5 ms·
> society taking a wrong turn to being driven by ratings on the I internet Workers being driven by ratings systems pre-dates the popularity of Internet gig eco
by Aurornis 3y ago
> society taking a wrong turn to being driven by ratings on the I internet
Workers being driven by ratings systems pre-dates the popularity of Internet gig economy jobs. By a lot.
The customer ratings concept even infected places like your local doctor’s office a couple decades ago. Doctors have been complaining about how patient satisfaction surveys have discouraged them from bringing up obesity, smoking, or excessive drinking for decades. Doctors are also more likely to give in to patient demands for unnecessary antibiotics or controlled substances when they know it’s going to result in a hit to their ratings if those ratings are related to their compensation.
Every time I’ve visited a car dealer for service in the past few decades, the service manager is almost begging me to give them a “9 or 10” on the survey that will be sent to me afterward. He pleads that I work with him first to address anything that might reduce his rating.
Even vehicle drivers have had “How is my driving?” numbers on the back of their cars for a very long time.
Having customer satisfaction surveys tied to performance reviews isn’t new if you’ve worked in anything customer-facing. It’s just getting more attention now because “gig economy” has become a journalistic buzzword and people are more likely to be sympathetic to an hourly worker than, say, the doctor or service manager at their local dealership.
Even long before all of this, tipping was the standard way of linking customer feedback to compensation. This applied to delivery drivers, too! The hand-wringing over customer feedback being an internet-era gig economy thing is misplaced. It has always been this way.
- LocalH 3y agoMy SO is a restaurant manager, and she has told me that the only reviews/ratings that have any positive effects are 5s out of 5. 4 out of 5? You might as well have put 0 or 1. It's extremely toxic.
- ghaff 3y agoAnd Ebay, so 20+ years. It was either positive and A+++++ or it's effectively negative.
- pc86 3y agoI remember once I bought a car and the salesman said if I had any reservations about giving him a 10/10 on every question in the survey no matter what it was that I should text or call his personal phone and he'd do whatever he could to fix it, also directly saying that it's better for them to have 95% of people not fill it out at all and get 10/10 from everyone else than to have 100% completion with a single 9/10. I don't know if it's true or not but he told me he lost out on a $10k volume bonus because someone who was extremely happy with everything gave him 9/10 on all questions and in the comments simply put "I wouldn't change anything about my experience, it was great! But perfection is reserved for God." I've heard this from everyone I've ever bought a car from, everyone I know who has ever been involved with that industry, etc. Why even have surveys if the point is just to collect 100%s and not actually find things to change without taking money out of people's pockets?
- AlexandrB 3y agoThis is classic Goodhart's Law stuff[1]. The key takeaway is that any company that implement these kinds of incentives doesn't actually give a shit about customer experience, they just like to play pretend. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- jjk166 3y ago> Why even have surveys if the point is just to collect 100%s and not actually find things to change without taking money out of people's pockets? "So if I implement this system then either I get confirmation that everything I'm responsible for is perfect or I get an excuse to save money on labor?" - management approximately 8 seconds before implementing the surveys.
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoThis mirrors my experience in retail. Anything less than the top score is counted as a negative, often counting the 1-9 score as a 0 with the 10 as a 1. The heat lands on a local manager when corporate comes to town. What ends up happening is that the customer-facing employees train the customers to put down 10s. It's ultimately a metric that's been gamified by everyone involved. I think the cynics keep it around because it gives customers a voice.
- LocalH 3y agoWhich is ironic, given that it modifies the customer's actual voice when interpreting the numbers in such a toxic way. I point to the cousin comment where a salesman lost a $10k bonus because a customer didn't give them a 10, despite the customer's comment being very explicit that they were extremely happy with the experience, but that they refused to rate anything perfectly, as they reserved that for God. Despite that comment, the 9 was used as justification to deny the bonus, effectively also denying the customer's voice.
- supertrope 3y ago[flagged]
- salad-tycoon 3y agoOr pull a YouTube/google and just eventually totally remove the option to down vote at all. “ Yeah… we’ve heard the vox populi and ehhh, gonna have to pass on that one.”
- wodenokoto 3y agoTo me that’s the crazy thing. You give a 4/5 and immediately you’re asked what was wrong. It’s also why Netflix moved tot the thumbs up/down system. When they moved into new territories their recommendations system had troubles since some territories would rate everything as “bad”, because in that territory 3/5 meant it was fine and they enjoyed the show.
- tyingq 3y ago> Workers being driven by ratings systems pre-dates the popularity of Internet gig economy jobs. By a lot. Your electronic report card is now more persistent, and there's a much smaller number of companies dominating these gig industries, and they cross areas (food delivery + driving people, for example). It's not as easy to start over.
- pc86 3y agoIs this necessarily a bad thing? Do we want to make it easy for someone to "start over" when that means instead of driving bags of food around they're now driving around people?
- tyingq 3y agoThe scoring system doesn't necessarily reflect reality. Separately, there is a drive towards a sort of "social credit rating" that I do think is a bad thing. In the narrower space of having a criminal history, the US is very different in how that affects people that have done their time. Any company can do a dirt-cheap background check, this makes people close to unemployable. In other countries, like Australia, employers can request a "yes/no" answer to "is this person's history suitable for this specific job" from a government agency...but they can't just get history themselves. The combination of consolidation in the space into a few giants, and dirt cheap sharing of data across employers is, over time, applying the same sort of permanent mark problem to everyone else. I think it's a bad thing.
