8 ms·
Student debt is haunting Americans from graduation to retirement
- sokoloff 3y ago> Part of the problem is the scale of the higher education system in the US, where hundreds of nonprofit colleges are competing for enrollment and talent, and a large proportion of upper- and middle-class parents are willing to pay top dollar — or even go into debt themselves — to give their kids the best education possible. This seems like something that's entirely unsurprising. If your STEM-oriented kid could attend <insert top 5 engineering school here> or your more Ivy-oriented kid could attend an Ivy League school and you could help them make that happen, why wouldn't you? Not in the literal sense of "make the best rational argument against it" but in the metaphorical sense of "yeah, an enormous number of families will make exactly that choice, even if some opt out".
- kcmastrpc 3y agoSTEM-kids aren't struggling to pay off their college debts. Liberal art degree holders, however.
- ceejayoz 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/20/opinion/medical-school-student-loans-tuition-debt-doctor.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/20/opinion/medical-school-st... > My personal experiences highlight the magnitude of the problem. Upon graduation from medical school in 2013, I owed approximately $180,000 in student debt — what might seem an outrageously high number that is actually about $10,000 less than the average for today’s medical school graduates. I scrounged and saved during residency, living in a tiny Chinatown apartment, riding my bicycle to work every day, and sneaking expired patient sandwiches for lunch so that I could make my monthly $700 debt payment. Yet upon completing residency, the amount I owed had, to my disbelief, increased to $188,000 — all my efforts had not been enough to cover even the interest accumulating on my loans. > I am far from alone. A mentor in residency, several years my senior and making over $200,000 per year, once revealed that she had moved back in with her mother just to get a handle on her student loans. Another colleague had a marriage proposal rejected because of his mortgage-size debt.
- brodouevencode 3y agoDo you have data that's not anecdotal? EDIT: Do you have data that's not anecdotal and shows that residents/doctors are struggling to pay off that debt?
- ceejayoz 3y agoPlenty. https://educationdata.org/average-medical-school-debt https://educationdata.org/average-medical-school-debt > The average medical school graduate owes $250,995 in total student loan debt. > The average medical school graduate owes 4 times as much as the average college graduate > In 1978, the average medical school debt in the U.S. was $13,500. That’s $53,648 when adjusted for inflation.
- floor2 3y agoMedical school debt seems like the least compelling example given how much doctors get paid. https://www.salary.com/research/salary/alternate/radiologist-salary https://www.salary.com/research/salary/alternate/radiologist... The median radiologist is making $459k. The bottom 10% is still making $344k. So you could finish med school, be the lowest-paid radiologist in your class, and pay off your debt in like 2 years if you wanted. A less lucrative specialty still makes the debt no big deal. If you're making $250k as a family doctor, you're still living comfortably after making your debt payments.
- 4death4 3y agoBut after residency, you’re looking at a salary of 200K. You’d be able to pay down your debt in a few years of frugal living. Debt itself isn’t bad if it’s taken on as an investment.
- lenerdenator 3y agoThere's consequences to frugal living, particularly in the form of people moving past the ideal window for starting a family.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- slackfan 3y agoThe thing that endlessly amuses me is that there are oodles of ways to get a libarts degree without incurring student debt. Heck, you can get a passable STEM degree without incurring student debt. Or at least not paying more for a degree than you'd pay for a decently-specced new car right off the lot. For reference, I have a degree in history that I paid (ending in 2014) 30k in 2024 dollars for over the course of six years. Even with current price, that same degree at the same institution would be ~60k over the course of four years. Inflationary and gouging - sure, but still rather affordable. The current system that perpetuates "college for everyone" along with a governmental debt guarantee to the universities leads to incessant price jacking. No, Boston University is emphatically not worth 63 thousand dollars a year. No state school is worth 30-40k/year.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoUC Berkeley is sure worth 40K a year. They call it “the people’s Harvard” for a reason.
- slackfan 3y agoBut the question is - is a 160k debt before you've ever held a job in your life worth it, whereas you have statistically the same outcome with a sub-60k-all-in degree?
- tzs 3y agoVery few people will incur debt anywhere near that for an undergraduate degree from UC Berkeley. 71% of undergraduates graduate with no debt. For those who borrow the average debt at graduation is around $18k.
