10 ms·
Tesla Profits Drop 55%
- cjk2 3y agoLuxury vehicles with limited market, Hertz dumping them due to ROI problems, asshole running PR, new product is a $70k MAGA hat / rusty coffin, geopolitical mess going on. Inevitable really. I know a couple of "faithful" investors who put money on late last year who are still telling themselves it's only temporary.
- youngtaff 3y agoLuxury prices but compared to the finish of the competition are they really luxury vehicles?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 3y agoNobody cares about "finish" apart from weird car enthusiasts (think like people who run homelabs, but for cars). It's all about the brand.
- onion2k 3y agoThe brand is the effectively the sum of what the company does though, and that includes building cars with a good finish. BMW, Merc, Audi, Lexus etc have strong brands because they're well known for make cars that are always well built. In the case of Tesla they could fix all the build problems and their brand would continue to suffer because they have a reputation for poor quality. That takes years to repair.
- Rinzler89 3y agoPretty much. Japanese and Germans have built those strong brands on the build quality, fit and finish, ride quality, noise insulation, etc. Tesla customers were willing to overlook that due to the focus on software and cutting edge tech at the expense of quality but people later realized quality also matters in a object you sit in and your life depends on it, since a car is more than an iPad.
- acdha 3y agoI would especially add that there is not much of a shortcut around that, either, because a lot of that reputation is based on older vehicles holding up well, not being noisy, etc. People think Mercedes is a luxury brand because they’re thinking about how their grandparents had one that was still in good shape after years of use, not just the day they bought it. Not coming from that kind of family background personally this was somewhat of a surprise to me when a friend first explained how they were expecting a vehicle to hold its value.
- ano-ther 3y agoJust went by taxi one way in a Mercedes, back with a Tesla. Similar mileage. The Tesla’s seats were already worn down so I could feel the steel tubes beneath the upholstery. The Benz was still fine. That’s better finish which I would care about without being a car enthusiast.
- cm2187 3y agoSame. The suspensions also make quite a different experience. Plus I don’t like cars where I need to figure out how to open a door.
- cjk2 3y agoNah I just want something that doesn't fall to bits. My Model S (yes I did own one) had worse finish than the ass end Citroen I had. The model S had paint runs and the drivers door didn't shut properly.
- OJFord 3y agoMaybe we have different definitions, but I think they absolutely do, I would say things like insisting on Apple CarPlay, or the UX of the self-driving software, the vibrance of the RGB dash/door lighting (...) etc. is caring about finish. Your car enthusiast might care to a different sort of extreme or niche (like wanting real leather not PU; or not wanting leather because the '66 never came with leather) but it's still caring about finish IMO, just different aspects.
- alistairSH 3y agoOf course they do. The brand is the sum of all the design and engineering decisions and marketing over time. I absolutely bought a Lexus because I perceived it as high quality - reliable, assembled properly, good finishes. Same for my BMW, though it’s almost certainly less reliable. My Honda truck, I expect reliable utility, not luxury.
- kstrauser 3y agoWTF. I was a kid out looking at cars with my dad. He was looking at Lincolns, saw one he otherwise liked, and noticed that the gap between the driver’s door and the back seat door was wider at the top than the bottom. The salesman tried to have the shop adjust the door so that it was aligned, but then it was misaligned in other ways (like the edge of the driver’s window was higher than the back seat’s window). He never looked at another Lincoln, ever. Choice quote: “I’d never be able to look at it without seeing that skewy door and it’d make me mad every time.” Fit and finish are absolutely things that non-geeks care tremendously about.
- Ekaros 3y agoLot of people care about fit. And feeling. A car should at least look right that means gaps in different places look same and there is no obvious problem. After all they are paying tens of thousands for something, that is absolute minimum you can expect for that price.
- cjk2 3y agoWell that is sort of the point. The pricing reflects luxury but the quality does not reflect the pricing.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoLease for $299/month isn't luxury pricing any more.
- rvnx 3y agoRemoving stalks and replacing them with turn signal controls to the same side of the steering wheel and arranging them in a reversed order did not help (many people think “Left” first, then only “Right” due to Western reading convention)
- Ekaros 3y agoHow are they arranged? Should Left be well on the left side? Like button being closer to side where action happens. Now I need to think about window switches too...
- Dalewyn 3y ago9% drop in revenue leading to a 54% drop in income, this suggests the main factor for the income reduction is an increase in costs/loss moreso than the drop in revenue.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoCould also just be reversion to the mean. COVID issues restricted the supply of new cars in general, resulting in higher prices/margins. Now that they're getting sorted out, prices return to normal and margins go back down.
