6 ms·
Citizenship Privilege Harms Science
- rayiner 3y agoWho comes up with this shit? “The global south?” The folks affected by this are mainly Chinese, which is at the same latitude as the US. All of India likewise is in the northern hemisphere. What’s the term “south” even meant to euphemistically reference? If you mean poor countries just say that.
- probably_wrong 3y agoRegarding the definition, they use the one Wikipedia mentions [1], namely, "the Global North consists of the world's developed countries, whereas the Global South consists of the world's developing countries and least developed countries". So the answer to "who comes up with this" would be "the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development". Both China and India are considered Global South. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South
- mc32 3y agoIncluding China in the definition, given that by some measures they are the top economy in the world with very restrictive visas is… illuminating.
- nkjnlknlk 3y agoThe alternative is the Global North (i.e., Western hegemony) admits that China is doing well or at least competitively.
- mc32 3y agoI'm not sure there are any serious people who would contend that. They may be seen as a pariah of sorts due to many of their policies but no one doubts their economic and military prowess.
- cge 3y agoFor one conference I attend regularly which is generally held in a different country each year, the year it was held in China was I think the only time where almost every attendee needed to get an actual visa and visit a consulate.
- karaterobot 3y ago> The terms are not strictly geographical, and are not "an image of the world divided by the equator, separating richer countries from their poorer counterparts." Rather, geography should be more readily understood as economic and migratory, the world understood through the "wider context of globalization or global capitalism." Sounds like a poorly considered label that is more divisive and confusing than helpful, which should be replaced with something better before it has a chance to do more damage.
- rayiner 3y ago> the Global North consists of the world's developed countries, whereas the Global South consists of the world's developing countries and least developed countries" So China is in the “south” while Taiwan and Singapore are in the “north?” And you’re saying it’s not stupid?
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoPrecisely this and China nor India are considered "poor". The thing is, there are already pathways in place for "exceptional talent" visas that make entry simple of you are getting sponsored for a visa. A lot of theese academics are coming from dubious institutions and most likely have dubious credentials. I don't have qualms having these hoops in place to qualify who is coming through the border. But this whole system is a joke when it's easier to get a semi legal status by illegally crossing than by entering legally. That's a different discussion. I'll take the downd00ts for an otherwise good discussion on this topic.
- aravindet 3y agoThe terms Global South and North have been around since the 1960s, and they denote the country's socioeconomic position, not geographic location. It's jargon used by organizations working on developmental economics, and as with any jargon it is more precisely defined than "poor country". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_Sout... While it's jargon, I'd have thought it was a fairly common and well understood jargon. Even if you haven't encountered these terms before, I'm not sure why you find them offensive. Are you opposed to fields of study adopting jargon to aid communication?
- tivert 3y ago> The terms Global South and North have been around since the 1960s, and they denote the country's socioeconomic position, not geographic location. It's jargon used by organizations working on developmental economics, and as with any jargon it is more precisely defined than "poor country". To me, the jargon term "Global South" seems inferior to in all respects to the much more common term "3rd World." Whatever minor confusion is caused by the latter term's origin in Cold War geopolitics [1], is far less than the obvious prejudice and nonsense baked into the former [2]. [1] 3rd world pretty much means poor now, and no one's going to be tripped up by its original meaning of "non-aligned." [2] Australia and New Zealand are in the South, Kyrgyzstan and Mongolia are in the North. Is the former populated by poors and latter rich, wealthy and developed?
- yareal 3y agoTo you, sure, the term is not as useful. But to the people involved in academia and politics, the jargon is useful. You can keep using words you prefer, language is adaptable like that. But the jargon used in those circles developed for a reason, which may not be obvious to those outside or who don't follow as closely. And yes, Cold War geopolitics and confusion around non aligned were a factor in the evolution of the language here. First world implies something about the relationship with the U.S. even to this day. The Cold War wasn't that long ago, and the political alliances haven't drifted that much since then. An old first world country like Chile might also be developing.
- ramesh31 3y agoAbolish the borders. Anyone who can pass a criminal background check gets in, no more questions asked. Immigration is our #1 competitive advantage in the US, as the entire rest of the industrialized world slips into a demographic abyss.
- jpollock 3y agoA criminal background check is more investigation than is currently done. That’s usually only done for multi-year visas.
- ramesh31 3y ago[flagged]
- rayiner 3y agoThis attitude displays a fundamental lack of understanding of human society. People from different cultures are different. Not because of race, but because of cultural socialization, which persists for generations even in a new host country. In a democracy, those cultural differences will be reflected in the government and society of the new country. There are perfectly good reasons why the people in new country wouldn’t want to live with those changes. For example, my parents come from Bangladesh, which was disarmed by the British. They cannot understand—for deeply cultural reasons—why anyone would need a gun. My wife’s parents, meanwhile, come from a frontier tradition, where you need guns to protect yourself from mountain lions or in places far from the reach of the law. Insofar as everyone votes their culture, why shouldn’t the people who are already here be able to say “we don’t have anything against your culture, but we prefer ours, and we don’t want you coming her and changing our society?”
- ramesh31 3y ago> People from different cultures are different. Not because of race, but because of cultural socialization, which persists for generations even in a new host country. In a democracy, those cultural differences will be reflected in the government and society of the new country. Yes, this is indeed the precise excuse given for every single wave of immigration in US history for hundreds of years. Yet somehow we're still here, leading the world economically, politically, and culturally, watching as the frightened closed societies of Europe and Asia circle their wagons and fade into oblivion.
- remram 3y agoIs there a list or database of countries, ranked by how easy it is to get into from other countries? Something that can be used as a reference when organizing a global conference. The opposite of the "Henley Passport index", if you will.