- zero-sharp 3y ago>71% of undergraduates graduate with no debt. That's borderline not believable. Somebody should probably take a closer look at where that data comes from. I went through the UC system, filling out the FAFSA every year, and had one parent who _partially_ supported me financially. I had that average amount of debt in two years. This was many years ago, and yes, I did work as well. >For those who borrow the average debt at graduation is around $18k. The debt specifically for tuition? What about housing? August to May is 10 months. It's easy to find studios that charge at least 1000/month. Assume rent is 900$. How does that housing cost calculation square with your average debt figure of 18k? If you're not including it, why not?
- redserk 3y agoExcept STEM extends beyond computer science and software engineering degrees. Many careers requiring hard science degrees have dreadful pay.
- brodouevencode 3y agoLike which ones?
- floor2 3y agoThe job market for people with a bachelors in Biology or Chemistry is pretty lousy. Lots of people end up doing repetitive lab work for low pay. Going to graduate school is essentially required to get a "good" job in the field.
- maxsilver 3y agoWell, where "liberal art degree" often means "high-skilled labor". People struggling to pay off college debt includes: - teachers and childcare workers - special education and/or disability workers - librarians - social workers, therapists, mental health workers - cnas, medical billing, and other heathcare admin - and many more not listed above People often seem to assume "liberal arts" translates to a fake profession, like "underwater basketweaving" or "economist" or something "silly". And while that's occasionally true, most folks with a Liberal Arts degree are hard-working career-oriented people, who society just pays terribly, arbitrarily, because they can. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education#Modern_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education#Modern_...
- dfxm12 3y agoMany places are facing a teacher shortage too. I think one would assume in a rational economy, since the labor is in short supply, they would pay more for it. However, the pay gap between teachers and the average worker is widening... https://www.usatoday.com/story/graphics/2024/03/19/teacher-shortage-crisis-explained/72958393007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/graphics/2024/03/19/teacher-s...
- johnkpaul 3y agoThis is 100% true. I have a chemistry degree that's technically from a liberal arts college and it was super confusing to my immigrant parents how that could happen. Now with the advent of the term "STEM" it's even more confusing because a huge portion of Science degrees are actually in liberal arts programs, not technically "Science" programs.
- maxsilver 3y ago> I have a chemistry degree that's technically from a liberal arts college and it was super confusing to my immigrant parents how that could happen. I kind of get it. The english words "liberal" and "arts" used to mean entirely different things for hundreds of years, and have been redefined into something else only recently (past ~30 years) via common usage. My degree program was in "Liberal Studies", and my parents consistently assumed it meant "studying how to become a Democrat voter", when in actuality, what it meant was "if you can justify it well, we give you permission to merge two-or-more different degree paths into one" The university eventually had to rename the program to "Integrative Studies", because too many people simply don't know what "Liberal" means in an traditional academic context, and couldn't shake the modern-political framing of the word.
- adra 3y agoIt's less about liberal arts, and more about those that graduate or not. It's more about those that fall into the "some collage" category. Most of the costs of a full degree, but none of the benefits.
- yareal 3y agoSTEM kids absolutely are struggling to pay off these loans. They have it easier, but college exploitation has gotten so bad that every degree program has some students graduating with lifelong debt. What you said used to be true, it's no longer true.
- anarticle 3y agoHold up, just so we're aware: STEM covers not only tech but also sciences. Let me say here I know three chemist undergrads that have been in the industry for 5-8y+: none are happy or over six figures. I am an ex-biochemist and trust me, PhDs in academia are not making six figures. There is a divide there between tech and science for sure. Of the maybe 25 or so younger people I worked with in the lab, the ones that did very well moved to tech. The ones that did ok were either from other countries, or their parents paid their way. Very few US people from the lab that stayed in science that had loans, paid off their loan. I can think of one. Lab work is super underpaid, and you need every degree in order to even get your foot in the door.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>and you could help them make that happen Is "lifetime of debt" in the realm of "help make that happen" at this point? At some point it's less an investment and more a very fancy splurge. The worst part is that this isn't just some crazy expense revserved for Harvard. Tuition for ASU is 30k out of state. You're paying some 200k for your kid to go to a school reputed (or perhaps, used to be reputed) for its party scene? That's where this really starts to be untenable.
