7 ms·
Palm OS and the devices that ran it
- moolcool 3y agoPalm OS never got the respect it deserved IMO. I had a Palm device in 2003 which had a camera, app support, and audio/video playback. The Palm Treo line existed in 2002 too, and that added cellular connectivity to the mix. Apple gets a lot of credit for pulling the idea of a modern idea of a smartphone out of thin air, but if you look at the interface of even the earliest Palm devices almost a decade earlier, so much of it was right there.
- acdha 3y agoGranted, Apple’s Newton was there before Palm, too, and that work fed into the iPod and iPhone designs. I think it’s a great lesson in how some ideas need time to gel – in this case, you needed multiple generations of improvements on the hardware to get not only viable CPUs but also things like screens with accurate and responsive digitizers to make the UI feel right. PalmOS had some nice features but it was also an old design with unprotected memory so it crashed enough to be annoying and even when the mobile CPUs were ready the software was a huge undertaking. On the social side, we also needed a big shift in usage. When the Palm or Newton designs were being made, wireless networking wasn’t common the way it is now and especially people weren’t used to using software the way we take for granted now. Email was a novelty for most people, business documents were exchanged physically, and mobile gaming was a kid’s pastime. The big thing which made the iPhone 1 so appealing was that everyone had spent the previous decade finding things they wanted to do on the web and then you could take that with you anywhere. People who were looking at the traditional PDA usage thought it’d fail since it didn’t have a Blackberry keyboard.
- throwaway74354 3y agoHandspring documentary by the Verge had an interesting perspective on the matter: https://youtu.be/b9_Vh9h3Ohw?start=773 https://youtu.be/b9_Vh9h3Ohw?start=773 (I'm bad at cropping YouTube videos. The part in question is [12:53 - 14:30])
- rbanffy 3y agoApple doesn't deserve credit for inventing the smartphone the same way Palm doesn't deserve the credit for inventing the touch-based PDA, but both companies made products that hit the perfect spot - the Palm was much cheaper than the Newton and the Zoomer, aiming much lower, and proved to be just enough computer to carry around. The iPhone was far less capable than a Windows CE (or a Palm) phone back then, but was a joy to use (unlike its competition).
- j45 3y agoAgreed. Apple does deserve credit for making the best device ever for beginners. Apple is very good at making things for beginners who are not super technical.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThese were truly ground breaking devices. I miss palm os and wish they didn't wait until Apple ate their lunch. The then ceo Ed colligan said something to the effect of, "how are the music player people going to make cell phones?" And the rest is history.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gelstudios 3y agoI'm trying to avoid sounding overly nostalgic about Palm OS but it really was a nice personal computer. This snippet highlights the focus on UX (beyond the look and feel!), and as creators I think many of us can relate to (and maybe remind others...) how great products require deliberate care in design AND implentation. > The user interface received particular scrutiny. Hawkins set firm limits that any slow operation be reworked instead of showing a busy indicator, and explicit error messages should be avoided. Graffiti was a given because handwriting had to work, as no physical keyboard would have fit at the time. Mindful of how unusual such a device would be to many users, Ed Colligan declared that Touchdown should “delight the customer,” and developer Rob Haitani established a design theory he grandly christened the “Zen of Palm"
- HeckFeck 3y agoFun little devices, really outgrew its origins as a business organiser to the point that a 13 year old me demanded one. Sure, I had a Gameboy, but I wanted a portable computer with real programs, dammit! I still have my Zire 31. Some day I will take it out of the drawer and savour the remains of my neglected island civilisation in Village Sim, before jumping into a spaceship and trading highly profitable goods in Space Trader. Then I'll enjoy some low bitrate YouTube rips in Kinoma Video, the few I could cram onto the 64MB SD card...
- alexisread 3y agoIf you'd been able to buy a Psion 3 (or even better 5) you'd have got your wish, they came with OPL to write on the device :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psion_Series_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psion_Series_3
- jhbadger 3y agoThere were on-device development systems for Palm as well. I remember playing with Chipmunk Basic that even had access to some UI elements so you could have working buttons and dialogue boxes in your programs.
- metabagel 3y agoI immediately looked for a comment on Space Trader. What a fun game that was! I feel like FTL is a direct descendant. I retired to my own moon a couple of times at least.
- brnt 3y agoTossing my Zire 31 is one of those things I still regret.
