4 ms·
Its not cardiovasuclar, but the top 2 causes of death in the US are tied to obesity, which takes zero time to reduce. You just have to not eat, which is actuall
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
Its not cardiovasuclar, but the top 2 causes of death in the US are tied to obesity, which takes zero time to reduce. You just have to not eat, which is actually time positive.
Most humans are just incredibly bad at impulse control.
- bagels 3y agoIt can take months to go from obese to not obese through calorie restriction
- s1artibartfast 3y agoOf course. I was responding to the time spent (out of ones day), opposed to calendar days of not eating. That said, people can make pretty rapid weight loss without eating. skip eating 1 day a week and that is 30 lbs a year for an average obese man. skip 2 days/week and that is 60 lbs/year.
- jagraff 3y agoThose numbers are assuming someone who skips a day of eating doesn’t increase their calorie consumption on other days to compensate
- davorak 3y agoAnd keep track of the calories in the meals they do eat to make sure they are not compensating is going to take nonzero time.
- aidenn0 3y agoExactly; when I fast for 24 hours, I feel a compulsion to consume every single calorie within a 3 block radius afterwards.
- WalterBright 3y agoPeople who do this regularly tell me it gets a lot easier after a while.
- EasyMark 3y agoA lot of people assume humans are mechanistic, unfeeling CICO convertors and exclude psychological and physiological realities of losing weight. I've grown used to it. It took several tries for me to drop 50lbs and most of it was psychological and good habit formation. it took about 3 years to complete that journey.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think the point is rather to communicate that there is no trick to around cico. Instead, they are reinforcing that the path is clear, and the the barriers Are entirely psychological. Effort to build habits, effort to exert self control, effort to find solutions when you stumble. If people are looking and waiting for a strategy that makes weight loss easier than inaction, they are bound for disappointment. Some rare people find a passion that makes the process of getting healthy and fit more fun and easy than getting fatter, but that is exceedingly rare.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYep. You can't eat your way to weight loss. There there isn't any easy trick to beat the laws of physics. Just eat less and burn more calories.
- agos 3y ago"just" is doing a lot of work here.
- throwaway2037 3y ago> people can make pretty rapid weight loss without eating Your suggestion is not sustainable. A staggering 90+% of people regain all weight loss a year after their diet ends. Seriously, who is not going to eat for two days per week? Your mental health would be a wreck. Can you do it? I cannot.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago90% of people regain weight because they go back to eating like they have a death wish. I think conflating between mental health and eating is at the heart of the obesity epidemic. Nobody will die if they skip a few meals. They will suffer some moderate discomfort depending on how much they fixate on it. I can go a week without eating and a few days is trivial. The longest a human has gone without food is 381 days and they lost 275 lbs
- wasmitnetzen 3y agoPlease do not assume your experience is universal. You simply cannot know how it feels for other people to be hungry, it might be a completely different feeling than what you get.
- throwaway2037 3y agoThis. Exactly. It took many, many years as an adult to realise that I was blessed with incredible genes that allowed me to reduce calorie intake without many negative consequences (insane hunger cravings, etc.). My point: I didn't do anything to "earn" this -- it was granted to me by birth. It gave me extra empathy for people who don't have it, who are trying to control their weight. It is a brutal battle. I always have so much respect for people who stuggle with weight gain, but beat the demons and lose weight long term. They really are someone special!
- imiric 3y agoTo be fair, our diets and lifestyles changed drastically in the 20th century. When we're bombarded with advertisements of highly caloric, processed, sugary foods engineered to flood our taste buds and trigger dopamine, we can't be surprised that people get addicted to it. Combine that with forms of entertainment, transportation, and a work culture that keep us sedentary, and it's no wonder many people struggle with being physically healthy.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoindeed, a lot has changed from when we lived on rural farms doing manual labor. People aren't going back to the farms, so we need to adopt new behaviors and norms around self control. There is simply no viable alternative.