- gedy 3y agoI don't disagree college is too expensive, but I don't know why people would go to out of state schools if they are concerned about money. Local schools with lower tuition and where you may have family housing and support makes a huge cost difference.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>I don't know why people would go to out of state schools if they are concerned about money. really depends on your state and your college aspects. Not all states are created equal in terms of education. >where you may have family housing There's also that. It's probably shifting these days, but commuter students had a reaction of "not getting the full college experience." social interactions aside, there is some point to be made on how college can be a good preperation for self-preservation without the gaze of the increasing helicopter parenting methodology in your midst. Or simply a way to finally disengage with a bad family dynamic.
- gedy 3y agoSure on all these - but basically I think putting all this on credit for 4 years is a bad start to life.
- jkestner 3y agoAn aside for that common ASU slander: It's a huge school (55K students on the main campus alone). It can have both a party scene and a good education. I remember it having quality departments in engineering, business, design (and there's a neat interdisciplinary program for those three), and journalism.
- kcmastrpc 3y agoWhile I can empathize here as someone with no degree and a job at FAANG, it's hard for me to have a lot of sympathy. I put the blame squarely on these institutions and our government for this situation. The institutions should be held liable for this debt, not the tax payer, and our government should not guarantee or subsidize these loans. Higher education is important in our society, but the situation we're in now is a complete disaster. 18-year olds taking on huge debt for useless degrees that can't be bankrupted, what could possibly go wrong?
- lapcat 3y ago> The institutions should be held liable for this debt, not the tax payer, and our government should not guarantee or subsidize these loans. A lot of the institutions are government entities, taxpayer sponsored public universitites. It's analogous to suing police departments for police brutality: it's not the police officers who end up paying (police officers don't have millions of dollars to pay out) but rather the taxpayers of the cities.
- kgdiem 3y ago> The institutions should be held liable for this debt, not the tax payer, and our government should not guarantee or subsidize these loans. This seems fair to me. Many universities have tremendous endowments and should be in a position to offer financing to their students. The extent of government subsidy could be no tax on the interest gained from the loans they write. It seems like the paradise papers at large and especially the connection to higher ed have been largely forgotten and maybe never fully acknowledged in the mainstream. https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/universities-colleges-offshore-leaks-database/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/universi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Papers
- webworker 3y ago> Many universities have tremendous endowments and should be in a position to offer financing to their students. This is exactly why every time my university comes calling for donations, I decline. Sorry, but I'm not making a donation that you'll use to rebuild a stadium when you're setting your students up to graduate with six-figure debt. Figure your priorities out, whether you want to educate students or play tone-deaf real estate developer.
- tejohnso 3y ago> She earned a master’s in religious studies in 2017, with dreams of teaching at a college. > But she couldn’t find any jobs in her field when she graduated Why the hell would you expect to find a job in religious studies? If you're interested in that, great. Pay for that education if you can afford it. Don't borrow thousands of dollars for your indulgence and then complain that you owe money. That's how borrowing works. This has been going on for decades now. It has been a long time since getting any degree was some kind of ticket to prosperity. If it ever was. On the other side of things, why isn't it considered class discrimination to require expensive degrees to work in jobs where high school education is sufficient?
- CoastalCoder 3y ago> Why the hell would you expect to find a job in religious studies? If you're interested in that, great. Pay for that education if you can afford it. Maybe we should (partially) reframe this is as: there's a widespread problem with long-term planning and financial literacy. I agree that foolish wishful thinking is blameworthy. But out of love for future generations, maybe we can try to help them be smarter about this stuff. (My point is simply that this issue should probably be part of any proposed solution.)
- gentleman11 3y agoYou don’t need a high school degree for those jobs either. Hamlet and biology isn’t needed day to day at most workplaces
- Symbiote 3y agoShe was 17 or maybe 18. I would make my own college decisions slightly differently in retrospect, so I can't put all the blame on a 17 year old. She probably had lots of different advice, some of it contradictory, incomplete or optimistic.
- zero-sharp 3y agoI think this is the right take. It's really easy to nitpick the decision making in retrospect, but I think people need perspective. Are we expecting all 18 year olds to be good financial planners now? I certainly wasn't educated on the long term consequences of debt when I was that age and I was relatively well off. We are, after all, discussing education. So the person who is striving for an education is being criticized for not being financially educated enough from the start? I know that somebody is going to get on my case for defending ignorance. But maybe we shouldn't have systems in place that allow millions of people to make the same wrong decision? Fault can lie on both sides. Maybe the difference here is that she chose to pay for a masters, which is a graduate degree. I think the personal responsibility argument carries more weight at that point.
