3 ms·
It's pretty funny to me to see an Apple user complaining about lack of interop with other ecosystems. You've chosen your walled garden; now it's time to realiz
by kelnos 3y ago
It's pretty funny to me to see an Apple user complaining about lack of interop with other ecosystems. You've chosen your walled garden; now it's time to realize you're stuck in it.
The author seems to blame everyone but Apple for this, though. Apparently it's Google's fault that his preferred podcast app isn't available on Android. What about the app developer, who has decided not to support Android? And it's the auto manufacturer's fault for deciding to go with Android Automotive as the infotainment OS. What about Apple, for refusing to license any of their OS offerings to third parties? (Let alone not having an automotive-suitable version of any of their OSes anyway.)
Instead, Apple wants auto manufacturers to implement a complex, proprietary Apple protocol to give iPhones the ability to control most aspects of the car's infotainment functions. Why would auto manufacturers want to do this? Not only would the auto manufacturer have to develop their own infotainment system (perhaps even using Android Automotive, but perhaps something else), but then they have to do all this extra work to essentially allow drivers to not use their own system. (And while I agree that most auto manufacturer software is weak or outright garbage, that point of fact isn't really relevant here.)
I don't agree with the author that some car makers are not excited about CarPlay 2 primarily because they want to own the automotive experience. It's because of all the extra work they need to do to support CarPlay 2 (probably an order of magnitude what it takes to support CarPlay 1 or Android Auto), and doing so isn't really in their interests, outside of Apple users who might refuse to consider their cars without CarPlay 2 support. But this is a chicken-and-egg problem: CP2 doesn't exist yet in any car, so customers don't know what they're potentially missing.
- willcipriano 3y agoImagine a world where Apple and Google (and others) worked together and made a open standard that is as good as what they both have today. Bluetooth but for cars. Such a missed opportunity.
- zeckalpha 3y agoThis would be considered a trust worth busting.
- pegasus 3y agoNot if it's open.
- npteljes 3y agoNot if it's anything like the video standardization efforts. The result is royalty free and open source. Every provider and consumer benefits when the infra is open https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliance_for_Open_Media https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliance_for_Open_Media
- hu3 3y agoIs USB a trust worth busting? Or DDR? Or M2? I'd argue those are trusts worth boosting.
- khimaros 3y agopersonally, i am hoping for (and working slowly toward) modernized AACS so that eg. a raspberry pi can be used to control most modern car head units unmodified: https://github.com/tomasz-grobelny/AACS https://github.com/tomasz-grobelny/AACS
- jnaina 3y agoCarPlay 2 needs a deeper integration to the car, as part of the vehicle's SDV stack. From what I understand, Apple will license software that runs on the vehicles SDV stack (RTOS, etc) with support for various Auto specific SoCs (Nvidia, Qualcomm, Renesas, NXP, etc). There is an existing vibrant ecosystem of Tier 1 partners who can do the CarPlay (or AA) integration, lessening the burden on the Auto OEMs for such specialised integration work (Luxoft, etc). CP2 is an eventual pathway (pure conjecture here) for Apple to offer other upgrades in the future, like an L2+ ADAS package, via a subscription model, with a potential profit split between Apple and the OEM. Somewhat like what MobilEye currently offers and their current business model. Apple gets valuable realtime traffic info from such an L2+ offering, which can feed into making Apple Maps better with up to the minute traffic updates. And the OEM gets to leverage a valuable "sticky" offering that is bound to attract the Apple crowed (usually well heeled folks with deeper pockets). And they both get to monetize CP2 via a paid subscription model.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> and doing so isn't really in their interests, outside of Apple users who might refuse to consider their cars without CarPlay 2 support. I would be interested in CarPlay 2 if I were buying a new car when it’s out. Infotainment is still a huge weakness in many cars, and is definitely a plus to many users. Carmakers are free to ignore it of course, but unless they are maybe Tesla, they have no good reputation to rely on in selling their own custom infotainment experiences.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> And it's the auto manufacturer's fault for deciding to go with Android Automotive as the infotainment OS. Yes, as far as I know, any automaker can choose to make the screen in the dash compatible with Carplay, at least the non fancy Carplay that will be able to show all the apps on the phone. Zero reason, in my opinion, to not offer a Carplay compatible screen, other than to inconvenience car users. Not the CarPlay 2 thing, but just original Carplay.
