9 ms·
At Microsoft, years of security debt come crashing down
- runjake 3y agoIMHO, this article isn't very substantive and reads like FUD for clicks. I'm inclined to believe that Microsoft is doing fairly well amongst Fortune 500 and cloud companies. Not perfect, but fairly well. Am I offbase? Edit: I guess I am. Thanks for clarifying and augmenting with more evidence, repliers.
- bayindirh 3y agoI think yes, you’re off base. Microsoft got their MSA secret stolen, allowing China to read government emails. Do you need another example? https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2023/09/06/microsoft_stolen_key_analysis/ https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2023/09/06/microsoft_stolen_...
- twisteriffic 3y agoAlso Microsoft still does not know how that secret was stolen and has knowingly mislead customers and the media about that fact. https://www.dhs.gov/news/2024/04/02/cyber-safety-review-board-releases-report-microsoft-online-exchange-incident-summer https://www.dhs.gov/news/2024/04/02/cyber-safety-review-boar...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HillRat 3y agoSpecifically, a vintage 2016, unrevokable consumer signing key that was inadvertently allowed to sign identity tokens for enterprise substrates, which is a whole security house of cards.
- ralph84 3y agoAgreed. Almost all of the quotes are from Microsoft competitors shilling their wares.
- wcchandler 3y agoYes, you are offbase. This is a fairly well written article that highlights and summarizes a few of their most recent gaffs. We recently re-evaluated our EDR solution and Microsoft was in the final 3. We didn't move them past the RFI process because of these recent incidents, on top of a very poorly packaged product (Defender). Microsoft has been really pushing the notion they're a security company (and my 401k would love it if that were true), but the sad reality is they continue to fall short in every possible way. I'll likely share this article with my peers when challenged on why we didn't move forward with them in our EDR project.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoMicrosoft Defender was, and is, an inexcusably poorly thought through product. Just the branding - the name and logo is exactly the same as Windows Defender. It even puts an icon in the taskbar tray, resulting in two identical logos for two identically named products that do completely different things. No idea what they were thinking there. It seems they thought that the separation in consumers’ minds between “Microsoft” and “Windows” was strong, which it absolutely is not.
- panzi 3y agoWhen I google for Windows Defender I only get hits for Microsoft Defender. What is it? I don't use Windows anymore.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoMicrosoft Defender for Individuals: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2022/06/16/introducing-microsoft-defender-a-new-microsoft-365-online-security-app-for-you-and-your-family/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2022/06/1... Windows Defender aka Windows Security: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/stay-protected-with-windows-security-2ae0363d-0ada-c064-8b56-6a39afb6a963 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/stay-protected-w... Microsoft Defender XDR (completely different thing, previously known as Microsoft Defender for 365): https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/business/siem-and-xdr/microsoft-defender-xdr https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/business/siem-and-x... Microsoft Defender for Endpoint (also a different thing, basically XDR lite): https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/business/endpoint-security/microsoft-defender-endpoint https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/business/endpoint-s...
- resource_waste 3y agoI am unsure if ancient tech companies doing well is an indicator of quality. Sales teams and various vendor lockouts/ins can cause people to bend the knee. I accidentally pay $70/mo to microsoft because I bought wrong licenses that I needed only to serve a customer. Up until I started this company, I was 0% Microsoft.
- Arnt 3y agoYou're right and wrong. I know about a team that does well and one that I think is begging for a major CVE. Microsoft is said to be a collection of almost independent companies sharing a domain and a CEO. Based on my experience, small as it is, I can believe it.
- patmorgan23 3y agoIt's a flotilla of product ships sailing in the same general direction (hopefully)
- nmcveity 3y agoAll with similar sounding names but vastly different purposes.
- RajT88 3y agoI've always described Microsoft to people thusly: "Microsoft is a many-headed beast. Some heads are benevolent. Some less so." > Microsoft is said to be a collection of almost independent companies sharing a domain and a CEO. Fairly true.
- LikelyABurner 3y agoThere is a very strong professional code of conduct within security circles that you should monetize the security of your own product as little as possible, because your own security is not a revenue stream, it's your most basic obligation to your customer. Like everything else in life, there's always trade-offs here, say, promoting your security practices to attract customers, but the general rule is that moment you start having different tiers of protection, you start venturing into some seriously morally grey areas. Microsoft didn't just start venturing into morally grey areas, they decided to set up their entire business model there, to the point that they didn't even know that they were hacked because they couldn't generate revenue from that knowledge. THAT'S why Microsoft deserves every piece of bad press it's getting right now. Not that they had a security incident (everyone will have security incidents), it's that they deliberately ignored accepted industry standards to do so, and to this day they're stonewalling efforts to assess the full impact.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rustcleaner 3y ago[flagged]
- gjsman-1000 3y agoDownvoted and flagged, because: A. There are no Microsoft employees in this thread saying anything about Qubes B. This is shameless Qubes promotion on an unrelated subject
- rustcleaner 3y agoQubes is relevant because it's a solution to the implicit "oh s*** my pants are down, what do I do now?" question this sort of news inevitably raises. I only shill things I dogfood, and I only do it for free.
