6 ms·
David Lynch presents 'A Thinking Room'
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mvkel 3y ago> a single armchair is surrounded by thick curtains made of blue velvet — a nod to Lynch’s 1986 film Blue Velvet. I feel like Lynch might disagree with this. He pretty consistently dissuades people from trying to explain his works. Also: > Lynch was adamant that his new foray into design exists separately from his film career.
- wk_end 3y agoFrom what I've seen, I've more gotten the sense that Lynch doesn't like people asking him what the "correct" interpretation of his work is, which is slightly different than opposing the personal act of interpretation, or discussing it.
- lagniappe 3y agoSometimes the essence of something is just 'to be'.
- grimgrin 3y agolead me to a different thought, from something I watched recently: "Art for No One". I wish I could submit Jacob Geller's video of that title, but rules are rules. art for no one is quite "to be", though https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6oqO3FXSecM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6oqO3FXSecM
- drooopy 3y ago- "Believe it or not, Eraserhead is my most spiritual film." - "Elaborate on that" - "No."
- Rinzler89 3y ago[flagged]
- alfalfasprout 3y agoExactly this. He's never (as far as I know at least) thought it's somehow bad to discuss how his work might be interpreted. He just doesn't like the idea that there's somehow a definitive interpretation of his work that he owns.
- colmmacc 3y agoMany artists do feel that all interpretations are equally valid and that they don't want to stomp on that. But when Lynch expands on this, he often connects it to mystery. Most of his works have a strong sense of surrealism but there's enough realism there too to also sense that there really is a central and consistent thematic logic that connects everything. It's not just randomly surreal. Often there is explicitly meta-textual layer at which a real deeper narrative is there; usually critiques of Hollywood and modern culture. Lynch's philosophy is that mystery endures, and that we naturally dwell on the mysterious. His mysteries become a gift to the viewer/reader, and the vividness of his strokes make them dwell for decades. I still dwell on so many aspects of Twin Peaks. If he simply gave his own interpretation or explanation, that would be that, and the gift would vanish like owls in the night.
- flyer_go 3y agoIt is pretty clear that his movies are meant to explore the existence of psychological phenomena and are not a statement in of themselves. In that way, I don't think they are meant to be interpreted.
- louthy 3y agoI don’t believe that’s true. Lynch uses characters as abstractions — they represent a concept, which when you understand them add up to a ‘statement’: * Twin Peaks is an meta commentary about the lack of balance on the small screen (our desire for sex and violence). Interestingly this ended up being a meta-meta-commentary when the network forced them to reveal the killer of Laura Palmer prematurely. Laura Palmer is balance, Dale Cooper is the audience, Bob is our desire for sex & violence, … * Mulholland Drive is about the casting couch and the destruction of the Hollywood dream for women. Rita is the casting couch, the cowboy is Hollywood, … * Lost Highway appears to be a comment about plagiarism (namely other directors plagiarising David Lynch). But it also has a similar theme to Twin Peaks as a meta commentary about film — the shots of the road are meant to look like film, the vehicles are meant to represent movies, … etc. He always talks about being “true to the idea” — so all abstractions and all surreal elements must be true to the underlying concept. It’s up to us to work out what the underlying theme is (that links all of the abstractions together).
- sn41 3y agoVery interesting take, thank you! Of course, my favorite David Lynch movie is "The Straight Story" - what a heartwarming tale!
- rapjr9 3y agoLynch has said that his interest in making movies came out of painting, which was the first art form he had an interest in. He had an epiphany where he saw making movies as making moving paintings. Some of the most surreal scenes in his movies/shows are just that, combinations of elements that produce feelings in the viewer in the same way a painting might. Watch that scene in Twin Peaks: The Return in the Fireman's Theatre where someone floats up into the air and there are all sorts of other things going on. It's like a framed painting where there are all these moving elements that combine to create something phenomenal.
- riedel 3y agoI guess he just also very much enjoys being the madman [0] . It is fascinating to see the childish fun he has in all the things he is doing. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqZpi8zAqe0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqZpi8zAqe0
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nicklecompte 3y agoOn the other hand Lynch has always been a bit of a troll, and despite his aloofness he is aware of his own celebrity. I could see this chair being a way of saying "yes this exhibition is by that David Lynch, the filmmaker."
- louthy 3y agoLynch has repeatedly hinted that there’s a correct interpretation to all of his works. He just wants you to have the joy of finding it yourself — which is why he refuses to explain any of it. Personally, as a massive David Lynch fan, I love the fact that he does this. I must have had half a dozen interpretations of Mulholland Drive over the years — all of which I like even though I’m fairly sure I know the ‘correct’ interpretation.
- rob74 3y agoAnd the red curtains outside the exhibit (https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/XjDqSXDkvQBVceLropEs3C-768-80.jpg.webp https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/XjDqSXDkvQBVceLropEs3C-768...) are obviously a nod to the red room in Twin Peaks...
