4 ms·
Tesla's 2M car Autopilot recall is now under federal scrutiny
- drcode 3y agoAmusing that they went with a photo from 2014 to illustrate the article
- landonxjames 3y agoI believe 2014 is the model year of that Tesla, it seems like that particular crash was in 2018. https://incidentdatabase.ai/cite/320/ https://incidentdatabase.ai/cite/320/
- LeafItAlone 3y agoIt says > A 2014 Tesla Model S the vehicle is a 2014. The photo is of a Jan 2018 crash https://www.ocregister.com/2019/09/04/ntsb-tesla-autopilot-let-driver-rely-too-much-on-automation/amp/ https://www.ocregister.com/2019/09/04/ntsb-tesla-autopilot-l...
- grecy 3y ago> The photo is of a Jan 2018 crash So still more than 5 years out of date. Would you accept a photo of a 5 year old iPhone on an article about some iPhone limitation? Would you accept a photo of a 5 year old version of Uber on an article about some Uber limitation? Would you accept a photo of a 5 year old robot vaccum on an article about some robot vac limitation? These things all change drastically each year. Five years ago is ancient history, and it's kind of silly to think "evidence" that is more than 5 years old has any bearing on how things perform now.
- Dylan16807 3y agoIt's a picture of a crashed car. Unless you're claiming the system doesn't crash now, a picture from 2018 is just as good as a picture from last week. It's not a main piece of evidence, it's an example. The evidence is in the text of the article where it talks about hundreds of crashes. As to your questions, as long as the issue in the article applies to the model in the picture, all of those are fine. I'd want a newer picture for phones because they cycle so fast but it wouldn't be a big deal. A crashed 4 year old 2014 model and a crashed 10 year old 2014 model look the same.
- grecy 3y agoIt's like showing a video of an iPhone taking ages to load a web page or a very grainy photo that it took.. but it's from a 5 year old iPhone. FSD has come a LONG way in 5 years. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43Lrrhn0CMk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43Lrrhn0CMk
- FireBeyond 3y ago> It's like showing a video of an iPhone taking ages to load a web page or a very grainy photo that it took LOL. The disclaimer "Sequences Shortened" on ads came about because of other manufacturer complaints to the FTC about very early iPhone ads very much editing sequences to make the iPhone look faster than it was. > FSD has come a LONG way in 5 years. And has an even longer way to go. Usable means things like driving in Pittsburgh in winter at night, not "hey, look, it no longer causes near misses attempting to figure out a roundabout in suburban California in the middle of the day".
- grecy 3y agoWhy are you changing the topic and moving the goal posts?
- reitzensteinm 3y agoYour first comment in this thread moved the goal posts from 2014 to 2018. Now you say we aren't allowed to move goal posts? That's, like, meta goal post moving, man.
- grecy 3y agoWhere did I say anything about 2014? I was saying that comparing a product from 2018 to what is available today is dishonest.
- Dylan16807 3y agoIt's more like showing someone holding the iPhone taking a picture. Unless you're saying the way it crashes is qualitatively different now, in a way that you can see just looking at the car afterwards? They're not showing it in action. Also that's an Autopilot crash, not FSD.
- altairprime 3y agoThe investigation conclusions are just over one page long and are plainly written: https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INCLA-EA22002-14498.pdf https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INCLA-EA22002-14498.pd... [pdf]
- jycr753 3y ago[flagged]
- loudmax 3y agoIf Tesla hadn't named their driver assistance system "Autopilot" they would have saved so much trouble (not to mention lives).
- lukan 3y agoAutopilots in planes maintain altitude and speed and no landing or evasion. But full self driving was a broken promise.
- spamizbad 3y agoSure, but there's an expectation that an automobile will be driven by virtually any adult that can pass a basic driving test. An airplane requires extensive training and certification.
- bombcar 3y agoAutoland exists - but it's potentially more like calling a trim wheel "autopilot" or an ILS system "autoland".
- kwhitefoot 3y agoAutopilot is not FSD.