- Tuna-Fish 3y agoNo. Their gross margin only fell by 0.2%, and operating expenses only increased by 151 million, neither of which explains more than a small fraction of what happened. The problem is simply that because they are so vertically integrated, they have high fixed costs, and so a relatively small drop in revenue means a huge loss in profit. Another 9% less revenue and they will be making a loss, unless they fire a lot of people.
- Stranger43 3y agoTesla failed at the monopoly grab that most VC funded tech companies depend on for their "valuation" and super-normal profits. Cars have no network effect as the roads are open standard accessible to any vendor and Tesla never had any secret sauce that kept well funded competitors from competing. Once the big traditional manufacturers started taking electric cars with diver assist features seriously they had the skill and money to match(and in some cases exceed) Tesla and that means Tesla will have to price their cars competitively.
- red-iron-pine 3y agonetwork effects and the broader value network are the big ones. without creating and then exploring that network, you're just a hot new product until someone else catches up. put another way, it's not just making cars, it's making the ecosystem. every phone after the iphone was trying to be the iphone, for example. for Tesla, it would have been something like getting charging stations everywhere, and getting the 3 price so low that they become ubiquitous. then the Hertz buy might have made sense, you'd see taxis everywhere switching (and they kind of did in some cities), and stronger adoption outside of tech-bro cities.
- cm2187 3y agoAlso a lacklustre demand for electric cars in general. Other manufacturers also impacted and probably the primary driver.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoEV's grew 31% in 2023 and will likely do a similar amount in 2024. The issue is that the number of available vehicles grew more than 31%; expectations were for around 50% growth. I don't think you can call 31% growth lacklustre.
- acdha 3y agoLackluster demand for very expensive vehicles is down across the board, and Tesla has only been serving the higher-end market. A lot of manufacturers were banking on interest rates staying low but there was no way that could last forever - the average ICE last year cost more than the US median income, at a time when many other prices were also rising. Based on the people I know who’ve bought recently, an EV targeting Camry pricing and quality would sell a lot better than the massive bling-tanks they had sitting in stock.
- rapsey 3y ago> Luxury vehicles with limited market Models 3/Y are literally one of the cheapest EVs available in EU/US? > Hertz dumping them due to ROI problems Hertz frankly had a pretty terrible strategy going in. Buying a ton of cars without any infrastructure for them (Hertz locations without chargers).
- Hamuko 3y ago>Models 3/Y are literally one of the cheapest EVs available in EU/US? BYD Dolphin is 34 990 € and a Tesla Model 3 is 41 990 €. And both are pretty high up there in comparison to like a hybrid Toyota Corolla.
- constantcrying 3y agoWhat? That is total nonsense. The ID.3 is much cheaper, even ignoring VW picking up the government subsidies. With the subsidies it costs about as much as an ID.5. Of course prices get much lower, with actual low end EVs which started to hit the market. Tesla is anything but the cheapest EV.
- dutchbrit 3y ago> Models 3/Y are literally one of the cheapest EVs available in EU/US? They aren't (in EU)? Dacia Spring, Citroën e-C3, Fiat 500e, BYD Dolphin, ID.3 & Peugeot e-208 to name a few are quite a bit cheaper.
- tnolet 3y ago> Models 3/Y are literally one of the cheapest EVs available in EU/US? Er, no. Peugeot, Renault, Volkswagen etc. all make (way) cheaper models. Heck, even Volvo now has an EV (the EX30) that is ~EUR 8k cheaper than a Model y. Not even mentioning the Asian brand like Hyundai etc.
- pvaldes 3y agoShh... I'll tell you a secret. For years and years a lot of the electric vehicles in lots of brands, weren't meant to be sold. The public were even advised by the car dealers not to buy them, and they were made so unattractive as possible. In part because the carmakers were probably unsure about its long term performance with a totally new technology, but the main reason was other. It just happens that the environmental emissions of a car maker fleet was calculated as the average of emissions from all their models in the current market. Those tiny, squared EV that looked like toys were built with the only purpose to decrease the brand average value. Thus they could have models contaminating more in the upper categories. (Plus painting the brand in green for PR purposes). All of this changed after Tesla started to show its claws and to be taken seriously.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pvaldes 3y agoThe arson attack at Gigafactory Berlin? What happened?
