3 ms·
Normally economists say competition leads to price reduction. There is obviously pretty aggressive competition in streaming, with at least 5 global players. I d
by ggm 3y ago
Normally economists say competition leads to price reduction. There is obviously pretty aggressive competition in streaming, with at least 5 global players. I don't believe they have formed a cartel or collude to set price but its pretty clear that they aren't competing on price. If they are colluding the FTC can act. Where's the evidence? The lack of FCC oversight is a problem but they lobbying has apparently been extreme. No politicians want the headaches.
I think the IPR rules mean that because "house" is non substitutable, there actually isn't as much competition as people want: if you want to watch Hugh Laurie in "house" you have to pay whatever the IPR holders want.
It's not surprising people pirate content. I happen to think we were better off with FTA television.
- unnamed76ri 3y agoEach streaming service has unique content. So each one is completely different. It isn’t like which grocery store has the better price for bananas. There’s no need for streaming services to compete on price because no one else has the same product.
- gonzo41 3y agoI would also add that people actually like movies and shows. But Netflix and the finance bro's who run Hollywood now seem hell bent on just taking quick speculative punts on shows and then running away after 1 season and no advertisement. Personally, I'd be happier if there wasn't multiple streamers and just one big marketplace I could access. And for a lot of people that's bit torrent.
- usrusr 3y agoAmazon seems to be the closest thing, with its studio channel subscription modules. If only it wasn't world-eating Amazon! (and if only the implementation did not suck: there are shows on "BBC player", of all things, that I can't get with an English audio track, only an atrocious German dub. Some even start perfectly fine and then surprise-switch to dub only in some later season)
- nicolas_t 3y agoAnd the practice of cancelling shows from Netflix is why I keep cancelling my subscription and waiting for them to have a show I actually like that has more than 1 season before I resubscribe. I have apple tv (because I like For all mankind, Acapulco, Trying, Severance and liked Ted Lasso) and I keep my subscription because they haven't casually cancelled something I liked immediately after engaging my interest. I have Disney plus because we want our son to speak Cantonese and Disney has actually invested in dubbing their cartoons in Cantonese despite the relatively small size of the market. Netflix just pisses me off and doesn't make me want to keep paying. I have bittorrent for things that are not available by streaming (and it amazes me how much content is available thanks to private trackers like PTP) but if a company invests money in providing me with a show I like (Apple TV, amazon occasionally) or preserving a language I care about, I'm going to vote with my wallet for this behavior.
- nemomarx 3y agoWhy is this the case, anyway? Music streaming services and ebook stores generally do compete on price or convenience and mostly all have the same content, and they have similar licensing agreements to movies and tv, right?
- Mindwipe 3y ago> Music streaming services and ebook stores generally do compete on price or convenience and mostly all have the same content, and they have similar licensing agreements to movies and tv, right? Broadly music licensing was dealt with by collective management because a) music is cheaper and has fewer rightsowners as they are simpler works and b) because radio was the primary means of consumption rather than single asset sales. And such collective schemes generally had legal backing. And ultimately the music model doesn't work - Spotify is slowly drowning financially, which is why they are so desperate to try and do other things where they can get exclusivity - first their push for exclusive podcasts and now their push for exclusive training courses and audiobooks.
- AlexandrB 3y agoBecause book and music publishers generally don't run their own streaming services. We're back to the equivalent of when movie studios owned their own theatre chains. Something that was eventually found to be a violation of antitrust law[1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pictures,_Inc https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_P....
