6 ms·
CO2 removal 'gap' shows countries 'lack progress' for 1.5C warming limit
- freddealmeida 3y ago[flagged]
- bluescrn 3y agoClimate change seems very real. The proposed solutions, on the other hand...
- i80and 3y agoThis comment feels like a mantra more to reassure yourself than to convince anybody. I don't want to be discourteous, but I don't see what kind of productive discussion that can happen as a result of it at this point in 2024?
- darby_eight 3y agoI realize carbon capture may be some part of reducing total carbon in the atmosphere, but it's disproportionately brought up as a potentially effective one. It stinks to high heaven of chasing public "investment" rather than actually holding industries accountable for actually reducing emissions.
- renewiltord 3y agoPeople when carbon capture: This stinks of redirecting tax money. Hold accountable. People when carbon tax: You made inflation high. Get out! The ideal voter gets to ask for things he'll never get but complain about them if he does get them. That way he can act free of sin and simultaneously vote out people who give him that. There's always some other pretext. "I'm not voting him out for his carbon tax. I'm voting him out because X". Because the space of actions a political leader must do is large enough that nothing is perfect, the voter can always claim he is optimizing to some good. In the West, people get what they vote for and my experience is that they're quite representative of peoples' views.
- klabb3 3y ago> People when carbon capture: This stinks of redirecting tax money. Hold accountable. > People when carbon tax: You made inflation high. Get out! This is quite a funny observation. And true. The general psychological bias is when immediate known losses are standing against unknown future gains. Also Americans in particular are allergic to the term tax. A carbon tax would be the most hands-off way to solve the problem. Ideally phased in slowly and with a clear price structure from the get-go. All you need is: - industry needs to know how much they will be taxed in X years, so the bean counters can put it in their projections so execs listen - the tax needs to be tight enough so you can’t escape through tax “planning” aka move operations to unregulated countries The rest takes care of itself. Once there’s a tangible measurable cost things will change quickly from green leaf-decorated “we care”-pamphlets to fire in the ass of the decision makers.
- partiallypro 3y agoI generally agree with you, but in terms of CO2 output the West is not really the problem anymore. It's developing countries, and the general argument they have is that "why should we have to suffer with slower economic output when you didn't?"
- adrianN 3y ago"The West" is absolutely still the problem. No country is on a path that is compatible with 2° warming.
- wakawaka28 3y agoNo country in the world is on a path compatible with the supposed 2 degree goal, and it's not mainly a problem of the West. I think the whole climate freakout is a scam in the first place. In any case, the West should not cripple itself as other countries continue business as usual. We can't survive like that, and it won't be the climate that gets us either.
- renewiltord 3y agoYeah, but that's not going to work because we used carbon to fuel growth and then decarbonized. Everyone else saw that China did the same thing to raise half a billion out of poverty. Everyone remaining saw that India raised more than that out of poverty burning carbon. It's not like we're going to give developing countries nuclear power so their choice is coal, natural gas, wind, and solar. And inevitably they follow that specific chain of energy build-out as their growing economy starts cleaning up. No one has demonstrated a high-scale success that is not that.
- janice1999 3y agoPretty much the same way that plastic recycling turned out to be huge scam.
- mywittyname 3y agoScientist knew plastic recycling was impossible. But marketing companies working for plastics producers came up with the idea of lying to the public about it to stave off a ban they were looking at. Today, it's basically impossible to convince people that plastics are not recyclable - at least not in the same way that glass or metals are - because of that little recyclable symbol ever piece of plastic has on it.
- scotty79 3y agoPlastics can be beneficial for global warming. They need less energy for making them and for transporting them than the alternatives. And they sequester CO2 when they are landfilled at the end of their useful life. We should be pushing them back underground through the same holes we used to dig up the carbon.
- nerdponx 3y agoHow do they sequester CO2?
- scotty79 3y agoThey consist of mostly carbon. If you don't burn them, that carbon doesn't end up in the atmosphere.
- legitster 3y agoAnd honestly, the a lot of the problems with plastics are actually a very specific and fixable problem. 90% of the plastics in the Pacific Ocean come from 2 rivers.
- janice1999 3y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWe have built our society on a lot of incentives that are bad for the planet unfortunately so we now have some conflicting requirements for tackling climate change. 1. Cut back on emissions 2. Nobody anywhere is allowed to lose money How can this possibly work? How do you cut emissions which are a proxy for consumption/production without anybody losing out?
