7 ms·
Korea sees more deaths than births for 52nd consecutive month in February
- wsc981 3y agoWeird. I have absolutely no idea what could cause this. Global warming perhaps?
- noobermin 3y agoEconomic development seems to be the only thing I know of that correlates with the birth rate in good times (as in not severe depressions or times of disease of famine) and that correlation is negative.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoUrbanization, wealth, and widespread mental health issues.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoAka capitalism. Look at other countries... The mental health problems are propably effecting lower wages more. And i guess work hours and alienation effect birth rate. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx's_theory_of_alienation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx's_theory_of_alienation
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt is perversely true that being bored in an incredible economy will bring more mental health problems than almost-starving in a Communist one. Things like gratitude are really tough - I'm unhappy that a shop doesn't have the exact thing I like, whereas undernourished comrades in Communist Russia had to queue for bread for hours, and might feel gratitude if on one day they only have to queue for one hour. What you're used to radically changes how you feel about a situation. It's tricky, but it's also not.
- petre 3y agoCommie states don't report mental healh issues. They sweep the problem under the rug, institutionalize the patients and then the caretakers make sure to abuse them and steal their food.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoRead your text again, skip all the whataboutism about communism and tell me whats left. The cognitive ability to reason about large scale problems is also in decline, in a society that sees no alternative, like whatabout socialism. Could you tell? If tou cannot adress the problem, maybe you are part of it! Also, "perversly true to be bored in an imcredible economy"? Sounds like GDP is more important than happiness to you. Maybe take your time and rethink that in the light of sociatal contracts and mortality too.
- kwere 3y agoWork Alienation is the byproduct of a mass-society and standardization/ commodification of goods & Services. Nobody gives a damn about your personal injections in your work bcs your work is fungible by design. Its mostly about being cheap and fast. On other ways very few would pay at scale premiums for "personalized" work. Such things are even more pronuncied in communist societies where efficiency, political ortodoxy, collective needs are placed well above personal social needs.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoGood point. I should have clarified that alienation is not the only source of unhappines, having no perpesctive in robotic labour is another important part, which i just scratched by mentioning low wage workers. There are very repetitive tasks that can still fullfill you, eg. simply by having contact to customers. Raising wages, lowering work hours or extending worker protections would help the depressed workforce but these things threaten capital income and so, have somehow less political momemtum until it explodes in a revolution.
- lm28469 3y agoIt's multifactorial, fertility is tied to a looooot of things, including but not limited to quality of life, religion, economic prosperity, personal wealth, education, access to contraception, view on having kids,... Online you'll find many accounts of people not wanting kids because it's too painful/will ruin your body, it's too expensive, it won't let you live your lifestyle, the future will be shit anyways, &c. Global warming will play a role later but for now it's probably more about our modern lifestyle and individualism. Obesity &co are mechanically reducing fertility but it's a drop in the ocean compared to the fact that people don't want (as many) kids anymore
- hackerlight 3y agoSK is having a large gender culture war. This is not the biggest factor but it would contribute a little.
- bamboozled 3y agoI think you're right about the global warming thing, it would be a bigger factor than people would like admit. But really I'm sure it's choice. Having a child is like having a pet now. You can either choose to have one or not. You don't need kids for survival and contraception is cheap and effective at preventing pregnancy. What aged care will look like when most people are old is a different story, I guess they'll except my kids to wipe their ass but that's a deferred problem for young people with money and a bunch of entertainment and no incentive to have kids.
- Moldoteck 3y agono, most important factors are wealth(lack of it), cheap housing in ok areas that can accommodate 1-2 children (lack of it, good social security (parental leave(adapted just recently to be better), free/cheap healthcare for mothers during pregnancy + for children, etc...) and proper infrastructure (walkable neighborhoods, play fields, cheap childcare, etc...). Some say that it's not possible and it's just what happens in developed nations, but if you look closely to the stats, you'll find out that for eg. in sweeden, the birthrates increase to >=2 when families reach certain income lvl. Others say that we must become poor again to increase brates, but I don't think it's that simple, if we look closely at different countries, basically brates are high when having more children increases the wealth/quality of life (v poor countries) or where having more children doesn't impact current lifestyle that much (if you have money you can afford nannies/childcare/school/bigger apt). Where it drops is when ppl achieved some lvl of wealth/good qol but it will be heavily impacted by having a child, aka the middle class.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPeople keep listing wealth, but the wealthier people are the less kids they have...
- maxrecursion 3y agoOr are they wealthy because they don't have kids.... But in general poor people have more kids, and as unpopular it will be to say, they can have more kids because the government subsidizes it. One parent doesn't work and gets all the benefits, so: no daycare costs, free medical care, welfare income, and food stamps/WIC. Not saying we shouldn't have those things, but when only poor people get the government assistance when it comes to having kids, they'll be the ones who have the most kids. Working class and above it costs a fortune to raise kids, not so for the non-working class. Now people will probably come say how wrong I am, but I live in a poor area and see this play out on a daily basis.
