3 ms·
A new problem I'm facing on the hiring end is an influx of imposters from Asia. Everything they claim is a lie, from their name, citizenship, location, picture,
by esafak 3y ago
A new problem I'm facing on the hiring end is an influx of imposters from Asia. Everything they claim is a lie, from their name, citizenship, location, picture, to their job history. They even set up fake company sites. And of course they use LLMs to help them pass the interview. I assume it's so they can bilk gullible companies and perhaps do some corporate espionage. I don't know. I haven't encountered anyone try to deepfake their voice and appearance but I assume it's a question of time.
Telltale signs: stilted English, poor internet connection, lack of LinkedIn connections, and an inability to drill down on their fake histories. One claimed to have contributed to an open source BI project while working at Facebook, so I pulled up its GitHub repo and said "Let's see your code". "It's on Gitlab!" he protested. No, it's not; I'm staring at it on GitHub. Another claimed to have worked as a front-end engineer at Netflix. Great, I have friends there. Which team? "The front-end team". I understood that you were a front-end engineer, but which team? Again: "The front-end team!"
In that instant I recalled the scene in Coming to America where Eddie Murphy's character is asked about his education and he confidently replies that he's attended "The University of the United States".
https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/4378beae-fdfb-4e6b-a7a9-667f365613bc https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/4378beae-fdfb-4e6b-a7a9-667f365...
- surfingdino 3y agoLast year I was reviewing about a dozen answers to the questions we were sending candidates to complete at home. In all cases those a*holes used ChatGPT to write answers and what did ChatGPT use? Original Python docs recombined with blog posts. I was able to verify this by copying passages from their answers and pasting them into Google. When I showed this to the hiring manager they had a serious conversation with the agency. It would have been hilarious if I did not know that some of the candidate were real people with good experience but too lazy to write simple code.
- esafak 3y agoYou can't assign homework any more. I was never into them anyway. One clumsy candidate accidentally revealed his cards by pasting the prompt he'd used in our chat window, like that paper whose introduction began "Certainly, here is a possible introduction to your topic." https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/1beaqya/obvious_chatgpt_prompt_reply_in_published_paper/ https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/1beaqya/obvious_chat... Another was unable to explain why his code was structured the way it was. I asked a multipart question that required refactoring, knowing that these tools are not good at that, or enforcing a consistent style. His initial code was a self-contained class and the refactor introduced a function outside of the class that also should have been a method. I asked him why he did that and, of course, he froze.
- lithos 3y agoAI code also alternates between technical levels IE: you'll see a part that looks like it was trained on beginner tutorials followed by another part that's looks trained on ripped open source projects. Sometimes just really silly things like 3D vector math written in a form that would easily support higher dimensions for whatever reason.
- knallfrosch 3y agoDid you tell them that AI was not allowed?
- surfingdino 3y agoWe did not, but using AI to generate or reformat answers is a big red flag to me, because it shows that a) you do not have the experience you claim to have, and b) you do not have written communication skills or knowledge of English required to do your job.
- rnewme 3y agoPeople you're calling assholes - did they get paid for the take home task? We're they instructed not to use llms? Have you confirmed they used them and didn't Google the same things you googled? Was the homework not correct?
- surfingdino 3y agoThey were not paid, but we spared them the stress of a timed online coding exercise which a lot of devs hate. We told them we expect short snippets of code to illustrate the answers to six questions which progressed from the obvious (if you code in the language for a few years) to more of "there are many was to do it, here is mine" to judge their ability to turn requirements into code. You could do the whole thing in half an hour. It was fair.
- Clubber 3y agoWe're really struggling to find good people. We do it the old fashioned way, just a one hour 4 dev interview. We don't ask really tough questions or anything. An example is, "can you describe normalization and what it's for?" I think the market is just supersaturated with bads right now and all the bads are the ones applying. The good developers we have we got from knowing them in previous jobs, etc. You might wanna hit up your current team to find better devs. You should probably pay your team a finder's fee if you hire from that. Also, if you are paying what you paid before covid, it's probably too low today. Times are tough for building good teams right now. You need to adapt. The same ole "call a recruiter and get 1 good guy out of 10," isn't a thing anymore. You might wanna pay 10-20% over market and see if that works. To justify that, just calculate what you are paying to not find good people now.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I think the market is just supersaturated with bads right now and all the bads are the ones applying. This is what it looks like where I work, too. There's been a huge decline in the quality of applicants over the past few years. I think the percentage of applicants that could be called "competent" has fallen to below 20%.
- nradov 3y agoI predict that high profile employers will soon start forcing job applicants to go through an identity verification service like Clear before allowing them to even fill out an application form. https://www.clearme.com/clear-verified https://www.clearme.com/clear-verified
- TeaBrain 3y agoA former co-worker mentioned to me that his dad runs a side business where he creates fake work and education histories for people coming to the US from his home country on work visas. He said that it works because employers never bother to verify work or education histories from said home country.
- red-iron-pine 3y agohow long you been doing hiring mon ami? that's been a thing since long before AI, the difference is that instead of getting slammed via Craigslist, now AI can handle Taleo
- esafak 3y agoNot long at my own company, but I never encountered such brazen impostors while working at other people's companies, either. I guess they were filtered out by recruiters before they reached me. Now it's something I'm developing a nose for.