3 ms·
Has anyone here ever seen this done, in any job they worked?
by tptacek 3y ago
Has anyone here ever seen this done, in any job they worked?
- tshaddox 3y agoI’ve never seen (as far as I know) the whole lying to your own team about hiring intentions, but I’ve been on small teams that aren’t actively hiring but leave stock job descriptions posted from the last time they were.
- ben_w 3y agoI've seen one case where a job ad must have stayed up for years, though I only noticed it after the company closed down.
- thaumaturgy 3y agoYes. About five years ago (so, not new), and for a smaller company. After months of carrying multiple projects myself, including one that deserved at least three more devs on it, I had run out of all the nice ways to plead with management to actually hire someone. So, during a companywide meeting, I loudly and firmly said I'd be out the door in 30 days if they didn't have someone started by then. They hired someone, I handled the technical interview, I trained him, and then they suggested maybe I should find a new job.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> So, during a companywide meeting, I loudly and firmly said I'd be out the door in 30 days if they didn't have someone started by then. Why on earth would you do this in a companywide meeting?
- muro 3y agoMaybe it was a 10 people company, then it might be the right place. Otherwise, lol.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoIf it's anything more than a 2 person company, it's still not the right place.
- thaumaturgy 3y agoWell, let's see, I had met with my boss, I met with my boss's boss, who was also the CEO, I met with my boss and the CEO, I met with my boss and the CEO and the cofounder. I wrote emails and had hallway chats and met in person. I asked, asked again, more formally outlined the situation, pleaded, asked for an update, and then said they weren't leaving me a lot of options. Throughout this period they kept promising they were trying to hire but I hadn't seen a single resume or interview. Most jobs, I'd just bounce and leave 'em hanging at that point. But, I actually liked most of the people I worked with, they just had a terrible CEO that had a bad habit of seeing devs strictly as cost centers. I wanted them to fix it, and this was an appropriate move for that company and the company's culture. Thanks for your judgement though, wish you'd been there to tell me how to be better.
- Simon_ORourke 3y agoIt's a business though, and devs need to contribute to the bottom line. How would you have management treat devs other than an operational cost?
- kevingadd 3y agoThe case we're discussing is one where they had exactly one developer doing the work of multiple developers, and he was about to quit. He did them a favor by not only staying around to train his replacement, but giving them advance notice of his intent to leave. Considering they hired someone new once he did this, it sounds like he was probably contributing to the bottom line!
- thraxil 3y agoTreating devs as people would be a good start.
- galaxyofdoom 3y ago[dead]
- kevinmchugh 3y agoSorry, you didn't say this: were they advertising openings the whole time you were there, but not interviewing? It seems like the ruse would depend on there being interviews for the role, but interviews are so expensive and disruptive that I don't see someone scheduling them if they're not going to hire
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- reactordev 3y agoYes. The tell is when the req has been open for a few weeks yet no one has been interviewed in person (or video) yet. The manager will claim they have, but have they really?
- 20after4 3y agoI've definitely seen evidence of this from a few big name tech employers. Revolving job postings that are regularly re-posted with the exact same details, and it appears that they never actually filled any positions. It's possible that they are hiring a lot of the same job description but these are sort of specialized roles with highly specific job requirements. I have a hard time believing that they are constantly hiring people for a very specific job description and continue to have openings for the same. Seems especially unlikely after they recently had big layoffs. More likely ghost jobs. I think that they aren't planning to fill unless a highly qualified candidate comes along that happens to be desperate and willing to accept a low offer. When that happens, I wouldn't be at all surprised if they hire them to replace someone who is earning significantly more. Potential for big cost savings at the expense of intangible accumulated institutional knowledge and team cohesion/morale.
- latenightcoding 3y agoAs an ML consultant, I’ve seen it happen. It’s hard to find good people and most want to work on impactful things that require big teams, CEOs will tell you to stick around because they plan to hire, soon.
- YZF 3y agoNo company I ever worked for did this but I have seen this once when looking. A job posting that is basically perpetual for a single role by a relatively large company with a bad hiring reputation. The posting is always up, for this single role, I think for more than a year now, when there's no way you can't find many people that could do that role. I applied and I had to go through some silliness before they told me they have a better candidate. A year later, that job is still posted. I would guess this practice is pretty rare. There can be stale postings e.g. when a large company pauses hiring but nothing along the lines of what parent is describing.
- hlfshell 3y agoYes. Interviewed someone that the team loved. We said definitely hire. HR said they didn't accept the offer and went elsewhere. What they didn't know is that the person LinkedIn messaged me saying they enjoyed the team, and were disappointed we passed, respectfully asking what I would recommend to work on for their interviewing. Opinions on whether to reach out after a rejection aside, it highlighted what I already suspected; the job was never going to be filled, and even as the team lead they were lying to me and the team. When there was yet another round of layoffs months later, the spot remained, unsurprisingly, unfilled.
- brandall10 3y agoThat is wild. Let me get this straight - the company actively lied to the team in an effort to get their hopes up that help was coming... by actually giving the extra overhead of sourcing a new hire? Were you guys actively trying to fill the role (screen dozens of candidates, several went through final rounds, etc), or was this just some passive thing where recruiting tried to push someone who looked great?
- ang_cire 3y agoAt my current job, we had a position that an absolutely stellar candidate supposedly ghosted HR on. Same thing; candidate reached out to me asking about next steps, and I was like, "let me check". Went and asked HR, and was told they'd handle the rest, and not to talk to candidates outside of HR-scheduled interviews. Never heard back again. That was 3 months ago (and 3 months into the position posting), and the position is still unfilled.
- brandall10 3y agoSame question - were you and are you continuing to actively interview candidates? That's the mystery for me, why put the team through a charade that actively harms their productivity? The only thing I can think of is the candidate disclosed something that would be a legal red flag and can't really divulge that is an issue without threat of a lawsuit. Or something came up in a background check, but I imagine it didn't get to that point if the candidate reached out to you directly.
- naet 3y agoI haven't personally seen that. I've seen us open a job and get really bad applicants, or one good applicant who ends up taking another job for whatever reasons, and have it go unfilled for long periods of time. I think we probably could have made the hire with a higher salary or looking in other regions or both, but the company wasn't flexible on those things. I've also seen my company open applications for a job that is almost definitely going to be an internal promotion rather than a new hire, but for the sake of "fairness" they interview a handful of other people. Hiring is expensive. It takes a lot of time and energy to do interviews and screens and stuff like that, and usually some higher ups are involved in the process, so wasting their time is probably worse than just not posting the job if you're not going to hire.
- zerr 3y agoYou can often see this even on HN Who's Hiring threads - people post the same exact blobs again and again over the years. I tend to believe that this is a form of masked advertising as well.
- jonatron 3y agoDrChrono was "hiring" a developer for years
- zerr 3y agoEDIT: This is also why candidates should spend as little time as possible when applying for jobs, omitting cover letters and refusing to fill huge forms. The legit job poster companies should understand this and stop requiring cover letters and so on.