8 ms·
Ubisoft is stripping people's licences for The Crew weeks after its shutdown
- tjpnz 3y ago>Frustratingly, despite a large portion of the game being doable in singleplayer, The Crew remained an online-only endeavour throughout its decade-long lifespan. This is the part which is most relevant and a reason to stay clear of "online only" releases if your main interest is single-player.
- MaxBarraclough 3y agoSomewhat related: GoG had to withdraw the recent games of the (singleplayer) Hitman series when customers realised many important features depended on Internet connectivity. How things progressed to the point that they released it in that state, I don't know. https://www.eurogamer.net/gog-pulls-hitman-from-its-own-store-admits-it-shouldnt-have-released-it-in-its-current-form https://www.eurogamer.net/gog-pulls-hitman-from-its-own-stor...
- Barrin92 3y agoas the article alludes to this should be next thing on the agenda for the EU. Users should have a guarantee that access to any software that runs offline can't be revoked and it'd probably be a good idea, just like with the gatekeeper legislation, have a requirement for publishers over a certain size to keep old software available, or if they can't do this or go out of business having to open source it.
- stavros 3y agoOr we need to make sure that, for things that can't run offline, the verbiage is clear that you're renting, not buying.
- philpem 3y agoSeems like we could have both.
- Mindwipe 3y agoThis can't run offline.
- progfix 3y agoThen give buyers the ability to make their own servers.
- FMecha 3y agoCritics are noting that Ubisoft did this to prevent exactly that.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThe point was "don't take away users' ability to run their own servers"
- usea 3y agoIt absolutely could. It just doesn't. For reasons.
- nottorp 3y agoSo said EA when they launched that Sim City... ;) TBH if you give money to the likes of Ubisoft and EA you deserve your fate. I've stopped ages ago*. * I don't even pirate their games. I have a backlog of legit bought games that will probably last me more than my natural life time.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoI hope the EU also applies this law retroactively and with fines that are a percentage of global revenue. Also it’s worth piercing the veil of limited liability for fraud.
- BlackFly 3y agoI'm pretty sure this is already covered by DIRECTIVE (EU) 2019/770. You purchase "Digital content" from the company; regardless of how they word it (like saying it is a license) while you are making your purchase this law defines it. You may also purchase digital service with an ongoing subscription fee. They render your content unusable, putting them in violation of Article 5, 7 and possibly 8. The preferred remedy is that they make it usable again or failing that provide a refund. The only real way around this is for the game to be free to play, or fully subscription based from the beginning. Then it is classified by this directive as a digital service. However, if they sell digital content like skins or other items then it again is covered as a digital good even if only used within the service (unless the purchase is actually declared time limited at the moment of purchase). In any case they would need to tell you the length of time for which you are purchasing service. If you are in the EU, demand a refund under this directive or that they supply you with the content you purchased. If you don't get a refund, issue a chargeback if your credit card company is willing.
- hd4 3y ago"acting as a stark reminder of how volatile digital ownership is" Okay I'm gonna say out loud what people are thinking, just pirate videogames. These companies are comfortable with taking away ownership of a product we paid for when they feel like, they broke the social contract, just take their shit.
- TiredOfLife 3y agoThis was online only game.
- nextaccountic 3y agoThen if they are shutting down they should be forced to release a server and let people host themselves This or else don't sell the software implying people own it
- javawizard 3y agoWas it? From TFA: > [...] despite a large portion of the game being doable in singleplayer [...]
- chiefjosh 3y agoIt's a single player game, that requires check-ins to an online server. When Ubisoft shuts down their servers the single player will be unplayable.
- workfromspace 3y agoI haven't played this game, but the article says: > despite a large portion of the game being doable in singleplayer, The Crew remained an online-only endeavour throughout its decade-long lifespan. So it didn't have to be online if it wasn't for corporate greed.
- gambiting 3y agoWell, hate to be a devils advocate but the entirety of The Crew was designed from the very start as an MMO-like experience with your session hosted on a server. It's not like the game was built as a single player experience and then Ubisoft HQnsaid "you know what guys, make it online only because that will make us more money". Ivory Tower wanted to build a permanently online car MMO-like game from the start. Arguably they didn't have to build it that way, but if that's the creative vision then I wouldn't say it's wrong. What's wrong is shutting down the servers.
- Sniffnoy 3y agoIt's kind of buried in the article, so probably worth pointing out the "Stop Killing Games" campaign, which will tell you what you can do[0] depending on where you live and whether you own "The Crew": https://www.stopkillinggames.com/ https://www.stopkillinggames.com/ (Admittedly, if you live in the US and don't own "The Crew", what you can do is not much. But if you live in, say, France or Australia and own it, they have a fair bit for you to do!) [0]In terms of stopping this sort of thing legally, rather than in terms of keeping your own copy playable via cracking, etc.