- FridgeSeal 3y ago> give iPhones the ability to control most aspects of the car's infotainment functions Because the solutions the auto makers came up with _sucked_ and as it’s not core to the operation of the car, I’d prefer it be done by someone that even approximately knows what they’re doing with software? I am not buying the car for their infotainment features, I’m buying it for the car. I’d like it the entertainment bits were just delegated to the setup I already have…
- eloisant 3y agoThat's why I'm happy with CarPlay/AA for infotainment... ONLY. Maps, music, podcasts, that's all I need. I don't need my whole car UI to be taken over by my phone. My car maker solution to display and control speed, HVAC, gas tank/battery status is perfectly fine.
- bonestamp2 3y ago> You've chosen your walled garden; now it's time to realize you're stuck in it. Yes and no. Android Automotive supports android apps, but GM's implementation (for example) still locks out android phones from using Android Auto. Yes, you can install the same apps, but the nice thing about hooking up your phone is that you're maintaining all of your apps, data, and state in one place instead of two and it's inherently different for as many different drivers as there are phones.
- kergonath 3y ago> It's pretty funny to me to see an Apple user complaining about lack of interop with other ecosystems. You've chosen your walled garden; now it's time to realize you're stuck in it. I am still amazed that some people see it as a brain-free non-decision to buy into a status symbol. I have an iPhone. It has things that I like and things that I hate. I have a brain that can process nuance, and it’s entirely possible to say nice things about some features and rant against others. I bought my current phone knowing what I can do and cannot do with it. It is an informed decision and a compromise by necessity. I bought it expecting it to integrate with my car via CarPlay, and I would definitely complain if it either stopped working or if car manufacturers dropped it. (I don’t care about CarPlay 2 at all)
- graftak 3y agoPretty much all new car reviews are complaining about the built in infotainment, and it only gotten worse after manufacturers decided to jump on the all out touch screen bandwagon (to save a few bucks) but without Tesla’s generally alright UI and responsiveness. In that respect a UI made by Apple will certainly appeal to an audience already demanding current CarPlay. On the other hand, it could be that the current level of CarPlay integration is already enough.
- napierzaza 3y ago[dead]
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoI also think the author misses the mark on this statement > Apple’s long-term goal is likely to find ways to directly monetize CarPlay. It could license CarPlay to carmakers at some point. But with the entire global car market amounting to only around 70 million cars per year and the car industry’s slim profit margins (ranging from 5% to 15%), it must reach a high market share to get significant revenue from it. However, carmakers may be hesitant to invest in what they see as a competing product. I don’t think Apple sees this as a promising revenue stream. It’s just another way to encourage people to stay within the walled garden. That seems many times more valuable than any possible licensing fees they would get from manufacturers
- karmakaze 3y agoI hate to say it but monetize subscriptions, not new car sales. It's got to be worth as much as a seat warmer.
- dmoy 3y agoWait I gotta be missing something. Are seat warmers a subscription now? Damn, indeed I missed that section > With their own software platforms, they are desperately trying to find recurring revenue streams, whether it's a subscription for seat heating or driver assistance systems ..........
- filoleg 3y ago> Are seat warmers a subscription now? They almost became a subscription, but BMW backpedaled at the last second[0]. 0. https://www.theverge.com/2023/9/7/23863258/bmw-cancel-heated-seat-subscription-microtransaction https://www.theverge.com/2023/9/7/23863258/bmw-cancel-heated...
- rrdharan 3y agoPretty soon the pedals will be a subscription or pay per use.
- valianteffort 3y ago[flagged]
- chris_wot 3y agoThat’s a ridiculous statement - he was responding to substantive points raised by the article. I’m a huge Apple fan, but let’s be fair here and not flame others.
- batch12 3y agoIt's funny that calling someone an Android user is considered a flag-worthy insult.
- freedomben 3y agoI don't think it is. I think dismissing a well thought out post by calling it "yapping" was the insult.
- internetter 3y agoTFA yapped about iPhones 8.7x more than OP
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]