- wil421 3y ago[deleted]
- ahahahahah 3y agoThat's a really dumb argument when the research exists explaining exactly how people understand autopilot in the context of cars.
- tgma 3y agoI can see you can potentially argue (unsuccessfully IMHO) that it is marketing fraud in inducing purchases of the vehicle, but I don't buy it that a single person who actually owns the vehicle and have driven on Autopilot for more than a week is confused by the abilities of the system because the name is Autopilot. People text and drive _all the time_ on their ICE carriages without Autopilot too. Thus the claim that renaming it would have saved a life, let alone lives, is simply sensationalism.
- psunavy03 3y agoAt some point, I just don't get how a lot of this is Tesla's problem. I'll buy that they should have called it something other than "Autopilot" and "Full Self Driving." But ultimately if it's in the manual saying "this is not fully automated and you must pay attention to the road," it should be on the driver to be held liable for abusing the system. Sure, go after Tesla if the system endangers people via spurious inputs or dangerous maneuvers. But it's also not Tesla's responsibility to nanny people any more than alcohol manufacturers are held liable for drunk driving. If some idiot zones out on their phone or tries to "drive" from the back seat, their negligence is not Tesla's responsibility. Self-driving systems shouldn't need all these "are you paying attention" bells and whistles. Just hammer the people who abuse them with reckless driving charges.
- vasco 3y ago> Just hammer the people who abuse them with reckless driving charges. That surely helps the now dead people they crash into. The manufacturer can prevent deaths by adding safety features, so it should to a reasonable extent.
- psunavy03 3y agoSo we are also going to require breathalyzer interlocks on everyone's car as well?
- whoknowsidont 3y agoHonestly not opposed to this.
- kbenson 3y agoWhy are we even going there when the article, and the NHTSA report note some very easy first steps? As Ars has noted time and again, Tesla's Autopilot system has a more permissive operational design domain than any comparable driver-assistance system that still requires the driver to keep their hands on the wheel and their eyes on the road, and NHTSA's report adds that "Autopilot invited greater driver confidence via its higher control authority and ease of engagement."
- FireBeyond 3y agoOne of the big things to remember from all of this is that "if airbags do not deploy, Tesla does not consider it an accident" when it is touting its (already inaccurate and misleading for other reasons) "safety". As an automobile manufacturer, there is no good conscience reasoning that Tesla is unaware that active restraint and airbag systems of today are far more nuanced and weigh multiple criteria when deciding to deploy (as compared to initial/early implementations, which were essentially "if collision=true and speed >= X mph then deploy"). You can have a very significant incident (two that I've witnessed recently as a paramedic involved vehicles into stationary objects at ~30mph) without airbag deployment. But if that was a Tesla in FSD that hit something at 30mph and didn't deploy airbags, well, that's not an accident according to Tesla. That also doesn't account for "incident was so catastrophic that restraint systems could not deploy", also "not counted" by Tesla. Or just as egregious, "systems failed to deploy for any reason up to and including poor assembly line quality control", also not an accident and also "not counted".
- Veserv 3y agoTo wit, "incident was so catastrophic that restraint systems could not deploy"/"incident was so catastrophic it could not report" is not theoretical. In fact it is the case in the majority (yes, majority) of reported conclusively fatal crashes [1]. [1] https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/ffdd/sgo-2021-01/SGO-2021-01_Incident_Reports_ADAS.csv https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/ffdd/sgo-2021-01/SGO-2021-01_In...
- bottlepalm 3y agoI'd rather be driving on the road with Autopilot cars than the impatient drivers, road ragers, distracted people on their phone, and people who drive like they're in a video game. I drive with it on 95% on the time, and I really only need to interrupt when it's too slow and too cautious.
- grecy 3y agoDon't forget all the drunk, high & exhausted drivers too. 100 people are killed every single day on the roads in the US. Day in and day out.