- lycos 3y agoI loved Palm since my first, the IIIe SE and have had many of their other later devices too. I was even invited to the launch party of the Zire 71 with it's cool slide out mechanism! Oh and the Tungsten|T when it could finally play MP3s was very neat, and another sliding mechanism making it more compact. Ah memories, well back to my non-distinctive slab of glass. I was also interested in the Sony CLIÉ's running PalmOS but never tried one. And of course the Psion's also seemed really cool but never landed its way in my hands.
- alexey-salmin 3y agoClie was quite good, first 320x320 device I got back then
- uxjw 3y agoI loved the Clié for the built-in camera. Not sure that the quality was much better than the old Sony cameras with built-in floppy disk drives though.
- navjack27 3y agoI love and miss the Dragonball era of Palm devices. Before arm. Very cool devices.
- etimberg 3y agoI remember buying a used Zire 72 off a friend in highschool. Was a great device; I think I still have it sitting in a box somewhere
- bayindirh 3y agoI had a Handspring Neo and organized the heck out of my life with it. Read books, played games, kept things organized, etc. Had a 128MB CF card extension on it, so it had "infinite memory" for that time. Then I got a Palm LifeDrive for the fun of it, however I had a smartphone at that time, it was just a retrocomputing device. I still miss Palm. They were so good.
- deltarholamda 3y agoWish they had talked a bit more my favorite Palm OS device, the Tapwave Zodiac. It had a nice big screen, was very durable, and while the game selection wasn't exactly robust, it was still fun. And it worked just fine as a Palm OS device. Played video quite well too. It was an excellent machine all around. I still have my Tungsten E2 with the WiFi SD card, though the WiFi only works with WEP. I kept a crappy old WiFi router with WEP on it as a bridge just to allow the Tungsten to connect for a long time.
- mactyler 3y agoTapwave Zodiac was really ahead of its time, great couple years I had with that thing and the community surrounding it.
- steve1977 3y agoI had a Treo 650 before I had an iPhone and always thought of the iPhone as an evolution, not a revolution. The reason that I switched was that I was mainly using Mac OS X on the desktop at that time, so using iPhone OS (as it was called then) as a companion was kind of a no-brainer. However, in hindsight, even more than Palm OS I actually miss Pocket PC.
- j45 3y agoAgreed. The revolution part was a smartphone for the masses instead of the super interested. It was so easy anyone could use it, and they sure did.
- ChickeNES 3y agoI don't agree actually, having used various mobile devices, including a Palm III, Jornada 548, Visor Pro, and the Samsung Blackjack 1 and 2. Sure, they had some nice features (and gimmicks) but the ease of use outside of the basic PIM apps left much to be desired, the screens were mediocre at best, and mobile web browsers on Pocket PC and the Blackjacks were at best good only for checking news/weather. I still remember watching the iPhone keynote livestream and being absolutely blown away, only settling for the Samsung because my parents didn't want to splurge (probably for the best, as I lost the 1 and got a 2 as the replacement). In my second year of college I lucked out and a friend sold me her iPhone with a shattered front glass, and with a bit of surgery I repaired it and used it until the launch of the 3GS. After that I never looked back (well, now I collect vintage PDAs so that's not /entirely/ true heh). Don't get me wrong the other devices were (and are!) fun to tinker with, but for something I use every day and depend on like a phone I just want it to work.
- steve1977 3y agoI actually had a Jornada 548 as well! Of course web browsing was “inferior” compared to an iPhone, but the Jornada also got released 7 years earlier. You could argue that the web itself wasn’t really useable beyond checking the news and weather back then (not saying it is today, but that’s another story). Also keep in mind that iPhone OS didn’t even have downloadable apps initially.
