6 ms·
It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new research says (2021)
- baal80spam 3y ago> The answer is less about age and more about lifestyle.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThat sounds pedantic. It's not like people get older and decide to be less active. Your muscles atrophy, and it's not as easy.
- logicchains 3y agoYour muscles atrophy if you don't use them. A 60 year old power lifter is stronger than a 30 year old who never lifts. On average people lose around 5% of their muscle mass per decade after 30; someone with twice as much muscle mass at 30 is still going to have more muscle mass at 60 than the person who started at 30 with half as much muscle mass.
- cassianoleal 3y agoExcept for really old age, they mostly atrophy because of sedentarism. Even then, I've seen excellent climbers and alpinists past 70. Keep moving and your body will keep working.
- latency-guy2 3y agoThe effect of atrophy, meaning non-use, is larger than the effect of aging, yes.
- keybored 3y agoI’m at the point where my peers complain about getting older.[1] And I’ve started wondering how much of that is really about age and how much is the cumulative effects of “lifestyle”. I mean if you sit in a chair for ten years for 12 hours a day you’ve probably become “too old” for doing cartwheels. But it could be reversed, maybe. [1] Am I 25 or 50? Impossible to say in this climate of complaining.
- silverquiet 3y agoYeah, late 30’s with a bad hip from childhood illness and I still managed to shed 50 pounds and get stronger than ever after being very sedentary for years. Diet and exercise and no drugs (I’d for sure take Ozempic if it was affordable too). Just me, but I spent way too much time thinking I was getting old and I was wrong.
- Brybry 3y agoThat doesn't seem to be what the study they cited said though. Basically the common model was that metabolism steadily declines with age (for adults). The study cited[1] says that doesn't match their data. What they found was that metabolism was higher than expected for kids 1-20, stable for adults 21-60, and lower than expected for senior adults 60+. [2] I don't want to say thresholds but you can look at the figures and see the rapid increase (0-1), decline (1-20), stability (21-60), and decline again (60+). So age probably matters more to metabolism (than we thought) for some age groups but not for other age groups. And I don't think there was really anything about lifestyle other than this bit: > consistent with the hypothesis that energy intake is coupled to expenditure But obviously that won't help anyone lose weight (which is usually what people are complaining about when they complain about an assumed slowing metabolism) cause it's saying people take in more calories when they burn more calories. [1] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abe5017 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abe5017 [2] https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/surprising-findings-about-metabolism-and-age-202110082613#:~:text=points%20of%20this%20study https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/surprising-findings-abou...
- cebert 3y agoI wonder if employers will be more receptive to regular breaks for knowledge workers who are mostly sedentary. One befits of working from home before being mandated back to the office was being able to go on a walk during lunch and less-critical meetings.
- sroussey 3y agoI always went on walks in the middle of the day at my office job. A quarter of the time I would bring a colleague, particularly from a different group but whom I would still interface with.
- WheatMillington 3y agoSurely you can do this from the office? I do.
- walthamstow 3y agoWhat kind of office/work culture do you have where you can't go for a walk at lunch?
- cebert 3y agoThere’s managers who make assumptions if you’re not in your seat you’re not working, which is one of the reasons I liked WFH.
- armchairhacker 3y agoCould you go for a walk during lunch in-office? My understanding is, unless the employer is paying you during lunch, they can’t mandate what you do. The only problems are 1) it’s not good socially if everyone else is eating lunch and you’re doing something else, and 2) your employer may not give or allow a long break during work hours, but I don’t how common that is (or how it would be justified, considering you’re not working for less hours).
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoYou see this often with middle class city people in their late 20s and 30s. You go from being athletic in high school and walking all day in college to suddenly being in your prime dating age, regularly out eating and drinking with friends or dates, hitting 2-3 cocktails a few nights a week. You start investing more into your ultra-sedentary career, which you drive to, which constantly requires more of your time to get that next promotion. You are unable to have healthy home cooking, instead replacing it with restaurant work lunches and happy hours with your coworkers. In addition, as you make more money, that enables even more convenience. Amazon delivers you products, no need to leave the house. Instacart delivers you groceries, no need to even go to the corner store. Doordash always at the ready to indulge every craving. Uber will happily save you every step you choose not to take. All of that quickly adds up way before you even hit your 40s, and many will claim that it's their metabolism, when in reality it's 100% a result of a dramatic lifestyle change.
- paulpauper 3y agoI don't think it's a s simple as inactivity. IF this were true, then being active would reverse the weight gains, but it does not, at least not for me and others. I was still as active in my 30s as I was in my late teens and 20s but still gained weight. Likewise, gyms are full of people in their 30s and 40s who are not losing weight despite regular attendance. Despite the popularity of fitness apps, people keep getting fatter. It is only GLP-1 drugs that has put some dent in obesity rates. I think metabolism or some other biological, non-environmental variable plays some role. Or some reduction of NEAT that cannot be explained by careers.
