3 ms·
So... I repeat the GP. What you gain is that the vulnerabilities will be harder to track down?
by marcosdumay 3y ago
So... I repeat the GP.
What you gain is that the vulnerabilities will be harder to track down?
- ongy 3y agoThe specific way sshd was infected would not have happened with libxz as dlopen library. Debian's sshd only uses libsystemd for the notify api. I.e. it doesn't need any feature that uses libxz. If it's dlopen()ed, it does not need to be loaded into the process context to use an unrelated feature. FWIW, IMO upstream systemd should split their monolithic library and allow users to pick better that way, but this has other implications on DX.
- newpavlov 3y agosshd should not have used libsystemd in the first place for the trivial notification. And the ifunc stuff is its own security nightmare. Papering over this by dlopen-ing some libs in libsystemd does not address the deeper issues.
- NewJazz 3y agoFWIW, IMO upstream systemd should split their monolithic library and allow users to pick better that way, but this has other implications on DX. They've done the exact opposite afaict. Libsysd used to be split up, now it is monolithic.
- Tuna-Fish 3y ago> FWIW, IMO upstream systemd should split their monolithic library and allow users to pick better that way, but this has other implications on DX. FWIW, upstream systemd has the opinion that no-one should load the library for startup notification, instead they should use the well documented api and just write a message to a socket.
- idoubtit 3y agoIndeed, that's what the Debian maintainer of OpenSSH did soon after the quick security fix. He replaced the dependency on libsystemd with some hand-made code that notifies systemd by socket. https://salsa.debian.org/ssh-team/openssh/-/commit/cc5f37cb8405cba624a133f4b8f464fbe381c5c8 https://salsa.debian.org/ssh-team/openssh/-/commit/cc5f37cb8...
- ptx 3y agoThat's not what they said in their update to the documentation[0] last week, which says that "although using libsystemd is a good choice, this protocol can also be reimplemented without external dependencies". It calls it a "good choice". Did they say somewhere else that no-one should do it despite it supposedly being a good choice? [0] https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/32030/files https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/32030/files
- klooney 3y agoYes- https://mastodon.social/@pid_eins/112202696589971319 https://mastodon.social/@pid_eins/112202696589971319
- marcosdumay 3y agoUpstream systemd should just cut the unused crap from their notification protocol and promise it's stable. They probably couldn't change it anymore if they tried to.
- Denvercoder9 3y agoThe systemd notification protocol has been stable and documented as such for years (probably even a decade at this point): https://systemd.io/PORTABILITY_AND_STABILITY/ https://systemd.io/PORTABILITY_AND_STABILITY/
- klooney 3y agoThe whole protocol is "write READY=1 to the socket found in the NOTIFY_SOCKET environment variable".
- advisedwang 3y agoIt meant that had the bad xz version been shipped to distros, only some people would been vulnerable instead of everyone. That is valuable.
- rcxdude 3y agoThough only with this particular approach to the backdoor. If systemd had always had this approach (or distros hadn't patched sshd to link it in), the attackers would have focused on a different path from delivering malicious code to widely-used distros which executes in a priviledged context to network RCE.
- cryptonector 3y ago> What you gain is that the vulnerabilities will be harder to track down? No, they're just as easily tracked. What you gain is that you can refuse to install optional dependencies because they are now optional when they used to be required. That's a fairly big deal. Of course, in practice all those optional dependencies will be installed anyways because of other things in the distro needing them. You can fairly object that not much changed, at least for now. A better approach would be to eliminate a lot of these dependencies somehow. Another approach would be to sandbox the dependencies that cannot be eliminated.