5 ms·
MTA banned from using facial recognition to enforce fare evasion
- foolfoolz 3y agoit is only a matter of time until people start asking for more facial recognition. as a whole facial recognition has a bad reputation. but if you ask people if they like walking out of an airport without waiting in line at customs they will say yes. when it helps identify criminals who would otherwise have gotten away they will support it. over time it will become normalized
- mbrumlow 3y agoI flew from sfo to iha the other day, id was not required. I walked up to a booth and they scanned my face and I was in. I did not sign up for anything special. I assume it’s from the real ID stuff. Cats out of the bag, facial recognition is here to stay. Idk if I like it or not, but I can see how it will make my life easy.
- iancmceachern 3y agoIt's like this for SF giants games now too
- dylan604 3y ago> Idk if I like it or not, When it works, I'm sure it's great. Now consider being a non-white person and it misidentifies you where you wind up being arrested for something you didn't do. Until it works equally well for everyone, it should not be used for things other than processes of convenience. Even then, it should have a way to gracefully fall back to something else that does not prevent anything
- habitue 3y agoAre you assuming there isn't a fallback? That's a big assumption if so
- GauntletWizard 3y agoI would assume that as soon as it's introduced, the agents in charge of fallback will be lazy, as has already been proven from numerous reports of people (mostly black) being arrested from a false positive in facial recognition[1] [1] https://apnews.com/article/mistaken-arrests-facial-recognition-technology-lawsuits-b613161c56472459df683f54320d08a7 https://apnews.com/article/mistaken-arrests-facial-recogniti...
- dylan604 3y agoIt depends on what it is. We've already seen situations where police arrested someone based on a facial recognition system incorrectly identifying someone. So, where's the supposed fallback in your opinion? We've seen stories out of NYC where landlords have installed facial rec to access to tenants that didn't go so well. I can't remember if traditional key access was still available or not, but you could see where that would go bad if not.
- olliej 3y agoThe issue isn’t “is there a fallback” it’s “there is incredible bias in who has to use those fallbacks, who has to schedule trips allowing for that fallback, and who gets erroneously subjected to false imprisonment”. If all people regardless of race, gender, or appearance were equally subject to the need to use the fallback then there would be less of an issue. But so far every commercial facial recognition program has demonstrated bias such that false positives and false negatives are much more common for PoC.
- mbrumlow 3y agoYah. You are probably right. As long as we have people who make assumptions about others.
- Simulacra 3y agoIt's a pilot project, did you realize you could opt out?
- bitzun 3y agoI opted out of this. There is insufficient transparency around the systems that process that data, who has access to it, what kinds of problems have occurred, and if it is being employed ethically (see the sibling comment about chronically poor facial detection of non-white people).
- hanniabu 3y agoAnd we should fight back against that
- VS1999 3y agoI'm always going to be against piling on significantly more invasive tools to make the state's job easier. I wonder if there's a word for this process where organizations make something intentionally difficult for us and then say "look at how hard this is, clearly you need to let me do this other thing to make it easier".
- StockHuman 3y agoThe degree of security theatre at airports aside, surely you don’t think public transit should suffer TSA-style security to warrant a solution to that self-imposed problem?
- infotainment 3y agoWell that’s unfortunate. Fare evasion should be punished, and facial recognition seems like a fairly efficient way to implement it.
- Retric 3y agoFunctional turnstiles seem like a much more robust and effective solution without false positive issues and can’t be that expensive.
- consumer451 3y agoAlso, one would have to assume that this function would be contracted out to a private party, which would sell the geolocation data of millions, or at least "share it with partners," because there is no US law against that.
- elijaht 3y agoDoes the NYC subway not have turnstiles?
- georgyo 3y agoWe do, they are easily hopped over. More recently people have discovered that if you pull the turnstile backwards a half turn you can squeeze by with very little effort.
- Retric 3y agoIn other words NYC doesn’t have working turnstiles.