- cjk2 3y agoSomeone set fire to a pylon and took the factory (and the important bit: local residents) out for a week or so. Apparently the motivation was protesting against deforestation and using groundwater in an area with drought problems already.
- constantcrying 3y agoEnvironmental activists committed an arson attack to punish Tesla for being economically unfriendly.
- weberer 3y agoIn Germany of all places? You'd think they'd worry about the lignite mines and power plants first.
- reducesuffering 3y agoThen you'd mistakenly think that those people were doing any actual thinking...
- piva00 3y agoThe arson was about localised issues (as another comment mentioned, groundwater and local deforestation), so yeah, they could think about the bigger picture for environmental impact but instead they focused on the local one. You can probably worry about big and small problems at the same time, it's not like because the world is burning that you will allow or ignore a company contaminating the groundwater you and your neighbours use.
- constantcrying 3y ago>The arson was about localised issues No, it certainly wasn't just that. It was also a general attack on Tesla among the reasons listed it was about what cars they were building.
- farseer 3y agoCEO tweeting insults towards his biggest customers in environmental conscience libs might not help either.
- intsunny 3y agoYes, a few days ago the Wall St Journal ran this article: "Elon Musk Lost Democrats on Tesla When He Needed Them Most" https://www.wsj.com/business/autos/elon-musk-turned-democrats-off-tesla-when-he-needed-them-most-176023af https://www.wsj.com/business/autos/elon-musk-turned-democrat...
- Voultapher 3y agoLet's not forget his unmistakable approval of anti-semitism. https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/15/media/elon-musk-antisemitism-white-people/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/15/media/elon-musk-antisemitism-... There is no wiggle room here, dude claimed afterwards "That's not anti-semitism" yeah right, read the tweet and come to your own conclusion. This alone should be enough for Democrats to stop supporting this guy.
- throwaway11460 3y agoI don't want to defend anti semitism, but... If somebody said that about "Russian communities", "Russians" or "Russia", would that also be wrong?
- Voultapher 3y agoPlease go and read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism In addition I think you are making a false equivalence here. As a German citizen, I can only emphasize that grouping people along the "Jew" line and drawing hateful conclusions from it is a path to a dark place. I don't care what other scenarios might also be problematic, I can say without a doubt, the sentiment he endorsed is anti-semitic!
- interactivecode 3y agoThe cybertruck was their latest in "big promises and falling short in delivering". the price cuts clearly don't make up for it and Elon is losing more and more interest.
- Tempest1981 3y agoHave battery costs reached an asymptote? I was expecting them to continue dropping, until EVs were clearly cheaper than gas/hybrids.
- cjk2 3y agoIt's an exponential decay in pricing. The marketing promise was a faster linear decay but that was unrealistic and was used to bolster investment capital. This affected confidence heavily. Examples here at EO 2023. https://cleantechnica.com/2023/12/01/record-low-ev-battery-prices/ https://cleantechnica.com/2023/12/01/record-low-ev-battery-p...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paganel 3y ago> until EVs were clearly cheaper than gas/hybrids. That's never going to happen, I'm not that good at physics but there must be some deep thermodynamically principle involved or similar to that. Something on the lines of what Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen [1] war writing about. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Georgescu-Roegen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Georgescu-Roegen
- pjc50 3y agoIt all depends on the tax treatment of carbon, not physics.
- paganel 3y agoWhich is why I mentioned Georgescu-Roegen [1], this is an economics + physics thing.
- Y-bar 3y ago> That's never going to happen Never say never, there is a clear theoretical possibility that we might one day properly price in all externalities (such as cost of dealing with climate change and conflicts related to hydrocarbons) into the cost of goods and services. That said, those chances are unfortunately small.
- neglesaks 3y agoLets see how the stock reacts to this.
- cjk2 3y agoIt shall continue to fall and it will have little impact on anything. The only thing propping it up is a bunch of investment companies who have it in their "environmental" funds. The damage reduction on those will be from other investments rising as Tesla tanks. Fund managers and then funds will be shuffled around. The world will continue to spin. This will result in some vapid marketing about price reductions and production increase and readjusting to market demands. Then a fat finger pointing at someone else. And some hype about battery technology. That will cause a temporary gain which can be used to sell more interest quickly and it'll tank again.
- l0ng1nu5 3y agoIt's been a long time since Tesla stock had any relationship with reality.
