6 ms·
The Paradox of x86
- flohofwoe 3y agoDon't bother reading into the article. Any potentially interesting stuff is behind a "Subscribe" button (also on the archive.org snapshot).
- dartharva 3y ago[flagged]
- cesaref 3y agoExcept that we're really running AMD's x64 ISA, not Intel's, so this moat concept doesn't really fit with the reality. Intel clearly thought x86s days were over when they started their 64 bit Itanium effort, and then quickly (and luckily) managed to get back into having a competitive x64 implementation when they realised they had backed the looser. I'm actually quite impressed with how they pivoted as lesser companies would have had trouble ditching that sort of investment.
- Cold_Miserable 3y agoBiased article. 14nm was delayed and 10nm was delayed by 4 years.
- dralley 3y agoIt's a moat around both AMD and Intel, since they're really the only two that can compete, due to the cross-licensing deal.
- The_Colonel 3y agoVIA also has a "dormant" license, potentially willing to sell.
- dralley 3y agoI thought the VIA license was only for Intel IP, which makes it kind of useless. Especially given a lot of patents are expiring soon.
- timw4mail 3y agoThat can't be the case, as the Zhaoxin CPUs have the same kinds of instructions as similar Intel chips, including those cross-licensed from AMD, like the 64bit instruction set.
- fourfour3 3y agoThat license is what https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhaoxin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhaoxin use to produce their x86 chips, now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ravenstine 3y ago> In short, there’s no meaningful difference between RISC/ARM and CISC/x86 as far as performance is concerned. Yet that usually doesn't seem to be the case in my experience, unless perhaps you don't care about power consumption. Then again, maybe the author doesn't consider frequent interrupts to be an issue of performance.
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe article never gets to the punch line, which is behind a paywall. It also fails to mention how thoroughly Intel wiped the floor with competitors in the "Workstation" space who had their own RISC flavors and mostly went out of business with the exception of IBM's PowerPC. It takes massive investment to make top performing chips which makes it a lot unlike, say cars, where a company like Ferrari can successfully make high performance cars in small numbers. Intel won HPC because it won the Desktop, not the other way around -- one reason why I am still irked when analysts talk about Intel being driven by HPC and hyperscalers while most of their sales still go to the client division. (If there's a reason to pander to hyperscalers it is that they're in a better position to move to another architectures.) The first force to challenge Intel has been ARM and it is not because ARM is fundamentally a better ISA but because ARM parts for phones are produced in such huge numbers, ARM achieved economies of scale that Intel never did. If I was going to point to a real weakness in Intel it is Microsoft, that is, the very slow evolution of the Windows platform such that Windows only started requiring the 2008 POPCOUNT instruction this year. It's not about POPCOUNT, it is about all of the new instructions added since then, which are a major part of claimed performance improvements. It's about a SIMD programming model that makes you rewrite your apps every 2 years, a model that delivers value to the national labs but not to the ordinary user. Apple retires older computers after a certain time in the sense of not providing new OS versions which means that newer OSes can be written to support 5 year computers, with Microsoft it is more like 15.
- pavlov 3y ago> "It also fails to mention how thoroughly Intel wiped the floor with competitors in the "Workstation" space who had their own RISC flavors and mostly went out of business with the exception of IBM's PowerPC." Intel's own product in this space was Itanium which also went out of business.
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe astonishing thing about Intel's history was how much happened by accident. In the 1980s they thought the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i960 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i960 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i860 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i860 were the future. This chip, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_80286 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_80286 which could have been vastly more useful than it was with tiny changes, was a big hit instead. Itanium though had fundamental problems with how it was built and couldn't have been saved with any amount of investment; explicit parallelism just doesn't work for ordinary kinds of code because the compiler never knows which data is in the cache except for special applications like DSP. Itanium certainly seduced a number of those workstation vendors to give up on architectures that could have had a future and invest in one that didn't.
- bee_rider 3y ago> This has always not always been impossible, as AMD, NEC, Via, and others, have done so in the past Was VIA ever competitive performance-wise with Intel or AMD? They’ve always been a weird bit of trivia, for my whole life… and I’m not so old but I’m not very young.
- bombcar 3y agoIIRC there was a old computer history blog talking about the various processors, and there were specific times when the Cyrix and VIA were competitive (including price/performance) - if you were talking about processors that were actually available to buy and use. AMD/Intel were always winning on paper but there were times when a CPU would be launched and simply unavailable.
- timw4mail 3y agoCyrix before the VIA buyout was competitive on integer performance. VIA (via Centuar, the CPU design firm), focused on low-power, lower-performance chips. They only used Cyrix for the name, and not for very long.
- api 3y agoIf Intel's moat made them fall behind, it was by lulling the company into a false sense of security allowing the bean counters to take over and under-invest in keeping up with everyone else in the all-important foundry space. Maybe that's the thesis, but if so it misattributes the cause. The cause is the same MBA-brain thinking that destroyed General Electric and Boeing. The root error in this thinking is to get behind a spreadsheet and completely abstract away all human and physical realities. There's now just units, COGS, gross margin, etc., and so you just optimize those levers to maximize the KPIs the stock market cares about with zero regard for the effect it has on the actual machine or its long term trajectory in the space it operates within. It's really the same set of fallacies that lie behind command economics at the national scale. MBA-brain doesn't work for the same reason centralized authoritarian communism doesn't work. It's the same abstraction away of details, the same optimization without regard for reality, the same hollow experts in "leadership" that aren't really experts in anything. Apparatchiks with no understanding of what's actually happening on the ground can't run things.
- pinum 3y ago@dang Hard paywall