4 ms·
For-profit hospitals that actually turn profits do pay income taxes. The concern is with non-profit hospitals. They don't distribute profits to shareholders. Bu
by nradov 3y ago
For-profit hospitals that actually turn profits do pay income taxes. The concern is with non-profit hospitals. They don't distribute profits to shareholders. But some do pay high salaries to employees or have large and growing endowment funds. The author is arguing that threatening to tax some of those funds would incentivize non-profit hospitals to lower prices and give out more charity care. This isn't necessarily a bad idea but I am skeptical whether this would actually achieve results.
- lupire 3y agoIt gets into more arcane policy than clear economic effects. Why are dividends taxed, but not investments in a shell company that collects dividends? Corporations aren't natural people (spare me the inane conflation of "legal person" with "natural person", everyone who doesn't understand why those two concepts have distinct legal names), so there is no inherent reason why there's any need to tax organizations instead of the people who profit from them as owners or wage earners or vendors.
- xkcdxckd 3y agoThe dividend deduction avoids double-taxation, that should be obvious. The dividend-issuing organization pays taxes on its income; that income is then distributed effectively post-tax (although the exact % dividend deduction depends on ownership percentage). Why should a parent corporation have to pay taxes twice just because of its corporate structure?
- samus 3y agoSuch corporate structures are often set up for the express purpose of optimizing tax. Replacing corporate tax with dividend tax would remove incentives from setting up such structures, which is a good thing. Apart from that, double taxation is a reality for natural persons since they have to pay income tax and VAT. Corporations are usually not subject to the latter.
- quickthrowman 3y ago> The concern is with non-profit hospitals. They don't distribute profits to shareholders. But some do pay high salaries to employees or have large and growing endowment funds. The non-profit healthcare organizations in my metro area spend tons of money expanding by building new clinics, surgery centers, specialty clinics, hospital wings, etc.