- floor2 3y agoReminder- there is no such thing as "cancelling student debt". The money was borrowed and spent, we're just moving the debt from the people who took it out and benefited from it, to other unrelated taxpayers who get stuck with the bill. The student who made all the prudent decisions- lived on cheap groceries, while attending a low-cost state school to major in something employable like nursing or accounting now gets saddled with the debt from the student who got a basketweaving degree from a private liberal arts school while ordering UberEats every day. The government should claw back the money from the universities that overcharged and failed to provide value (as they have done in a few extreme cases against for-profit scam colleges) but it's frustratingly unjust to see people who made frugal decisions be forced to pay for others who didn't.
- hgomersall 3y agoInsomuch as all money is debt, you are right, but thinking of government debt as such is deeply misleading - without it, there would be no money in circulation. That's not too say that the universities aren't a big part of the problem.
- Zigurd 3y agoDo we all pay for usury laws, too? Or do we all, net of costs, benefit from those laws?
- lapcat 3y ago> we're just moving the debt from the people who took it out and benefited from it, to other unrelated taxpayers who get stuck with the bill. That's always the case, regardless of whether the debt is paid back later. With government-sponsored loans, which are most student loans nowadays, the money is disbursed from the tax revenue and goes immediately to the universities and students to pay for tuition and other expenses. After the student leaves college, the loan is paid back slowly over many years. But note, crucially, that the identity of the taxpayers also changes over time. Taxpayers retire and/or die, new taxpayers enter the system, worker incomes change over time, indeed tax rates themselves change over time. It's never the case that individual taxpayer X is directly paid back for their tax money that went towards the disbursement in year YYYY.
- 3y ago
- myself248 3y agoI blame the employers for requiring these degrees. Skipping $10,000 worth of on-the-job training in favor of $100,000 of personal debt is unconscionable, but that's the way their incentives are structured right now. (And if experience is any guide, fresh-out-of-college hires still require a mountain of on-the-job training. The time I've spent showing MsEE's how to use an oscilloscope is absurd.)
- ceejayoz 3y agoI'd very much like to see a resurgence in apprenticeship-style training for a lot of roles.
- randomdata 3y agoTo be fair, lawmakers put them in that position as it has been effectively illegal to filter by anything else. If you have 1,000 people lined up down the street vying for your open position, you have to apply some kind of filter to whittle them down to manageable numbers for deeper consideration. Us being increasingly more accepting of diversity hiring has helped somewhat. Now employers can say "To everyone not a gay black woman, thanks for applying, but no thanks." without much legal scrutiny, but that has only come on somewhat recently. 30 years ago when we were at peak "degree required" that would have been as unacceptable as saying the same about straight white men. Employers have flirted with other filtering mechanisms, like credit score, but when that was gaining traction there was immediately calls to make that illegal[1] too. A degree is the only filter that has been consistently upheld and accepted. Nonsensically, but that's the power of marketing, I suppose. [1] https://www.thestreet.com/personal-finance/employer-credit-checks-may-soon-be-illegal-12806755 https://www.thestreet.com/personal-finance/employer-credit-c...
- MR4D 3y agoLet's see how we got here... 1 - Everyone says you need to have a degree to succeed 2 - the government guarantees tons of school loans 3 - schools raise prices because loans are so easy to get 4 - many student choose majors that have a negative return 5 - people suffer from student debt, but can't discharge it in bankruptcy ... Huge economic impact ensues. It took 5 steps to get here. We only need to change one to change this problem.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoOngoing student debt accumulation is a far more serious issue than existing debt. Throwing money at existing debt wins easy political points but it really makes the situation worse. Now prospective students are going to start expecting relief and there is no incentive to actually address the issue.
- alistairSH 3y agoTotally agree. I'm all for forgiving existing debt where there's a legal framework to do so. But, this needs to come alongside systemic reforms to how society funds higher education. If we don't make those harder changes, we'll just be stuck revisiting this topic in a generation.
- lenerdenator 3y agoI'm 32, and while I was fortunate enough to not have any debt of my own, I think that the economic and demographic consequences of loading up a generation with this much debt this early have already taken hold. There is a sizable plurality of Millennials who just see themselves as financially screwed. Kids? Nah. House? Possibly attainable before 2022, but not anymore. Retirement? Get real. Economies need workers and un-concentrated capital to grow. We're not making enough babies, and we're sending more of the capital up the ladder to people who already have it and just don't want to spend it. We're transferring value from the future to pay for the costs of now, because the people of wealth (who are almost always older) now don't want to pay for it.