- brnt 3y agoI miss how production focused those applications were. There's some really good apps on F-Droid, but it's clear those apps come from a different community. PalmOS apps were for people trying to automate the boring or laborious bits of a working day at an office, F-droid productivity apps are for programmers on HN ;)
- no_wizard 3y agoI liked PalmOS, but I want to give a shoutout specifically to WebOS, which I felt was ahead of its time, both in concept and execution, in terms of what it could do and its potential. An entire OS built around web technologies, has not only proven to be something people would have gravitated toward (given the prevalence of React Native, NativeScript, Ionic et. al.), I also felt it looked beautiful and for its time, it was very snappy. Unfortunately, it took them too long to acknowledge and figure out touchscreens, and by then they had dwindled their capital to such a point that a buyout was their only hope of surviving at any rate, and their touch screen phone never shipped. HP buying them out was the worst thing that could have happened, they had no resolve to sustain the phone market, which was and is incredibly competitive. I do feel though, with sustained investment and prioritization, that WebOS could have supplanted Android, particularly if they licensed it (which I think was ultimately what Palm needed to do. Their hardware was never the secret sauce). FireFox OS was also a valiant attempt at something similar, but Mozilla couldn't quite get it where it needed to be, unfortunately. disclosure: this is a very biased take, very much my opinions, but I look forward to discussion! EDIT: To clarify, what I mean by 'figuring out touchscreens' is using one as the primary modality of interaction, sans any hardware inputs (like a hardware keyboard). For instance, the Pre had a touch screen, but no onscreen keyboard, so to type anything into it, you had to slide up the screen.
- pavlov 3y ago> "their touch screen phone never shipped" You're perhaps misremembering Palm's webOS hardware. Touch was always part of the platform. The first device, Palm Pre launched in 2009, had a multitouch screen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palm_Pre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palm_Pre
- no_wizard 3y agoI edited my comment to clarify, however to do so here: what I mean is they didn't adopt the touchscreen paradigms, such as onscreen keyboards. The Pre required you to use the hardware keyboard, and had no virtual keyboard functionality built in. It lead to some odd interaction patterns. My recollection - which could be wrong - is that Palm did pivot to pure multi-touch interactions but it was never released, as HP largely gave up on the phone market by that time.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoI feel the pad is the modern pda, but it has been stuffed too much and is usually too large and heavy. Do we have a modern non iOS non Android (Android's app env is a disaster) product?
- pavlov 3y agoWhat would be the selling point for a non-phone, non-Android standalone PDA today? I'm trying hard to imagine what it could do, but drawing a blank. It wouldn't be meaningfully smaller or lighter than a phone, it would be bigger than a smartwatch, and it wouldn't have any of the apps that people are used to.
- RetroTechie 3y agoBattery life? If modest cpu, lightweight OS + e-paper screen, for example. Oh wait... that's e-reader territory. Could make for a nice tablet alternative though, if coupled with a decent library of apps.
- pavlov 3y agoBut where do the apps come from, if not Android? The bar for PDA software is considerably higher than in 1997. Even just a calendar needs cloud integrations and instant smart search and whatever. Email is a much bigger can of worms. Developing that software suite on a non-Android platform seems like a lot of work for something that would still leave many users disappointed to find features missing.
- dmitrygr 3y agohttps://dmitry.gr/?r=05.Projects&proj=27.%20rePalm https://dmitry.gr/?r=05.Projects&proj=27.%20rePalm
- ckz 3y agoI switched back to PalmOS for my daily mobile computing a couple of years ago, so I think I've given it time for the nostalgia effect to wear off. It's still incredibly fun and absolutely doable. To the article's point, what we do with modern devices today is just another iteration of what these do. For the average modern app/SaaS, there's a very often a Palm app that did the same thing in 2002. There's also still active exploration in the Palm space (ARM board swaps, new expansion modules for the Visor, apps in-dev from several folks including myself). Happy to provide recommendations.
- jhbadger 3y agoThere was even an external GPS module that you could get for the Palm (using offline maps that you could sync). I felt so cyberpunkish carrying the combo around and navigating cities on foot with directions -- basically what anyone can do today with Google Maps on their phone, but this was over twenty years ago!
- sintezcs 3y agoWow, that’s cool! Can you share a bit more details about your day to day usage of Palm? Are you using any third-party apps? If yes, where did you get them? Do you sync your palm with your PC?
