7 ms·
Today, I started picking up what I started some time back -- the book “Debt: The First 5,000 Years” by David Graeber goes deep into the details of Debt. I've he
by Brajeshwar 3y ago
Today, I started picking up what I started some time back -- the book “Debt: The First 5,000 Years” by David Graeber goes deep into the details of Debt. I've heard good reviews and I hope this is a good book as they say.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt:_The_First_5000_Years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt:_The_First_5000_Years
- arj 3y agoIt is
- throw0101d 3y ago> the book “Debt: The First 5,000 Years” by David Graeber Also would recommend Money: The True Story of a Made-Up Thing: > Money only works because we all agree to believe in it. In Money, Jacob Goldstein shows how money is a useful fiction that has shaped societies for thousands of years, from the rise of coins in ancient Greece to the first stock market in Amsterdam to the emergence of shadow banking in the 21st century. > At the heart of the story are the fringe thinkers and world leaders who reimagined money. Kublai Khan, the Mongol emperor, created paper money backed by nothing, centuries before it appeared in the west. John Law, a professional gambler and convicted murderer, brought modern money to France (and destroyed the country's economy). The cypherpunks, a group of radical libertarian computer programmers, paved the way for bitcoin. * https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/50358103 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/50358103 And The power of gold : the history of an obsession (and Bernstein's other books): > Incorporating myth, history and contemporary investigation, Bernstein tells the story of how human beings have become intoxicated, obsessed, enriched, impoverished, humbled and proud for the sake of gold. From the past to the future, Bernstein's portrayal of gold is intimately linked to the character of humankind. * https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/249245 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/249245
- belval 3y ago> Money only works because we all agree to believe in it. Respectfully, this is the type of true-that-sounds-deep statements that are absolutely shallow and pointless. Yes money the "paper" is not worth anything, but the same could be said of anything in an organized society. Ownership means nothing, it's just a title backed by the government which has a monopoly on violence. Ethics means nothing, it's just something we culturally decided was desirable because if you feel a-ok with murder any trip anywhere would turn into a blood bath. At this point it should be a named fallacy (maybe it is), if we are discussing the merits of debt as a tool, saying "money isn't worth anything" as if it means something is not some ground breaking statement.
- throw0101d 3y ago> Respectfully, this is the type of true-that-sounds-deep statements that are absolutely shallow and pointless. And yet people still insist on the idea that money (or, quite commonly, gold) does have some kind of intrinsic value. The statement may be trope-y, but it's a psychological hurdle that many folks can't seem to get their head around.
- shoo 3y agoGraeber's book is about how debts work in different societies and cultures and what they mean. i finished the book being more confused about debt and money than when i started. that said, it was an interesting read, i don't regret reading it. in contrast, this brief blog post by Morgan Housel gives a small visual metophor and a rule of thumb about how too much debt might be fatal when operating a business. arguably it teaches you something actionable, but doesn't tell you anything about your society. Graeber's book is not at all concerned with giving you actionable advice on how to best use (or avoid) debt to run a business within your society. that said, Graeber's book may give you some actionable advice on how to get along better with your neighbours, family and community. the tip would be: try to have everyone in the village owe each other debts. the idea is everyone should feel they have some obligation to others that they can never fully repay, but maybe they can return some other incomparable favour or assistance in future. this encourages cooperation. trying to fully repay or balance these debts would be frowned upon -- such behaviour is what one might do if one were seeking to not participate in society any more. not pro-social.
- cies 3y agoRIP Graeber.
- lurking15 3y agoI feel like Graeber's book is another (left leaning) fad to glom on to, like Piketty's book some years back. I found this book, The Price of Time by Edward Chancellor [1], very useful for understanding the development of money and debt over history. It's so detailed and clearly extensively researched. [1]: https://www.harvard.com/book/the_price_of_time/ https://www.harvard.com/book/the_price_of_time/
- imtringued 3y agoIn a general equilibrium economy with no innovation or all innovation potential being exhausted, money demand and interest disappear. "Interest" isn't the price of time, it is the price of liquidity. For some reason economists seem to gloss over that money doesn't abstract over just time. It abstracts over everything including location, trade partner, the specific commodity being traded and minimum quantities. Since people involuntarily produce liquidity by bringing their goods to the market, people owning the rights to that liquidity (aka capitalists) can "reap where they haven't sown". This leads to a paradoxical situation. Liquidity production is work like any other. In short, liquidity production demands to be compensated. Since the holders of liquidity can utilize the benefits of the liquidity services without paying they can either decide to use the liquidity benefits themselves or they can decide to monetize them by selling liquidity on the capital markets. The compensation for this liquidity service is known as risk free interest. As I mentioned, liquidity demands to be compensated, but since the producer of liquidity does not get paid, they will eventually wisen up and cease producing liquidity in the national transaction network. This leads to production capacity in the economy being dismantled since it represents a commitment in time-commodity-quantity-person-space. Instead, future producers of liquidity await the holders of liquidity to effectively signal their demand so that they know to what production process they should commit to. Since information acquisition is costly, it is perceived to be cheaper to avoid committing oneself or in more direct terms: interest measures the reluctance to lose control over ones capital.
- venv 3y agoPiketty's book (Capital in the Twenty-First Century) is most definitely not a fad. It is a result of serious research into historical economic data and anyone intellectually honest ought take it seriously. As anything in the social science of economics, it is subject to debate, but to call it a 'fad' is odd, to put it mildly.
- mempko 3y agoThis is a life changing book. It demystifies the biggest part of our lives, which is money (and debt) and helps you contextualize your world by looking into the past. It's the best researched book on the subject.