3 ms·
Tesla Autopilot feature was involved in 13 fatal crashes, US regulator says
- dools 3y agoIt does seem rather ridiculous that they’re allowed to call this feature either autopilot or full self driving beta.
- BugsJustFindMe 3y agoOh, I don't know. When my brain is on autopilot I'm prone to accidents too.
- sjrjsksjf 3y ago[flagged]
- madamelic 3y agoEven if self-driving is 1% better in the best conditions, that's a safer car than one driven entirely by humans. Humans right now are the best they'll ever be at driving, you can't say the same for self-driving cars. Even for a mediocre solution currently, it's likely better to use the self-driving in good conditions than drive it manually. Computers never get tired, distracted, or emotional. What the humans' jobs are is to understand when it is a good condition for self-driving and when isn't it. I'd venture to guess these fatal self-driving accidents are one of the following: - freak accidents (ie: not the self-driving cars fault / it would've happened either way) - accidents due to humans trusting the car too much (ie: we aren't level 5, be available to take over) - the self-driving just being bad. This is the category a lot of people want these to be. To get really morbid in my full-throated apology: cars are really dangerous. People die in car accidents all the time. The main reason these get attention is because it is notable. It's unfortunately not nationally notable when an entire family gets wiped out on their way to their child's soccer game in a non self-driving car.
- dools 3y agoBut the article specifically says that the features contributed to the accident in foreseeable ways. Meaning that a human without the feature would not have had the accident. It may well be a power user problem, ie. it makes you better if you use it properly but otherwise makes it worse.
- dools 3y agoI actually think it was just a joke. Acknowledgingthat FSB and autopilot are accident prone and therefore appropriately named.
- BugsJustFindMe 3y agoThis is correct.
- al_borland 3y agoIt seems like this number need context. Ideally computers would never make mistakes, but are these numbers better than a human driver? By how much? I see people distracted and not paying attention every time I drive, and they don’t have anything in the car helping them. The only reason they don’t hit me is because I moved out of the way when they come in my lane.
- this_user 3y agoThe real question is how many fatal accidents have been prevented by Autopilot.
- sjrjsksjf 3y agoThe root cause to problem is more important precisely because people will decide to recontextualise statistically to justify their poor performance. In good faith and bad
- hnlmorg 3y agoAgreed though it’s also worth noting that every time an autopilot fatality hits the news it’s combined with the driver also not paying attention. Often it’s claimed that the driver isn’t paying attention because of their faith in autopilot. And that is the real issue. Even Tesla themselves say it shouldn’t be relied upon, despite what their marketing suggests.
- vagrantJin 3y agoSuch being the case, a person recklessly endangering your life can and will be held to account. Im afraid human lives perishing because of a bug in the software is less than tolerable. Who can hold the software to account? The court? Internal QA? If these systems actually did the hard part of driving, avoid crashes with super-human reaction times - then they would be extremely valuable. But that's not the case and they are essentially worthless. Might as well hire a driver for you of you feel driving isn't for you. Save you and the whole planet the trouble until these systems actually do the stuff that matters.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- x86x87 3y ago> After closing the first investigation, regulators opened another, this one into whether that recall to install new Autopilot safeguards was adequate. Tesla in a nutshell.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40170135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40170135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40171540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40171540
- mrkandy 3y ago3,855/278,870,463 = 0.00138% - average for all 13/6,000,000 = 0.00021% - average per tesla
- 7e 3y agoAre you trolling, or a pro-Tesla bot? It's not 13 fatalities. It's 13 incidents involving a total of 29 deaths. https://www.tesladeaths.com https://www.tesladeaths.com has the total fatality account involving Slaugherpilot at 42. Also, you're omitting all the deaths in Teslas for which it hasn't yet been proven that "Autopilot" was involved. Teslas are driven my more affluent people, are newer, and incorporate safer non-Autopilot tech. than the average car. Finally, 6M is the worldwide number of cars Tesla has sold, which you're comparing to a U.S. count of non-Teslas.
- 7e 3y agotesladeaths.com has the total number of Tesla fatalities, from any cause, at 500.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoThe math is wrong but the idea isn't wrong. Its never going to be zero, what matters is how it compares to humans driving.
- olliej 3y agoIt remains absurd that we have a mechanism that n the road to allow self driving” cars, but only if there’s a person in the drivers seat that has greater focus and skill than an airline pilot.