- ckz 3y agoSure thing! Third party apps yes (see: palmdb.net), but obviously not typical 3rd party services (no Spotify, etc.). I mostly use a few models of Handspring Visor, typically grayscale, so not even the latest OS. Visor Edge for something as thin and sleek as a modern phone. Visor Neo if I want expandability (similar to pg6-7 in the Ars article). There's a fun module that adds both more memory and a vibrate motor for alarms, but I'll swap that out for a camera or mp3 module at times. Charge or swap batteries once or twice a month. Common tasks: * Notes, To Dos, Contacts, Calendar (excellent stock calendar, per @j45 above) * Alarms & Reminders (stock + Diddlebug, which lets you draw/write notes w/ a timer) * Offline browsing (Plucker can crawl pages and sync them) * Weather (note: cached on sync because my Palm doesn't have wifi) * Calorie tracking * Games (we have a Wordle port!) * Longform writing - I have a foldable keyboard and usually use plaintext, but there are word processing apps that save to HTML if you want. I also often write on an Alphasmart Neo, which can IR beam back and forth with the Palm and PC. * Personal project tracking/flows * Photos (technically video too, but only have 8MB memory for everything) I have newer PDAs too that can natively handle things like voice recording, cameras, video playback, etc., but I really like the grayscale ones. A late Clié like a VZ90 or some of the others in this thread will have more bells and whistles (even OLED!). Note also that all of the above is a more manual process than modern phones (and more manual today than it was then, because Outlook supported Palms in 2002 unlike now). If you use Google Calendar I think you can still sync, but if there's an important work meeting that I want in my pocket in addition to the laptop--I do the little ritual of adding it myself.
- sirtaj 3y agoThese days it's fashionable to say that your database is not an app integration interface, but imo Palm OS did this right. Having a single, omnipresent DB with published schema for important PIM databases was a pretty great thing for apps operating on common data, or just structured data in general. It's taken sqlite's ubiquity for the benefits of an always-available platform DBMS to become well-known again, but the common tables paradigm has only come back in an ad-hoc way (eg addressbook and calendar in Android).
- Apocryphon 3y agoI'm a bit disappointed that this discussion thread has mostly been about nostalgia (which is great) and not the technical details TFA brings up. Really curious about the "everything is a database" concept and how it contrasts with other operating systems. Based on the article it sounds like the choice to design Palm OS like that was because of "strongly influenced by the classic Mac OS," and for "computing memory consumption"?
- sirtaj 3y agoThe "everything is a database" took two forms. First, apps had no filesystem available, only a database which they could use as a datastore. It was not a particularly powerful or fancy database, everything had to be done via the C++ API rather than a query language IIRC. But it simplified app development quite a bit and made the apps smaller and more robust. Second, there was a set of common tables available to all apps that provided the basic PIM data, including addresses, calendar, todo, email and notes. This meant that third party apps could safely interoperate with this data alongside the builtin apps and extend functionality.
- kalleboo 3y agoIt was also pretty cool how they included the original versions of all the built-in PIM apps as sample code in their SDK. It meant that there was a huge amount of "Datebook+" or "Memos+" type apps that was just the built-in app plus some handy features the developer wanted themselves, without the developer having to re-invent the wheel (culminating in some fantastic advanced apps like Datebk4)
- liotier 3y agoPrimitive as they were, Palm OS devices were amazingly fast. Some programs pushed the envelope too far, so their slowness relegated them to proof of concept - but the bread and butter applications offered instant interaction: my lowly Pilot 1000 was absolutely snappy, switching from calendar to agenda and searching among my contacts - never a perceptible delay and no unnecessary user manipulation... Optimized ! A similar feeling when migrating from 3270 forms to HTML forms: infinitely more functional, but still - some of the "all business and not one unnecessary gram" streamlined optimum got lost along the way. I miss my Palm Pilot 1000, I miss my Treo 650. I know they don't do a hundredth of what my cheap Android does - but I'm nostalgic nevertheless.
- gunapologist99 3y agoAgreed! To be fair, Androids still don't last more than two weeks on a pair of AAA batteries though!
- j45 3y agoStill, what the palm did it did with a lot of focus on helping users be more productive.
- billfor 3y agoI loved being able to go a month without charging or changing batteries. I don’t know if there is currently anything on the market than can run for a month on its own.