- riffic 3y ago[flagged]
- 1970-01-01 3y agoBecause they're still drunk on OpenAI integrations being the next unicorn, and have completely forgotten the trustworthy computing email Bill sent them 20 years ago.
- tithe 3y agoLink to memo mentioned above: https://web.archive.org/web/20080621065707/http://www.computerbytesman.com/security/billsmemo.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20080621065707/http://www.comput...
- cjk2 3y agoIs that the one that bought us various fad service oriented technologies, even more broken DCOM and Code Access Security in the .Net Framework, topped with a peppering of Vista, UAC and shovelling the lumpy turds that remained into virtualization (LSASS etc) yet still somehow managing to run their entire AV software as SYSTEM resulting in a zero touch complete system remote compromise? Trust is of course earned. Bill's words were lost unfortunately under the next year's priority, the one after that and the one after that. Today it's AI. Tomorrow it's whatever Satya says that pumps the stock. I've worked with their tech for 30 years and customer requirements, safety and security is somewhere down the priority list. That is the only truth.
- troupo 3y ago> Privacy: Users should be in control of how their data is used. Policies for information use should be clear to the user. Users should be in control of when and if they receive information to make best use of their time. It should be easy for users to specify appropriate use of their information including controlling the use of email they send. Thrown out of the window long since
- Terr_ 3y ago> Availability: Our products should always be available when our customers need them. "Beginning mandatory shutdown for software updates. There's nothing you could possibly need your own computer for in the next hour, and all the data you lost when we killed your programs is your fault for not using Microsoft applications instead." > Privacy: Users should be in control of how their data is used "Telemetry is very important, for example the hardware IDs of that USB stick you plugged in were also reported to us by another computer an hour earlier, so now we know there's a relationship between you! Isn't metadata grand? But trust us, we have only your privacy in mind. By the way, did you ever finish that novel you were working on from the last crash report?" > Users should be in control of when and if they receive information to make best use of their time. "Hey! You still haven't linked your logon to a Microsoft account! Hey! Use Bing! Hey! It looks like you launched a web browser that isn't from Microsoft, switch to Edge instead! Hey! Here are advertisements on your lock-screen just cuz we can!"
- the_biot 3y agoYears? Try decades. When has Microsoft not been a source of endless security problems?
- IshKebab 3y agoWindows is quite secure these days. Arguably more secure than Linux.
- nosefrog 3y agoWho argues that?
- dboreham 3y agoPeople who know something about both kernels?
- staunton 3y agoLike who?
- fr4nkr 3y agoIf I had to guess, people who judge Linux security based on niche desktop distros with no security features enabled.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 3y agoLots of security professionals say that user-facing (as opposed to server) Linux except for Qubes, Android and ChromeOS is significantly less secure than user-facing Windows, MacOS, iOS, Qubes, Android and ChromeOS. And I think they're probably right (although I'm not a security professional).
- JackSlateur 3y ago
- bennyhill 3y agoMy impression was that they did a hard switch to proper Secure OS engineers for Windows about 10 years back.. I kind of wonder if that pushed engineers and managers with the worst habits out to periphery things from the OS perspective..
- mynameisvlad 3y agoThe article has nothing to do with Windows; it talks about security issues and breaches in their services, mainly Exchange.
- bennyhill 3y agoRight, something that runs on windows is the periphery from an OS engineers perspective. "You don't have to leave the company, but you can't stay here."
- nicklecompte 3y ago> Microsoft has placed a major bet that customers will embrace its effort to incorporate AI into its security product platforms. Microsoft said, after months of testing with customers, that Security Copilot helped security analysts be 22% faster and 7% more accurate. Good news! I am sure there aren't any deeper issues around Microsoft's ideology, arrogance, or crass financially-motivated reasoning. Otherwise I might start wondering if maybe Microsoft's security AI might not actually work that well.
- Clubber 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trustworthy_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trustworthy_computing Trustworthy Computing initiative was 22 years ago. Hopefully the new start menu ads won't be another attack vector.
- cjk2 3y agoBased on their existing screw ups, the ads process probably runs as SYSTEM and have more rights to your system than you do.
- m463 3y agoThis is what bothers me about the precedent that smartphones set. apple and apps have more access to my phone than I do. And they have unfettered network access to exfiltrate anything they want.
- cjk2 3y agoWindows XP did that way before smartphones came up with it. We are unfortunately prisoner of the masses. The smart phone is a 99% device which means it caters for 99% of the users. And it's probably not a good idea letting 99% of the users anywhere near the thing based on the crap I've had to unstick over the years. We can of course choose not to participate in this still if we don't want to.