- Dalewyn 3y agoFrom the article: >The results, posted after markets closed Tuesday, sent shares up as much as 12% following the release as investors appeared to be more focused on Tesla’s forward-looking remarks about future products,
- postmeta 3y agoNew Performance Model 3 is only 45k with tax credit in US, crazy
- cheinic73030 3y ago> New Performance Model 3 is only 45k with tax credit in US, crazy If you are middle class on W-2 income, sure. The rich have moved onto other brands such as Porsche, Mercedes, Lucid, and Rivian.
- fergie 3y agoMusk seems to be dropping sensible but boring projects that would sell well globably (low cost compact car, semi-truck) in favour of magical technology that may or may not materialise, and if so may be legislated against outside the US (robotaxi, self-driving tech).
- spiderfarmer 3y agoI think a major factor in Musk's decision making is how many headlines will be written about him. The press helped him get to where he is now. Not making the headlines because he does boring stuff probably makes him more anxious than a negative headline ever can.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey announced a plan to bring Model 2 out a year earlier than originally planned and showed pictures of the build-out of the Semi factory.
- ac29 3y ago> They announced a plan to bring Model 2 out Have a link? The stories I read said they specifically declined to comment on Model 2
- bryanlarsen 3y agoFirst sentence of first story for TSLA search: > but it assured investors that it plans to move ahead with a cheaper model due out next year. https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/23/business/tesla-report-earnings-result/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/23/business/tesla-report-earning...
- alangibson 3y agoMy cynical take on them cancelling the model 2 in favor of robotaxis is that they've (temporarily?) given up on being a car company. They're hoping a new influx of capital after going all in on AI hype will keep them afloat. Given that the Cybertruck is a laughing stock and growth/profits from China are in bad shape, they may actually be doing the right thing if the only goal is to stay in business for one more quarter.
- Hamuko 3y agoHow many investors are going to humour Elon on his robotaxi plan? He's made public statements about Tesla getting robotaxis out in 2020, if not even earlier.
- alangibson 3y agoWe're going to find out soon. I think it totally depends where we are in the AI hype cycle.
- constantcrying 3y agoThey still want to make an affordable car.
- alangibson 3y agoIf that were true they would have worked on the model 2 instead of the Cybertruck. As it turned out the model 2 is shelved in favor of robotaxis. TBH, it doesn't matter too much what their intent is because they can't make a cheap car. Battery prices have not dropped fast enough.
- constantcrying 3y agoThey literally wrote it in their investor presentation. >Battery prices have not dropped fast enough. Irrelevant. It is about if they actually want to compete in that segment.
- 3y ago
- carrja99 3y agoBut on Twitter they said lord Elon CRUSHED the earnings call.
- ArtTimeInvestor 3y agoI watched some commentary on CNN about Tesla's Q1 today. Popular opinion seems to be that doubling down on self driving will not "rescue" the stock because self driving cars are 5 to 10 years away. To me, that seems not that far away. At current interest rates of 5%, that means the robotaxi business would be devalued by 28% if it manifests in 5 years and by 63% if it manifests in 10 years. Given the size of the opportunity (2 billion cars on the road, so about 700 billion yearly manhours that can be automated), a devaluation of 28% or 63% seems to be not too much to make it unreasonable as an investment. One robotaxi would add something like $5k per year to the bottom line. So every million robotaxis would add $5B. Give that a p/e ratio of 30, and it increases Tesla's market cap by $150B. Can Tesla bring one million robotaxis to the market by 2029? Assuming the numbers above, that would increase their market cap by $150B. Or in today's dollars by $100B. Even if they never get beyond 1 million robotaxis. If one assumes that from 2029 on, they add one million of these every year, today's value of that future business probably exceeds all of the current Tesla market cap.
- eqmvii 3y agocounterpoint: robo taxis might be much, much further away than 5-10 years.
- dagw 3y agoAnd even if they're not (I believe they are), how long would Tesla get to keep that market to themselves?
- ArtTimeInvestor 3y agoOptimally as long as google has managed to dominate the search business.
- nocoiner 3y agoAdditional counterpoint: the current risk-free rate is probably not the right discount rate for the robo-taxi business.
- 3y ago
- lifestyleguru 3y agoHere goes down another hype.
- DilettanteQuant 3y agoMany people in the comments claiming to be liberals who wont buy from Tesla due to Elon. What exactly do you dislike about him, and why is punishing Elon by boycotting Tesla worth slowing the transition to sustainable transportation?
