5 ms·
Bret Victor: What can a technologist do about climate change? A personal view
- omgCPhuture 3y agoHey, I have an idea: How about we retro-fit the 8 biggest container freight ships on earth with nuclear engines like submarines, air carriers etc. have, or even electric ones. That would cut the air pollution by something akin to the pollution by most of the cars on the planet, combined. Those things run on the worst sludge fossil fuel in existance. So why are we not doing that? I wonder because cows do not fart, they burp. And methane breaks down into water within 14 days of UV exposure in the atmosphere, and I like cows. Another idea is Thorium reactors, they can run on spent fuel from traditional nuclear plants which is mostly _not used up_ and therefor must be stored millions of years. This would reduce storage time to thousands of years, make the spent rods a commodity and the physics preclude catastrophic meltdowns, make it really hard to enrich whatever those thingies they make thermonuclear atomic weapons with. .. why are we not doing that either? $0.02
- nonrandomstring 3y agoA very well written and sobering article, and a question each of us should ask seriously. "How can I realistically help, as a tech person and hacker?" 18 Terawatts of demand, and rising, with just a few hours of stored capacity. It's like reaching an energy escape velocity. We're basically betting entirely on fusion and probably are not going to "make it". So personally, I think about transitioning society to resilient non-dependence, and about designing for intermittent and highly variable energy and connectivity as vital goals. A lot of what we do with computers - is really about what we don't do. Stop helping create obsolescence and waste. Curb the pointless chindogu, costly aesthetics above function, feeding vanity and insecurity to stoke demand etc. Tech seems to have a culture of gratuitous indulgence and luxury against a global backdrop of austere caution.
- omgCPhuture 3y agoI cannot speak for others, but one hacker did respond w/ ideas for a couple of things he is wondering like crazy about why are not implemented because of the massive RoI. Hackers and technologists shouuld be able to join forces. Maybe someone brighter than I am can explain why those things are not done post-haste.I am hardly among the brightest folks here, or anywhere. I am just curious about things. Curious, or fiend for that A-ha experience!:)
- glandium 3y agoOT: oh wow, did chindōgu really make it to English? (it's Japanese for gadget)
- nonrandomstring 3y agoFor me, absolutely yes! It's a really important art-form with lots to say about technology but hides inside fun and frivolity. I'm really into studying it. :)
- nonrandomstring 3y agoMaybe you know, what's the plaural of chindogu? Like sheep (one chindogu, many chindogu)?
- glandium 3y agoThere is no plural in Japanese.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago[dead]
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago(2015)
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoUhg, yes thank you. I was reading through and I got to the section on battery storage. Anyone following CAISO lately knows that batteries are already doing some heavy lifting each single day, and the article seemed years out of date. Had to scroll back up to the top to see that yes, indeed it’s old.
- smgit 3y agoIts a political problem much more than a technical problem cuz all people wont accept the purely tech solution. And technologists are still learning how to incorporate the political dimensions into their solutions. Its non-optional to ignore them - https://jacobin.com/2023/12/evgeny-morozov-interview-technology-sovereignty-global-south-development-cybersyn https://jacobin.com/2023/12/evgeny-morozov-interview-technol...
- atonse 3y agoJust realized this article was written in 2015. Because I feel the biggest problem to overcome now is politics. If we could magically rid the world of the toxic and addictive qualities of social media algorithms, (something technologists could do directly), and put more focus on fact finding and disseminating, it would have an impact.
- omgCPhuture 3y agoTHIS. Politics, The big money drowns out even an enormous amount of citizens, hackers or not. 8 container ships cannot be a very massive income for the industries throwing money at politicians and would go a long way. Thorium reactors would create new jobs, deal with the problem om storing radioactive fuel rods for millions of years by making them a commodity for a new industry that makes use of them and reduces the millions of years needed to store those down to thousands of years and when we run out of nuclear waste we can continue fueling them with thorium, which is _everywhere_. The air would get cleaner & ther is money to be made. You would think not that much political will was needed for small, big impact things like that. Of course, ther eis always the chance I am insane and will wake up from this nightmare in a haze from forcefully administered anti-psychotics via injection
- rayiner 3y ago> Because I feel the biggest problem to overcome now is politics Politics is just a proxy for people’s desires and motivations and willingness to make trade offs. Polls show that most americans agree humans are causing climate change, but most won’t spend even $10 a month to combat climate change: https://apnorc.org/projects/is-the-public-willing-to-pay-to-help-fix-climate-change https://apnorc.org/projects/is-the-public-willing-to-pay-to-... (open the top line results pdf). Forget EVs. What’s it going to cost for people to replace their gas and oil heat with heat pumps? Way more than $10/month!
- atonse 3y agoBut the article has a few examples where government action helped start a movement (like with financing large solar projects because private banks wouldn’t) So things like subsidies could just help nudge markets to go. So strong subsidies for heat pumps would incentivize more people to make that move. But to use your analogy, it’s also something mentioned in the article (or maybe I wanted to interpret it how I wanted to), we also don’t do a good job of communicating the risks. My eyes glaze over when I read 2 degrees, “metric tons of CO2” cuz I can’t imagine how to weigh a gas, and other similar figures that are simply harder to relate to. So we need to find better ways to communicate these things than very nerdy statistical model figures and such.
- melling 3y ago“The primary cause of that is the burning of coal, natural gas, and petroleum in order to generate electricity and move vehicles around” It was written almost 9 years ago and we’re almost in the same place. Peak fossil fuels are expected in the next few years. https://www.npr.org/2023/10/24/1207976763/global-shift-to-clean-energy-means-fossil-fuel-demand-will-peak-soon-iea-says https://www.npr.org/2023/10/24/1207976763/global-shift-to-cl...
- jnxx 3y agoIn the realm of electricity production, things are now changing very quickly, though not yet as fast as needed. Where a huge amount of works needs to be done is carbon-economic transport, housing and construction, and agriculture. And, yes, we will need to say farewell to a few things. That's OK, we are also not using steam engines any more.
- greenie_beans 3y agothis is one of the pieces of writing that encouraged me to get into tech.