7 ms·
The Lonely Funeral Project in Amsterdam
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoI hope this benefits the living
- verisimi 3y ago[flagged]
- lukas099 3y ago'holier than thou' implies that they are being judgemental of others. Kind of a harsh thing to pin on somebody with zero evidence.
- zingababba 3y agoBook sales
- mapcars 3y ago> "I feel everybody deserves something humane at the end of life" Everybody deserves something humane throughout their life, at the end is way too late.
- gambiting 3y agoYeah exactly, as nice as it is as an idea, that does literally nothing for the person who might have died completely alone.
- ziddoap 3y agoGood thing this idea isn't mutually exclusive with helping people before they die. Edit: Curious at the downvoters, do you think this is mutually exclusive or something? What am I missing?
- derbOac 3y agoI agree although late is also better than never.
- Filligree 3y agoSince they're already dead, it's arguably "never". Funerals exist for the survivors, and for the sake of society. I wouldn't go as far as to say it's pointless, and I also don't believe it is. But "too little, too late" does apply here. All respect to the people who do it...
- lukas099 3y ago> Funerals exist for the survivors, and for the sake of society. Exactly. Every living person in Amsterdam knows that somebody will be there at their funeral.
- wanderingstan 3y agoAnd at a wider level, I and many others on the internet have a renewed appreciation for human kindness and the depths of feeling that people can have for each other, for the value we can place on having lived. It’s a beautiful project.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NietTim 3y agoNo, contacting relatives might be impossible but become possible over the years, them knowing someone they lost contact with but still loved was given a proper burial might relieve some of the shock of finding out they're dead.
- dazc 3y agoBetter late than never?
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThis is a terrible perspective. Por que no los dos?
- scop 3y agoIt is interesting that the first two comments on here are in relation to the living. Yes we should strive to reduce the suffering of the living to the fullest extent possible. But, just as much, the dead do deserve our attention and respect. Is it “pointless” from some sort of “efficient use of time and resources”? Of course it is. That isn’t the point. Much of what gives meaning and purpose in life can be deemed “pointless” (music, fiction, liturgy). As Aristotle said: > we are unleisurely in order to have leisure The dignity of a person doesn’t cease when they are dead.
- lukas099 3y agoI used to look down on the "spiritual, but not religious" thing. But now I think that being spiritual means choosing to keep some things sacred. You can do this without believing in anything supernatural (I believe we all do to some extent or another).
- hfsh 3y ago> But, just as much, the dead do deserve our attention and respect. They do in a way, but don't fool yourself that it's actually about the individual dead. It's about humanity in general, and the contribution – good, bad, or meaningless – that every single human life has made to our collective existence. It's good that we admire rainbows, but that doesn't mean we should revere every droplet of water. > The dignity of a person doesn’t cease when they are dead. It doesn't 'cease' inasmuch as it becomes a meaningless term. The dead don't have dignity, they are no longer people. It's the memories of the dead have dignity. Those memories are not a part of the dead, they are a part of the living that remember them.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoI'm not sure you believe what you're saying. The dead don't have dignity? They aren't people anymore? Treating the dead with dignity isn't solely for the sake of the dead, it's literally one of the oldest cultural norms of homo sapiens and perhaps even our homonid ancestors. A homeless man is found dead outside city hall. He is nominally identified, but no relatives can be identified. What should the city do with him or - excuse me - his remains?
- PreInternet01 3y agoHmm, well, imagine this turning up on HN! I attend 1,2-maybe-3 funerals every year because of this exact project, and while every one of these is very different, the experience is always humbling. Most of the time, literally nobody will show up. So, you'll pay your respect to the deceased using a short speech that is based on the information provided (which is usually pretty scarce, like: "found abandoned, identified, but no next-of-kin responded") complemented with Google and your imagination, and that's about it. Then, there are the occasions where one or two people will attend. These are usually the hardest: you have to make clear that you don't actually know the first thing about the deceased, other than what Google told you, and that might be ENTIRELY wrong, but still have to deliver a coherent eulogy. Poems work best for these situations, and sometimes talking to the visitors is quite revealing as well. And then, there are surprises, like a room full of people turning up, and you being able to elicit stories from family and friends, and basically having a regular funeral. But I admit that happened once in like the past decade or so. Anyway, I think it's important that nobody is left to their final resting place without witnesses, and I also find avoiding that is a good way to engage with your community...
- delichon 3y agoIt would probably be emotionally harder to spend the same energy on visiting the dying in hospice care but it would be more than symbolic. I'd rather have you show up and say "Hi, want to talk?" than go to my wake. But since I don't do either you're a more compassionate person than me either way.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoIs it right to critique someone's good works because you can think of an even more challenging and selfless activity they could be doing instead?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- muffinman26 3y agoI notice several people saying the energy is better spent on hospice, but these seem like different activities to me? Not everyone who dies spends time in hospice. Wikipedia says 7-8% die from accidents and violence, and over 30% die from heart disease, which would include sudden death due to things like heart attack. I'd also expect those who die in hospice to be less likely to have unattended/low-attendance funerals. Family and friends have time to plan and gather for the death because they know it's coming. They also have time to adjust start the grieving process. If someone I knew died suddenly and I was the only one who could make it to their funeral, I would certainly appreciate having someone else there as a witness, even if they didn't know much about the deceased.
