6 ms·
SpaceX's most-flown reusable rocket will go for its 20th launch tonight
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BenFranklin100 3y agoIt’s remarkable what SpaceX is accomplishing in terms of making access to space routine. I did not realize how much progress they’ve been making over the last few years.
- _joel 3y agoThey've got 24/7 ops and building of Starbase in Boca Chica and KSC going on as well as loads of other sites, it's quite something. Checkout LabPadre and NASA Space Flight (NSF) on Youtube, tank watching is quite fun.
- inglor_cz 3y agoGoing from expendable to reusable rockets will be a transition similar to the transition from silent movies to sound movies. Many of the old stars of the field won't survive the change.
- dylan604 3y agoThat's a creative comparison I would never have come up with. Boeing has been beaten up here for their planes, rightly so, but that mess has made itself know with Starliner as well. Since it hasn't killed anyone or gotten off the ground with people at all, it's pretty much a joke. Any time I hear of another delay, my response is "of course it is". At least they are not forcing the issues and putting astronaut lives on the line. About the only good thing I can say about that program
- dralley 3y ago> Boeing has been beaten up here for their planes, rightly so, but that mess has made itself know with Starliner as well. And the Air Force One contract, and the KC-46 contract, and...
- bumby 3y ago>At least they are not forcing the issues and putting astronaut lives on the line. Which "they" do you think is driving this choice? NASA or Boeing? I suspect it's the former, so I don't know how much credit should go to Boeing.
- lupusreal 3y agoIf Starship succeeds, the window of opportunity for small launch providers might be closed since there is no way they could compete. Commercial launch providers without a similar capability could all be pushed out of business. For any new company to challenge SpaceX would basically be impossible. Old companies with deep wallets might still be in the running.
- zie 3y agoThe US govt will force into existence a competitor OR keep one of the old ones around on life support. They have made their position clear and have been backing it up with money. All governments probably want their own space program, but only some can afford it. Those that can all force into existence a local space program because they need to be able to launch their own stuff for national security and defence purposes. Countries with their own space program: EU, India, China, Russia, etc. None of them are cheaper than Falcon 9 and none of them will be able to compete with Starship anytime soon, but they will all continue to exist even if Starship becomes a runaway success.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI worry that corporations have gotten better at the art of siphoning money from such programs without delivering on the intent, making more money from repeated failures. I worry that there is no longer the political ability to punish big companies for their failures. At such of a point it becomes impossible to will such projects into existence. I wonder if China, in essence, has more of an ability to punish corporations due to the power concentration at the top and if this paradoxically allows for better competition between corporations that are less powerful than the politicians. Perhaps at a certain point of corruption the leadership in effect already owns everything so the agency costs from such corruption is greatly reduced.
- zie 3y agoThat's a separate concern, but it's definitely a concern. I agree China could potentially punish easier, but they can also bribe/allow grifting easier.
- chris_va 3y ago... Are they the same engines though? Don't get me wrong, it's impressive that the pressure tanks can take that many cryogenic cycles, but I am not sure I would call it the same "rocket".
- dylan604 3y agoDoes it matter if they are the same? If they have an inventory of engines that get rebuilt after launches but enough that they do not need to delay launches, it's good enough for my use. It's similar to a NASCAR race. They pretty much tear those down and rebuild after each race as well, but it's the "same" car.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt matters and it doesn't. It doesn't affect turn around because you can have a ready to go inventory. But it matters how much an engine can be reused because it's a significant material and labor effort to produce them. Are the 9 engines from each flight reusable, and to what extent? Does half the motor get replaced each time or is it generally ok? The Ship of Theseus debate doesn't have a hard answer to it. We can -like the Persian Immortal - respect the continuity of the thing. But so too we should track and follow the churn of the pieces, acknowledge the parts decayed. I for one am very curious how much of the ship and how much of the motor needs replacement, and how often.
- Isamu 3y agoIn the context of rockets, what is important and salient here is reuse, and even if some motors are swapped out, they are still available for refurbishment, rather than destroyed on reentry.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoUnless they have to be written off cause they are wrecked? Tesla's kept this one close to the chest. We really don't seem to have much data at all on how the rocket engines are doing after re-entry. The rocket engine itself might well be it's own Ship of Theseus, requiring considerable replacement. We just don't know, it's just not clear.
- jlmorton 3y agoIt's worth noting that when George Sowers and ULA did their well-known business case analysis for re-use (nearly 10 years ago, in 2015), their analysis concluded that it would take 10 flights to pay-off the penalty of re-use. The analysis was flawed from the start, because it falsely assumed you could charge for every kg of capacity, but in reality customers are largely paying by flight, and much of the Falcon 9 capacity is unused. But even according to their flawed analysis, they assumed there would never be a need for so many flights, and re-use would just eat into their production line productivity, raising the cost of each rocket. These false assumptions caused them not to pursue any real type of reusabilty. Though they proposed a janky system where the engines would be recovered by parachute and helicopter, they never funded it, and the current Vulcan doesn't support any type of reuse. Flash forward to today, and ULA has a contract for possibly 83 launches from Amazon for Kuiper. What a terrible lack of foresight.
- PowerfulWizard 3y agoSpaceX’s propulsive recovery testing began over ten years ago, meaning a development campaign starting today would be ten years behind SpaceX if they can progress at the same speed. It seems crazy to me that essentially no one is even trying to follow the path demonstrated by SpaceX.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ortusdux 3y agohttps://www.relativityspace.com/terran-r https://www.relativityspace.com/terran-r
- PowerfulWizard 3y agoIt's true that Relativity Space Terran-R, Rocket Lab Neutron, and Blue Origin New Glenn are under development and are planning first stage re-use although none have flown. And also Stoke Space is developing a 2nd stage re-use solution which SpaceX hasn't solved yet. I think another American company could have a Falcon 9 competitor within 5 years if they really move fast. But they haven't yet reached the stage that SpaceX reached 10 years ago.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 3y agoGeneration-defining technology. Humanity is back, baby! Man, this guy is going to be immortal for the stuff he's done. He'll be remembered like Edison.
- moffkalast 3y ago>like Edison sensible chuckle