- alistairSH 3y agoI'm GenX and the beginnings of the loan crisis was definitely getting started in the 90s and 00s, as the tail end of X moved into the workforce. I had friends who definitely forwent consumption of things like vacations, newer cars, etc due to loan obligations. And it was the same pattern we see now - largely liberal arts graduates from expensive private schools or out-of-state schools.
- lenerdenator 3y agoThis isn't vacations and newer cars, though. This is having kids or equity in a property that one lives in. And it's not just the underwater basket weavers.
- alistairSH 3y agoNo question, just pointing out this trend was observable ~30 years ago. It's not a new problem, just getting progressively worse.
- koolba 3y ago> This isn't vacations and newer cars, though. They did take a vacation though, for about four years. Sometimes more. Divide that out by the next fifty years of life and you get 4 x 250 / 50 = 20 vacation days per year. Plus, based on the time value of money, those "taken in advance" vacation days are arguably worth more than the ones years from now. I'll be honest. I have no sympathy for liberal arts majors that are saddled with debt and cannot find meaningful work that leverages their education.
- bdzr 3y agoReminder that the average student loan debt is somewhere in the ballpark of $40k with the median being a little lower. I've found that most of the coverage on student loans misleadingly focuses on outliers. Edit: downvoted for factual information :-/.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat's absolutely true, but let's not forget that $40k financed over 10 years is about $400/month payment and about $10k in interest of the loan duration. That's a lot of money monthly. That's a car payment, or groceries, or a lot other consumption that isn't happening.
- bdzr 3y agoSure, though I can't cite the source off hand, I remember the statistic being something like a bachelor's degree of any kind increases earnings by roughly 17k. It's very hard to consider this anything other than a bargain for the average bachelor's student, interest included. AFAIR the stats show that the people who are truly destroyed are the ones who get loans but don't get the piece of paper.
- alistairSH 3y agoYep, that's a big problem. And if I'm remembering correctly, that problem was vastly worse with the for-profit schools (actual for-profit like Capella and WyoTech, not privates like Harvard or Georgetown, which are still non-profit). And for the average graduate, yeah, it usually works out in the end, but there can definitely be cash-flow problems in the early phases of careers (thinking about teachers and other "service" jobs that require/prefer college but don't pay well).
- caseysoftware 3y agoWhen you dig into the debt holders, the more interesting pattern is that the majority of the debt is held by white women with masters degrees or above. What makes this group so different and prone to this problem?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- r3trohack3r 3y agoI feel like the elephant in the room on student loans, that I rarely hear talked about, is bankruptcy. When I graduated I dumped every penny I had into my student loans against the advice of my parents, peers, and financial advisors. Why? Because I was income rich and had a class of debt with variable rate interest that couldn’t be discharged in bankruptcy. There is a large % of Americans that can not afford to pay the accumulated interest on their loans every month. Every month the balance of their loan increases. They are bankrupt. I don’t think further subsidizing education is going to do anything. We don’t need to pay these loans off for them. We just need to let them declare bankruptcy again and discharge the debt. Right now, lenders have no incentive to minimize the balance of a loan. They’re nearly guaranteed a return, since the borrower will owe the debt for life. With access to unlimited credit by proxy of student debt, universities have little incentive to reduce tuition. If you allow borrowers to declare bankruptcy, I’m fairly confident the financial system will properly price in the true value of each degree program over night. They’ll have data on which degree programs from which universities have what placement rates at what salaries. They’ll weigh the expected lifetime return on that loan against the probability of it being discharged in bankruptcy. For many degree programs, I suspect students won’t be able to find a lender to cover the cost and universities will be forced to get costs back inline with the true expected return on the degree. I’m not in favor of student loan forgiveness. I just want to bring bank bankruptcy.
- catwalk_moto 3y ago[dead]
- scoofy 3y agoThe idea that education, one of the most long term profitable things for a society to have in it's electorate, isn't highly subsidized is insane to me. Yea, it costs a lot of money, and you want market incentives driving decision making, but even when people study something like art history, a university education makes people smarter. A subsidized system will easily pay for itself in the long run.