- Moldoteck 3y ago"but if you look closely to the stats, you'll find out that for eg. in sweeden, the birthrates increase to >=2 when families reach certain income lvl." https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subject-area/population/population-projections/demographic-analysis-demog/pong/statistical-news/demographic-analysis-childbearing-in-corona-times/ https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subje... I should have mentioned income instead of wealth, but my point holds
- lemper 3y agoi heard many times about hell joseon, mate. seems like working your back off without decent remuneration cannot support living a decent life.
- ookblah 3y agofor korea at least: - culture that prioritizes "status" heavily. this manifests as a consumerist/materialist society. everybody wanting designer clothes, live in a nice apt complex, go to the best colleges, drive a nice car, kids go to the best schools and after school programs, etc. this is present elsewhere but it's amped up to another level here. - housing prices are crazy. huge increases over the last decade (and it was already running hot before that). failed gov't policy and covid pushed this to the extreme. at one point you needed something like 60% down (purpose was to reduce speculation) but all this did was empower the cash buyers to snatch up everything. salaries are not keeping pace at all. - women feeling more empowered in the work place, not having to follow the typical path of getting married and stay at home and take care of your kids. basically all the pressure of even making it here WITHOUT kids... OFC nobody is going to prioritize it. people have had enough.
- StefanBatory 3y agoWouldn't military service be a factor too? It's 2 years and only for males.
- petre 3y agoOne could postpone it for a few years but who knows. Korean society is highly paternalistic and there's a lot of pressure on women. A novel by Kim Jiyeong called Born 1982 goes into details. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Ji-young,_Born_1982 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Ji-young,_Born_1982
- StefanBatory 3y agoI do still wonder how much military service plays into this. I imagine a strong ressentment from men towards woman for that; and the hierarchical structure endured there and abuse can't help too.
- withinboredom 3y ago[flagged]
- stavros 3y agoKorea sees more deaths than births for 52nd consecutive month, in February
- robertlagrant 3y agoIn February, Korea saw more deaths than births for 52nd consecutive month
- xandrius 3y agoI get it that reading the article might take effort but this one is relatively easy and short. The title means that February was the 52nd month in a row having more deaths than births. It's explained at the end of the article in a sentence.
- withinboredom 3y agoUsage of a comma makes all the difference in the world.
- junon 3y agoUsage of common sense also helps.
- withinboredom 3y agoWhat’s so common about sense?
- junon 3y agoYawn, I see you're a troll.
- tverrbjelke 3y ago[flagged]
- eneerhut 3y agoKorea is used interchangeably with South Korea. In the same way the United States of America and America are used interchangeably. And it's South Korea, not Southkorea if you want to be pedantic.
- korowod 3y agoActually, it's Republic of Korea.
- nickserv 3y agoOff topic, but would be interesting to compare the birthrates in both countries.
- pjc50 3y agoYou're not going to get good statistical information out of NK; it may not even exist. And it also matters what the death rates and child mortality rates are in a country which apparently has famines. Almost certainly the NK birth rate is higher to compensate.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoIt took less time in the search to get [0] than for you to type your comment. > it may not even exist Why did you even think what NK doesn't have that data? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_North_Korea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_North_Korea
- Moldoteck 3y agomost recent data is from 2008 and still you can't be sure data was not faked since it's a dictatorship (it is considered credible, but there's no way to check)
- Cartoxy 3y agoIs life worth beginning? Do the non existent yern to live... Overcome your machinery. live your life and get out clean. This is fine.
- phantompeace 3y agoOf course it is. Give life a chance.
- wetpaws 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway6734 3y agoyes. passing on the gift of life is one of the fundamental duties of society. luckily this is a self correcting problem
- frontman1988 3y agoGift of life quite often turns out to be the curse of life. If I was given the opportunity to respawn again I would politely decline than risk being born in North Korea or Sudan.
- rexpop 3y ago> fundamental duties of society Citation desperately needed. > We are here on Earth to fart around, and don't let anybody tell you different. — Kurt Vonnegut
- pjc50 3y agoStill looks pretty crowded to me (ok, 2022, but Seoul is notorious for this) https://english.hani.co.kr/arti/english_edition/e_national/1065223 https://english.hani.co.kr/arti/english_edition/e_national/1... (meta-comment: someone keeps posting population doomerism to HN. Why do you think this is relevant, or that a trend dipping negative for a while will inevitably continue that way?)
