5 ms·
FTC says Amazon executives destroyed potential evidence using apps like Signal
- ranger_danger 3y ago> accused of using a chat app > You can't use apps for what they're designed for! my sides, in orbit
- madeofpalk 3y agoGuns are made for shooting, but murder is still illegal.
- hereme888 3y agoMurder = killing without just cause. Killing is not illegal (for self defense, or to save an innocent life). Neither is revolting against an oppressive government in the US, as per the constitution.
- User23 3y agoTo be fair the legal use of lethal force involves an intent to stop the perpetrator, not to kill him. You can very much get yourself convicted of murder in what would otherwise be a self defense case if a jury is convinced you were looking to kill someone intentionally. That’s why among other reasons you should call for an ambulance immediately and politely keep your mouth shut until you speak with your lawyer.
- banish-m4 3y agoThe first part is true. Murder doesn't require a gun, murder isn't a universally essential act, and guns don't have to shoot. Knife crime murder is epidemic in some countries. Guns can also be decorations, used for sport of marksmanship, or insurance policies against home invasion; they are inanimate objects without intent of their own. Killing is occasionally essential when all other means of self-defense have been thoroughly exhausted and someone else is intent on great bodily harm or murder that cannot otherwise be prevented with lesser available force or evasion.
- pessimizer 3y agoWho cares what apps are designed for? "That's what the shredder was designed for, officer."
- MyFedora 3y agoThis made me laugh. Thank you, kind stranger.
- pylua 3y agoI would have imagine most major ceos are on constant litigation hold considering the sheer volume of lawsuits. If I am reading that correctly, the ceo got a litigation hold from internal legal nine months after the original issuance to Amazon ? That is also strange.
- branon 3y agoGood, this is why E2EE and user-controlled communications need protected at all costs. Citizens need to defend the right to communicate privately and ephemerally from government snoops. Because if they can force (or try to) Amazon to fork over comms records, they can do the same to me or to you. Destruction of evidence is one thing, let them get nailed for that. But they weren't afraid to communicate privately and neither should we. And we can't let the government hold these antitrust suits up as an example of "this is why we need to break encryption, so we can protect consumers from the big bad monopolies" either. I bet that'll be the narrative at some point.
- hereme888 3y agoAgreed. If their data is safe, the rest of us are safe, too. I'll keep using Signal.
- 1oooqooq 3y agoproblem with signal is that server is an unknown. still a million times better than most alternatives. maybe matrix today can compete. but that's it.
- fragmede 3y agoyou can verify safety number out of band to assert that signal's server isn't mitm-ing you
- gaganyaan 3y agoYou can't actually assert that. You have to hope that they or someone else hasn't found an SGX weakness: https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkyzek/signal-new-pin-feature-worries-cybersecurity-experts https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkyzek/signal-new-pin-featur...
- fragmede 3y agoThat article doesn't contradict that. Signal's new feature is to store users' address book on their servers. That's not great in the case of an SGX break, but that's not the same thing as Signal mitm-ing messages.
- jrockway 3y agoI've never been a big fan of mandatory message retention. To me, it just seems like punishment for the literate. You don't make people under litigation holds carry around a voice recorder all day, so you're giving people an out; if they are a more talkative person than a writing person. Since writing is harder than talking, this has always felt awfully unfair. As for the lack of messages in this case, they always say the coverup is worse than the crime, but if you don't know what the crime is, how can you be so sure?
- vlovich123 3y agoOne difference is that writing and digital communication more broadly is a far more efficient communication mechanism than in person voice communications. > of using the ephemeral messaging app for months after the feds notified Amazon of the antitrust investigation I think switching to ephemeral messaging apps specifically in response to antitrust investigation is evidence of mens rea that you’re in an illicit conspiracy. As for the crime: > The FTC accused Amazon of creating a secret “Project Nessie” pricing algorithm that may have generated more than $1 billion in extra profits.) You can distrust the government or not believe their argument, but our criminal justice system does depend on the government being able to perform an investigation.
- nickff 3y agoGovernment officials are also known to be using non-governmental channels for official business, in violation of regulation, and avoiding accountability and transparency. It seems to me that whats’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
- vlovich123 3y agoUnfortunately, that just leaves you in a low-trust dysfunctional society. The correct response is to make sure that all parties are behaving above board. Engaging in whataboutism just degrades society and honestly I thought most people learned to mature outside of this childish way of thinking after puberty.
- ararar 3y agoMost Fortune 500 companies have (I am extrapolating wildly here since I haven't worked at all of them) email retention policies that specify that emails will not be kept past a certain time after reception. So when an opposing lawyer requires the emails that were sent a year ago ... well, those were deleted as per policy. It's weird that if the companies had a policy to immediately delete them it would be "bad" but if they delete them after 30 days due to "storage" reasons and a clear, global, openly stated policy, it's OK. It doesn't stop someone from stuffing old emails in a folder.
- j33zusjuice 3y agoIn my experience, the email retention policy is guided by whatever regulations with which the company has to comply. I’ve worked at places with insanely long retention policies because of that.