- nradov 3y agoSome US states have now adopted "ban the box" legislation which prohibits asking job candidates about criminal history (at least for certain jobs). Of course, it's still tough to explain a 10-year employment gap on a CV. https://www.nelp.org/publication/ban-the-box-fair-chance-hiring-state-and-local-guide/ https://www.nelp.org/publication/ban-the-box-fair-chance-hir...
- BobaFloutist 3y ago
- cm2012 3y agoDoctors telling patients they're fat doesn't help them get skinnier. The literature is pretty clear that in every double blind study, the category of medical advice or helping make nutrition and exercise plans leads to 0lbs average weight loss over 5 years.
- everforward 3y agoNo, but some people do need to be informed of how dangerous it is, and doctors can either prescribe weight loss medications or give a referral to a doctor specializing in medical and surgical weight loss. Regardless, it’s something I would expect doctors to nag patients about, the same way my dentist nags me to floss.
- FeepingCreature 3y agoWhy, if there's proven to be no benefit?
- youcantcook 3y ago[dead]
- lupusreal 3y ago"Proven to have no benefit" in this case only means that most people won't lose weight after being told to. A minority will though, so doctors refusing to tell fat people to lose weight is a disservice to the few who stand a chance of making it. The rest should either be signed up for surgery, drugs, or written off as lost causes.
- everforward 3y agoThe person I responded to said that there's no benefit to advice to diet and exercise. Presuming that's true (I doubt that there's 0 effect, and e.g. [1] would disagree), there are still benefits. As I mentioned, advice on dieting and exercising is far from the only tool doctors can reach for here. There are medical options that doctors can prescribe (or refer to another doctor for a prescription). WeGovy/semaglutide, Adipex, HCG, good old adderall, etc. I haven't followed the space in about a decade so I don't know what's in and what's banned, but I'm aware there are a range of options there. I believe there are some outpatient programs as well, semantically similar to outpatient rehabs. There are also surgical options that doctors can refer patients to a surgeon for. Laparoscopic bands, gastric bypasses, I think there's a third that I can't recall. The incredibly sad issue is that doctors are sometimes forced to fall back on advice to diet and exercise because many of these treatments are contra-indicated with common comorbidities of obesity. Anesthesia can be very risky for patients with a BMI of 45 or 50, so they may need to lose weight the old fashioned way until they're at a weight where they can be safely anesthetized. Stimulants (adipex and adderall) are very effective at curbing hunger, but are contra-indicated by high blood pressure which is incredibly common. I also believe there's a large segment of primary care physicians who aren't up to date on weight loss procedures, because they change fairly frequently relative to something like treating strep throat. [1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6169796/#:~:text=Studies%20have%20suggested%20that%20weight,of%20overweight%20and%20obese%20patients.&text=Patients%20who%20reported%20receiving%20such%20advice%20had%20greater%20intention%20to%20lose%20weight https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6169796/#:~:tex... (
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, these ratings problems aren't new, but they are more pervasive and less useful than ever before. For my part, I just refuse to give ratings or pay attention to them. The effective binary nature of ratings (if you don't give the best one, you may as well give worst one) was the last straw for me. Ratings are a game that harms both customers and the people providing good and services.
- AlexandrB 3y agoAgreed. And because ratings are so broken, there are multiple ways to game them. In addition to rarely leaving ratings, I rarely trust the damn things either. In my opinion, ratings need to decay over time. For service workers like Uber drivers any rating >1 year old (or maybe less) should decay to 0 significance. For online retail like Amazon, maybe 2 years but not much longer than that. This not only allows people to "clean up their act" after bad ratings, but makes botting a recurring cost instead of a one-time investment.
- 20after4 3y agoNotably steam ratings on games are divided into "all time" and "recent" categories.
- supertrope 3y agoApp store ratings are gamed through bugging users to rate the app, cozying up to the app store maintainer who can delete reviews, or even Sybil attacks on competing apps.
- nox101 3y agoI had I think, a related issue. I moved, need a new dentist, called one, told them I wanted to take a sleeping pill because it helps me with my anxiety from previous painful dentist visits. They said they'd have their office manager call me back. He vehemently steered me to another dentist. It was ridiculous how much corp-speak he used to try to convince me it was in my best interest. They had a 5/5 rating. I assume it's because they reject anyone the think might lower it.
- tengbretson 3y agoAsking someone to temporarily take on the responsibility of your medical wellbeing while admittedly being on psychotropics is a bit of an ask, isn't it?
- nox101 3y agoIs it? My last dentist did it
- nradov 3y agoYou're probably reading too much into that interaction. Look for a local sedation dentistry practice. They specialize in managing patients with anxiety. Regular dentists may not be set up to handle patients with major anxiety. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/22275-sedation-dentistry https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/22275-sedat...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nox101 3y agomy last dentist did it and was not a "sedation Dentistry" practice. She was head of the California Dental Association tho
- cess11 3y agoIt's much broader than that. Having people with little to no understanding of work evaluate and exercise power over it has been foundational for capitalism since its beginning.