5 ms·
How Perfectly Can Reality Be Simulated?
- echelon 3y agoHow perfectly can the reverse light cone be simulated? That's something I think about more and more. It seems plausible and, moreover, every bit as interesting as exploring what's left in the whole rest of the universe.
- qazxcvbnm 3y agoThe world is chaotic. > In chaotic systems, the uncertainty in a forecast increases exponentially with elapsed time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory (The above applies equally to the past)
- PikachuEXE 3y agoNever perfectly enough. We can never know true knowledge/wisdom which is reserved for Gods. We can at most be lovers of knowledge/wisdom.
- can16358p 3y agoAnd what if those "gods" are just hypervisors/controllers/programmers of the simulation?
- dsego 3y agoNot only that, if the simulation theory is true, than it's most likely that there are more levels of simulations and we live in one of the many simulations within simulations. I've read somewhere that this could be more probable than the chance of living in an original first universe. Btw, this is esoteric, but NDE-s usually speak of akashic records, whereby everything in this universe is being recorded and can be revisited.
- xandrius 3y agoIf I fully simulate a car and its internal, I pretty sure I don't need to know about its "gods" wisdom/knowledge, I've just got to replicate how the system behaves.
- jareklupinski 3y agoAt some point we'll build a perfect mimicry of the natural world. The interesting part is what happens in the first fork.
- lukan 3y ago"At some point we'll build a perfect mimicry of the natural world." A perfect simulation of the natural world, would be a second natural world.
- kromem 3y agoThis assumes that the natural world isn't itself simulated, or it's not a second natural world, but an nth natural world. Turtles all the way down.
- lukan 3y agoYes it does, but so far there are lots of indications for infinite complexity and 0 indications for it being a simulation.
- kromem 3y agoGiven we're in a universe that at macro scales appears to be continuous, and even continues to appear that way at micro scales until interacted with leaving persistent information around state changes (and switching back if the information is erased, like any good memory optimization might), we should probably seriously entertain that being in an emulated continuous universe with discrete side effects would mean real computing would be on the table for a foundational reality. Can you point to any "indications of infinite complexity" that couldn't be run on a real computer?
- lukan 3y ago"Can you point to any "indications of infinite complexity" that couldn't be run on a real computer?" Have you ever seen an accurate long term weather forecast?
- kfarr 3y agoThis reads like an Epic Games PR piece. Good for them but there’s nothing new here for close followers of 3d tech.
- Animats 3y agoRight. The new thing, for people who don't follow this, is that UE5 has crawled most of the way out of the uncanny valley. They still can't do totally convincing humans in real time, but they are getting close.
- Vecr 3y agoHow much time do you have? In real time, I'm not super optimistic. If you don't care about speed you're just limited by storage and maintenance.
- mensetmanusman 3y ago“ Sweeney, Epic’s C.E.O., has the backstory of tech-founder lore—college dropout, headquarters in his parents’ basement, posture-ruining work ethic—and the stage presence of a spelling-bee contestant who’s dissociating.” Okay. Made me laugh.
- noxs 3y agowe can't even perfectly simulate a single hydrogen atom (perturbative theory would need infinitely many terms to be exact)
- panda-giddiness 3y agoI don't know about "perfectly", but we can simulate hydrogen from QCD; we just estimate the path integral directly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD
- adrian_b 3y agoI am not sure what you mean by hydrogen. QCD is about the strong forces, i.e. about the nucleus, which is a proton or a deuteron in the case of hydrogen. However nobody has ever succeeded to make a useful simulation of the proton or of any other hadron. Such a simulation must be based on a small number of universal parameters, e.g. the masses of the quarks etc., and it must be able to compute useful physical quantities, e.g. the masses of the hadrons, the magnetic moments of the hadrons, the energies of their excited states and so on, with a precision comparable with that of the empirical measurements. Nobody has succeeded until now to perform such a simulation. On the other hand, if we assign to the proton the properties determined by empirical measurements (i.e. mass and magnetic moment), quantum electrodynamics can be used to compute with high precision various properties of the proton-electron system, i.e. of the hydrogen atom.
