6 ms·
> people use it Protonmail is not a person. If the allegation is true, it looks like Protonmail decided to munge e-mails without anyone opting into it. Spont
by kazinator 3y ago
> people use it
Protonmail is not a person.
If the allegation is true, it looks like Protonmail decided to munge e-mails without anyone opting into it.
Spontaneously doing anything unusual with e-mails is a bad idea, until it becomes a standard behavior that everyone else does.
How about a prompt?
Your recipient foo@example.com has registered a public key with openpgp.org.
Would you like to encrypt this mail with they public key?
If you know that the recipient is prepared for encrypted e-mails, say Yes.
If unsure, choose "No".
[ Yes ] [ No ] [ ] Don't ask again for this recipient
- cdmckay 3y agoYeah, my mom would totally understand that prompt.
- kazinator 3y ago1. Given that Mom doesn't understand the bulk of the prompt, should we take away the prompt and encrypt the e-mail; i.e. treat the e-mail in a way she doesn't understand? (Maybe! After all sending an e-mail over TCP/IP and SMTP, and adding various headers and whatnot also treats it in ways Mom doesn't understand, and those have to be done. Or maybe not. Encryption literally obliterates the content, making it unreadable without the key.) 2. Your mom would likely understand "If unsure, answer No", and end up sending a normal e-mail. That text should be in bold, probably. Some of the verbiage could be behind some "learn more" link, where there is space and scope for a better explanation. It is probably better if the switch is on the receiver's side, as some kind of Boolean field in the key registration record.
- PurestGuava 3y agoGiven that mom isn't going to understand any of the prompt, and presumably has no pressing care or need for encrypting an email, the sensible default would be to send email unencrypted unless she expressly asks otherwise. It is pretty interesting seeing the various different design philosophies for computer UIs compete in this thread: the typical Linux approach (ask the user a convoluted question, expect them to understand it and expect an informed response - if/when the user selects wrong, tough shit) the Windows approach (ask a convoluted question but give an out for the 99% of people who don't understand it - if the user still selects wrong, tough shit) the Apple approach (don't ask the question at all and choose a sensible default, because 99% won't care - 99% of users get the exact result they wanted to begin with)
- ComodoHacker 3y ago>the sensible default would be to send email unencrypted That's exactly what anti-encryptionists would want.
- kazinator 3y agoThat's the same sort of argument form as "everything encrypted is what the terrorists and child pornographers would want". Just sayin'.
- lxgr 3y agoOr realists that think that encryption-by-default needs to be designed very differently from PGP, and that forcing people into something brittle will not win any sympathy.
- twiss 3y agoHi! Proton crypto team lead here. Our motto is "Privacy by default". We're aiming to fulfill that mission as much as is practically possible. In this case, looking up keys on keys.openpgp.org caused an issue for this user because they didn't know they have a key there. We'll try to make that more clear in the received (encrypted) emails - and we might look into opting out somehow. However, we don't want to make it opt-in if we can avoid it, even if that's what would make sense for Linux, Windows and Apple; it's not what would make sense for Proton. You can't change the world by copying someone else :)
- kelnos 3y ago"Privacy by default" is a good motto when the mechanisms used to ensure privacy actually work most of the time. I'm sure that between ProtonMail users, it does indeed work most (if not all) of the time. But once you leave the ProtonMail ecosystem, I expect you'll find that enabling PGP automatically doesn't work most or all of the time. It likely only works occasionally or even rarely. > You can't change the world by copying someone else :) Please take this as gently as I intend it: ProtonMail is unlikely to change the world on user privacy, at least when it comes to email. Larger providers are too entrenched, and most people won't care enough about privacy to change their email address (and very few people have a custom email domain to move between providers). At any rate, it seems like you're copying Facebook: "move fast and break things". Not great when we're talking about messaging. You're breaking email for some people, and some of those people are your users. OP may not be one of your users, but OP's mom is, and you have broken her ability to send her son email with this misguided policy.
- eviks 3y agoAnyone can understand this > If unsure, choose "No".
- thedanbob 3y agoUnfortunately, when presented with a prompt they don't understand a lot of people stop reading entirely and just click "yes" to make it go away.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoThose people will click the most brightly colored button, which in this case would be "no"
- mcv 3y agoHow did OP not opt in? If they uploaded a key for their email address, then doesn't that mean they opted in? I'm not familiar with any of this at all, but this sounds to me exactly how it should work: upload and verify the key, so people know they can use that key to send you encrypted email. The thing protonmail might consider is to put an unencrypted standard message in the body that the message is encrypted because the recipient has published a key, so the recipient understands that it's encrypted and why it's encrypted.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoThey uploaded a key to a third-party website for their own reasons. They didn't upload it to Protonmail. Protonmail chose to interpret participation in that third-party website as participation in their E2E encrypted email format.
- pxx 3y agoBaffling. This really is like buying a billboard with your phone number on it, along with text that reads "contact me!!" and then getting upset that you're getting phone calls. The whole point of associating an encryption key with your email address on a public keyserver is so that you get encrypted mail!
- thayne 3y agoMany keyservers don't verify you own the email address. Someone else could have uploaded a PGP key for your email. You shouldn't trust the value in the keyserver without additional confirmation via another channel (like giving someone the fingerprint in person). And PGP/GPG keys are used for more than just email, so just because you have a key on a keyserver doesn't necessarily mean you want your emails encrypted with it.
- pxx 3y ago1. This keyserver does. 2. Keys have types. These keys were marked for use for encryption. You can upload keys for signing only if you wanted to.
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago> If the allegation is true, it looks like Protonmail decided to munge e-mails without anyone opting into it. As an active protonmail user, unfortunately they have a long history of this. My major gripe is that they manipulate emails that I've sent over the desktop bridge. If you sign your emails locally, this of course completely breaks the signature. And if you are sending emails to mailing lists, their internal email header fuckery has a history of eating things like reply-to headers that they can't find a local copy of in your mailbox. I love their web interface and I am a big advocate of their other features but I am begging Protonmail to just give users the option to send their emails without interference through the desktop bridge.
- tristan957 3y agoI just want an opt-in IMAP and SMTP endpoint that actually works. I've debated moving to Fastmail so many times.
- twiss 3y agoUnfortunately, we can't easily offer direct IMAP access, because no external email client offers support for everything we need and use in OpenPGP (such as for automatic forwarding, which is currently just a draft [1], but we hope will become an RFC in the future). That's why Proton Bridge exists: to be able to decrypt all emails, including internally forwarded ones, and present them to the email client unencrypted - and vice versa when sending. Obviously this involves some muching of the emails, for better or worse. [1] https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-wussler-openpgp-forwarding https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-wussler-openpgp-...
- tristan957 3y agoIf the Bridge always has to exist, it would be great if Proton gave it more love. We don't have any WebDAV support right now, which means I can't see my calendars in GNOME Calendar or my contacts in GNOME Contacts. JMAP would be a great addition. Adding support for various IMAP RFCs would be great too. As it is right now, the IMAP is pretty much unusable in my email client of choice. I'm pretty much forced to use Thunderbird due to the RFCs that just aren't supported by the Bridge (gluon). Even going to the gluon repo, the last commit was 2 months ago :(. I don't understand how I as a power user who sends plain text emails is supposed to survive on Proton Mail. I can't use it for mailing list development, at all. Fastmail just seems to be blowing Proton Mail out of the water in terms of IMAP/SMTP/JMAP. They are actively working on the protocols. Proton doesn't seem to be. Link: https://github.com/ProtonMail/gluon/issues/378 https://github.com/ProtonMail/gluon/issues/378