4 ms·
Exercise, metabolism, and weight: New research from The Biggest Loser (2022)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hi-v-rocknroll 3y agoJust don't try to lose weight primarily through increasing activity. Activity is great for other reasons, but the human body is just too damn efficient and it would consume too much time. Caloric deficit is the best primary way. The '5kg in 50 days' Diet! (2017) https://youtu.be/mTABw0EyIWY https://youtu.be/mTABw0EyIWY
- kiba 3y agoCaloric deficit is definitely true. The hard part is the implementation. For example, I was supposed to meal prep ingredient for taco for this week so that I can have lunch, but I procrastinated and instead had noodle and ate out for a family occasion. It used to be worse. For example, I had an expensive addiction to all you can eat hotpot.
- hi-v-rocknroll 3y agoAmen. I've tried more-or-less starving myself just by not having any food in the house other than healthy food ingredients that require significant time and attention to cook. I also went for 3 weeks without eating once, other than drinking 0 calorie hydration beverages, multivitamin, and fish oil to keep the gallbladder moving. My current strategy involves avoidance of food whenever possible.
- paulpauper 3y agoI did the same. One afternoon I cleaned out the fridge. Food that was still 'good'. All gone. Never bought it again even though I was highly tempted at times and caved once. I knew I was wasting money by throwing away perfectly good but unhealthy food, but it was hurting my goals.
- hackerlight 3y agoSelf-control fluctuates with tiredness level and mood. You want to build systems to protect yourself when those things dip and you're not thinking properly, by adding some artificial friction.
- alfiedotwtf 3y agoInteresting. How long until you get over the hard part? I did meal replacement for a while (ALL meals replaced by essentially Soylent) but I just dreamt of food whenever I went to bed - which was super weird because I never dream!
- hi-v-rocknroll 3y agoFor near total caloric restriction, the hump is ~3-4 days. The downside with this method is causes lose of muscle mass. It's not a safe or sustainable weight loss method in most cases.
- alfiedotwtf 3y agoI’m fine with losing muscle, but not being sustainable is a downer :(
- euroderf 3y agoI knew I'd have to feel full once in a while, so my rule was, only foods with 1 kcal or less per gram. This pretty much meant sauerkraut, pickles, raw veggies. Lemon water. Long walks. Two weeks of this worked great.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoAbsolutely. Unless you do some very vigorous exercise for many hours per week it’s not going to make much of a dent. I remember jogging for an hour (I’m out of shape) and it was very difficult - I felt like getting a pizza afterwards as a reward. That would have been something like -500 calories from the jog, +2000 from the whole pizza == +1500 net. After many years of doing it wrong - now I go with low calorie and high protein meals until dinner. ~150 calories for breakfast for example and no snacking. Once I got used to being hungry most of the day, weight loss actually became realistic.
- paulpauper 3y agoit is even worse than that. the energy constrained model suggests it is impossible to ever work off a pizza. you just simply burn fewer calories later to negate exercise, such as lowed BMR or less NEAT. As you lose weight, your constraint is lowered and any calories above it will produce weight gain regardless of exercise. The constraint throws off all the calorie math in regard to exercise. You find that no amount of exercise helps at producing lasting weight loss even if the meter/app says you burned 700 or whatever, which is .2 lbs. If you do this for 10 days you should lose 2 pounds of fat , keeping diet constant, but you don't. Either you lose less or just water.
- rale00 3y agoIf only we could find some way to harness the power of these thermodynamics-violating pizzas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kiba 3y agoI don't think your basal metabolic rate goes down to zero as you increase exercise. There's probably at some point in which your daily total expenditure must increase, but it's unsustainable.
- apsurd 3y ago
- morkalork 3y agoHow do you go to work and think and function under a calorie deficit? Brains need calories and mine feels crippled without, like I am forced to choose between diet and productivity.
- boppo1 3y agoStart slow. First eat what you normally would to feel full, and merely measure it. Use a spreadsheet and the nutrition labels to see how many calories you're getting as well as macro %s. Leave nothing out! First, start with obvious cuts: alcohol and candy/desserts. You don't need beer or ice cream and you will function better without them. Then, cut 100 calories a week. Cut from fat and carbs, make sure to keep your protein and fiber up.
- dieselgate 3y agoFor me it’s best to eat filling whole foods that are inherently lower calorie - potato, rice, beans etc. If you’re stuffed it won’t feel like calorie restriction.