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 3y agoIt is not fucking with video games. It is governments forcing companies to respect customers, it is literally the job of governments. The same way car makers were forced to put seatbelts in all cars.
- flumpcakes 3y agoI completely agree. OP probably doesn't want governments meddling, like forcing companies to provide _clean_ drinking water. Or provide citizens with housing rights. Or stop companies dumping toxic waste... There are very few laws that protect the average person, and they should be embraced where ever possible. Who cares that a billion dollar company has to keep a few GB available to download and patch their game to remove DRM when they've themselves decided to stop supporting the game (and thus surely don't care about sales?). That's all it would take to not be complete dicks to consumers.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>like forcing companies to provide _clean_ drinking water. Or provide citizens with housing rights. Or stop companies dumping toxic waste... Unlike those, vidja gaemz don't cause physical harm upon anyone. It's one thing to regulate asbestos, it's another to suggest regulating something of ultimately no consequence.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoI heard that this deletion was done to remove game files from people’s computers - maybe so they don’t hack the game to make it playable offline?? But they aren’t the first. Bungie (then part of Activision) famously deleted the original campaign Destiny 2 shipped with and did the same to subsequent expansions one by one, claiming that older content took up too much space on people’s drives or some other excuse.
- maccard 3y agoWhere did you hear that? > claiming that older content took up too much space on peoples drives or some other excuse. Well which is it? I've worked on games where we've stripped old content in a patch. Like code, content has a cost to maintain it. If we update an Uber shader do we need to keep a branch for ever for that one edge case of an asset that we know 11 people out of our 1 million players use? The flip side is that when we don't strip content, we get accused of being lazy or incompetent - see any thread on patching or updating games here for what I'm talking about.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y ago> If we update an Uber shader do we need to keep a branch for ever for that one edge case of an asset that we know 11 people out of our 1 million players use? Yes, I would think you do need to keep it. It’s content people paid for already.
- atoav 3y agoUbisoft for me turned from a corp I'd describe as: "don't have any opinion on them, but sometimes their logo shows up in a game I enjoy" to a corp: "actively avoid their products even if I think I might get some joy out of them". But I guess that is the fate of all business MBAs: To reach the short term gains they need to get those bonuses, you think you have to exhaust some less easily quantifiable resource, be it quality, reputation, nature, workers, health, safety or whatever — until one day that intangible debt stacks high enough for it to collapse in catastrophic fashion. But guess what: Just make sure that you are no longer working there by that point and nobody will hold you accountable, and you got your bonuses for selling the contents of the first aid kit.
- caseyy 3y agoThe MBA theory is a limited take. The broader take is that these companies have become bloated with mediocre talent in the era of highly leveraged investment in the games industry, when "money was cheap". It made good business sense (MBA or otherwise) to churn out safe mediocre games that have modest returns, like 250mil game would return 400mil. Although arguably the same game could have been made for 50mil in a smaller team with more exceptional talent, like in the 2000s where ROI on games was much higher on average. But the low ROI method was low-risk and repeatable. That is why around 2010, after the financial crisis when the world was showered in low interest rates, the games industry largely stopped innovating. The "brute force" method for making games with very large teams where managing them has become almost impossible (most people in the AAA companies know what I'm talking about) is no longer sustainable now that money is no longer cheap. What is worse, executives in game companies have leaned into this model over the years, laying off expensive, very experienced talented staff and replacing each with 3-5 graduates. The 3-5 graduates can pump out more content for a mediocre game, the 1 experienced developer with decades of institutional knowledge could make a game that would perform exceptionally well, but not as reliably (this industry used to be called "hit-driven"). Layoffs did target the most expensive staff in many companies, by the way. This will come to light eventually. So what can a game company that's all bought into this model do now? Many managers weren't even around in the 00s when the previous model worked. They don't know what to do. So they're panicking in various ways. Doing more layoffs, rushing games, upping the game prices, cutting support for old titles even if supporting them didn't cost that much. But the industry has been over this once or twice. Notably in the 80s there was a shovelware games crash, then a lot of new small companies like Activision sprung up with small veteran teams and made great games in the 90s. This became the norm in the 00s, which saw the inception of many of the game titles we play today. The 10s paralleled the 80s, and we are heading towards a sort of crash or a soft crash now where the industry makes a lot of rushed shovelware. And those in games already know that many of their veteran colleagues are starting their own studios and working on very ambitious new projects that break the mould. None of this is new. Some of it is just new for people who haven't been around long enough. But all in all, the MBA stuff is not seeing the forest for the trees. In the bigger picture, it's just a cycle. You can see it in all sorts of graphs, like ones that show average game quality over the last decades, and how the indie game sector is suddenly growing. Exactly like during and after the 80s crash.
- not_your_vase 3y agoI say, vote with your wallet. Buy more games from Ubisoft, I'm sure they have learned their lesson, and won't do any similar shenanigans again. Just like they did the last time. And the time before that. And...
