6 ms·
Vision Pro Demand Dwindles as Customer Interest Dropped After Initial Hype
- rickdeckard 3y agoSanity is slowly restored also within the Apple reality distortion field. They combined the best technology available to make the best possible consumer product, not caring about the final price, but then insisted that it shall NOT be used for the only consumer use-case which has SOME traction: VR-Gaming. Like insisting that the Apple Watch shall never display the time under any circumstances...
- Vecr 3y agoIs the statement about the watch a joke? I guess so, unless there's some conspiracy to trick non-owners...
- rickdeckard 3y agoyeah, it's an analogy to how odd of a strategy it is to design a consumer VR-device at this point in time without considering VR-gaming as a central use-case.
- sanitycheck 3y agoThis would also require Apple to start caring about ("real") gaming and ("real") gamers. Not a market they're remotely interested in, as far as I can gather. I think they don't like to be seen to be playing on the same field as other companies - I mean, they won't even call their VR goggles "VR", right?
- willis936 3y agoRight, so instead of growing an existing market they just assumed they would generate a new market when in reality there isn't one to make. They even knew this because Meta has publicly burned a container ship of cash in the past five years failing to make this imaginary market exist.
- rickdeckard 3y agoEven more odd, they didn't define that new market they are making, probably in hopes to not limit the possibilities. But they defined that they don't want the people who are buying VR-headsets now. "Here, new Platform. NO, NOT VR! Go ahead, do something with it. NOT GAMES!"
- sanitycheck 3y agoI don't try to predict what Apple will succeed with any more, not after the iPad. A major use case for the personal computer is games too and they don't try to compete there either. They could turn this AR headset thing into a success, with version 2 or 3. Maybe they figure that there are more (well-off) people interested in watching TV on a giant virtual screen than playing VR games, and maybe they're right. Regarding price, 10 years ago the idea of spending €2000 on a phone was unheard of but enough people are doing that now to justify the existence of the iPhone 15 Pro Max. If anyone can do it, Apple can.
- rickdeckard 3y agoThis is true, but what's different in this case is that they seem to rely fully on their developer community to create the end-user value. The iPhone was a Browser, a iPod, a Phone. The iPad was a Browser and a Reading Device. The Watch was a Wellness/Fitness companion. The Vision Pro is TBD, depending on what the community will come up with... The only thing that's clear and well-prepared this time is, that Apple gets a share of any revenue someone may create with it. If there's one company that can keep putting money into this until someone comes up with value, it's Apple. - I believe Apple's end-game is, that every user is wearing this all-day and Apple becomes the master-profiler and gatekeeper to any type of consumption also in the real world. But until they can execute on this direction they need to come up with a reason for someone to put this device on his head in first place...
- sanitycheck 3y agoIt's quite easy to get devs on board, all they need to do is add some new rules for App Store submissions. "All submitted apps targeting Apple TV devices must also fully support Apple Vision Pro by the end of Q1 2025" (Maybe only for apps with greater than X users in the previous Y months, initially.) We're all used to dealing with Apple by now, there would be some minor pushback and a bunch of reluctant AVP purchases by companies making VOD apps.
- karmakaze 3y agoThe product they made isn't the best VR device and they weren't aiming for it, so they had to distance themselves from VR naming. The best form-factor for VR is the Bigscreen Beyond IMO.
- vaylian 3y agoAlready discussed in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40113203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40113203 (different article though)
- LaurensBER 3y agoI'm not sure if this is a suprise for anyone. At 3.5k this is completely unaffordable for most of the world and even for high-earners in the US it's a tough pill to swallow for a first generation product. Not to mention that the Quest 3 is highly capable at 1/7th the price. I'm not sure what Apple's sales expectations were but if the Apple Vision Pro is not meeting them, they built the wrong product.
- bitwize 3y agoAdjusted for inflation, the Mac 128K cost as much as two Vision Pros. $2495 in 1984 dollars, equivalent to $7300 in 2023. It came with only 128k of RAM, as much as the Commodore 128, but with a fully bitmapped, high-resolution display and a much more sophisticated OS, leaving less room for applications. It did not come with a programming language; you had to buy third-party software to do anything with it and it could run only one, relatively simple, application at a time. It was the nearest thing to useless. Tech weenies dismissed it as the "Macintoy" and wondered how it would compete against far less expensive, but more programmable, machines like the PC and even the Commodore 128. And yet, it completely changed how the world computed. I do not see why the Vision Pro will not follow a similar trajectory, not least simply because it's an Apple product. Even if you sniffed at the first model, subsequent models will sport more powerful CPUs, more memory, better displays, and they will get the APIs and development model right to enable more kinds of applications. Apple is just dipping their toes into the water with this initial product much like they did with the Mac. Once they roll out more refined products, the difference with the Quest will be as night and day and it will be obvious that once again, Apple has changed how we compute.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoExcept it’s not 1984 anymore.
- dartos 3y agoIt’s always been 1984
- 3y ago
- Syzygies 3y agoI lucked into a demo yesterday while my wife bought a new iPhone and Apple Watch. The guy was free. The device is stunning, beyond our normal experience with other devices. One should try one, before debating its future. My potential use case is to better understand 3-dimensional topology. I'm not concerned about "popular" uses other than how that affects the viability of the product. There's a potential for some astounding abstract art, when visual artists catch up with musicians who master their own digital tools. This thing is capable of inducing drug-free hallucinations. And of course one recalls the killer app for VCRs...
- lm28469 3y ago> One should try one, before debating its future. Sound like a solution looking for problems
- vaylian 3y agoOr an alternative to existing solutions
- rickdeckard 3y agofor which existing problems?
