3 ms·
If we want to look at this purely in terms of economics then we have to "discount" the life years saved with a quality adjustment. Most elderly or chronically i
by nradov 3y ago
If we want to look at this purely in terms of economics then we have to "discount" the life years saved with a quality adjustment. Most elderly or chronically ill people who undergo ECMO treatment are never able to live independently again even if they are able to get off the machine.
I'm not saying that we shouldn't use ECMO in those cases. But we need to be realistic about probable outcomes and not expect anything like a cure.
- huitzitziltzin 3y agoYou are correct and I’m happy to discount. The older of the two patients in the original example was under 50. That’s a lot of QALYs. Even at an implausibly high discount rate it makes sense. The outcomes reported in the article are suggestive of a large decrease in mortality due to heart attack. Even assuming the effect is much smaller than reported, more widespread use of ecmo machines makes a lot of sense.
- ejstronge 3y agoI’m not a domain expert, but I haven’t seen ECMO offered to ‘old’ patients (over ~70). Do you have data on ECMO recipients’ age?