- spudlyo 3y agoYour brain needs glucose, not calories to function. Yes, we can get glucose from the calories we eat, but that's not the only way. Thanks to insulin, extra glucose can be stored in the liver and muscle tissues as glycogen. When those stores are full, it gets converted to fat and stored in your adipose tissue. This is lipogenesis. When you're in a deficit, your body keeps blood glucose levels stable (and your ability to think and work constant) by tapping into glycogen stores from the liver. When your liver is out of glycogen, the body can convert glycerol, a component of fat molecules stored in your adipose tissue, into glucose through a process called gluconeogenesis. While this process works, it's not always comfortable. However you can become more adapted to it and get to the point where your comfortable doing light exercise and heavy thinking in a fasted state.
- oh_sigh 3y agoActivity might not be a directly efficient way to lose weight, but (imo) increased activity leads to increased willpower to make healthy eating choices.
- switchbak 3y agoInactivity (not our human default) comes with such a host of health issues, that even if activity had no bearing on weight, it would still be a no brainer to do it.
- strken 3y agoI find this kind of attitude frustrating because it likely discourages people from exercising, when they could benefit a great deal from doing both exercise and caloric restriction. Exercise is so connected to everything else in life, like mental health and (per the article) metabolism, that the benefits to be reaped from even just walking a few thousand extra steps a day might easily make the difference between sticking to a caloric deficit or exceeding it.
- DangitBobby 3y agoBy bogging down the concept of weightloss with an exercise requirement, you lose a lot of people who would otherwise be willing to diet to lose weight. Is exercise good for you? Yes, very. But you can lose weight without it.
- maxglute 3y ago>By bogging down the concept of weightloss with an exercise requirement Conceptually weightloss for genpop is really get skinnier to fit into things. Body recomposition with more muscle and less fat can get you there faster and more muscle makes long terms maintaining higher weight at same waist size easier. In my experience the people who lost weight and kept it are the ones who got more muscular or have exercise goals that regulates their caloric intake. People who just diet tend to yoyo.
- strken 3y agoThis feels to me like saying "hey, you don't need to buy a fire extinguisher to keep your house safe from bushfires, the primary way of protecting it is clearing vegetation away from the walls." While technically true, it presents the two methods as if they were in opposition to each other, when they are in fact complimentary. You can do both! If you absolutely have to prioritise one, then I guess you could pick one, but why bother? It also assumes you'll "lose" people if you even mention exercising in a positive way unless someone comes along to tell them how pointless exercising is. I think the exact opposite is true: people get burnt out on weight loss because they aren't able to make it stick, and the solution is to incorporate exercise as well as educate them about concepts like losing your weight in stages then stabilising before metabolic adaptation hits, how your BMR needs to be recalculated as the weight comes off, water retention and weight loss plateaus, calorie tracking, satiation, and everything else that's been learnt through trial and error over the years.
- taeric 3y agoAs a contrary take, start doing weights. Go for walks. Not short ones. Adjust eating, but largely do so to give yourself more time for the activity. If it motivates you, jog or run. Bike, if you can and that motivates you. What never worked for me, was just changing diet. No matter what the food, I can eat a lot of it. Unreasonably so. After a run of most any length, eating is just not something I want to do. Same for a long bike ride. So, yeah, don't expect that exercise can lead to weight loss on its own. But also don't be surprised if you can't eat the same while doing exercise. Of course, I think that is a related trap. High level athletes have a lot of calories they need. A lot of energy bars and such are necessary for long hikes, but complete overkill for walks. So, odds are you should avoid athletic food until you are an athlete...
- paulpauper 3y agomedically induced weight loss is really damn hard. vastly more drugs produce weight gain as a side effect compared to weight loss, and the few that do tend to be really dangerous or addictive. It took 90 years after the discovery of insulin, and ushering in the field of endocrinology, to develop Ozempic--the first in a class of non-stimulant and (mostly) safe weight loss drugs that work for a general population and produces substantial weight loss for most ppl who take it.
- barnabyjones 3y ago>after [reaching 291 lbs], had to consume an 800-calorie-per-day diet to maintain his weight. >A more recent study aims to explain and interpret the findings The lengths highly educated individuals go to to explain away obvious fibs. A 300lb person only eats one small meal a day and doesn't lose weight? Come on!