- vkou 3y agoWe can't, we won't, and we'll regret it.
- kranke155 3y agoIt's as if human civilization is reaching adulthood, late 20s early 30s, where the errors of being young and foolish start catching up to you.
- vkou 3y agoThose errors don't really catch up to you until your late 40s, when your health is shot, your bank account is empty, and you don't really have enough time left to dig your way out of the hole you're in. That's about the stage we're at.
- kranke155 3y agoI certainly hope not!
- bumby 3y agoI maybe be misremembering, but I think one of Carl Sagan’s characters in the book Contact was asked what she would want to ask extra terrestrials if given the opportunity. Her answer was along the lines of “how did you manage to survive this technological adolescence we are currently experiencing?”
- Workaccount2 3y agoEfficiency, which is what we have been (sort of) doing and why things are moving so slowly. For instance, efficiency is what has made solar panels both effective enough to use, and cheap enough to install.
- causal 3y agoLikewise Robin Wall Kimmerer talks about how sustainability hype in general is oriented toward sustaining consumer lifestyles, which will never really be compatible with living in a closed ecosystem.
- scotty79 3y agoWe can capture carbon before emitting it. For example if we can use carbon to make plastic that saves us energy (especially in areas where energy doesn't come from renewables) then it's a huge benefit. Especially if we don't burn the plastic afterwards, just put it under ground instead.
- adrianN 3y agoWe can either leave the oil in the ground, or turn it into long lived products. But we can't economically suck carbon from the air and turn it into long lived products, but that's exactly what we need to do to prevent catastrophic warming. We have already emitted too much carbon dioxide.
- marcosdumay 3y agoNot only it's a small part of the effort, it's also only really effective after we stop generating that huge amount of CO2, and almost all the initiatives around are snake-oil that can't grow enough to make an impact. Some accountability would go a long way here. Most of the stuff around carbon capture are plainly fraudulent.
- vvvvvvvvvvvvv 3y agoI agree with this in principle, but only insofar as it applies to western countries. Emissions from the developing world will continue to increase (rightfully so, given we had such massive head start) and they will have little incentive to curtail emissions, even when climate-related disasters become more frequent. The only unilateral solution seems to be a technological one, therefore necessitating carbon capture.
- marcosdumay 3y agoJust like late-development countries didn't avoid getting celphones and investing in mobile internet before they could put their wired internet in place, developing countries will stop their emissions on about the same time as developed ones. Nobody is making any bit of extra work towards cleaning the planet. And that's a really big shame for the developed countries.
- hackerlight 3y ago> The only unilateral solution seems to be a technological one Or a political one. Developed countries provide them a small financial incentive to build out renewables instead. Some kind of UN fund. It doesn't have to be a large incentive, it just needs to tip the financial decision over at the margin. The economic logic: it's a retroactive carbon tax, of sorts, given the extreme inequality in emissions per-capita since the industrial revolution. It's also a pragmatic solution, because it's cheaper to prevent the emissions than extract it after they've been released.
- darby_eight 3y agoThere's a simpler solution: rich (read "developed") nations can simply pay poor countries to not use coal or other carbon-emitting processes.
- LargeWu 3y agoThe only argument for investing in carbon capture today seems to be to allow the technology to mature. We'd probably be saying similar things about the effectiveness of solar panels if we started developing that technology now. The idea is that maybe, and that's a big maybe, by the time we get to a point where all of our power generation is low emissions, we will have matured carbon capture tech enough to make it viable.
- 11101010001100 3y agoGood thing we invested in solar when did then because if CC has any chance of success, then it will heavily depend on solar.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoThe difference is that thermodynamic analysis of solar panels, even before building them or improving them, tells us that it is a winning bet. We can't say the same for carbon capture. It's a thermodynamically losing bet. The humongous amount of entropy we will have to generate to offset any significant part of current emissions via carbon capture (let alone already emitted CO2) basically tells us that carbon capture can only be used in exceptional circumstances where there are no feasible methods of reducing emissions. If there are, then the winning method is to not emit in the first place.