- Ono-Sendai 3y agoNot only that, we can't even simulate a single nucleon
- breuleux 3y agoIt depends on which aspects you're trying to simulate accurately. If you consider the physically optimal implementation of any function (e.g. the optimal NAND gate), that system cannot be simulated in real time: the simulation will always be slower, pretty much by definition. Insofar that physics optimally implements itself, you cannot simulate reality in general without a massive performance hit (think about the recursive absurdity of the simulator simulating itself). What you can try to do is simulate the most salient/important aspects of reality, but the more physically optimal these aspects become, the harder simulation of them will get. For instance, as our computers become faster and more efficient, fast simulation of our reality becomes progressively harder. That's without even considering the physical optimality of natural systems, of course, which I imagine is rather high.
- naasking 3y agoSimulated time does not need to match real time.
- breuleux 3y agoDepends on the application. If you're playing a video game, you want real time. If you're trying to predict something, the simulation needs to run faster than real time. If you're trying to model a new technology or a recurrent situation, up to a few orders of magnitude of slowdown is quite acceptable.
- mr_toad 3y ago> Depends on the application. If you're playing a video game, you want real time. If the player is part of the simulation they won’t know.
- breuleux 3y agoI mean, sure, but the value proposition of a slow simulation containing slow minds is a little dubious, isn't it? It would be neither cheap nor useful, so why would it be made?
- polemic 3y agoReminds me of an excellent conference talk I went to once - landslip modellers in BC, Canada spend a lot of time trying to prevent slips from damanging the railways that wind throught the mountainous terrain. There was a lot of research into statistical models of slips – in particular boudler movement and how they break up – which didn't really work. It turned out that game engines with good dynamic object desctruction are pretty good at modelling them, and they were able to get much better results using the game engine vs statistical models.
- user_7832 3y agoAlso reminds me of how Plague Inc (a Miniclip game, pretty good if you haven't played) was very realisitc at modelling disease outbreaks, during ebola and covid times, prompting the makers to put out a statement. [0] - https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/01/plague-inc-maker-dont-use-our-game-for-coronavirus-modeling/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/01/plague-inc-maker-dont...
- simne 3y ago> There was a lot of research into statistical models of slips – in particular boudler movement and how they break up – which didn't really work. You remembered me history from Harrington Emerson (The twelve principles of efficiency). As railroad worker, he frequently seen rails flooded by rain. Exist at least two solutions. First, to build Embankment, so rails will be much over water level, which will cost at least few millions dollars. And sure, suffer all problems with slips in future. Second, to dig trench near rails (in most cases it is obvious, where to dig) and just constantly pump out water from it, so all water from rain will be pumped out - it will cost few hundred dollars for digging and less than thousand dollars per year to support (100 years ago, now, sure more). No slips at all, because when ground is dry, no slip happen. Guess, what usually chose management and why? :)
- simne 3y agoBTW, greetings from Kyiv, Ukraine, country now at war, and city, whole build on hills and over hundred years spent to build drainage system under hills so last decades slips are very rare.
- shiroiushi 3y agoThe simulation we're living in simulates reality down to the Planck length, so maybe that's the answer.
- atleastoptimal 3y agoWhat's the most intuitive explanation for why a Planck length exists?
- jajko 3y agoI don't think universe/reality bothers with whys. It just is, just like everything else, deal with it. But it does put an effective stop on those fantasies that reality is like an endless fractal.
- DexesTTP 3y agoTo simplify equations that create ratios between distance, time and energy. That's literally it. Using Planck units is a math trick to remove a bunch of constants from a bunch of equations. The Planck length doesn't really have any known physical importance, at least no more than a meter does. There's some things that happens around a planck length (for example, the current theories predict that black holes need to be at least bigger than a planck length to exist, or alternatively the Planck length is the point where the quantum uncertainty completely overtakes any other classical theory) but particles can "move" distances less than a planck length (with lots of caveats, mainly because quantum uncertainty makes the notion of "moving" in the classical sense kinda weird and barely applicable, but still, they _can_). A common belief is that the Planck length is kind of the "minimal distance" and start thinking that it's the "pixel of the universe" but there's no actual theoretical framework saying that. It's just a common misconception.
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoPlanck length is where quantum gravity overtakes a nonrelativistic theory, quantum stuff happens on a 25 orders of magnitude larger scale. For comparison: the universe is about as much bigger than you.