- jasode 3y ago>Why is this the case, anyway? Music streaming services [...] mostly all have the same content, Producing song tracks or books is "cheap" compared to tv & films. Because tv series episodes cost more than $1 million each and movies productions can cost over $300 million, the studios are more tightfisted and financially incentivized to hold on to them exclusively for their own networks & streaming platforms instead of licensing it out to all the other streaming services. Right now, the studios believe they can get more $$$ by using their exclusives to attract more subscribers rather than the sum of licensing money they could realistically negotiate from all their competitors. (The streaming competitors all want to underpay for licenses which contradicts the ip owners wanting max dollars.) E.g. Disney thought the old Netflix license contract was too much in favor of Netflix so Disney pulled their content and used it as "exclusives" on their own streaming service to attract subscription revenue. In other words, the early years of Netflix streaming where they seemingly had "everything" (that consumers look back on with fondness) ... was also the time period where Disney/HBO/etc thought they were getting financially shafted by Netflix. Music doesn't have the same economics so the content owners are more willing to syndicate across all music streaming platforms. Nevertheless, there are a few "exclusive" arrangements such as Garth Brooks only offering his studio albums on Amazon Music and rejecting Spotify and Apple Music. It's definitely not the norm compared to tv & movies.
- WithinReason 3y agoCurrently only Netflix is profitable, e.g. Disney lost more than a billion on Disney+. Not sure how they can keep this up if people keep moving to piracy.
- draugadrotten 3y agoHollywood accounting makes it very hard to trust tales of "losses". The money has just been siphoned away to a tax haven somewhere through overpaying for e.g. renting a property or licensing some IP. The money wasn't really "lost", it was just not taxed.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoAre you certain of this? I know Hollywood Accounting is a thing for movie production, but I haven't heard any evidence that it's being used for streaming services. If nothing else, I'd expect a risk of this being treated as securities fraud if streaming service P&L is broken out in public-company reports.
- exe34 3y agoI'll believe the poor rich people who are struggling to buy their third yacht when they open up their accounts books and show where all the money comes from and where it goes to. As long as they keep it secret, I'll assume it's because they don't like paying taxes.
- c0wb0yc0d3r 3y agoThis article[0] indicates that Disney removed shows to write them off. [0]: https://gizmodo.com/disney-streaming-cuts-tax-writeoffs-1850502594 https://gizmodo.com/disney-streaming-cuts-tax-writeoffs-1850...
- Mindwipe 3y ago> Hollywood accounting makes it very hard to trust tales of "losses". Hollywood accounting applies to individual titles. It doesn't apply to entire services - why would you tell your shareholders that you are making a loss to depress the stock price?
- tichiian 3y agoThere is no or very limited competition of streaming services because they do not share content. Almost everything is unique to each streaming service. And big copyright holders even carve out their content and create their own services ala Disney. We would need compulsory licensing to get even a modicum of competition, and even then the licensing deals will work as a pricing cartel. There can be no competition if there is copyright involved.
- bzzzt 3y agoSee the big difference between TV and music streaming. I can switch from Spotify to Apple Music without losing access to most of my songs, but Amazon can't show 'Netflix original' series. I get that movie studio's don't want to 'flat rate' their premium content. Online movie "purchases" seem to be better covered. You can buy/rent about the same movies from Apple, Amazon and some others but they cover a very small number of popular movies. Older movies like the Criterion collection needs yet another subscription which isn't even available in big parts of the world, especially in the EU there seems to be a copyright clusterf*ck of epic proportions where every member state has it's own rule, regulations and small time film licensing companies making it totally impossible to release niche content. Combined with the demise of disc-based movies (I give it about 10 years before major movies are only streamable) I fully expect an increase in enthusiasts resorting to piracy. It really is a service problem...
- izacus 3y agoThis is just big studios trying to avoid the 1948 Paramount vs. USA situation, where they were banned from owning cinemas and thus creating market competition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pictures,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pic.... They're trying to not make that mistake again and being forced to actually... compete!
- littlestymaar 3y ago> There can be no competition if there is copyright involved. Truth is there can almost never be real competition on any market that isn't raw materials, because there's IP (not just copyright, but patents and trademarks as well) almost everywhere else.
- Mindwipe 3y ago> I don't believe they have formed a cartel or collude to set price but its pretty clear that they aren't competing on price. Sure they are. It's just that they were competing on price so much that every service was operating on a loss making basis until interest rates went up and that became unsustainable. You don't need collusion for interest rates skyrocketing to lead to unprofitable services needing to raise pricing at the same time.