- crims0n 3y agoThe opening line strikes a nerve... gadgets really are no longer fun. Everything has been virtualized and abstracted away into a sleek, inoffensive, but boring rectangle we are forced to carry around everywhere.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI got the out-of-print book Piloting Palm as research for my book. You can get a used copy for about $9. (it's co-written by David Pogue, the guy you see on PBS all the time) Shameless self-promotion: This New Internet Thing, by the way, will be free to read in serial form! Just search on Amazon for my pen name "Albert Cory" to pre-order the Kindle version. I actually spoke to Donna Dubinsky and got a "job" for one of my characters. Palm plays a key role for one of the characters. The context is that "handheld computer" was already a tainted category, after GO, Newton, Momenta, Zoomer, and General Magic had all wasted money and failed to catch fire. Everyone insisted that you had to have wireless communication, and you had to recognize cursive. Jeff Hawkins had the guts to defy that, and focus on the price and the form factor, period. He gave up on cursive and gambled that people would use Grafiti. Saying "no" to features is one of the hardest things in tech.
- don-code 3y agoI was a Palm holdout into close to 2013. They weren't capable of the same range of things that a modern Android smartphone is, but it genuinely felt that someone had put time and effort into making the absolute best experience out of what they _could_ do. On the Treo 650, for instance, making a call meant hitting Send (a hard key) from anywhere in the UI, typing a name to start a live search - you did not need to focus into a text box first - and hitting Send again to start the call. Likewise, if I wanted to send a text message, I'd hit the SMS button, start typing a name, hit Select to open that conversation, and then start typing the message. The device had a touchscreen, but for the most common activities, you didn't need it. The 650 did not have built-in Wi-Fi, but with the Enfora Wi-Fi Sled and Opera Mobile, Web browsing was actually a decent experience. Likewise, I had some basic networked apps like AIM on there. Before the 650, I had a Handspring Visor and the VisorPhone attachment. The VisorPhone was way ahead of its time, but what finally killed that for me was a side effect of Palm devices not having memory protection. If someone sent me an MMS message, the entire thing would immediately freeze (it had no MMS support, and didn't handle receiving one gracefully). I'd have to take the batteries out to reset it. As more and more people did this, it became a more frequent occurrence.
- lou2ser 3y agoWow, never thought I'd see Enfora mentioned in a thread in 2024. I worked there for a year or so, supporting those early GPRS cards. I remember sending ICQ messages to friends while sitting in traffic on I-635. It was kinda unbelievable to be online in a car
- soylentcola 3y agoI never had the WiFi sled, but I remember feeling this way when I used my 650 in the car, plugged into the aux audio input, to stream 128kbps music from Shoutcast servers via some media player I've since forgotten (it aped the Winamp interface, but wasn't a port if I remember correctly). This was at a time when folks I knew were getting XM radio, but for the cost of the data plan I was already paying for (only a $10/mo addon for unlimited!) I could listen to hundreds of stations. I even ran a Shoutcast server from home so I could listen to my music collection on shuffle as a sort of bespoke radio station.
- causi 3y agoBack when they actually paid attention to hand-feel. No smartphone has ever felt as good in the hand as my Lifedrive or Tungsten TX.
- gunapologist99 3y agoThe Palm III's and V's and later Treo's were amazing for their time. The simplicity and minimalism of the applications resulted in some of the best productivity I've ever had. Here's another from Samsung at the very end of PalmOS's life that probably deserved more recognition as a startlingly effective PDA and phone: https://www.palminfocenter.com/view_story.asp?ID=4840 https://www.palminfocenter.com/view_story.asp?ID=4840 https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/photos.php?p=187 https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/photos.php?p=187 (great video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4J3QREiuJ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4J3QREiuJ0 )
- Apocryphon 3y agoWow. I chanced upon the existence of the Tandy Zoomer this past year while browsing vintage PDA videos on YouTube. Compared to the Atari Portfolio, the HP 200LX, the Handspring Visor, and of course the PalmPilot, there's hardly any videos about it at all. Had no idea it was Jeff Hawkins' first device that led to the founding of Palm! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGjysw9VhIM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGjysw9VhIM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rNbUiB_PWQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rNbUiB_PWQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xl-53WtBzxA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xl-53WtBzxA
- sparrish 3y agoPalm rewired my mind. I still write my upper case 'E' in jot.