- jncfhnb 3y agoI find Lynch’s works to be very puzzling to unpack. Most analyses which I find compelling have his intentions as a director conveyed within each scene independently, and not really within the larger narrative. Whereas most works seem to have a thesis and then explore them on different levels, Lynch seems to just throw out ideas in different scenes. I would love to unpack what parts of twin peaks were Lynch’s design and what parts were not
- wk_end 3y agoLynch's work tends to operate on dream logic. And that's how dreams often work - there can be coherent ideas - some random, and some related to concerns in the real world - and there can also be just bizarre, insane, inexplicable stuff.
- vundercind 3y agoIt’s a bit like the automatic-writing quality of Bob Dylan lyrics (or especially text he’d write for his album covers) but in film form. Similar deal where the “text” is obscure and seems full of puzzles, and you can make connections and draw some conclusions—and certainly a tone, themes, and even a point or message may be communicated clearly—but you can’t count on everything lining up and making logical sense.
- MisterTea 3y agoI have the impression that we are observers suddenly thrust into the dream and we, like a detective, must piece together the puzzle. This allows everyone to walk away with a different view which is a far cry from linear plots where everything is wrapped up, concluded - roll credits. Lynch makes you think about his work after they conclude. I know some people who hate his works for this reason. They want a neatly packaged story that doesn't require them to think.
- robocat 3y agoI love surrealism, dreamscapes and many forms of nonsense and randomness. I loath anything that feels like it is on the edge of making sense. I hate searching for hidden meaning in something that doesn't actually have a legible hidden meaning. I suspect some of Lynch's work fits in that category. I'm on the engineer spectrum and I just accept that others rate things that I never will enjoy. Maybe I should learn the appeal of tarot? I vicariously enjoy being around my friend that watches movies non-linearly. I don't understand another friend who watched a popular old movie thousands of times and applied their smarts to analysing it multiple different ways. I don't think I fit your stereotype for people that want a nice linear packaged story they don't need to think about. But maybe I'm overthinking. I do enjoy trying to understand what smart friends intensely direct their thoughts towards: so I would enjoy talking with a friend who loves Mulholland Drive.
- idkwhatimdoin 3y ago[flagged]
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> ... a single armchair is surrounded by thick curtains made of blue velvet — a nod to Lynch’s 1986 film Blue Velvet. Or, you know, it just means the curtains are fucking blue! (for anyone who gets the reference).
- AndyNemmity 3y agogreat reference
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- looping8 3y agoLynch has very unique tastes, so it is very possible that he likes the material and the color and there is no other reason for it. But he is also a very funny man with a good sense of humor, so it can also be a joke from him specifically to have people argue about the curtains.
- gordon_freeman 3y agoFor the folks new to Lynch movies don't forget to watch his possibly the strangest of movies: Eraserhead. I have watched it more than 5 times and everytime I watch it I learn something new. And btw this scene from his movie is just gold: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UozhOo0Dt4o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UozhOo0Dt4o
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imjonse 3y agoThe short "What did Jack do?" is also strange, even by his standards.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gklitz 3y agoI am propably wrong on this, and counter examples are very welcome. But to me it seems like he’s the only person in Hollywood who makes films that show dreams how they actually subjectively feel to us when we are dreaming. Not just the “picture perfect narrative but with a pink tint” but all the strangeness that dreams involve, like something mundane being incredibly scratch without a clear reason why. characters simultaneously being different people, or someone in a dream clearly being someone yet looking different. And of cause all the strangeness of realizing you are in a dream yet still dreaming. The mix of absurd control and at times complete lack of control.
- FiatLuxDave 3y agoTry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strawberry_Mansion_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strawberry_Mansion_(film)
- PixelPioneerZZ 3y agoAlthough I can't understand the intention behind these exhibition designs, I must say the images are quite interesting.
- MrGinkgo 3y agoWhat it does to you is often more important that what the artist's intention is
- filoleg 3y agoYeah, exhibits like this are basically the old adage of “people won’t remember what you told them, but they will rememember how what you told them made them feel”, but with the expectation that you will indeed focus on the latter. Not doing so would render most of this type of art in general feeling flat.
- darepublic 3y agoI always wanted to do an art installation where you would act out the part of Moses speaking to God on mount sinai. You would go through a curtain into a type of waiting room, where you would be outfitted with sandals, and a staff. Then you go through a second set of curtains out of the dark into a seeming mountain set, similar to the one from the burning bush scene in the ten commandments. And the art installation, playing the part of God, commands you to go and free his people. Then you exit via a long twisting slide into a ballpit.
- lb1lf 3y agoTo top it off, you could do worse than asking Bob Walkenhorst of The Rainmakers to be the inaugural Moses. The Rainmakers' 'Let my people go-go' [0] remains a masterpiece. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTEIjM3BkLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTEIjM3BkLo
- redder23 3y agoIf you somehow end up here without having ever watched Mulholland Drive. I encourage you to watch it! It's my favorite movie.
- SergeAx 3y ago> known for cult films like Mulholland Drive, Inland Empire and Wild at Heart Really? No, really? Not Twin Peaks? Not Lost Highway? Not Eraserhead, not The Elephant Man? Not Dune?!