- aaron695 3y agoNot sure why a link to a deadly crowd crush and responses. > population doomerism to HN. Why do you think this is relevant Because as we age society will 'somewhat' collapse. There will not be enough people to do the work. The idea young workers will be imported from other countries doesn't add up. Nursing homes are currently disgusting places and lacking skilled workers. Nursing homes need to be 'disrupted' so they can handle the incoming load (and the current load) is one obvious reason it's relevant to HN. > or that a trend dipping negative for a while will inevitably continue that way? Of course it will. Unless you claim this is Covid deaths. South Koreas birth rate is .7 the lowest in the world, that is what one assumes is at play. As far as the birth rate or population rising again it will take a significant technological event. AGI will do it for instance or longevity drugs. But there can be large pain points before we get there which is how the graph is heading.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoDepends on how good autonomous robots get.
- oblio 3y agoNot how good... how fast and how cost effective. If they become good and cheap in 2250, that's not going to be much of a consolation for these countries.
- alephnerd 3y ago> someone keeps posting population doomerism to HN. Why do you think this is relevant While a lopsided population pyramid does cause issues, it's not the end of the world for a lot of countries. A lot of the population doomerism I'm noticing started off as a Zeihan or Perun trope that was repeated ad nauseum on certain subreddits and percolated into HN because of readership overlap. If you want to see a country that has been old before it truly became rich, just take a look at Thailand. They are a large country with a very low TFR, a high median age, and a low median household income ($7k/yr) yet they have not collapsed. Most of this is because of social welfare - most high revenue industries are very highly skilled and this require a small skilled or semi-skilled population. Think industries like Automotive, Semiconductors, ONG Refining, Finance, etc - this is the Thai economy (tourism is actually a relatively small portion compared to those). Deploying tax money generated from those industries into social welfare such as expanded healthcare, expanded social services, etc helps minimize a lot of the issues at hand. Japan's population has also been shrinking, for decades now, and it's the same story, as has Italy's. Countries like Japan, Italy, Korea, and Thailand do supplement their unskilled sector with migrant workers - they just don't get counted as immigrants (eg. Most "Work Trainees" and "Interns" in Japan and Korea are actually Indonesian and Vietnamese migrant workers who are doing low prestige jobs like gutting fish, working at a below minimum wage factory, cleaning toilets, working at nail salons, etc) And workers will always chase a higher salary - the same Thai people who wouldn't clean toilets in Khon Kaen (and thus depend on Cambodians, Laotians, and Burmese to do it) would clean toilets in Korea or Italy, and then Koreans and Italians themselves try to emigrate abroad to the US or Canada because of better salaries and easier work culture, etc. Realistically, Korea will leverage the Vietnamese population pipeline (it already has) and maybe NK down the line if relations start to warm up again.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThe one that shocks me is that 300,000,000 Chinese retire in the next decade. This is going to hurt. No way the fed can stop inflation with these demographic trends.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWhy is a large retired population inflationary? Retired people tend to be downsizing, and consuming less.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoBecause the cost of goods out of China will increase as they are required to compete and raise salaries for the shrinking labor pool. This is happening with the service sector in the United States right now where getting manual labor done on houses has increased nearly 50% in a few years due to the lower population of workers.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThis is counterbalanced by a falling exchange rate, if the USD strengthens enough per year relative to CNY. However that would mean less buying of government debt, less bank loans being issued, etc...
- chrsw 3y agoConsuming less than they generate?
- sdsd 3y agoTheir reduction in productivity is greater than their reduction in consumption, so you have a large population that only consumes.
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoCan that be assumed? A lot of people retiring may not be very productive in those last years, and if they're replaced by automation it could very well be that total productivity goes up when they retire. I wouldn't assume that either, my point is that I don't think either of these scenarios is a given.
- mrtri 3y ago[dead]
- fallingfrog 3y agoOne thing to bear in mind is that we may have a partial or total cure for aging within a couple decades, and that’s going to change the calculus here significantly.
- kwere 3y ago1. we dont have a couple of decades of runaway decline for most if not all countries. Even USA Social Security will be bankrupt by 2030s 2. People dont want to keep working till death while their parents enjoyed "UBI" in their golden years. Over 45s being the voting block of most countries will continue the Pension scheme bonanza till collapse
- fallingfrog 3y agoHere’s an interesting thought experiment: let’s say you work hard your whole life, you pile up a million dollars in cash, which you hope to retire on. However, tragedy strikes and your pile of cash catches fire and it all burns. But, your government is very accommodating, and they don’t worry- we know you really saved it, we’ll just print you some more. But in that case, why store it at all? Why not save the money you spent storing it, burn it now and get some printed later? What if the whole economy does that? What is the actual value of stored wealth? And does it make any sense for the government to have a “social security trust fund”? (No! It’s meaningless. Might as well just print the money later) Well, you hope to exchange it for goods and services. Goods and services performed and created by your children. So you’re laying claim to their labor. But what if there aren’t enough of them or they don’t really like this deal? What happens then? Well, we know really- the answer is inflation. Too many dollars chasing too little labor power. That’s why blaming inflation on Biden is absurdly silly. It’s a demographic effect that we’ve known was coming for decades. It’s not a surprise.