- NikkiA 3y agoI always felt that graffiti/jot got the 'return' gesture wrong, it should always be a down stroke followed by a leftwards stroke, which IIRC both MacOS X's and Windows Pen both used.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoPalm was incredible. Enyo, webOS, the list is a long one. It's hard to overstate Palm's effect on handhelds, how they successfully challenged Blackberry to the benefit of both companies, and the tragedy of its demise[1]. Jon Rubinstein, Palm's creator, is bitter about its fate to this day. I hiked the entire Appalachian Trail with my Palm TX, dutifully logging my thoughts and ideas on the two thousand mile walk from Georgia (USA) to Maine, saving them to a tiny SSD, then beaming them all to a journal when I hit a wifi spot in a town library or somewhere. I still think back on that thing, and the absolutely AWESOME folding keyboard I had for it (2 oz, smaller than a pack of cigarettes folded up, folded out into a rigid keyboard that had a tray for the Palm, really useful typing on your elbows on the floor of a tent). It was a full commodity computing environment: calculator, cached wikipedia, word processor, email, pdf maps/guidebooks/almanacs. Honestly, if you added Maps to that thing, I would still use it today, no question. Palm was - once Elevation Partners sucked all of the cash from the place - hoovered into the giant value-destroying machine of HP, where it promptly died, as do all things that enter HP post-HPUX. [1] The moral of which: "Do Not Trust Private Equity. Ever"
- philistine 3y agoYou're right that Palm was fighting against Blackberry and it made each of them better. But Palm, Blackberry and Microsoft were laser-focused on one another's products. Then Apple came in and did something so out of left field they were caught with their pants down. What do you mean we need a GPU to render transitions?
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoHandspring Visor was THE BEST. The cartridge expansion ("Springboard" slot) was great. The unit was relatively affordable to begin with and was easy to tinker with. Once I had gotten it online by a series of like 3 or 4 cables and adapters from Handspring to my Motorola Startac, connecting to the GPRS network. It wasn't fast, but for simple text applications (email, AIM, etc) it worked. Also I had an uber powerful IR Blaster (that could also learn any remote) that was great for terrorizing my father. Good times.
- supportengineer 3y agoDid you ever use Vindigo to find restaurants near you?
- msephton 3y agoSony CLIÉ were my choice of Palm devices. Hi-resolution (double), better colour, better screens, better system apps. Crazy hardware design, cyberdecks with so much personality, a far cry from what we have today. And one CLIÉ device that perhaps inspired the iPhone, the TH55, as both Steve Jobs and Jony Ive were fans. I did some preservation of Palm stuff, lost SEGA games https://blog.gingerbeardman.com/2019/04/24/recovered-forgotten-sega-exclusives-on-palm-os/ https://blog.gingerbeardman.com/2019/04/24/recovered-forgott..., app hacking, and more. When browsing the Wayback Machine for old Palm apps, it's so interesting to see pretty much all development stop once the iPhone was released. The original Palm software and user interface design was heavily inspired by the Macintosh. "Piloting Palm" by Andrea Butter & David Pogue is a great read.
- glonq 3y agoPalmOS was a decently civilized platform to develop against. I remember using the CodeWarrior IDE to build a little portable app for managing parking meters. Using XModem over RS-232 you could update the machines' configuration, download transaction records, etc. We were using the HP-95X before that, and the Tandy 102 even earlier. The Palm was a sexy modern alternative to those clunky platforms.
- TomMasz 3y agoI started with a Palm V, then a Zire 72, then finally a Treo 700p. Everything just worked and Graffiti was remarkably easy to use (its replacement wasn't). But ultimately, the Treo couldn't keep up with the iPhone and (later) Android. I bought the original Motorola Droid but was disappointed when OS updates stopped so early and went for an iPhone once 4G was available. Continuing innovation requires a lot of resources and there aren't many places where that's the case.
- wazoox 3y agoI still have my Visor, VisorPhone, Treo 270, Treo 600, Treo 650 in a drawer somewhere :) I had a Palm Pré too, but the USB connector died after 5 years...
- buescher 3y agoOmits the very interesting AlphaSmart Dana and Neo devices.
- cdstamper 3y agoToward the end I was using PalmOS almost exclusively with fingertip input rather than a stylus. The 5-way navigator on newer devices is still arguably better than anything we have on modern smartphones; you could page through Launcher categories using the hardware button, select an app using up/down left/right and open it with the center button. You could even navigate the menus without touching the screen at all. Much of the UI could be interacted with this way. There was even a third-party keyboard which was somewhat usable without a stylus (although best in landscape mode). But the iPhone brought capacitive multitouch to the table and changed everything. Even discounting the multitouch (eg pinch-to-zoom) features, it was lightyears ahead in terms of sensitivity and precision. There was just no comparison!