 3y ago> People complain about this relentlessly, but never change What do you mean by this? How would “people change” to get out of resort fees or confusing pricing systems?
- joshstrange 3y agoI believe they are saying that people fall for the hook pricing and won't go with an alternative that is upfront about their price (because it looks higher). If companies aren't rewarded for doing the "right" thing then why would they do it?
- vanviegen 3y agoVote for politicians that haven't been bought by big corp (yet).
- jimjimjim 3y ago"people" as a group need to stop shopping solely on price. Btw, You may look at other factors but as a general rule "people" look at price.
- tpm 3y agoBan them. Here in the EU such behavior is mostly illegal.
- s1artibartfast 3y agopeople could stop buying from sellers with confusing pricing systems. People are capable of change.
- diob 3y agoThis is why other countries just have laws for this, it evens the playing field and removes the bs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alex_lav 3y agoHiding blatant fraud behind the label of “convenience”. Every industry. Pay for Amazon prime to get 2 day shipping “for free”. Item arrives in six days. Prime does not get refunded. Pay +10% for “priority” rides in Lyft, supposed to arrive in 1-5 minutes, whereas “regular” is 7-15. Car shows up in 18 minutes. Priority payment does not get refunded. Honestly what’s even the point in caring anymore. Living in America is about getting grifted until you can hopefully figure out your own grift. The irony of posting this thought on this website is intentional.
- lapphi 3y agoYes. Frank reynolds in the popular television show it’s always sunny in Philadelphia lays it out in plain terms on one of the episodes. “In America you’re either the duper or the dupee”. PT Barnum also knew this essential truth about our nation.
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoLess advanced economies have discovered this pricing innovation, but are generally not able to scale it beyond hostess bar scams and the like :)
- wongarsu 3y agoWhich is especially weird for the country that fought the cold war to show the supremacy of capitalism; a system that is based on market actors knowing the price and value of every product and service offered and making rational purchase decisions based on that.
- heavyset_go 3y agoCapitalism can't work without information asymmetry when it comes to pricing.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoMaybe that's why credit cards are so extremely popular in the US? I suppose if you never know how much you're going to pay for anything, it helps to have a buffer between the vendor and your bank account, allowing you to review the charges after the fact, and should you dispute some, be on a somewhat even playing field with the vendor.
- silverquiet 3y agoI have to say that my response to "not knowing what you're going to pay for something until you're billed" is basically, "well I guess we'll see if I can pay it then". You sort of start asking yourself, "what if I just don't pay?". I have a (deadbeat) buddy who's entire medical plan is essentially to give a fake name to the ER, and if you're poor in America, what else can you do?
- pjlegato 3y ago> give a fake name to the ER, and if you're poor in America, what else can you do? The American government spends something approaching a trillion dollars annually on Medicaid, "a government program that provides health insurance for adults and children with limited income and resources."[1] Seperately, Obamacare[2] created a private health insurance market where low income people can obtain free or heavily discounted private health insurance coverage, according to their income. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicaid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicaid [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordable_Care_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordable_Care_Act
- notaustinpowers 3y agoObamacare is (largely) a failure due to insurance meddling and laws preventing government insurance programs from negotiating prices with drug companies. I'm a healthy individual, not even 30 yet, never smoked, never broken a bone, and never even had stitches in my life. And when I last checked their prices, I was making only $45k/yr. For coverage with Obamacare, I would be paying $350/month for the "catastrophic" plan. Which includes no prescription copay, no dental, no vision, and only kicks in after I've spent $100,000 in one year, and it takes 6 months to take effect after signing up. It's only there for serious issues like losing a leg or cancer.
- dangrossman 3y agoObamacare is not a plan, it's a law that set minimum standards for health insurance plans, created marketplaces to cross-shop plans across providers on a single website, and created a system where you can receive government subsidies towards their cost if your income is low enough. At $45K, you would receive subsidies towards your insurance premiums. I've bought my insurance on the ACA marketplace since it opened ten years ago. There's no difference I can see between the plans offered on the health insurance marketplace and those offered directly from the websites of the same insurers that offer coverage in my state (Blue Cross, CVS Aetna, United, Ambetter, etc). The very highest deductible "catastrophic" plan offered on the marketplace in California for a 29 year old has a $9450/year deductible, which is also the maximum out-of-pocket expense for the year if you have this plan. A $100K deductible plan does not exist, and when you enroll during the annual enrollment period or after a qualifying life event, plans take effect the day you make your first payment, not months later. I'm 10 years your senior and pay less than $350 per month with a lower deductible than the plan quoted above, with no government subsidies.
- godelski 3y agoDon't get me started on dark patterns! I think the fact that we create them should be something we discuss. But I think we need to up our game in this cat and mouse game a bit. For example, in aggregators -- like Expedia or Google Flights, etc -- why not try to capture some of these fees in the price? I can search for hotels with parking but what about sorting hotels by price and including the parking price? It's hard to compare when I see a $120 hotel that has a $50 valet vs a $150 hotel that includes parking. But that's the thing I'm actually after a lot of times. Or similar with flights and baggage fees. We should be able to collect a lot of this type of information and properly present it to the users and try to make these types of dark patterns ineffective (still will be cat and mouse and this is only a specific type of pattern, but still, I think there are things we can do)
- mikepurvis 3y agoProbably an opportunity there to gather and expose that data, same as how flight aggregators like orbitz twenty years ago started showing prices inclusive of taxes and fees.
- jameshart 3y agoThen pay for it with a credit card that gives you a random amount of cash back, and pay your credit card bill using your tax refund that came as a nice surprise at the end of the year, because you over withheld all year so you don’t actually even know what your real take home pay is supposed to be. No wonder Americans have no idea how the economy is doing.
- TechDebtDevin 3y agoI'm always surprised by people who expect and are excited for their refund. Half the country is pitching about politicians taxation plans when all the while they're volunteering to overpay out of every paycheck.
- jkingsman 3y agoWhen you lack the self-control to save, over-withholding + refund becomes an ersatz year-long savings account. It's terrible, lacking any interest at all, but when it's all you've got, breaking open the piggy bank to get your money back feels good even if it doesn't make financial sense.
- tatpacc 3y ago> people who expect and are excited for their refund. and then pay % of your refund as a fee to CPA, so they help you maximize your refund.
- gadflyinyoureye 3y agoI know how many guns I have. I know the Feds have more. Therefore give them their pound of flesh before they show up with the myriad of guns.
- _factor 3y agoEven paying cash. Unless the establishment offers a cash discount, you’re paying inflated credit card induced compensatory pricing. It’s a real shame banks received 2-5% of most transaction for what costs them pennies. Sure, there are benefits, but their ask isn’t covering it.
- 127 3y agoIt's strange from a foreigners perspective because all of this looks exactly like a dark pattern made to distract and confuse gambling addicts. Why does American government allow direct predation on its own citizens?
- bee_rider 3y agoDid they manage to get AWS to provide some mechanism to get an up-front price in your country? That’s pretty neat if so. I think lots of people go along with these as-you-go services because they’d rather deal with an unexpected bill, than having their servers shut off.
- datavirtue 3y agoDont forget the runaway interest that accumulates on the credit you used to pay for it. It really never ends. The IRS even has a few pitfalls that allow you to pay taxes you don't really owe, that can't be refunded.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]