- BlueTemplar 3y agoYeah, I'm always surprised that there are people that still buy Ubisoft games with the kind of reputation they not only have now, but had already for more than a decade now !
- NKosmatos 3y ago"digital ownership" LOL People need to realize that most of the things they buy are actually rented. Same goes for Facebook pages, Spotify/Apple songs, Amazon books, Google/Apple developer accounts. If you don't really own it and can control it, it's not yours ;-)
- tracker1 3y agoI think the FTC should push for the term "Lease" and a lifetime guarantee that is disclosed in simple terms before purchase beyond EULA boilerplate. Lifetime being the life out minimum life of the lease. You shutdown the servers before a player got N years, full cash refund to those players. What happened now is clearly deceptive practice.
- wodenokoto 3y agoNo, legislators need to realize that most digital assets sold are actually leased and that they need to punish companies misleading consumers. It’s the perpetrators that are at fault, not the victims.
- rvz 3y agoDigital game downloads are as scam. You never owned it in the first place.
- acka 3y agoThis. All you do when you download a game is perform the initial cache update of its binary and asset files.
- anthk 3y ago"Free software for a free society" stil holds lots of truth.
- gmerc 3y agoThis will get more ruthless over the years as the attention economy isn’t growing anymore. It’s only a matter of time until publishers decide they can’t afford leaving people waste time that could be monetized by new titles on older, no longer monetizable titles It’s as inevitable in capitalism as is making worse appliances to ensure future sales - Games operate in a weird state where competition isn’t possible - nobody can just offer a better version of the game
- BlueTemplar 3y agoExcept they can : consider unofficial WoW servers.
- gmerc 3y agoThey’ll try to shut them down when they start taking too much valuable attention See Yuzu yoo
- sammy2255 3y agoI want Overwatch 1 back
- 93po 3y agosame, i wont even play it anymore
- flumpcakes 3y agoThere are people in this thread equating consumer protections to "authoritarian governments". This is patently ridiculous. Consumer rights and protections (along with environmental protections) are probably the single greatest thing our governments provide citizenry. This is also being championed by the EU the most. Frankly I want my government to mandate I can't be screwed by the handful of hundred billion dollar companies more than I already am. "Market forces" are completely irrelevant when the entire industry is a one giant racketeering exercise. Fortunately I can choose to only buy DRM free ebooks, and DRM free games, but this is < 1% of media available and certainly never the most popular titles. This needs to change. There needs to be laws in place to protect consumers from this shitty behaviour - with or without DRM. Steam for all it's faults have said since day 1 than there is a mechanism in Steam to unlock all of your games should Valve go bankrupt: I'm not sure if this is true now they sell mainly over peoples' games. Steam also never remove the ability for you to download and play a game you have bought - even when the publishers have delisted and removed it from Steam.
- Havoc 3y agoWhy does it feel like a disproportionate amount of gaming companies are slimy and sketchy? Every sector has its dodgy folks but the % here seems way off. Most of the big names seem to be steeped in scandal
- maccard 3y agoAs opposed to the tech industry as a whole where the biggest companies are basically data collection agencies subsidising VC backed loss leading subscriptions?
- Havoc 3y agoThere is definitely shady shit happening all round, but it does seem higher density in gaming to me. Obviously entirely subjective
- tyfon 3y agoWe got a law here in Norway in 2021 that states that if you lose access to digital goods you have paid for the seller needs to fully refund you. Now the laws here are not retroactive, so it only applies to digital goods bought after 2021. It's also worth noting that any agreement that gives the consumer less rights than the law are invalid, so you can't just slap something in the eula to get around it. This also applies to things like forced arbitration etc. I think this type of regulation is the only way to curb the practice.
- maccard 3y agoI'm European, and generally support the idea of these kinds of regulations, but this is onerous if it is what you say. You're forcing people to indefinitely support an app against a moving target - that's fine on windows, but Mac has had two architecture changes in my career, browsers are ever moving targets. If a chrome update breaks my paid extension that you've used for 3 years, then im forced to refund you?
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoYes you will refund him and then sue Google for breaking compatibility and damaging you in the process. Suddenly we will have incentive to keep backwards compatibility on all systems.
- maccard 3y agoThis sounds awful for everyone involved. No breaking APIs ever. How many man hours have been wasted supporting platforms that are dead for 20 years. Look at C++'s modules - they've taken 15 years to get to where we are now - they're still not usable because we're hamstrung by not ever breaking compatibility.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoLook at Windows and how awesome it is to use. I can run exe files from Windows 95 without recompilation.
- scotty79 3y agoIf purchase is not ownership then piracy is not theft.
- iinnPP 3y agoSounds like a 1030 violation. It's unauthorized, obviously impacts commerce, and transmits code that renders a function useless. IANAL
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]