- paulgerhardt 3y agoI fasted for a while (40 days) and definitely noticed a slowdown in basal metabolic rate towards the end. Initially I was around 2,600 calories but towards the end dropped to 1,700. Engaging in intense physical activity after ending my fast got me back up to 2,300 calories per day (rowing and CrossFit).
- bluecalm 3y agoHow much lighter were you at the end of your fast? It's expected a lighter body needs fewer calories to maintain.
- deadbabe 3y agoSo it seems like fast metabolism is one of those things that once you lose it you never really gain it back? Makes sense. For many, Ozempic may truly be the only viable path to healthy weight.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- medler 3y agoThis article links to this paper: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/oby.23308 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/oby.23308 It’s short and interesting, but the most interesting tidbit in there for me was that physically active hunter-gatherers have roughly the same daily energy expenditure as sedentary westerners. I always thought they’d have to eat huge amounts of food to fuel their activity, but that doesn’t seem to be the case. [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22848382/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22848382/]
- the_real_cher 3y agoSo many thoughts and questions about this. That's INSANE that 6 years later the bodies metabolism had not adjusted back!!? Hard to believe!! Is there a decent sample size study for this or we going on one guy? Maybe this person has some sort of syndrome? If this is normal for the human race as a whole...is metabolic readjustment a spectrum like many things in biology? Like will some recover their original pre-fat metabolism after a period of time? Are there medicines or areas of research into how to trigger this metabolism? Are there foods and/or exercise that can build a metabolism back. How does gastric bypass seem to work so well? Does it basically just reduce the distance of your digestive tract so that you absorb less calories which matches up to your new fat metabolism? Ozympic seems to be a miracle drug in that it curbs the appetite so people can maintain this new low calorie diet.
- medler 3y ago> That's INSANE that 6 years later the bodies metabolism had not adjusted back!!? Hard to believe! The paper argues it’s because they continued to have high levels of physical activity, which kept their resting metabolic rate low. The ones with the highest metabolic adaptations were the ones who kept the most weight off, and were also the most physically active.
- taeric 3y agoIt can be surprising for folks that athletes have a lower resting heart rate than others do. I had thought it was greater efficiency in blood to muscle delivery, but I don't know why I thought that.
- the_real_cher 3y agoWhat is it then?
- taeric 3y agoI don't know. Haven't read up on it.
- bluecalm 3y agoOnce you arrive at: "and achieved a weight of 191 pounds, yet six years later, after regaining 100 pounds of that lost weight, had to consume an 800-calorie-per-day diet to maintain his weight." You should just take a step back and look at your assumption. The contestant either wasn't able to count calories, was in medically induced coma or more likely was just deluding themselves about their calorie intake and/or lying about it. "Metabolism slowing down" is such a nonsense term as well. Like how does it matter if your body gets slower at processing food? Maybe the body becomes a bit more efficient but that's about it. It's a good thing. It won't magically start producing energy from the sun though. Like if you ever were around competitive athletes who care about their diet you would instantly see how nonsensical the thesis is. People struggle to eat enough to not lose weight. They eat as much as the body can process during activity (currently 90/120g of carbs per hour is a new normal at high level) and then eat a lot after to replenish their glycogen and lost fat. They would kill for "metabolism slowing down" allowing you to function on 800 kcal per day but no such thing was ever observed. We know quite well how much the body burns during activity. It's normal to burn 500-1000kcal per hour (or more at pro level) on a bike or running and you need to eat enough to cover that if you want to sustain your training volume. Harvard publishing "people are clueless about their calorie intake but let's assume they aren't and reason from there" kind of "research " isn't good for their credibility.
- class3shock 3y agoIt's an error, it shouldn't say 800 a day but 800 less than normal a day.
- bluecalm 3y agoI doubt it's an error but let's assume it is. When I look at an online calculator for fat loss which uses some standard formulas for BMR (google fatcalc) I see that losing 62.5kg (91 pounds) means your "calories to maintain" are 1000kcal lower than at your starting weight. It takes less calories to maintain a lighter body. Nothing surprising here. Metabolism didn't "slow down".
- medler 3y ago> One contestant . . . had to consume an 800-calorie-per-day diet to maintain his weight. This is wrong. The linked source says he “now has to eat 800 calories a day less than a typical man his size.” That’s very different.
- turtleyacht 3y agoGoing for 0.1 lb weight lost per week [1]. I started too high the first week, and now--a month in--getting a bit closer to a lose threshold. Probably will adjust as things go. Not a lot to go on from a comment, but it seems doable. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39200900 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39200900