3 ms·
Can we focus on the fact that anyone in this country can register to run for a president? When do we fight for such right to freely nominate and endorse each o
by altodemo 3y ago
Can we focus on the fact that anyone in this country can register to run for a president?
When do we fight for such right to freely nominate and endorse each other for leadership positions in our countries, too?
- seabass-labrax 3y agoWhat's kind of a problem for me is that, in my country, namely the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, doing such a thing would amount to high treason. Lowering my sights from 'King' to 'Prime Minster' is more doable, but technically that is not a democratically elected position anyway; it's an appointment by the favour of the reigning monarch. That is, you can freely endorse someone, but the King isn't obliged to take any notice. The truly direct and democratic path to leadership is that of running for membership of the House of Commons, which is not something I haven't considered with some seriousness on occasions. However, independent candidates rarely get as far as their party-affiliated counterparts.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThe US is about the same, isn't it? https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_for_presidential_candidates#Requirements_for_independents https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_for_presidential_candi...
- altodemo 3y agoIn one country it’s so easy, you can do it by accident (11 people this last weekend). In US it’s possible… with hundreds of thousands signatures, thousands of $ and going through 50 bureaucratic procedures. About the same, huh?
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou need to read the article more carefully. A bunch of people accidentally signed up to the process that lets people collect endorsements. They still need 1500 endorsements to actually get on the ballot. Much like you need 800 signatures to get on the ballot in New Jersey. Making it digital instead of paper is more convenient but doesn't change things all that much. And while some states have pretty big numbers for signature count, at most they seem to be a pretty similar percentage of the population to Iceland's 1500. Most states are far less. Edit: I forgot to address needing 50 filings, but that's easy compared to the signatures. The population-adjusted equivalent of a candidate with 3 hardcore supporters in Iceland is a candidate with 2500 hardcore supporters in the US.
- altodemo 3y agoI think I understood the article well. I'm trying to compare the barriers to entry—very easy in Iceland, very difficult in US. There are 11 confirmed candidates in Iceland's 2024 election. Following your suggestion with population-adjusted equivalents, USA should have 9946 candidates in this year elections, if you believe that "convenience doesn't change things all that much". With such difficult barriers of entry, we effectively bar majority of the population from running for office. I don't think it's either fair or truly democratic.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Following your suggestion with population-adjusted equivalents, USA should have 9946 candidates in this year elections, if you believe that "convenience doesn't change things all that much". That's not how the population adjustment works. If the threshold is that 0.4% of the population has to endorse a candidate, then 1000x population does not mean 1000x candidates. Maybe you could find 9900 people that have 1500 supporters. But those people aren't trying to get on the ballot because that's a tiny amount of support in the US. > With such difficult barriers of entry, we effectively bar majority of the population from running for office. I don't think it's either fair or truly democratic. Not any office, specifically a country-wide office has these thresholds. And I think they're just fine. I think a bare minimum threshold should be 0.1% of the population. Why would you want anyone below that level to be on the ballot? People that are going to get 0% of the vote are just wasting space. It's not undemocratic to tell them to get more endorsements. That's not to say there couldn't be improvements, but it's hard to imagine more than 10-20 viable candidates.