7 ms·
Physical fitness and risk of mental disorders in children and adolescents
- delichon 3y agoThe role of brain health in mental illness is commonly discounted, but so consistently found in studies. I got roasted here for recommending psychiatrist Mary Edes' book on improving mental health with dietary changes, but the benefits of the approach are clear. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2024/01/27/1227062470/keto-ketogenic-diet-mental-illness-bipolar-depression https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2024/01/27/1227062... I've resolved most of my diabetes type 2 with diet, and nobody should be surprised that this came with improved mental clarity and emotional stability.
- hanniabu 3y agoYour gut microbiome plays a huge part in brain health and mental illness. That's likely why improving your diet improved your mental clarity and emotional stability.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tomcar288 3y agoThis! Absolutely. It's as if people think the brain isn't even an organ in the body and that it's completely disconnected from the rest of the body. After doing a ton of research and listening to many talks on metabolic syndrome and all the diseases caused by our modern diets, I've realized just how impactful diet can be on the body, the brain and the many modern diseases caused by our modern diets and lifestyle.
- lambdaba 3y agoYes. For those wanting to research this further look up keywords like "metabolic psychiatry" and "brain energy".
- AlexandrB 3y ago> It's as if people think the brain isn't even an organ in the body and that it's completely disconnected from the rest of the body. This happens a lot in a different context when people talk about AI and try to reduce human intelligence and creativity to just brain function.
- Attummm 3y agoThe individual parts of diabetes, blood glucose, nutrition, cell energy systems are really well documented. But yet putting those facts together leads significant resistance.
- lambdaba 3y agoI'm convinced brain health *is* mental health. With more nuance, mental health is brain health accreted through time. Healing the brain is possible, mainstream medicine and psychiatry is entirely ignorant of this, and once the brain is healed, the learned behavior oftentimes also needs some unlearning. For this, psychedelics are the most powerful tools. I think they can also be healing to the brain, particularly psilocybin, but the ideal order in my opinion is getting the brain to homeostasis first. The main intervention there is ketogenic dieting. Ketosis is required for brain healing, as a sick brain is an overexcited brain, to the point of toxicity. Of course, optimal nutrient intake, particularly brain related nutrients (which is most of them, really, but omega-3 fatty acids, and, yes, cholesterol are particularly important).
- delichon 3y agoOops, that's nutritional psychiatrist Georgia Ede. I confused her with another low carb physician and author, Mary Eades.
- thefz 3y ago> I got roasted here for recommending psychiatrist Mary Edes' book on improving mental health with dietary changes, This is because sadly diet, fitness and weight loss are some of the topics this otherwise very lucid website literally loses its mind over. Another is natality.
- diob 3y agoOnly want to chime in here for folks to not feel bad about also getting help beyond physical fitness and diet. I've been a health junky my whole life, very in shape, and I eat well. Of course that helps my mental health a lot. However, I still get depressed. I suffer from chronic sleep apnea (it's related to my anatomy, so I can't exercise out of it, it's around 79 AHI). I take zoloft for anxiety and it has helped me to calm down and enjoy my life more. And finally, I recently got diagnosed with ADHD. I'm fairly high functioning without meds, but with meds I can finally do all the things I've wanted to. My todo list, those things I used to forget or put off, I just do them now. So yes, take care of yourself, but don't feel bad if it doesn't solve everything. Some of us need extra help, and it's nothing to be ashamed of. I understand you weren't shaming folks, but I really want to share this in case folks think they're broken for needing medication. And sometimes you need the help from medication to kick-start being more healthy physically, don't be ashamed! We are all different.
- sn9 3y agoI think most people are on board with diet plausibly being a significant lever for improving mental health, and keto can be a way to do that, but the meat-heavy way most people implement keto massively increases risk of cardiovascular disease. We have an overwhelming mountain of evidence that saturated fat intake from animal sources above a certain threshold percent of one's caloric intake causally increases risk of heart disease through well-characterized mechanisms and that reducing one's intake below that threshold causally improves health. https://www.barbellmedicine.com/blog/a-basic-guide-to-cholesterol-part-2-myths-misconceptions/#_Toc92630813 https://www.barbellmedicine.com/blog/a-basic-guide-to-choles... Likewise the benefits of a high fiber diet are also overwhelmingly documented, and it's a rare person for whom it isn't beneficial. Your doctor can tell you if you're one of these unlucky people. You can eat a keto diet that's low in saturated fats from animals and high in fiber, but that's rarely done and most of the health benefits from keto is from the increased rate of adherence to a diet that makes it easier to stay in a caloric deficit.