- vaylian 3y agoRepresenting, manipulating and discussing data in a more detailed way
- tw04 3y agoMy buddy got one for free. The continual feedback is “this is cool but not worth anything close to $3500”. Unless Apple is willing to significantly reduce their normal margin profile this just isn’t ever going to see mass adoption.
- jinushaun 3y ago
- akmarinov 3y agoYeah, this was a devkit and hype machine, outside of some devs, people with money and Youtube reviewers- there’s no market for a $3500 device
- poisonborz 3y agoOk, but where are the devs and where is the hype?
- akmarinov 3y agoThe devs already got theirs, whoever was interested got theirs, some companies likely got 1 for their team and that’s that. There was a ton of hype - Casey Neistat’s video trended, MKBHD spent three weeks pretty much only talking about it, Joanna Stern, etc At this point if it was in the $1000 range - it’ll likely sell very well. Naturally things died down and when we get a simpler, cheaper version in ~2 years - there’ll be interest.
- self_awareness 3y agoMaybe VR isn't the technology we should invest in after all. I mean, we are all living in a simulation anyway, and nesting it seems like an insane move :)
- harryp_peng 3y agoNo, it's simply a faster way to operate a computer. Imagine if you didn't have to scroll and click using a mouse - that alone is a killer.
- self_awareness 3y agoI don't think the world has invented a better pointing/control device than a mouse + keyboard: trackballs are nice, but the ball gets sweaty quickly, and they're not as fast. Touch interfaces are nice, but they're nowhere near as precise as the mouse. Trackpads are nice, but they stress the palm more than a mouse. Similarily, VR interface would be nice, but I don't think it will be as precise as the mouse. Maybe the interfaces themselves will compensate, as they do now for touch controls, by making everything bigger and putting a lot of empty space, but will it be better? I doubt it. Human hand has evolved to use physical tools, not by waving empty hands in the air to show abstract concepts. So I'm not sure why some people think the latter is some kind of natural behavior for humans. We use sticks, hammers, knives. Physical stuff. We have to know how it feels, what is the weight, the texture of the surface. By moving everything to virtual space we are depraving ourselves a large part of our senses. Is that better? Not for me. A better way would probably something that would not depend on the eyes that much, and would provide the same/better control than a mouse can give. Not only this would use more senses, but also would actually improve the quality of life of all people with severe vision deficiences. Currently we all put everything related to IT to the eyes; and if our eyes fail, then we're f*cked. And technology should be there to support and protect us.
- prmoustache 3y agoBut at this point shouldn't we directly put chips/electrodes into our brain and not have to wear an uncomfortable device? The vision pro is just an half assed middle point between regular desktop/laptop use and an almost telepathic way of interacting with computers. And if you need a middle point, I mean at the very least build something that is actually bearable and that still make you look like a socially apt person like the Xreal air glasses.
- lesserknowndan 3y agoI think that it is important to note that currently it is only available in the USA; and that anyone who wanted one, and could readily afford one, has probably bought it already. There are also probably many in the US that have decided to wait for the next version. I’m sure that when they release it in literally every other country in the world they will sell more (including to me).
- harryp_peng 3y agoYeah, it's the future, and will definitely be buying it. That and neural interface will be the desktop off 2040 I think.
- sovietmudkipz 3y agoI think VR is missing its killer app generally so useful that it makes the experience worth it. I think the tech is so new that we’re all collectively barely scratching the surface on what the medium could be. I’ve had thoughts drawing from my experience playing RTS and organizing information and action under an “inspired by RTS” paradigm. A warehouse with robots could lend itself to management software that could benefit from occasionally putting on a headset and commanding a tiny fleet of drones. I’ve had thoughts and some experiments using a web based Unity VR but haven’t had as much time to pursue more. I wonder if there’s real opportunity in this space I should be doing more in, especially because it doesn’t seem like very many XR developers exist right now, and there is a new community of Apple users hungry for more useful XR apps. Early days still. Thus far I’ve trained myself on Unity and have enjoy delivering multiplayer games (thus far built using AWS as platform). I’ve gone through Unity’s VR training (~170 had completed at time of taking) and my personal project was a helms deep style tower defense game, which I loaded up on my valve index through a web browser (pre webGPU support). I think a dedicated app for the target OS is probably best for a VR application but I have tickled myself thinking about hypothetical boring enterprise VR apps served over a web browser. Any advice from the community? If I wanted to explore XR/VR apps as a developer with more of my daily time, how might I capitalize enough to support myself and one or more families worth of people who can work as collaborators? I’m a moonlighter and there’s only so much time in a day. Nothing is holding me back from spending personal coin hiring freelancers but there is also a local entrepreneurial tech sales pitch event I could present at if I wanted to work with local investors/talent. Should I apply at Meta/Apple or any other big company to see what their XR ops are? Try to bootstrap more by selling online education content and/or create a community and thus unlock more opportunities? I’m open to advice; thanks in advance to anyone who writes back.
- jbluepolarbear 3y agoIn my experience, VR is hindered by a new “boys club”: a group of people that aren’t game developers, but invested early in VR tech. Issue being that this group of developers can build decent VR controls and mechanics, but don’t know much, if anything, about how games should be made. Too many VR games are plagued with clunky controls, poor gameplay mechanics, and uninteresting progression. And to top it off these VR companies refuse to hire veteran game devs because they don’t have VR experience.
- SmarsJerry 3y agoIt’s hard to claim the launch was anything but a disaster. It’s an expensive toy, one that doesn’t offer much benefit, if any, over its much cheaper counterpart which is 1/10th the price, which also isn’t blowing up in sales either. Should have waited to enter this market until it could at least double the features of the cheaper counter part at this price.