- rasz 3y ago>allow the technology to mature just like recycling plastics matured, right? :)
- xethos 3y ago> only argument for investing in carbon capture today seems to be to allow the technology to mature > CDR currently removes about 3bn tonnes of CO2 from the air every year, of which almost 100% comes from land-based methods, *such as afforestation and reforestation*, the study says. Trees have pretty well matured. They will not get the same improvements through material science that solar got. "Letting carbon capture tech mature" is hoping for a moonshot to bear fruit.
- r00fus 3y ago"Carbon capture" == "clean coal". Different decade, same scam.
- scratcheee 3y agoOne potential value of CC today is as a final and most flexible solution. Even with the limited and experimental technology of today, which is obviously economically insane, we have a way (with enough money) to make anything carbon neutral. The value is not that we actually do that (humanity cannot afford it, in general), but instead to give us the number to beat, the correct carbon tax, the absolute cost of failing to decarbonise. It’s easier to justify improved efficiency when the cost of spilling carbon is a big number of dollars rather than a tiny slither of a global problem. That said, I do agree investment should be limited, it’s obviously only going to be the “best” solution in the rare circumstance that there is no good solution.
- mywittyname 3y agoCO2 removal is the least-effective solution we have for mitigating climate change. Renewables have the potential to displace fossil fuel sources through market forces by eventually becoming cheaper. Demand reduction via taxes and requiring energy-efficient products can be effective for the same reasons. But there's no way to fit CO2 removal into the economy in the same way. Nobody wants to pay for CO2 removal, and we'll be relying on government agencies to coordinate, fund, and verify the process. It's always going to be prone to corruption, fraud, and mismanagement. So I'm not surprised that everyone is behind on CO2 removal.
- m4x 3y agoDo you think we can avoid multiple-degree temperature increases with the amount of CO2 (and equivalents) in the atmosphere already? If not, how do we mitigate those increases without CDR?
- silverquiet 3y ago> Do you think we can avoid multiple-degree temperature increases with the amount of CO2 (and equivalents) in the atmosphere already? If we ceased all economic activity today, then probably, but I assume you'd have to nuke most of the population or something equally catastrophic. > If not, how do we mitigate those increases without CDR? The half-assed approach (which I assume we'll take), is solar radiation management.
- mikestew 3y agoIf not, how do we mitigate those increases without CDR? Maybe we don't, and the magical CDR unicorn isn't going to come and save us. I don't mean to speak for parent, but CDR is the "least effective way", yet many are speaking as if it's the most viable solution. And maybe it is, because $DEITY forbid that a dollar of CO2-producing profit be left on the table, but if that's the case then we are most certainly doomed.
- staunton 3y ago> It's always going to be prone to corruption, fraud, and mismanagement. A lot of things get done despite corruption, fraud and mismanagement. As soon as people decide to actually do something about it, it will be done. The amount of investment required is significantly less than what a world war cost, for example. A lot of people thought such a war was impossible because nobody could (or at least would) afford it but here we are. The main question is how much pain it's going to take to push people into action, and how much additional pain will be no longer avoidable by then. Looks like it's going to be a lot but humanity will survive.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI try to keep up with the latest science on climate change. From what I understand we're currently on course for ~ 3.4C of warming, no where near 1.5. It's not all doom and gloom. China's 'dumping' of cheap solar and evs are actually a hugely good thing for the world. We're not on as dire a path as we once thought but 3+C of warming is still bad enough that I ultimately think we'll resort to geoengineering to stop it. No matter how dangerous geoengineering is, it's cheaper than completely revamping our economic system, and for whatever reason we seem to care far, far more about the 'cost' of a solution over it's risk.
- legitster 3y agoWell, yeah, it's really hard to send money to carbon capture when it's hard for 99.99% of voters to even begin to quantify the value of a ton of carbon captured. I'm all for carbon capture as a technology, but if a company was to take $100 from me as a service for capturing my carbon, I literally have no way of knowing what I am even getting for my money. And it sounds like the same is true even at a utility/national level. Go back to economics 101. Rational consumers purchase at the margin. Carbon capture is still only an irrational action. If we want to have any progress on global warming, CRD or not, we really need to start price setting the value of carbon.
- hcarvalhoalves 3y agoIt's hard to sell CO2 capture unless all governments start enforcing it, don't expect free market forces to solve it by itself. CO2 capture has to be the side-effect of other useful, incentivised and subsidised economic activity. E.g. we build everything in concrete and glass nowadays (a huge source of CO2) while we could build with wood (an actual proven form of CO2 capture), but there are zero incentives for timber production and construction.
