4 ms·
Google Fit dev APIs shutdown set, fate of Android, Wear OS apps go unannounced
- lionkor 3y agoFree things are only free until they become 1. discontinued 2. commercialized (paid), or 3. broken with nobody to fix it IMO the only free services and free software (free as in free beer) you can rely on is software that is open source or source available (in its entirety). Lets disregard the "youre the product" (and the fact that the hardware wasnt free) for a second and focus on the fact that all these dead services have one thing in common: They shut down because theyre centralized, or because their development is centralized. If an open source project (where all parts are open source) is developed by a paid dev team, and they abandon the project and kill the dev team, the code remains and people can continue to use it if they wish to maintain it also. I'm no stallman, and I dont generally care for idealistic arguments, but this may be one of those rare times when the "FOSS is better" crowd has a really good point. Even if its source available, or a non-commercial license, thats still more pro-consumer than whatever google fit et al did.
- zarzavat 3y agoGoogle has several completely free services. I won’t name them because I’m superstitious that they will get shut down after I write this comment. Google doesn’t shut down services because they are free. It shuts down services because they are unpopular at trillion dollar corporation scale. Stadia was paid and it got shut down too. Unfortunately, this leads to the second-order effect of people not using new Google services because they are afraid it will get shut down.
- globular-toast 3y agoIt's easy for things to get forgotten about at big companies. But sooner or later someone looking for a promotion will discover it, shut it down and put the saved money part on their CV.
- mococa 3y agoThey are not free, you are the product. There is no free lunch.
- beretguy 3y ago> They shut down because theyre centralized Let’s add computer games to the list while we are at it, please https://www.stopkillinggames.com/ https://www.stopkillinggames.com/
- CoconutPilot 3y agoFree is only Free when it is disconnected.
- frankacter 3y agoThis is a bit sensationalistic of a headline as Google had already previously paved the path to transition from Google Fit to the Health Connect platform, the centralized hub for all health data. It's more secure and allows a wider more diverse suite of apps to integrate into it. From the article: >While we’ve deprecated the Google Fit Android API, we’re aiming to turn down the API no sooner than June 30, 2025. This is to give users enough time to switch to Health Connect and continue their service. Specifically they indicate, as they have in the past, that developers should transition from the Google Fit API to the Health Connect API. The Google Fit app already uses the Health Connect API itself to upload health data to a centralized repository. The article also mentions no "big updates" since 2022, while I can't gauge what they're qualifying as "big", there have been 20+ app updates since that time frame and there is a major beta release ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.healthdata&hl=en&gl=US&pli=1 https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and... ) that has been in public testing for some time now.
- anty 3y ago> It's more secure and allows a wider more diverse suite of apps to integrate into it. It's more secure, yes. But since the data stays on the device now, web apps cannot read or write health data anymore. You need to develop a dedicated app to access the data on the device. And the user has to interact with the app, or the data will not be accessible. E.g. my Withings scale writes my body weight to Google Health Connect. But I need to open the Withings app every time for that to work. The app-developers cannot do this in the background afaik. (The data flow is: scale -> cloud -> app -> Google Health Connect.) Another issue I see is: There is no incentive for app developers to write data to Google Health Connect. Even if you subscribe to the idea of using it as your data-store, you will lose access to the data if a user uninstalls your app. It's only possible to read data up to 30 days in the past, or however long the user has installed your app – hopefully they don't decide to reinstall it. I really appreciate the inter-connectivity Google Health Connect allows between apps, though.
- greatgib 3y agoI don't know how you kind of appreciate that all your health data is uploaded to some random cloud server...
- f055 3y agoGoogle Fit is being replaced by Goolge Fitbit, but as usual with Google what is really happening is Google is one by one replacing the sections of the original Fitbit app with the Google Fit interface. The first thing that got replaced is the Fitbit Sleep tracking, and believe me when I say what Google did is an abomination in terms of UI/UX design. The previous Fitbit sleep tracking screen was near perfection of readability and clarity. The new one is Google's usual form-over-function design language where the most important metric (weekly-view sleep score) is hidden and requires many taps to access.
- nineteen999 3y agoHonestly the Fitbit UI has always been terrible, so they are only making it worse than terrible.
- interloxia 3y agoImho the app was pretty fancy early on. The sleep stages/timeline graph now looks more like a scatter plot than a progression of sleep states. Example screenshots https://www.techradar.com/health-fitness/fitbits-redesigned-its-sleep-page-to-make-it-more-useful-heres-whats-changing https://www.techradar.com/health-fitness/fitbits-redesigned-...
- espinielli 3y agoAnother example of Google inability in anything but Search (and even there I find it lower and lower in quality these days.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eska 3y agoAnd another one https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/ Regular reminder that you’re asking for it.
- jgerrish 3y agoI'm worried things like this will incentivize startups to take risks with that 30-day retention period. Startups were a way out for me. I may have the strength, but that's not necessarily a good thing with long-term health choices.