- safety1st 3y agoTo frame the discussion as one of either/or alternatives is self-defeating, a more productive framing is what are the various strategies we can employ to reduce obesity? There are plenty which are unrelated to self-control or personal discipline. One is a sugar tax (not a huge fan personally but it exists). One I do like is to regulate the advertising and labeling of food. Frankly I'd like to know how many calories I'm eating or being persuaded to eat, pretty much all the time. This is a work in progress with the FDA gradually expanding the types of restaurants that are required to disclose caloric and nutrition info about their food. Frankly I'd like to see it required in advertisements too, if you're advertising a pizza, the advertisement should disclose that there are 2,000 calories in that pizza, many people actually are not aware. Not that I ever thought they were serving health food at the Cheesecake Factory, but I recently learned that their peanut butter cheesecake is 1650 calories per slice! Almost a full day's calories in one slice of cake! Nearly everyone I've talked to about it knew it was a gut buster but no one guessed that high. Those cheesecakes are only for special occasions now and it's because C.F. is required to disclose calories, I'd be fatter if not for this simple government intervention. Nothing to do with self control. Apologies to C.F. but with the nation's obesity rate cresting 50% I consider this a wholly reasonable imposition on their free speech rights or whatever.
- Aerroon 3y agoThere was a relatively recent study that found that BMR has actually been dropping over the last 30 years. The difference in men was large enough (7% iirc) that it would explain most of the obesity epidemic. Why it's dropping is still a n mystery though. Nevertheless, the solution is still the same: eat less. The study: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10445668/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10445668/
- Scoundreller 3y ago> Nevertheless, the solution is still the same: eat less. Or make life harder! Quit the elevator. Quit the automatic transmission (and car). Quit the online shopping. Making some progress with self-checkouts and pointless lineups at airports. Less jokingly (hard to outrun a bad diet) but more pedanticly: drinking less (alcohol and calorific beverages) might be a better start than eating less.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI'm not an expert on the literature, but I do know Bmr isn't a fixed number. It is a function of activity, muscle mass, and other factors. It seems that a largely sedentary lifestyle free from exertion matches both. It would be insightful to see the sensitivity analysis for BMR with respect to strength, activity, muscle mass, ect. I know there is a body of data about environmental hormones and BMR, ect, but my understanding is that the impact is barely measurable with large sample sizes. I expect that it can't hold a candle to activity. In my personal experience, my BMR can easily modulate by 1000 calories based on body composition and behavior. That is a huge impact.
- the_third_wave 3y agoIt would be interesting to correlate these results with data about reduced testosteron levels and sperm counts/fertility, especially whether one of these leads the other or whether both go down at the same time.
- cycomanic 3y agoPeople here complain a lot about social media and the tuning for engagement which makes people addicted to their phones etc.. Well compared to the food industry industry that's nothing. Incidentally they learned their trade from the tobacco industry who invested heavily in the junk food industry in the 60s. [1] All to say, much of modern food (and the advertising around it) is designed to get people hooked on junk food from a very early age. So saying just eat less is a simplistic solution that requires people to act against a conditioning that has been aggressively imprinted on them from a very early age. [1] https://lsa.umich.edu/psych/news-events/all-news/faculty-news/how-big-tobacco-created-america-s-junk-food-diet-and-obesity-epi.html https://lsa.umich.edu/psych/news-events/all-news/faculty-new...
- s1artibartfast 3y agoMost of life is acting against one conditioned impulse in favor of a better one. Every solution to every problem involves overcoming ones own detrimental impulses in favor of positive ones.
- WalterBright 3y agoFortunately, people have minds which can override their programming.
- EasyMark 3y agoclearly there is no "just" to it as a level of effort on the part of those who are overweight. It is not an easy road and something like 95% of the people fail at it, so I guess it depends on what your meaning of "just" is.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago“Just“ means the options and consequences are clear. The actions are the hard part. People are faced with the choice between eating more or living longer, and nearly everyone knows it.