- 3y ago
- boring-alterego 3y agoRecommendations in article are sound, zero trust infrastructure is a nice to have. Probably need something similar to a wake up call some industrial companies got with stux in the 2010s or hell their insurance company charging the sh*t out them unless they fix some things.
- rationalfaith 3y ago[dead]
- a_wild_dandan 3y ago> Regrettably, the marketplace is far from healthy The unhealthy thing here isn't the marketplace, it's government policy. If you eschew popular open-source tools for closed/proprietary alternatives, this will happen. Linux will always have several orders of magnitude more experts banging on it than Windows ever will. Vendors pontificating about security will not change this fundamental asymmetry. Also, don't want product lock-in? Don't choose vendors with a significant risk or history of lock-in. Don't endorse face-eating leopards and then blame others when they eat your face.
- cjk2 3y agoIt's not really about open source versus priority, it's about open source quality, which quite frankly isn't there. It's like living in a rickety shed at the best of times on the desktop.
- mistrial9 3y ago> open source quality you are communicating on it right now
- cjk2 3y agoHN is proprietary and closed source. I am looking at it with Safari which a fair chunk of it is closed source on my Mac which is mostly closed source. It's routed over a bunch of commercial routers, which are closed source and infrastructure which is closed source. YMMV. But that isn't the point. The point is that the open source desktops do not even touch Windows in usability, quality, reliability and consistency. At best everything is fragmented at 80% complete. Show me an open source O365 and you might have something fit for an SME or government.
- hehdhdjehehegwv 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- miohtama 3y agoHaving more healthy competition in the form of Linux would have been net positive for the society: > Failure of accountability Many in the security community see the CSRB report and the recent CISA emergency directive as direct indictments not only of Microsoft’s security culture, but a government that has allowed Microsoft to maintain lucrative government contracts with no fear of competition across many of its services. “The federal government gets off the hook a little easy in this report,” said Mark Montgomery, senior director at the Center on Cyber and Technology Innovation at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. “Despite significant encouragement from outside experts, the Biden administration, and its predecessors, have failed to treat cloud computing as a national critical infrastructure, that is itself critical to maintaining the security of our national critical infrastructures.” Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., who called for a federal investigation following the State Department email hack, said the federal government shared responsibility for the negligent behavior disclosed in the report. Wyden said Microsoft has been rewarded with billions of dollars in federal contracts, while not being held to account for even the most basic security standards.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoI pound this a lot here, but open source investment is a security and military matter to the state. Relying on unfunded overworked and frankly exploited programmers for major aspects of security infrastructure is madness. The US has a billion or ten to spare for this. Billion. With a B. This is an investment that is not just defense, it is an investment in the general economy. The NSA budget is (maybe) 3.6 billion dollars. A general secure computing base for the American economy is worth at least 3x that.
- Vegenoid 3y ago> Attacks like these will spur proactive security measures at many companies, for example increasing employee training, upgrading email security to an E5 level, adopting the use of audit logs and increasing the use of encryption during file transfers, Stella said. E5 is considered the premium tier for Microsoft 365 customers, offering enhanced security and other services, he said. What incentive does Microsoft have to change when the customer response to security breaches is to buy more expensive licenses from them? There's not much leverage in criticizing Microsoft, as is hinted in the article: the leverage is in criticizing orgs that continue to give MS more money.
- hehdhdjehehegwv 3y agoYes, we will hit you in the skull with a large stick repeatedly, but if you subscribe to our Helmet Deluxe Plan it will hurt much less!
- hulitu 3y agoThis is basically their stategy. And, with the outsourcing of IT to the cloud and to external companies, their success is assured.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoImplicating some of their cheaper products don't offer enough security. I don't understand what goes through the head of people working at Microsoft today but the results are quite lacking.
- hulitu 3y ago> I don't understand what goes through the head of people working at Microsoft today but the results are quite lacking This is nothing new. Microsoft and security was always a problem mariage.
- swader999 3y agoSeems like they are trying hard to be the Boeing of tech.
- courseofaction 3y agoEveryone has slowly been trying to be the boeing of everything for 50 years now and we're starting to feel it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jedd 3y agoI recall the brief storm that came up ~ 7 months ago with: 'Everything authenticated by Microsoft is tainted' ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37702095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37702095 ) ... and thought something significant will definitely come out of this. (It didn't, so far I could tell.) Here in AU it feels most orgs and gov agencies still assume Microsoft is the arbiter and epitome of good security practice, and their products seem to be excluded from serious scrutiny or regular review, as per almost every other vendor. (Google may be another exception, but their attack surface is obviously quite different.)
- swingingFlyFish 3y agoIt's crazy how slack big tech is. For companies who have such a grueling application process you'd think they'd have more to show for it. disappointing.