- kurthr 3y agoI generally agree it does great on freeways, but not in urban situations where there are tight corners and lots of parked cars, or rural areas with twisty roads and farm equipment. I'd turn it off in construction areas too.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoIt straight up useless in urban areas. Even some country roads that are too windy/hilly it will become more of a babysit than yourself. I agree on highway. Easily 95% use, likely more.
- bottlepalm 3y agoWhat are you talking about? It works amazing off highway. I use it all day long. Have you used v12?
- dzhiurgis 3y agoWe're talking Autopilot, not FSD
- bottlepalm 3y agoI'm the OP, and I'm talking about FSD. Sorry if that wasn't implied when I said I drive with it on 95% of the time. On all road types. It does great in construction areas as well.
- d_theorist 3y agoThe relevant metric should be accident rate per million miles driven. What is the rate with autopilot vs without autopilot.
- HPsquared 3y agoNot all "miles driven" are the same. Autopilot is going to be engaged on highway driving which already has a lower accident rate per mile driven. So that biases a simple comparison. Edit: and even within highway miles, autopilot will be enabled more in the "easy" stretches and turned off in roadworks etc.
- FireBeyond 3y agoPrecisely. If these systems aren't or can't be engaged on a Pittsburgh street at night in a whiteout, then I don't much care. Tesla jukes the stats by "Oh, this won't go well, so we're not even going to try", which isn't an option for human drivers, short of "don't drive at all".
- Someone 3y agoOn similar roads, in similar traffic, in similar weather. If you look at fatalities or define “accident” as cases where somebody had to visit a doctor or something like that, you also need to compare to similar cars. Most self-driving cars are relatively new and relatively large, and both decrease those (probably even accident rate because they statistically have newer brakes and tires and have more active safety features) It’s far from trivial to decide whether some program is a better driver than the average human driver if the program gets the newer bigger car and can decide to cop out in cases where we do not expect humans to do so.
- d_theorist 3y agoI agree you need to control for other factors. But I don't think that is particularly beyond the wit of man.
- lurkingmba 3y ago
- outside1234 3y agoThis whole company is going to collapse into an Enron isn't it?
- jdminhbg 3y agoProbably not, no.
- londons_explore 3y ago> , it only records an accident if the airbags deploy, I've often wondered if Tesla is gaming the figures by only deploying the airbags in really bad crashes, whereas other manufacturers might deploy the airbags for pretty minor bumps. This in turn makes them look really good on 'number of accidents where airbags deploy'.
- bangaladore 3y agoThe IIHS has repeatedly shown that Tesla airbags are the best in class. Deploying airbags when not needed can do significant harm to occupants. Not to mention total vehicles for no good reason. There isn't a need to wonder when independent data gatherers have already answered the question.
- londons_explore 3y agoIt can be best in class, yet still rarely deploy... It can even be best in class when tested, rarely deploy, and save more lives than competitors. It just needs to correctly detect cases like this[1]. [1]: https://youtu.be/MTX0MvqBqL0?t=10 https://youtu.be/MTX0MvqBqL0?t=10
- bangaladore 3y agoYou claim that Tesla is gaming the system. I'm not aware of a definition of gaming in which the system is overall safer or equivalently safer than other top-tier competitors. That seems objectively better than deploying airbags when they will harm the occupants or total the vehicle when not-needed.
- chucksta 3y agoIt only makes sense if everyone else is gaming the system, and then it just proves it's still the best lol.
- thenewnewguy 3y agoTesla is not gaming the system by having a good airbag system that only deploys when necessary (that's actually really good!). Tesla is gaming the system by excluding accidents where the airbags don't deploy from the "Autopilot/FSD accidents" dataset, thus artificially deflating the number of accidents.
- londons_explore 3y ago> a portion of the remedy both requires the owner to opt in and allows a driver to readily reverse it I think ~all recalls are opt-in. The owner of the car can simply not bother taking the car in to the garage, turn off auto updates, etc. It would be funny if Tesla decides to separate out software updates for 'recalls' vs software updates for new features, and lets users have the new features without installing the 'nannying' recall fixes. In most cases it would be easy to implement via feature flags.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40170135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40170135