- DangitBobby 3y agoFor those of you with better understanding, did they establish causality? Does exercise fend of mental disorders, or do people with mental disorders find it harder to exercise consistently? The first could be a novel finding, but the latter seems obvious. Forcing yourself to exercise routinely requires discipline, and many mental disorders carry along with them executive dysfunction that make discipline harder to come by.
- tomcar288 3y agoExperientally, my brother with ADHD and severe depression, has told me many times, that he notices a huge difference in the severity of his depression based on how much he exercises.
- DangitBobby 3y agoI certainly notice a relationship between the two in myself, but I couldn't tell you which one is in control.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- loeg 3y agoThis is a cohort study. They show association, not causality.
- zzzeek 3y agoless anxious / depressed kids get to do more sports in the first place. kids without "the right attitude" or a lack of innate ability are routinely excluded from sports, as im sure many of us here have experienced.
- recursive 3y agoI've also experienced that I feel better when I exercise more, when I get passed the initial "barrier to entry".
- hollywood_court 3y agoPerhaps that can be resolved by getting the children started in sports while they are very young? But you may be right because I have experienced this while watching the other kids in my son's sports classes. My son started going to a gym called "Kidstrong" when he was 3.5 years old. It was basically a bunch of kids following instructions and performing basic calisthenic exercises and beginner gymnastics moves. However, we had to stop going because there was a kid in the class who simply couldn't get his act together. Maybe he was special needs or maybe that's just the way he was allowed to behave at home. But the coaches spent so much time trying to get that one kid to follow basic instructions that it ended up detracting from the time that my child and the other kids got with the coaches. It came to the point where my wife and I (along with a number of other parents) realized that we were paying $25 per 45 minute session for our children to sit and watch the coaches spend 20 minutes trying to corral this one kid who couldn't behave. So we put my son into BJJ instead. And we're experiencing something very similar. There are two other kids in his class that simply can't follow instructions or chose not too. Fortunately this is a locally owned gym so we spoke to the owner about our concerns and he spoke to the kids' parents. The kids have been behaving better lately, but they still serve as a huge distraction.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoThe risk isn’t anxious kids with involved parents that can gently push them into activity. It’s kids with not enough food at home and no one at home to give a shit bout them.
- billconan 3y agoshouldn't the title be "Physical weakness/unhealthiness and the risk of mental disorders"? based on the abstract, Physical weakness/unhealthiness is positively correlate to mental disorders. not the opposite.
- Firaxus 3y agoThe title is matching the title of the linked article (if you’re referring to the title here on HN, and not the title the author chose to use for their article). From a pedantic perspective, the title doesn’t imply the positivity/negativity of the correlation, just that there is a relationship to be elaborated upon in the article.
- surfpel 3y agoNot doubting the importance of physical activity, but poor mental health makes it significantly harder to maintain fitness as a child. Often, school sports have minimum GPA requirements. A poor home life increases chances of mental illness and decreases chances that someone will drive you to practice. Will you even maintain the team sport if your teammates never accept you, given whatever mental condition that gives you anxiety or quirks? When can you even consider being active when much of the rest of your life is in shambles? You’re also less likely to have the ability to pay for it, given the correlations between low household income and poor mental health. Poor mental health just makes everything harder to do, and you see that impact every aspect of life in aggregate. The paper isn’t public so “controlling for confounders” is all you get, but I doubt they went through all the effort to have deep, revealing conversations about the home life or other nuanced cofounders of each participant.
- itsoktocry 3y ago>but I doubt they went through all the effort to have deep, revealing conversations about the home life or other nuanced cofounders of each participant. Why is it that nearly every paper linked on HN, someone is in the comments saying the research didn't go far enough? In this case without even reading the paper? Nothing in your critique is relevant to the fact that the authors found physical fitness and mental health linked. No, not everyone has equal access to sports. Yes mental health is complicated.