- galleywest200 3y agoWe sell VoIP B2B and our retention time is measured in multiples of years. Businesses like to sue each other and proof of phone calls or work on their phone lines can be subpoenaed.
- ararar 3y agoWow. The companies I've worked at only kept old emails if there was a litigation hold. Otherwise, the email retention policy was enforced. It seems to me a double edged sword that slightly favors the deleter. I think that you will find that your industry is an outlier.
- pests 3y agoWouldn't that be more reason for having less time tho?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AgentOrange1234 3y ago
- jgtor 3y agoFor exactly the same reasons, Amazon limits message retentions on it's internal Slack platform and aggressively enforces mailbox quotas in it's internal email system. Up to some shady shenanigans, and don't have to hand it over as part of discovery if they don't got the record in the first place. Exactly the same way criminal gangs operate!
- brevitea 3y agoThe sudden disappearance of Slack channels is definitely a thing, along with giant sets of trouble tickets. Don't forget the disappearing wikis... Can't have documentation.
- 8note 3y agoIt's definitely given me the opinion that the only reliable docs are what's in git. Links to stories are useless Links to tickets are better Links to wikis are awful Comments are misleading Code review links are ok, but mostly link to unreliable sources, and older code review links are gone. Commit history also goes missing, so don't bother leaving too much info in the commit text Current code is mostly reliable, but might need extra knowledge to actually reason about. It's crazy how much useful info get deleted or not migrated or gets moved in a way where you'd never find it again, or the search tools stop indexing it
- redditor98654 3y agoSpent almost 12 years at Amazon till early 2023 and some of this is very surprising to me. I know the annoying slack retention policy but I had never heard of tickets, issues, or wikis or even git commits being auto deleted. When I was there I could go back a decade and open up old tickets or wikis. Has things changed so much in less than two years?
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Washington Post article referenced: Federal regulators accuse Amazon executives of deleting messages https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40182270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40182270
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nickff 3y agoSomewhat ironic for government officials to say that private organizations are destroying evidence by using these apps. I heard an interview with Janet Napoletano (when she was secretary of homeland security) saying she avoided corresponding over e-mail or instant message to avoid leaving a ‘paper trail’.
- toofy 3y agoand what she did should be illegal as well. we should have privacy for individuals / citizens and no privacy for those with power, whether they’re a government official or company. it’s wild to me how quickly this is flipping on its heads, we’re now entering a space where citizens get less and less privacy while billionaires, corps, and governments are getting more. it’s becoming a genuine two tier system, those who get ultimate privacy and those who get none.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI could be wrong, but my assumption is that tech companies with a lot of talent develop their own messaging apps for the execs and friends. Why would they risk using a popular platform? The data could be sent via whatever medium, doesn't need to be ethernet. I also assume this is how most illegal collusion is done as well, unless someone wants to give me other data points.
- banish-m4 3y agoIn-house tools are jobs programs for megacorps. "Why use COTS when you can grow a pyramid with something made internally?" More work = job security. Meta has Workplace, for example.
- fao_ 3y ago> my assumption is that tech companies with a lot of talent develop their own messaging apps for the execs and friends. err- i dont mean to be rude but, what gave you that assumption?
- schmidtleonard 3y agoIt's not an app, it's the golf club. This is what golf clubs are for.
- Aurornis 3y ago> I could be wrong, but my assumption is that tech companies with a lot of talent develop their own messaging apps for the execs and friends. This is an incorrect assumption. E-mail and even SMS text messaging are heavily relied upon. This very story shows that Amazon execs were using Signal, not some custom application. If a company was found to have developed a custom in-house app that was exclusively used by executives and their friends, it would immediately become the central target of their investigation. > Why would they risk using a popular platform? I think the part you've missed is that if someone is discussing something sensitive or illegal, they avoid writing it down in any medium at all. They won't develop an in-house app for messaging because they're not going to be messaging these things if it can be avoided. Instead, they send a meeting invite and then discuss it in an ephemeral medium like voice or in person. > I also assume this is how most illegal collusion is done as well, Smart people colluding for illegal activities aren't going to take notes or leave anything in writing. It's done in person or in voice, not via e-mail or in-house apps.
- lebean 3y agoJeff Bezos can't use signal because Amazon uses... a pricing algorithm? Call me a bootlicker but that's insane.
- bradleybuda 3y agoBut it generated “extra profits”
- tecleandor 3y agoNothing to do with that. They were under investigation and they could be destroying evidence. "Companies and individuals have a legal responsibility to preserve documents when involved in government investigations or litigation in order to promote efficient and effective enforcement that protects the American public."
- elevatedastalt 3y agoPreserve documents, yes. But there is no responsibility to create new potentially incriminating evidence against themselves. Just because you are under investigation does not mean all your communication henceforth needs to be recorded.
- ameister14 3y agoIt does, however, mean that your new documents related to the litigation must be preserved. Just because a machine destroys it for you as a service doesn't mean you don't have a duty to preserve. They control the disappearing time.
