7 ms·
Don't Japanese people have smartphones or tablets with navigation on them that they can use? I'd rather cars just have a place I can mount my own device, rather
by ryandrake 3y ago
Don't Japanese people have smartphones or tablets with navigation on them that they can use? I'd rather cars just have a place I can mount my own device, rather than include any kind of screen whatsoever with crappy un-updated, un-maintained software.
- astrange 3y agoCars can have better GPS reception, which is important when you're trying to drive in an urban area with a lot of buildings. Phones are bad at accuracy there. (CarPlay can provide car GPS to the phone though.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- katbyte 3y agoMy iPhone 12 has much better reception then my 22 Tacoma even when tossed on the passenger seat. Like waaaaaay better and more accurate
- withinboredom 3y agoIt just pretends to be more accurate by using AI. A car tends to be more raw, which is what you want when navigating at speed. As someone who used to help out with Waze maps, raw GPS tracks from phones can be WAAAY off from actual roads and other GPS tracks. Your phone looks for the most likely road for you to be on and snaps you to that road. Your car does a similar thing but has much higher GPS resolution than your phone so it is more likely to be right.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoCould we please for once stop using the term "AI" when we mean "heuristics"?
- withinboredom 3y agoPhones do use AI though, at least iPhones. They look at all sensors (accelerometers, gps, wifi, etc).
- lupusreal 3y agoSensor fusion is AI I guess.
- withinboredom 3y agoAI can be distilled down to a series of if-statements. That's basically all it is.
- lupusreal 3y agoRight, expert systems are GOF AI. What isn't?
- fennecbutt 3y agoThis is true of literally any software and if you really wanna oversimplify it, our brains are just a bunch of if statements (condition based logic) too...
- withinboredom 3y agoI noticed too late to add /s or to attribute the quote, but kinda sad that people are taking it literally. It’s a play on the quote “Life is a series of choices and reactions” from “Before The Fall”
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoGosh, so the moment you use an if-statement, or an aggregate function (like sum or average), or weighting coefficients to mark some inputs as more significant than others, it's "AI" already? And I naïvely thought it was just, well, "computing". You could do "AI" on a 8086, ffs.
- katbyte 3y agono it IS more accurate. When i am off-roading i always record my track and have to unplug my phone from the trucks system to get an accurate un-smoothed track. google maps does weird things but gaia just uses the raw GPS data from the phone and doesn't snap, however when you are plugged into carplay the phone seems to always consider the car/trucks data more accurate even when its clearly not. this could very well my specific truck (dealer has refused to look and i don't have another to compare to) or a general tacoma thing but it both smooths the GPS data to make "nicer" looking lines and often introduces drift over time as likely some processing it does compounds an error (i also realize i said the wrong phone, iphone 14 not 12 but even with the 12 it was notably better then the truck but the 14 pro has a much improved GPS and it shows)
- withinboredom 3y agoAFAIK, and I could be wrong (though I did google this first), plugging your phone into CarPlay does not use the car’s gps unit. That’s just your phone trying to find a road because it’s connected to a car. Even if you are getting the car’s gps, it’s not going to give you raw values, but display values to show in an app, which should be smooth, IMHO.
- astrange 3y agoNo, it does use the car's GPS unit if it's provided to the phone. Which is why I started this thread by saying it did.
- katbyte 3y agohttps://discussions.apple.com/thread/250076351?sortBy=best https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250076351?sortBy=best > If your vehicle has wireless CarPlay, the iPhone's GPS chip is completely ignored. > If your vehicle has wired CarPlay, the iPhone's GPS chip may be ignored, depending upon what the head unit tells the phone to do. this happens when near roads or not. the truck is doing something weird and wrong with the GPS data and forcing the phone to use it
- t0mas88 3y agoBut the in-car unit has both GPS (with the antenna being on the roof) as well as wheel speed. Noticeable in longer tunnels with traffic jams that make the speed vary. Then it's clear Google maps takes a random guess at where you are while the in-car system knows how far along you are.
- katbyte 3y agothe only time i am paying attention is when off-roading and recording a track, and then its very obvious when the GPS is doing a good or bad job and unplugged from carplay i get a far more accurate track.
- beagle3 3y agoPhones also use WiFi access points and some Bluetooth beacons to get a better location. AFAIK only Google and Apple have up-to-date maps of these that are useful for navigation, and no one else does (Mozilla threw the towel a year or two ago). Cars can theoretically have better GPS antennae, and can do better dead reckoning using wheel position and wheel rotation speed. But do they? I haven’t seen any evidence that any car actually does better than a modern phone. Especially inside a dense city, WiFi location can be much more precise than GPS.
- katbyte 3y agoi only really care about accurate when off-roading in the middle of nowhere with no reception and recording my track - my iphone performs far better when unplugged from the truck then when plugged into it.
- astrange 3y agoThat's possible too, but the issue I was thinking of wasn't exactly reception - it's that GPS signals bounce off buildings and so it looks like you're somewhere else. Stronger reception might actually make that worse. Japan has local satellites to help with this (QZSS) and local cars may handle that better than global phones.
- mavhc 3y agoCars have wheel rotation and direction sensors so can do dead reckoning when the gps isn't being useful
- solardev 3y agoPhones will use the accelerometer and gyro to do dead reckoning too, like when you're in a tunnel.
- johnwalkr 3y agoThe Japanese navigation units in cars have been really good for at least 15 years. The signs and lane markings usually match exactly what’s ahead of you in real-life, and there’s a radio system on the highway gives traffic and road closure information even if you’re not connected to the internet. It’s only recently that smartphone apps are as good.
- babypuncher 3y agoThis is sort of the goal of Android Auto and CarPlay, but not as a mount for your phone. Rather, it turns the screen into a dumb terminal for your phone, bypassing all the shitty built-in software and providing a UX designed specifically for use while driving.
- mikepurvis 3y agoAnd critically lets you directly access CarPlay interfaces to apps for streaming, podcasts, navigation, etc, all of which is much richer than a dumb audio only passthru with skip buttons.
- drekipus 3y agoIn car navigation came before mobile smart phones
- adamomada 3y agoIronically, the nav unit I used on a rental car circa 2007-08 (birth of touchscreen smartphones) was exactly like the GP describes, a separate unit that had a mount like the modern smartphone variants.
- makeitdouble 3y agoPhone navigation apps are surprisingly bad in Japan (Google ones in particular). Not unusable, but the in-car GPS is more competitive than in other markets IMHO. Also with an aging population a phone screen is just too small for many. BTW, to parent's point VW has been trying different approaches with a top mounted GPS/infotainment unit that can be omitted on cheaper trims.
- onethought 3y agoAging population prefers low quality tiny screens with awkward interfaces?
- oneplane 3y agoThey prefer something they are already familiar with.
- chgs 3y agoThat’s one reason I use CarPlay - the interface hasn’t changed for years. Apart from one really annoying change to Apple Maps when they replaced the “silence directions” toggle from a big square to a touch, wait, touch tiny icon interface.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThey're not tiny, at least not compared to a phone. https://www.daihatsu.co.jp/lineup/move_canbus/03_exterior_interior.htm?type=1 https://www.daihatsu.co.jp/lineup/move_canbus/03_exterior_in...
- 10u152 3y agoDamn that looks like a cool car. Shame it's Japan only
- germinalphrase 3y agoJapan gets way better small car options than the US.