- Moldoteck 3y agoSuch a shame there are so few initiatives to increase the quality, speed, reliability and nr of public transport(esp trams). So much travel can be done with good pub transport while reducing car dependency and related emissions + freeing so much space (parking and roads)
- dweinus 3y agoCarbon capture from the air is at best a tiny fraction of the solutions we need. Right now our time is better spent on emissions reduction. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-00953-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-00953-x
- dariosalvi78 3y agoThe 1.5 train has long gone and we are about to miss the next one too.
- dangilostmywang 3y ago[flagged]
- coolhand2120 3y agoA lot of people are intellectually devoted to this idea in the same way Ptolemaic devotees believed in geocentrism, it will be hard to get anything but emotional reactions. We know for a fact that more than 50% of science is wrong (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis), but at the same time the people who downvote you are sure as a Christian in Christ that this science about climate change is _always_ flawless. When science turns political it dies.
- RetroTechie 3y agoIn articles like this, there's recurring themes: 1) However much C is stored by protecting forests / planting trees, is peanuts compared to humanity's GHG emissions. Read: phasing out fossil fuels is the #1 task that we should focus on, as it has the biggest effect - by far. Planting trees etc helps, but it's not what will get us where we need to be. 2) Re-forestation is hard. Saplings die, growing trees takes time, and they may fall victim to drought/forest fires later on. Correspondence between [trees saved/planted] and [carbon credits] is... well, not 1:1. To put it mild. 3) Carbon capture is mostly a fantasy. Existing plants capture a minute fraction of human-emitted C at high cost, and this won't change for the foreseeable future. Maybe CC will work at scale, some day. And for that reason, exploring the tech is worthwhile. But as it is, it's not a 'solution' in any way, shape or form. A different but similar story goes for geo-engineering. 4) We're racing past 1.5°C warming, no matter what. We'll probably run past 2°C warming, too. 2.5°? 3°? Even more? Don't rule it out! Prepare.
- betaby 3y agoThose discussions are irrelevant given the population growth. UN is consistently wrong about populating growth. Earth population doubled in last 50 years.
- vixen99 3y agoI don't know the cost of the measures that have been put in place to date to reduce CO2 emissions globally but undoubtedly it's a massive sum. On looking at this graph, it seems that whatever the sum it's had no discernible effect whatsoever on atmospheric CO2, irrespective of quoted emission reductions. https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/ https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends/
- Glench 3y agoGlad to see other comments bringing this to light. As Saul Griffith likes to point out, physics indicates that stuffing CO2 back into the ground is not an easy or cost-effective job. Stopping it from entering the atmosphere is much simpler. Also Saul mentioned that the IPCC models have a disproportionate amount of faith in CO2 removal technologies which at this point is an unproven and uneconomical option and for physics-related reasons will probably remain so. Also, there doesn't seem to be an appreciation of the speed at which we need to stop emissions to meet 1.5C or even 2C of warming. It's at the point where if we don't replace almost every car, furnace, stove, etc with its electric counterpart and power them with clean electricity (due to the continuous emissions of those machines for their lifetime, assuming no early retirement), we can guarantee breaching the 1.5C limit. We need a World War 2 level buy-in from government, industry, and consumers. I wish this was more widely known.
- wilg 3y agoIn my heart I still think we should be able to make negative carbon wood for construction and paper products. Surely this is doable, right? Trees sequester the carbon so we just have to make the supply chain clean and not re-release it back into the atmosphere via decomposition.
- throwaway22032 3y agoIs carbon capture theoretically viable from a thermodynamic viewpoint with all externalities accounted for? That is to say - can I burn 1 litre of oil in order to capture more than the emissions of 1 litre of oil (without cheating and boxing it at the point of emission), can I use the lifetime energy produced by a 1sqm solar panel to capture the emissions required in the process of creating a 1sqm solar panel? Including creation and maintenance of whatever apparatus is required to capture the carbon. It seems to me as if the arguments all focus on money when what really matters is something more akin to an energy return on energy invested calculation.
- idrathernot 3y agoI will not entertain this nonsense catastrophism until these “political influencers” lead by example and first stop using all forms of “high emission” materials and manufactured goods from their own lives. No metals, no plastic, no transportation, air-conditioning, concrete, meat, fish, etc… All of the costs associated with their alarmism do nothing but further damage the middle/working classes of society.