- throwaway22032 3y agoCounterpoint - everyone I know who counts calories is able to either lose or gain weight roughly according to their plan. This is borne out in essentially every sport which has weight classes at both the amateur and professional level. Part of becoming healthy is calibrating yourself against other healthy individuals. No, not genetic freaks, just that neighbour who actually looks after themselves.
- lapcat 3y ago(2021)
- somenameforme 3y agoThe article failed to mention another huge benefit of protein - it makes you feel full for longer. Eating 2000 calories of carbs is super easy. Eating 2000 calories of chicken breast is painfully hard.
- euroderf 3y ago2000 calories of protein def fends off hunger. If I know I'm going to be traveling all day, I load up on eggs for breakfast. It beats getting ripped off for crappy snacks at travel waypoints.
- fsckboy 3y agowhole eggs have substantial fat, as a confounding factor in your analysis
- justsocrateasin 3y agoI think OP's statement was cutting corners. Protein and fat both help you stay full for longer. Carbs/sugar do not. Even this statement cuts corners, but overall science supports the general sentiment.
- csa 3y ago> Eating 2000 calories of carbs is super easy. Is it? That’s about 10 cups of cooked plain boiled rice. I think carbs only hit the “easy to hit 2k” mark when it’s sugar (maybe?) or when it’s added with fat, especially fried foods. > Eating 2000 calories of chicken breast is painfully hard. I think this is about 7 cups of boiled, skinless breast of chicken. I think this gets back to fat, or lack thereof. For me personally, lean proteins don’t really fill me up — I have knocked back a pound of chicken breast with fresh veggies and I was hungry a few hours later. It’s mainly fats that do the trick for me for feeling sated — nuts, fat in meat, cheese, oil (esp. for roasting vegetables), etc.
- Detrytus 3y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI do wonder if this study is confusing, at some level, cause and effect. Yes, I definitely understand the argument that people blame things on "my slowing metabolism", but then don't seem to notice that the requirements of middle age (e.g. full time job and especially folks with kids) can make it harder to get exercise. At the same time, I don't have kids, and while I've stayed relatively active into middle age I've definitely noticed that it takes me much longer to recover after strenuous exercise than it did when I was younger. And so it's simply harder to stay as active, because my body is basically telling me "stop!" more often. It's already well documented that testosterone levels in men begin to decline starting in your thirties at about 1% a year, so I think skepticism is in order if researchers would claim that this reduction in testosterone levels would have no impact on activity level and metabolic rate.
- 331c8c71 3y ago> takes me much longer to recover after strenuous exercise than it did when I was younger The biggest difference I feel is proclivity to (small but reoccurring) injuries in certain weak spots...
- BeetleB 3y agoThis is from 2021 and was widely reported at the time. I see a lot of know-it-all comments, but the reality is they do not yet know why people gain weight in their middle age. No - the data doesn't show that it's merely due to being sedentary or changing diets.
- monero-xmr 3y agoIf you want to reduce weight, then lower your caloric intake. You don’t even need to workout. Just measure your calories and keep decreasing them until the weight falls off. If you want to add in exercise, that’s great too, and then you can eat more calories. But if you studiously count calories and reduce them, you will lose weight - it’s guaranteed. If I put you on a desert island and starved you, you would lose weight. It’s the same principle. Trying to imagine that there is a mystery here to explain weight gain is a coping mechanism. There is no mystery.
- BeetleB 3y agoThe mystery isn't how to lose weight but why weight increases despite no change in activity and diet.
- nradov 3y agoBut it doesn't. Weight only increases if energy input exceeds output. People lie about how much they eat.
- 331c8c71 3y agoThe problem with losing weight without exercising is that it's not only fat but also muscles that are lost.
- thefz 3y agoMostly bullshit as fat is the primary source for energy in the body and hard to earn protein are not. It's a myth mostly, do fast, do exercise, you will not lose muscle.
- wolverine876 3y agoThe paper in Science: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abe5017 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abe5017
- inetsee 3y agoIf it is true that frequent, brief, moderately intense exercise is that beneficial, I can see several ways that office workers can fit that into their workday. If you work in a multi-floor office building: when going to the restroom, walk up stairs to a restroom on a floor above the one you work on; if you go out for lunch, walk to lunch, then walk up the stairs when you get back; if you are going to a meeting, leave you desk a couple of minutes early and walk up and down the stairs before going to the meeting room. All of these ideas have something in common: walking up stairs is as close to HIIT that most people get during their day.
- nradov 3y agoA lot of people claim they have trouble losing weight because of a "slow metabolism". In most cases their metabolism is normal and they haven't even had a resting metabolic rate (RMR) test. Those tests are easy, inexpensive, and non-invasive. It's worth getting one just to understand your baseline energy expenditure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoI just eat too much. But I am always hungry too.
- datatrashfire 3y agoBest way to stay in shape in my opinion is to play a sport, especially in some sort of league/club. If you genuinely enjoy playing, it doesn't feel like a chore! Now into my mid 30s, I do not regularly go to the gym, I do not have any special dietary habits, and I weigh the same as 18.