- LeafItAlone 3y ago> More recently people have discovered that if you pull the turnstile backwards a half turn you can squeeze by with very little effort. This has been going on forever…
- couchand 3y ago
- neverokay 3y agoSunglasses and an N95 mask anyone?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- echan00 3y agoSorry. That's just stupid. That's like saying mugshots should be banned too. Doesn't make any sense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olliej 3y agoNo, the issue is not “mugshots” bad it’s “automatic enforcement mechanisms with a very well documented tendency to produce false positives” are bad. The issue is not “facial recognition to prevent fare dodging”, it’s facial recognition to provide “reasonable suspicion” to warrant arrest and detainment of specific groups. NYC has a long documented history of creating laws solely for the purpose of racial discrimination - “stop and frisk” laws that functionally only applied to black residents for example, IIRC it was only the lack of probable cause that did anything to limit that. Systems like this launder the racism and provide “probable cause” for unconstitutional search and seizure, as well as false imprisonment. It also means you get subject to the stigma of being stopped and questioned by police when entering a station while the wrong race - it’s obviously worse for black Americans whom the police routinely execute because they’re scared (specifically racist claims of super human strength, claims the victims are substantially larger than they are, etc), but these systems mean you’re more likely to be falsely accused if you’re any group other than white with european descent. So obviously black people are going to be victimized here, but Pacific Islanders, Hispanic, more or less any Asian country, etc are demonstrably subject to higher false positive rates, and there’s no penalty for the false accusations or detention.
- akira2501 3y agoYet they can setup automatic license plate readers to enforce "congestion pricing." Once more, those who follow the rules are punished, in favor of those who don't.
- esperent 3y agoApples to oranges comparison. There's a reason why we never accepted that humans should wear an identifying number while walking around the streets but we're happy for cars to do this. Facial recognition software is equivalent to humans wearing a license plate. It's never been acceptable before and it's not acceptable now.
- akira2501 3y agoI didn't make the comparison clear. The MTA can't catch fare evaders because facial recognition is bad. The NYC government can read peoples license plates and charge them arbitrary prices, partially, because the MTA is so broke. So, fare evaders continue to get a free rides, in exchange for similarly Orwellian recording and logging of all vehicles entering and exiting certain parts of the city, which is effectively only one layer of abstraction different than scanning faces. Apples to pears, really. It's what they do with the data in the long term that should be concerning in both cases.
- aaomidi 3y agoCars are a luxury item for most in NYC. Tolling roads is as old as cars themselves. There’s nothing new here.
- akira2501 3y agoThen I guess getting a plumber or an electrician to fix problems is a luxury item for everyone in NYC now too. Toll roads are not the exclusive route to and from a given area yet this system is. The tolls aren't even funding the road they're funding a broken public transportation system. There's a lot that's new here which is why this exact thing is often in the news.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vaadu 3y agoImplement something similar to that used to sort out green tomatoes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOTaNK-8LYY&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOTaNK-8LYY&t=2s
- olliej 3y agoThe problem is that that’s essentially what most “facial recognition” systems used for law enforcement and adjacent do: they filter by skin color - false positives are overwhelmingly black.
- cute_boi 3y agoIn that case, they can use human review before accusing anyone.
- Larrikin 3y agoThis could be reasonable policy if the police in the US didn't have racial bias in enforcement. It's not even historically
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- Shawnj2 3y agoPhotographic equipment “accidentally” being bad at taking pictures of dark skinned people- the more things change, the more they stay the same
- RecycledEle 3y agoWhy would the false positives be overwhelmingly black unless the fare jumpers are also overwhelmingly black?
- robot_no_421 3y ago“There has long been a concern [facial recognition] could invade upon people's lives through expanded surveillance and through the criminalization of just existing within the public sphere,” Mamdani said. Except, nobody is calling the regular fare paying people criminals. Just the people who aren't paying the fare and breaking the rules.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoAnd the people falsely identified as criminals by inevitably faulty AI that no one can directly fix bugs with.
- robot_no_421 3y agoRight, but you could theoretically say this about any software or technology (and this argument has very frequently in the past been used to argue against technologies like cars and airplanes). DNA sampling has "flaws" and "bugs" in it too that occasionally lead to false positives. Even police officers and lawyers falsely identify people occasionally. AI technology would just be another tool we collect evidence with for use in making inferences about the world. Imperfect technology never has been a blocker for using or improving that technology until it meets its purposes.
- LightHugger 3y agoI feel like dismissals like this always lack imagination, you can't think of any uses for facial recognition surveillance that pegs you at specific locations at specific times? You can't imagine a single way how to monetize that data and use it against you or other law abiding citizens? People said the same thing for social media data collection and now first degree price discrimination is getting more common. It's a total lie that it's only "people who are breaking the rules" suffer consequences with tracking and surveillance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- dools 3y agoPublic transport should be free anyway
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prvc 3y agoFacial recognition to be used for political crimes only.
- alexeiz 3y agoWhat facial recognition are you talking about when people jump over the turnstiles and walk into the open gates without any regard for police officers that stand nearby and just watch this happen? MTA is a joke. I keep wondering why am I even paying for the subway?