- dagw 3y agoslowing the transition to sustainable transportation? How is buying an electric Not-Tesla slowing down the transition to sustainable transportation compared to buying a Tesla?
- DilettanteQuant 3y agoThe only Western automaker that can produce electric cars without losing massive amounts of money. Only Western automaker that produces EVs at scale. By far the leader in terms of technology and efficiency in the industry. Best range/dollar vehicles you can buy in north America. A couple Chinese automakers like BYD and Xpeng might survive the next couple years, they did it by relentlessly copying Tesla.
- johneth 3y ago> What exactly do you dislike about him Everything. Guy's a prick. Specifically, he's a huge narcissist surrounding himself with yes men to stroke his ego. Not a good environment for push back (resulting in obvious failures like the Cybertruck, Twitter-to-X rebranding, 'FSD is ready!', The Boring Company, etc.) > why is punishing Elon by boycotting Tesla worth slowing the transition to sustainable transportation? Even if we take the Elon factor out of the equation and just decide not to buy a Tesla for any other reason, it isn't 'slowing the transition to sustainable transportation' because I can buy a (much of the time) cheaper, better build quality, modern electric car from Rivian, Hyundai, BMW, Volkswagen, Audi, BYD, Volvo, Ford, Lucid, Buick, Cadillac, Chevrolet, Chrysler, Fiat, GMC, Honda, Jaguar, Kia, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, Polestar, Porsche, Ram, etc.
- DilettanteQuant 3y agoWhy does it matter? He's not particularly more narcissistic than any other CEO. Steve Jobs? I'm generally not concerned about the specific personality type of the CEO or any other employee at a company when I buy a product. Tesla is clearly the industry leader in terms of volume, technology, and efficiency. The market wouldn't exist without them. Most of those companies your listing can't/don't produce in volume because they have massive negative margin and range/dollar is inferior to Tesla. Only a few companies are in a place where they can make money on selling electric vehicles such as BYD and they did it through relentlessly copying Tesla.
- knowriju 3y agoI don't quite understand the robotaxi angle. So in future, a person A's Tesla would go around autonomously and ferry around people. I am guessing the only reason Tesla shares would be up since they would take a cut from the earnings? 1. Won't Tesla need to get permission city by city to drive around autonomously ( like Waymo, Cruise )? 2. I am not well aware of US laws, but where I am from personal vehicles have different registration from commercial registration. Expectation is every Tesla owner does the leg work to upgrade their registration? 3. Who cleans up the car if a passenger has made it dirty ? 4. I would guess that most people want to go to work around the same time in the day and come home the same time as well, including the Tesla owner. Which leaves the Tesla to become a taxi only during the non-peak demand times ? Won't there be a supply-demand mismatch? I could go on and on. Can't really fathom what potential did the market see to have their shares go up post-market. Anything I am missing?
- meyum33 3y agoI don’t get how personal cars can be rented out to reduce idle time and maximize utilization. By the same logic we should be making our homes ultrashort WeWork spaces while we travel or go to work. Cars are somewhat like an extension of our home. For some it’s a highly private space. If this analogy is true then they will never be rented like ultrashort cabs.
- DilettanteQuant 3y agoPeople literally do this, it's called Airbnb. I don't understand, this is supposed to be a tech news site and you guys are acting like you haven't heard of any of these massively successful peer 2 peer companies. It seems that you don't like Tesla for other reasons, so you're bringing up easily dismissed business challenges that have already been solved.
- WA 3y agoLast time I went to an Airbnb that was actually the home of someone else was in 2016 or so. I assume most Airbnbs are apartments made explicitly for using them as Airbnb rentals. Same logic applies to Robo taxis. This won't happen. The "private space" argument is quite strong imho.
- csomar 3y agoSo let's look at the Q1 report: https://digitalassets.tesla.com/tesla-contents/image/upload/IR/TSLA-Q1-2024-Update.pdf https://digitalassets.tesla.com/tesla-contents/image/upload/... - Total revenue is down 9% yearly and worse quarterly. - Service revenue is up 25% yearly. Milking current customers. Nice. - Quarterly profit down 55% yearly and 80%+ quarterly. hmm. - Operating cash flow disappeared. Free cash flow at -$2.5 billion. It's not like interest rates are low... - Stock is up 11.5% pre-market because Musk said that Tesla is moving to the tight margin market (low cost EVs). Makes sense huh? The stock market/US economy is now a confirmed meme/ponzi scheme.