- frank_bb 3y ago[dead]
- shoman3003 3y agoForget about it, unless quantum computers get here, we can't simulate deep stuff (from what I hear of my Denmark contacts, 2035)
- Simon_ORourke 3y agoWe've already got Madden NFL 09, how more real do people want to get?
- amelius 3y agoWhat would a universe look like where everything can be perfectly simulated in real time? I guess an empty universe would work. Or a universe that is a boring state machine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- woopwoop24 3y agoyou don't need to simulate everything in a big monolith and with all the complexity of everybody in it, that does not scale well. You only need to simulate the perspective of you and what you can see, observe and the interactions you make right now. Same as video games just render in a certain radius around you. That scales well per human. Heck everybody around you might be an NPC and you will never know
- lloeki 3y agoYou can still simulate it as a whole and have it scale: - You can simulate whatever is not observed statistically and collapse to a discrete reality only when actually observed - You can handwave away whatever is outside the observable universe since information (and thus effects) will never reach the observer - Heck you can even handwave whatever has been observed and over time return to statistics thanks to n-body problem, n>2; it would be somewhat incorrect but no one would be able to check that it is wrong as long as it fits within a lightcone I think that it's actually more "perfect" than simulating every atom, in the sense that it matches quantum mechanics, foregoing the intuitive model of a fully deterministic Newtonian universe that would need to be simulated "perfectly" everywhere all at once down to Planck scale.
- breuleux 3y agoDepending on capabilities within the simulation, that method scales unpredictably. If you can build supercomputers and run programs on them, these need to be simulated accurately at all times lest it becomes noticeable that they don't perform according to spec. Basically, the more machines you build, the larger the set of interactions that must be simulated becomes, and if your simulator's capacity is limited, then either things have to break from the perspective of the simulation, or the simulatees are effectively performing a denial of service attack on the simulator.
- woopwoop24 3y agointeresting perspective. So all entities in one big simulation to ensure everyone has the same clock/variables/... and then just simulate around the person?
- codeulike 3y agoIf you think back to Descartes and a lot of the philosophy about determinism and free will, they had quite a naive understanding of systems and determinism because their mental model of a complex system was a clockwork watch or a steam engine with lots of gears. Because their argument was, that if the universe is deterministic everything seems a bit scary because whats going to happen is already 'known' and so we have no free will. But now we have a better understanding of how mind bogglingly complex deterministic systems can be - broadly this is what Chaos Theory is all about - e.g. sensitive dependence on initial conditions - you can model how a magnetic pendulum moves between three magnets, but the tinyest infinitessimal change in the starting position makes a big difference to the eventual path. And we know that through various fundamental forces, every subatomic particle interacts with every other one in its light cone. And so if we assume that the universe is deterministic, we can see it would be impossible to build a computer to exploit that determinism and 'calculate ahead' to see what state the universe would be in at some future point. Two main reasons - (a) the computer would inevitably use more atoms than the atoms it was trying to simulate and (b) sensitive dependence on initial conditions. And so even in a deterministic universe, the future is literally unknowable. So you can think of the universe as a computer that is calculating its own future, one picosecond at a time. We can't jump ahead. (we can, of course, use simplified models to give us good guesses for specific short term situations) That means determinism is nothing to worry about, in terms of free will. (and anyway, how would the opposite - randomness - be any better for free will?) (so what is Free Will? Its not really a concept that makes any sense - "I chose to do X but in completely identical conditions I could have been free to choose Y" - how do you even test that? But if you want a colloquial definition: Broadly I'd say we have something that you might choose to call "free will" because what we do next is (usually) proximately determined by processes inside our skulls. And yes, if you want to trace the state of our brains back in time eventually all of it originated from outside our skulls, memories etc, but lets set all that historical complexity aside. What we do next is broadly determined by processes within us. As opposed to a rock rolling down a hill which is just subject to external forces. I think thats the only thing Free Will can really mean)
- shkkmo 3y ago> That means determinism is nothing to worry about, in terms of free will. (and anyway, how would the opposite - randomness - be any better for free will?) You've misunderstood the root of their concern, it isn't practical predictability but omniscient predestination.
- mclau154 3y agoisnt MATLAB, Simulink, and Simscape already doing this at much finer detail?