3 ms·
The illustration of the door handle is a great example of piss-poor affordance. A slight ridge is not going to clearly communicate push vs. pull. Especially sin
by snowwrestler 15y ago
The illustration of the door handle is a great example of piss-poor affordance. A slight ridge is not going to clearly communicate push vs. pull. Especially since our fingers, when gripping, actually like a ridge to fill in the open angle behind the first knuckles.
If you want someone to push, give them a big fat flat metal plate or bar to push on. If they can't pull, they are guaranteed to get it right every time. I bet pretty much every restaurant kitchen and high school gym door in the U.S. gets this right.
- jasonkester 15y agoThe door handle could actually be described as an anti-affordance. I looked at the photo and thought to myself what a great idea it was that it gave you a comfortable ridge for your knuckles while pulling and a nice rounded bit (instead of a sharp-edged flat surface) to push on. That is, it signalled to me the exact opposite of the designer's intended use. I would have been doubly surprised if pulling on that clearly "pull-only" handle didn't open the door.
- duaneb 15y agoI would have tried to rotate both of those handles. You want to know a great user interface that is universally understood? PUSH: http://www.vanseodesign.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/door-push-bar.jpg http://www.vanseodesign.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/... PULL: http://www.artfactory.com/images/Door-Handle-HH199.jpg http://www.artfactory.com/images/Door-Handle-HH199.jpg The door handle sacrifices usability for aesthetics.
- mertd 15y agoExcept your pull handle looks like it is on both sides, and the big flat surface regardless of the shape of the handle communicates "push" to me.
- pcopley 15y agoPUSH looks perfect to me, but while I wouldn't say the PULL example is anti-affordance it is at best confusing. If the handles were rounded and rotated so the curve faced the user (http://image.made-in-china.com/2f0j00fviQTDboYJqL/Door-Pull-Handle-JD-4113-.jpg http://image.made-in-china.com/2f0j00fviQTDboYJqL/Door-Pull-... OR http://www.bnl.com.au/catalogue/door_handles/6x4%20handles/Door-Pull.jpg http://www.bnl.com.au/catalogue/door_handles/6x4%20handles/D...) then I'd agree 100%.