- piva00 3y agoSeems like big investors also fall easily for the Sunken Cost fallacy. Instead of a fire sale as we'd expect they prefer to trust yet again Elon's words, the same person saying that FSD will become a reality in the next 3-6 months for the past 8 years... My belief is that Elon himself is in a tight spot now, if Tesla's financials continue to falter he will lose the last bit of trust which will probably unwind it all, probably including ouster him as CEO. He keeps promising dreams (FSD and robotaxis, Cybertruck, etc.) and not delivering them, instead he's losing public trust and respect, at some point the chickens will come home to roost.
- rsynnott 3y ago> The stock market/US economy is now a confirmed meme/ponzi scheme. I mean, I'm not sure how you can go from "the stocks of this one weird company behave irrationally" to "the US economy is a Ponzi scheme". Bubbles are basically as old as markets; meme stocks (which arguably Tesla is now an example of) are a somewhat newer concept, but are not a _big_ part of the market. The existence of things like TSLA demonstrates that the markets aren't the sort of spherical-cow perfect efficient markets that, say, the weirder varieties of libertarians believe to exist, but everyone pretty much already knew that anyway.
- guax 3y agoStocks are horse betting at short term. Always have been. People will buy and sell short term based on triggers that cause the stock go up or down and that's enough to move the price in that direction. Sometimes that trigger is disconnected to reality.
- jc_811 3y agoRemember that robot Elon "unveiled" that turned out just to be a person in a robot costume? He is saying[1] that this robot will be in production before the end of this year, and: "Will be more valuable than everything else combined because if you have a sentient humanoid robot that is able to navigate reality and do tasks at request there is no meaningful limit to the size of the economy. So that's what's going to happen" How does anybody take him seriously as this point? [1] https://twitter.com/cb_doge/status/1782892725521535437 https://twitter.com/cb_doge/status/1782892725521535437 Further context - https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-could-start-selling-optimus-robots-by-end-next-year-musk-says-2024-04-24/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-could-start-selling...
- 93po 3y ago> Remember that robot Elon "unveiled" that turned out just to be a person in a robot costume? this characterization is laughably far from the truth. there was no attempt at deceit here, it was a "let's have fun with it" moment. there was no promise or suggestion that there was supposed to be a real robot. elon derangement syndrome is alive and well
- jc_811 3y agoValid point, you're right that was more of a "let's have fun" than an actual reveal. However that doesn't change the fact that it's now an actual reveal. On the earnings call he said the robot should be in production by the end of this year, and being sold by the end of next year. And implied it will: - Be more valuable than everything else combined - A sentient humanoid robot that is able to navigate reality and do tasks at request - There is no meaningful limit to the size of the economy (whatever this means) And finished up by saying "So that's what's going to happen" I don't think I have Elon derangement syndrome, but I just can't take him seriously with how wildly inaccurate so many of his claims are.
- 93po 3y agoWhat the actual quotes are, starting at 12:30 timestamp during investor questions segment: "We are able to do simple factory tasks in the lab" "We think we'll have Optimus in limited production in the factory doing useful tasks by the end of this year" "We may be able to sell it externally by end of next year. These are just guesses" For the first quote, they literally have a PR video on youtube showing this. Go see it for yourself. For the second, this is a no-brainer. They already have robots in their factories doing useful tasks. It's not really a stretch that a humanoid form-factor robot could be doing the same. For the third, he clearly said "may" and made it super clear this was a guess. He's also not saying it will be doing your dishes by end of next year, he said selling it externally. Which may be for external lab purposes or for other manufacturers. "There is no meaningful limit to the size of the economy (whatever this means)" I think it's pretty clear what it means - autonomous robots that can intelligently do human tasks are going to massively change how the economy works. And it's very, very likely that we will (at some point) get to here. He's not promising when that's going to be. You're continuing to prove my point - people take the things he says and wildly misconstrue them and then act like he's literally Hitler. Don't get me wrong, Elon is an asshole and a transphobe and has some weird stick up his ass about immigration. But it's a pet peeve of mine for people to make up shit to be critical about while ignoring the real problems (like transphobia). It's also attacking the amazing talent and teams at Tesla/SpaceX for people to keep acting like it's a total shit show when it's really just Elon not shutting up sometimes
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion on the earnings post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40136709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40136709
- lamontcg 3y agoAnd Tesla is trying to reward Musk with $56B for these results: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cqqndqndpq5o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cqqndqndpq5o
- pmcjones 3y agoThat's to replace the original deal from 2018 that the Delaware court invalidated.