4 ms·
TikTok owner has strong First Amendment case against US ban, professors say
- Simulacra 3y agoBut TikTok was not banned… Nor was this about speech. It was about Chinese CCP ownership and control. If the CCP divests and sells it to an American company, TikTok will live on.
- starttoaster 3y agoCan't you argue that stifling speech is as bad as all out forbidding it? And if it's about CCP ownership and control, I guess we should probably institute a ban on relying on China for anything at all, including building all of the cell phones kids watch TikTok from. Interesting how the narrative is that social media can only be a thing if it's controlled by an entity that the US government can effectively bully into violating our privacy domestically. This doesn't strike you as a plain old case of common xenophobia, does it? Citizens in the US will mock other countries for censoring the internet, but this doesn't strike me as all that different from that.
- zardo 3y agoThe actual criteria is greater than 20% ownership by: (A) a foreign person that is domiciled in, is headquartered in, has its principal place of business in, or is organized under the laws of a foreign adversary country;
- nasdaq-txn 3y agoI assume this means the law would also force sales of WeChat and VK in the US as well?
- yogorenapan 3y agoThe bill doesn’t, but it should. Banning all apps owned by adversaries like China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and Palestine would make it fair
- wrsh07 3y agoI'm not sure why you're being downvoted. The law doesn't ban TikTok. It was written carefully with the doj, and being passed by Congress holds real weight vs an executive order (as it should!)
- Simulacra 3y agoA lot of people like TikTok and I would venture most of HN falls in that. People want what they want and when it becomes threatened they get angry.
- corimaith 3y agoI do think some of these people here probably don't have the best interests of the US in mind. The reaction to this, calling out "hypocrisy" or essentially insulting Congress does nothing to assuage the central question of whether TikTok is a national security threat. It's only going to make those with suspicions dig their heels in deeper.
- starttoaster 3y agoExplain how it is a national security threat, and I can start to work on explaining why it isn’t.
- troll_v_bridge 3y agoLet’s flip it, explain why US social media is not a national security threat to China.
- falcolas 3y agoWhile not written as a de jure ban, it is a de facto ban. China has said from the earliest ban attempts under Trump that they would not allow the divestment of Chinese interests. Legislators knew this - they knew that the divestment would never happen, and so in my eyes, they wrote ban into law with a thin veneer of distraction.
- janalsncm 3y agoAnd one of the consequences of TikTok not divesting would be banning it. So if banning TikTok is illegal, that removes the entire reason they would divest.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tayo42 3y ago> While the Chinese government engaging in propaganda is a problem, "we need to address that as a government propaganda problem, and not just limited to China," Don't disagree with that. But I don't get why TikTok the company gets speech. The company it self isn't saying anything. Its just providing a way for people to share their message. Individual them selves aren't being told they cant share. They can still make videos.
- dc_ist 3y agoCorporate personhood for me but not for thee?
- allturtles 3y agoAFAIU from the article, the 1st amendment argument is not about the company, it's about the users. Quoting from the article: > Molloy's ruling said that without TikTok, "User Plaintiffs are deprived of communicating by their preferred means of speech, and thus First Amendment scrutiny is appropriate."
- wrsh07 3y agoI don't really understand why banning one short form video platform infringes on speech. Wouldn't that mean banning any web 2.0 platform infringes on my speech if I use that platform? Regardless of why the platform might be banned? There's no way that holds water
- cute_boi 3y agoTiktok is a platform used by millions of people, and it acts like a news site for many people. Banning it due to unproved national security problem kinda make it speech problem. If web 2.0 like facebook was banned for national security issue I think it would be first amendment problem. We haven't banned rt.com yet.
- wrsh07 3y ago"unproved national security problem" and yet Congress was fairly well galvanized to vote for this bill after their intelligence briefings - multiple senators seem to want the briefing declassified: https://www.npr.org/2024/03/21/1239691465/tiktok-ban-bill-senate https://www.npr.org/2024/03/21/1239691465/tiktok-ban-bill-se... Say what you want about the US government, Americans vote for them and their job is to synthesize the information brought to them and take action. The Senate obviously wasn't as overwhelmingly enthusiastic about this bill as the house, but it sure seems like people on capital hill saw something concerning. We should all probably want this information to be declassified so we can judge it for ourselves, but until then it feels unjustified to say there is no basis for the national security concern
- troll_v_bridge 3y agoAs long as US social media is banned in China, they don’t have much legal ground, as it can be seen as a tit for tat trade embargo / national security
- delichon 3y agoI'm not finding a game theory exception to the first amendment.
- troll_v_bridge 3y agoA Chinese company, you just found one.
- nasdaq-txn 3y ago"Amendment I Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." Not seeing exceptions for a tit for tat trade embargo or a Chinese company here.
- troll_v_bridge 3y agoHuawei is an example. Foreign companies don’t have the same rights, in large part because of national security concerns. For example is the concern is that a China is trying to infringe on American rights, such as using algorithms, then it’s a moot argument to say TikTok is protected by us law.
- falcolas 3y ago> China is trying to infringe on American rights, such as using algorithms There is no constitutionally protected right for American citizens to not be subjected to propaganda. In fact, it's quite the opposite, since propaganda has been specifically identified as a form of speech protected by the first amendment.
- janalsncm 3y agoThis will be really interesting if it makes it to SCOTUS. They really don’t like pitting two principles against each other. In this case it would be national security and First Amendment protections. They will try to find any reason why this doesn’t really fit on procedural grounds or some limited circumstances. As a layperson I find the oral arguments surprisingly accessible. Oyez even has them in podcast format. All of the justices ask sharp questions despite media loving to portray them as clowns or partisan hacks.
- threatofrain 3y agoTensions between fundamental values is exactly what top courts are for!
- avmich 3y ago> All of the justices ask sharp questions despite media loving to portray them as clowns or partisan hacks. The intent of laws is to be understandable at specifying and clear in application. If it takes efforts of highly professional people to determine the application and explain the rationale - the latter part often not really done - then those sharp questions aren't worth much, and loving to portray as clowns gets quite old and turns into hopeless illustrations of the lost of reason in the important activity. > They really don’t like pitting two principles against each other. They shouldn't have any animosity here. If two principles do conflict, it's not the judges' job to invent a solution - they have to uncover the conflict, make it visible - a sort of a bug report - and apply some decision, with all caveats clearly stated.
- janalsncm 3y agoIt’s not that you have to be professional to understand, it’s that professionals reliably do. The vast majority of Americans can’t even name what the Bill of Rights does, or what the enumerated powers of Congress are, for example. It’s not that these are inaccessible pieces of knowledge, but people aren’t aware of them. With a basic grounding in civics and after brushing up on the laws in question, I think most people could follow along.
- akomtu 3y agoI want to see how the TikTok owner sends its representative - a high ranked CCP officer - to defend TikTok in the US court.
- silverquiet 3y agoI assume they'll have no problem finding American Ivy League Lawyers willing to represent the company in court for a handsome fee.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]