- z2 3y agohttps://visalist.io/visa/ranking https://visalist.io/visa/ranking but you will need to exercise your own judgement, as it doesn't cover conference infrastructure or anything else that might be a challenge in getting to or operating inside a region!
- tossandthrow 3y agoSigh, academic politics. you first lay some unreasonable foundation. such as an extremely stressful environment where you don't know who pays you next paycheck and you have to move away from your friends and family o stay competitive. then you work up. from that unreasonable environment and assign privilege to those who are able to even be a part of it. the last thing you'd want for researcher is a calm environment to work...
- GardenLetter27 3y agoA decent article until it devolves into skin-colour based racism at the end (the UK is predominantly white, so of course professors are too - and skin colour has nothing do with the national discrimination anyway). But really more of the world should follow the great example of Nayib Bukele in just offering full citizenship to productive scientists and engineers. Also surprised it didn't mention when Chinese nationals were banned from the 2nd Kepler Science Conference.
- oceanplexian 3y agoIt devolved the minute they used the term "Global South". What do Singapore, Argentina, Dubai, China, and South Africa have in common? Literally nothing, except the racist implication that paints half of the planet with a single brush. As "third world country" isn't politically correct in 2024 we have to make up new vocabulary which is less descriptive and even more offensive.
- ametrau 3y agoEvery country is America.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThere's "developing" and "underdeveloped". Those quite good enough for the article.
- yareal 3y agoGlobal south and third world are different concepts, and cover a different set of countries. Brazil and Chile, for instance, were first world countries that are members of the global south. Here's a summary of differences between the terms: Third World countries were countries not aligned with the first world (NATO) or second world (Warsaw Pact). The idea that third world nations were developing nations is a sort of neologism. (There were plenty of first and second world developing nations as well.) Global South was a term used in the Vietnam war era largely academically, then introduced by the UN in the 2010s to avoid judgement around "developing" nations. (What is a developing nation? We sort of understand the term, but it's not self describing. Developing what, exactly?) The global south is definitely a phenomena that shows in data, in general, the global south is much less wealthy, less politically stable, and there is less individual freedom. That much is demonstrably true, but the reasons for this are a subject of much debate. You might also debate the merit of using the term. But if the set of countries exists, what do you name that set? Developing nations? That's probably not quite right, as several members of the set are developed. Third world? Also definitely wrong. Historically confusing to boot. I don't know what else to name that set, and I've settled on global south for no other reason than that's what others seem to use. It's an imperfect name.
- ciabattabread 3y agoMaybe it’s my low expectations, but I don’t expect a US organization that primarily serves the US to start holding conferences outside the US. The article mentions the availability of short-term postdoctoral fellowships from three European institutions to the “global south”. But they’re in Europe. Of course they’re biased toward Europe because that’s who they’re serving. The actual issue seems that for whatever reason incumbent US and European institutions look down on peer institutions in other counties (the part about the gatekeepers). Everything else is a hack around that.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThe unfortunate irony is that if you enter a country illegally you'll get easier access to some form of a legality status than if you enter a country legally which you then have to jump through hoops of bureaucracy to make happen. I'll take the downd00ts for an otherwise good discussion on this topic.
- analognoise 3y agoPeople overusing the term “privilege” harm their cause celebre.
- yareal 3y agoPrivilege absolutely exists. And overuse of the term privilege absolutely dilutes the impact of the concept, imo. But people are going to attach themselves to a term they like, that's just human nature, unfortunately. So I think it's best to just be like, "yeah, this term is going to get bandied about, let's make sure not to get too attached to every instance it is used."
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoCool, now do security clearances, i.e. the real citizenship now.
- seesawtron 3y agoI wonder if someone actually did a long-term study to generate evidence for a causal link that not being able to go to specific conference(s) actually "harmed" science? On a side note, the same citizenship privilege would also "harm" any other industry market. E.g., there are tons of talented engineers and programmers in "global south" (or insert a more PC term for the under-developed countries) who face years of waiting time to get their work-visa. In extreme cases, there are some companies who do not have a proper visa-support team so they prefer not to hire people such countries. It shouldn't surpise anyone that being born in the wrong part of the world plays a monumental role in terms of the oppprtunities to which one is exposed.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> I wonder if someone actually did a long-term study to generate evidence for a causal link that not being able to go to specific conference(s) actually "harmed" science? Back up a step. Is there any evidence that specific conferences help science?
- seesawtron 3y agoA -> B is same as ~B -> ~A
- hagbard_c 3y agoI suggest Nature change its name into Nurture given the way they have been on a politicised bent for a long time now. Among the damage done by Critical Theory spin-offs like Identity Politics (which is the 'praxis' of Critical Identity Theories) and related attempts at ideological subterfuge the devaluation of the concept of 'science' and the devaluation of the scientific method is probably the most damaging to society. What Nature publishes here is agitprop, not scientific debate. This happens all too frequent and it devalues the publication as well as taints its contents. Thank ${deity} for open-access network-based journals and other alternative publication venues.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoWhat's funny to me is they could have just come out and said 'Hey, we need to reform our visa process for academics' and I would have nodded along and said 'yep, that sounds reasonable', but no they had to wrap it in identity politics which automatically makes the reader more skeptical of their point. I'm just so used to the word 'privilege' being used in bad faith.
- wakawaka28 3y agoI for one happen to think that current immigration laws are fine and must necessarily be strict to account for fraud and scams. While it would be nice to have everyone attend any conference they want in person with zero oversight, it is not essential for scientific progress. This article is unnecessarily divisive and whiney, and infused with politics.