- surfpel 3y agoThis is such a bad, overly-cynical take. > Why is it that nearly every paper linked on HN, someone is in the comments saying the research didn't go far enough? Because they usually don't. And for those who are actually curious, look up "reproducibility crisis" and "publish or perish" to learn more about issues in academia, and ask ChatGPT about why systemic skepticism of scientific research is critical to the process of science. > In this case without even reading the paper? Nothing in your critique is relevant to the fact that the authors found physical fitness and mental health linked. Nothing in your critique is relevant to the fact that the authors found physical fitness and mental health linked. Such irony, that you didn't read any part of the preview yourself. If you did, you'd see: "This study highlights the potential protective role of cardiorespiratory fitness, muscular endurance, and muscular power in preventing the onset of mental disorders. It warrants further investigation of the effectiveness of physical fitness programs as a preventive measure for mental disorders among children and adolescents." The viability of this correlation, given controls for confounders, changes the significance of the results dramatically. Perhaps you think the point of research is to publish pointless correlations and suggest wild ideas for journalists to turn into clickbait? For those actually curious: the authors are proposing a causation, and given the absence of any counter, it's a biased conclusion that attempts to increase the significance of the findings for the sake of publishing, at the cost of coming uncomfortably close to declaring a causal relationship. Not a criticism of the authors necessarily, but of the poor incentives plaguing academia. For studies like this to be of higher quality, they become very expensive, so given the lack of discussion regarding confounders in the preview, one should have strong skepticism regarding the actual practical significance of the strength of the causal relationship. Though if the research is of low quality, then it really all was pointless and probably only serves to keep the authors employed. At that point, the paper is only an unsubstantiated suggestion to study something else, so why even bother with the rest of the paper. That being said, having been an athlete for most of my life, I'm a huge proponent of children being given access to sports. > No, not everyone has equal access to sports. Yes mental health is complicated. Do you talk to people in real life like this? That's quite upsetting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mattmaroon 3y agoThis seems like a very easy one to point out that they may be getting the cause and effect backward.
- canucker2016 3y agoThey've done the analysis: meta-analysis of random controlled trials , see https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-075847 https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-075847 "Exercise is an effective treatment for depression, with walking or jogging, yoga, and strength training more effective than other exercises, particularly when intense. Yoga and strength training were well tolerated compared with other treatments. Exercise appeared equally effective for people with and without comorbidities and with different baseline levels of depression."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mattmaroon 3y agoThat’s a meta analysis (which is always a solid indicator of pseudoscience) of studies that are not really controlled because A.) you have to actually do the exercise, which means the people who don’t may simply not do so because their mental illness is worse or at least different than the ones who do. 2. If you’ve ever read the attempts to quantify various mental illnesses, they’re extremely unscientific and borderline laughable if you’ve ever known a few people who suffer from them. What we call “depression” affects so many people in so many ways that in the future, it’s likely it will become a category of diseases with many different individual names. One of my exes medicated her depression by working, one by calling off work, for example. One would have (and did) do lots of exercise, one did not, and there’d be no way to quantify either on any simple scale. 3.) It’s obviously neither double nor single blind. You can’t not know if you’re exercising, and the researcher can likely tell which are which to a decent degree just by looking at them. All a meta analysis of a bunch of non-controlled studies really tells you is the prevailing pre-sentiment among the researchers of a topic. Which, really, isn’t nothing (they’re more likely to guess correctly than a random person) but it’s far from an actual controlled study. And I still stand by that there’s no way you could realistically say this study indicates causation with any certainty. Though that never stops people in the social sciences I guess.
- localhost 3y agoI wonder if enhanced operation of the lymphatic system might be causal to better mental health outcomes? The lymphatic system doesn't have a "pump", so it relies on muscle contraction to drive circulation. So more movement/exercise drives more lymphatic activity which may lead to better outcomes in people, especially if mental disorders are correlated with buildup of waste materials in the brain.
- lambdaba 3y agoWell, the brain is a heavily vascularized organ. Proper sleep and exercise are both crucial for cleaning up waste products, and supplying nutrients and good blood flow.
- mrinterweb 3y agoI am trying to learn how to interpret clinical study results. It seems that the confidence intervals and p-values suggest there is high degree of certainty in the results. Still, the odds ratio seems to have marginal improvements over the control, 4-8% depending on what was being measured. If I'm interpreting this study correctly, exercise has a marginal impact on adolescents mental health. I kind of hope I misread that study, and that exercise plays a larger role. If I read a study that tells me I may see a 4% chance of improvement if I make significant changes to my lifestyle, the chances that I ignore that study are about 96%. Guess, when viewed on aggregate a 4-8% improvement would be a valuable improvement.
- jasonpeacock 3y agoSpark[1] is a good book about the connection between exercise and brain performance, especially in school children. From 2008, this is nothing new. [1] https://a.co/d/9jqlU9z https://a.co/d/9jqlU9z
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIts kind of obvious kids should be sweating 30 minutes a day at school.