4 ms·
Boeing whistleblower says 787 fleet should be grounded
- burcs 3y agoBrave of him for speaking out after what happened to John Barnett. Hope more people will listen to him and he will have a more fortunate outcome than the previous whistleblower.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tavavex 3y agoIf this complaint ends in an investigation (big if) and the investigation reveals those issues, this is going to be Boeing's nightmare that will pile onto their growing list of issues. Would it even be possible for the company to be salvaged at that point?
- dotnet00 3y agoThey don't have to worry about reputation, they can just grease Congress's pockets as they've been doing for the past 2-3 decades despite blatant problems. As long as they can keep blocking American competitors from emerging, they'll be fine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- InitialLastName 3y agoBoeing is about as close as a company can get to being a strategic asset for US national security. Functional passenger airplanes or not, I have a strong suspicion they will not be allowed to fail.
- gosub100 3y agoA broken clock is right twice a day. the 787 fleet has been flying since, what, 2011, without a single hull-loss event. There was a youtube documentary I saw at least 5 years ago (before the max disasters), who had a hit piece on boeing. They duped them into letting them film in the (North|South) Carolina plant (787 I believe), until they started asking pointed questions about safety and were asked to leave. They interviewed (off-site) one of the hourly manufacturing employees who attested to a bunch of careless practices. This was right about the time one of the Middle Eastern airlines said they only wanted 787's from Seattle, not the Carolina plant. Even though their documentary proved prescient with the Max problem, I still don't think they were able to really connect anything. IIRC most of the documentary focused on mechanical issues, leaving pliers/plastic junk inside the airframe, whereas the root-cause turned out to be a systems engineering: MCAS and allowing cost-saving on one AOA sensor. I would try to find it, but given all the recent press, I highly doubt I could. It may not have been Youtube, it could have been Al-Jazeera or Vice, etc. But if you pick the most popular flying vehicle and then start a doomer prophecy, of course there will eventually be something that makes it sound like you were right.
- nomilk 3y agoTo help find it, you could try searching youtube with this operator <search terms> before:2018-10-28
- amiga386 3y agoYou're referring to The Boeing 787: Broken Dreams published in 2014 by Al Jazeera https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvkEpstd9os https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvkEpstd9os This revealed a host of problems with the 787 Dreamliner, mainly that its battery packs catch fire (which is why it was grounded by the FAA from January to April 2013 to revise the battery design). This is the plane relevant to this latest whistleblower, but not the same plane as the 737 MAX, the one with the MCAS system and the door plugs missing bolts
- gosub100 3y agothank you for finding this. I disagree that this documentary revealed the battery pack fires. I remember seeing several of those stories in the news around 2011-12 because they were catching fire with passengers on board.
- Aeolun 3y ago> “We are fully confident in the 787 Dreamliner,” a Boeing spokesperson said in a statement. Forgive me if I say you’ve lost the credibility necessary to make such a statement.
- asmithmd1 3y ago"We are confident in the safety of the 737 MAX and in the work of the men and women who design and build it," Boeing Chief Executive Officer Dennis Muilenburg March 2019 https://au.news.yahoo.com/boeing-ceo-says-confident-safety-215457037.html https://au.news.yahoo.com/boeing-ceo-says-confident-safety-2...
- yencabulator 3y agoITYM "We are fully convinced we will receive our usual bonuses, and if we get fired we expect a severance package of tens of millions of dollars."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bri3d 3y agoI'm a bit skeptical that this in particular is a major issue, for the sole reason that fuselage joint shims, tolerances, bends, and fasteners on the 787 have been under a ridiculous level of scrutiny since 2019 and earlier: https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/new-boeing-787-fix-details-reveal-extent-gap-check-challenge https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/new-boeing-787-fix-de... It's clear that Boeing have awful quality control issues, but this one seems like it's already been investigated extensively. I absolutely believe that non-approved, dangerous procedures were used to fit 787 panels together, but this was known 5+ years ago and heavily investigated. Of course, that doesn't justify retribution against a whistleblower. Which is all to say - I do believe Boeing are deeply questionable as an organization, but I'd still be comfortable flying on a 787.
- coliveira 3y agoFrom what I understood, the problem is not how the job has been done, but the design of the fuselage itself that can fall apart with time. The solution is to inspect several of these airplanes to make sure that the joints are in good condition.
- delichon 3y agoSeems like Boeing could benefit from a Netflix style chaos monkey approach. Formalize a red team with the power to sabotage parts and processes throughout the build, measure downstream inspectors' responsiveness and demote and promote accordingly. Isolate the red team from the rest of the corporate culture, reward them in proportion to estimated lives saved, and arrange for their reports to be made public without a filter. Anyway it will take some such radical reform and transparency to regain trust. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_engineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_engineering
- bathtub365 3y agoExcept if one of the intentional faults gets through people could die.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoThey could stop it from going out to the customer
- zarzavat 3y agoYes but you don’t know what other faults may be introduced when trying to fix the first one. “X is broken. X is fixed. But while fixing X, Y is accidentally broken” is a common accident pattern. Unlike in software, you can’t just roll back to a last known good configuration. Every modification carries a risk.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoDon't fix it, dispose it
- bathtub365 3y agoThrow out an entire brand new airplane?
- 3y ago
- tootie 3y agoCan we use the original article? The Hill is clickbait and not reliable. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/whistleblower-outlines-safety-concern-boeing-787-dreamliner-rcna148063 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/whistleblower-outlines-... https://www.propublica.org/article/how-a-veteran-reporter-worked-with-giuliani-associates-to-launch-the-ukraine-conspiracy https://www.propublica.org/article/how-a-veteran-reporter-wo...
- sorwin 3y agoWhile it sounds like there are problems, and they should be investigated, taking the word of a one (or even a few) whistleblower on something like this should be taken with skepticism. Everything involving airplanes extremely complex, and most people work on very specific parts. Most engineers work on very specific parts of it (like any field). It's like a doctor coming out and saying "this drug, procedure, etc is completely worthless!". It takes more than a few single individuals to assess the problems or efficacy of things. We should push for the government to investigate, but journalism pieces like this just erode trust when their headline is a single person is saying the equivalent of "SHUT IT ALL DOWN, TRUST ME". We have no idea what his role, skill set, or knowledge of all this is.