- dlubarov 3y agoLooking at FRCP rule 37, it uses language like "reasonable steps to preserve" electronic information, and "intent to deprive another party of the information’s use". I'm no expert, but it does sound like this might imply an obligation to change retention settings, switch to another chat app, or figure out some other way to preserve relevant information (if litigation is anticipated).
- banish-m4 3y agoProving it seems exceedingly difficult unless a party to the convo testifies it was done to evade potential discovery. Any record suggesting use of Signal for work purposes could be bad for their side. One prime directive of megacorp comms, don't write down anything that could be used as evidence. If possible, have an unscheduled chat in person.
- ranger_danger 3y ago> in person I'm curious how using Signal in this way is any different from talking in person. Nobody considers a private conversation during a walk in the park to be destroying evidence just because it wasn't recorded.
- banish-m4 3y agoSignal can leave metadata (phone numbers) behind whereas talking in person doesn't usually unless some comms were used to suggest it, security footage, or cell phone pings were to allude it. I'm wondering if evidence of a conversation occurring can be used in a legal context as circumstantial evidence or to suggest suspicion or intrigue.
- ameister14 3y agoBecause when using signal it was recorded, just deleted after two weeks.
- ranger_danger 3y agoWhere do you draw the line at "recorded"... is a 5-second disappearing message still "recorded" ?
- ameister14 3y ago>is a 5-second disappearing message still "recorded" Yes. What's the difference, functionally? Ignore the time limitation, what is the command being given, in the end?
- abeppu 3y agoI feel like I'm ok with Amazon execs needing to not auto-delete their messages when the FTC is doing discovery about anti-competitive practices ... but how far down does that go? - can a smaller or privately held company being sued be obligated to keep all their communications in a form which can be subpoenaed? - is a family business being sued under the same obligation? What if execs in that family business have both personal and business conversations? - is an individual being sued under the same obligation? - if I want access to someone's personal messages, can I contrive a reason to sue them, and create such an obligation to deliver personal correspondence to my counsel? - if Senator McCarthy thinks you're maybe a communist, can he publish your name as part of a list of suspicious persons and provide legal funds for to any wannabe vigilante who can contrive a suit against you? At some point, I think we as a society need to agree on what rights to privacy exist, how solid they are, which rights are enjoyed by individuals and which rights if any also apply to corporations.
- j33zusjuice 3y ago> for months after the feds notified Amazon of the antitrust investigation. That’s the problem. Had they always used signal—-even if they had started the day before the notice of investigation was sent—-it’s a non-issue. They did it in response to a notice. That’s shady shit.
- stefan_ 3y agoWell its certainly not going to be privacy rights for corporations, seeing how there also seems to be no legal repercussions for them. But I think you are just overall missing the entire point: these people were notified that they are recordkeepers.
- balls187 3y agoI cannot see how this will go well for Amazon at all. I don’t imagine judges like businesses being cute with evidentiary rules, and even less so when they continually refuse to address the issue.
- doener 3y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40177032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40177032
- CodeWriter23 3y agoI mean if the feds can't win on the Amazon Business Services Agreement being written by Amazon Legal and stipulates most favored nation status when it comes to pricing, what the fuck are they actually doing? Who cares what messages exist? The crime is in writing in a forced click-wrap agreement ticked by every Amazon Seller.
- ranger_danger 3y ago> If the judge finds that Amazon was negligent in failing to preserve data tied to the case I think there's several big obstacles the prosecution would have to overcome in order for that to happen. For one, someone would have to violate their own Fifth Amendment right and admit that they used Signal intentionally to hide things relevant to the investigation. Also, how is "disappearing messages" any different from a private IRL conversation? Nobody is calling a casual chat in the park "destruction of evidence".
- tacocataco 3y agoIt's interesting how in some cases, text communication isn't allowed to be recognized as official communication in the eyes of the law. I am referencing communicating with a landlord about a fault in the building. I have gotten screwed in the past because I didn't put the information sent to a landlord in a email. Goodbye security deposit. I guess you can crush a stone, mix with water, and turn the dust into a blood slurry after all. If only the city held these deposits and the landlord would have to prove in court that they deserve it.
- kingspact 3y agoWhen are stupid government regulators going to learn who runs this country anyway?
- ergocoder 3y agoThis would be a great advertisement for Signal. Even US can't retrieve its messages. I know other apps can do it but other apps aren't being tested publicly in a high profile case like this.
- dns_snek 3y agoYou're assuming that they would burn such a high profile backdoor over a low profile case like this. If Signal is ever breached, or has some sort of a backdoor, they'll likely only use it against the likes of Snowden, for "national security" reasons.
- jdelman 3y agoIt's wrong to call using a privacy preserving messaging app "destroying evidence".
- wobfan 3y agoWhy? It's just another perspective? It's not Signal's or encryptions fault (although many politicians will frame it like that), but it's JBs and employees fault to use it, and to set it up to remove messages in a given timeframe. Which, in this case, is probably "destroying evidence in a given timeframe".
- ath3nd 3y agoI hate Amazon executives as much as the next guy, but apps like Signal are not the problem, nor is e2e encryption. The FTC should have some other way to collect evidence. Like getting a warrant to obtain their phones, or old-fashion bug their home.