3 ms·
> The perspective is seeing the law explicitly says said activity is unfair and illegal independent of whether one's ideology agrees said law is reasonable or
by Dylan16807 3y ago
> The perspective is seeing the law explicitly says said activity is unfair and illegal independent of whether one's ideology agrees said law is reasonable or should exist.
It still needs an explanation because at a surface level the crime and the name of the law have nothing to do with each other.
Until that explanation exists of how the law says it's illegal, I don't have the perspective of seeing the law explicitly say that!
I am not even in the realm of talking about whether the law makes sense.
- zamadatix 3y agoThe name of the law is neither here nor there in the end (most laws have useless names really) and you don't have to possess an explanation of why it's covered under that law to be given the perspective that it is. On that front though, and following the link to the body of the law, a shortened version might be: The saves are encrypted and proprietary. As a result modifying them to get rare items runs afoul into the "trade secrets" verbiage. Selling work based on such trade secrets then falls under the unfair competition definition and is what results in said penalties. My stab at the likely background reasoning for having these rules (i.e. not explicitly written into the law but rather why the law might have been made) is something along the lines that the guy made money off of devaluing the rarity of IP the company was supposed to have control of distributing through their proprietary means.
- Dylan16807 3y agoIt's still pretty important to me to understand some of the mechanism. What it takes to not break the law. Some potential reasonings are much more sensible than others, and the overall consequences differ.
- SllX 3y agoI kind of wanted an explanation too so I looked up the law, but to be honest it’s dense and beyond me. [1] It reads like an anti-circumvention law to me, but I’m not clear on what specifically in there would make it applicable to modified video game save data unless you can argue that modifying save data is a wrongful way to acquire to a particular game state. [1] https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/en/laws/view/3629 https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/en/laws/view/3629