- motohagiography 3y agoabout a decade ago i stood in as a pall bearer for someone who didn't have enough people and i decided it was important to be able to convene a party of six. found a fraternal organization and after some vetting, joined. it's what you make it, someone dies every couple of years and the loss of loose acquaintances and casual friends gives you some valuable perspective on lives lived and how to apply the time you are given. overall, recommend.
- nobody9999 3y ago>Anyway, I think it's important that nobody is left to their final resting place without witnesses, and I also find avoiding that is a good way to engage with your community... Funerals, like life, are for the living. The dead don't care -- they're dead. This seems like a ghoulish way to make oneself feel more compassionate and caring, and does absolutely nothing for the deceased. As I said, they're dead -- they don't care. That said, if using a dead person as as a prop to make you feel better about yourself, go for it. The dead person doesn't care -- they're dead. But pretending that it somehow makes a difference to the dead person is rather silly -- they're dead, they don't care. Edit: Fixed prose.
- gedy 3y agoI think you are coming from a belief system that makes this all pointless and cynical, but this is quite kind for people with some religious beliefs.
- Filligree 3y agoWell, it's kind to their relatives. Not to the person in question, given they're dead. The theory here is that the dead person is looking down from above? That works if the person giving the eulogy is also religious. If they aren't, then they shouldn't be believing that.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoYou don't necessarily need to be religious to have a belief in the afterlife, or at least a strong enough suspicion of it to want to be respectful. As an analogy, there's some evidence that people form memories when in a coma. Even if you can never prove that an individual is aware of you, it is still compassionate to assume that they can hear what you say about them.
- wpietri 3y agoWhen you were a baby, many people were kind to you in ways that you don't remember. Was that also pointless? I also think this goes well beyond the relatives. Part of being in a society is caring for one another. Here I am on another continent, and I feel better that these people are taking a moment to mark someone's passing. If it doesn't matter to you, fine, you don't have to do it. But I don't get why you're putting so much energy into being negative about it.
- ThaDood 3y agoOddly enough, I actually tried to make something like this happen at my high school. My high school was a private and catholic one. We had a strong relationship with a lot of the local parishes and shelters and there was always a need for some paulbearers or otherwise "witnesses" for individuals with no family (older, homeless etc) who had passed. Initially I would just attend a few burials. I did not say much (if anything), nor do much. I just tried reflecting on the person and hoped they found some peace and comfort. When I tried getting it off the ground into something more formal we ran into some bureaucratic issues. Makes me kind of sad. Maybe I should reach back out and see if I could get it started again.
- echelon 3y agoI feel really weird about this. It's too late for the person to receive any benefit. They won't know or care. If it's not accurate and you're making stuff up, this feels like a creative writing exercise to make the eulogizers feel good. Like getting a dopamine kick off of someone's macabre death. I don't think I'd like if I knew people would do this to me. Whatever the case, death sucks. Loneliness sucks. We have a lot of problems to solve.
- PreInternet01 3y agoNo, I'm not making stuff up, and yes, it's weird. But: if you die, and nobody is around to eulogize you, would you rather be completely forgotten, or have a total stranger think about what happened to you and make a short-and-ultimately-meaningless speech accordingly? For me, it's the latter, but then, I'm biased :)
- krisoft 3y ago> if you die, and nobody is around to eulogize you, would you rather be completely forgotten If i die and there is nobody around to eulogize me then I am already forgotten. > or have a total stranger think about what happened to you and make a short-and-ultimately-meaningless speech accordingly I would prefer that not to happen. It feels fake. Of course your time is your time, you spend it as you see it best fit, but haven’t you thought about reaching out to someone old and lonely before they die? That would feel to me much more likely to be meaningfull.
- lukas099 3y agoIs it fake? They put real time and effort into showing up for you.
- noneparticular 3y agoDiffering perspectives I suppose. It's comforting to me to think that no one would be bothered if tomorrow I dropped dead. I'd actually be somewhat happy if they could just leave my corpse to rot somewhere in a field, or at least be disposed of in a landfill. No funeral, just compacted in the back of a garbage truck and then tossed as refuse. Somewhat a little harsh, but at least I'd rather people worry about the living then fretting about my remains. By the point, I would be beyond caring.
- mparnisari 3y agoI don't understand this project. If you want people to feel less lonely, then do it while they are alive. I know I wouldn't want a funeral attended by strangers that didn't know me, for me it feels even sadder than a funeral attended by no-one. What do the poets gain from this, an avenue to exercise their creativity? I'm sorry if I sound rude but I genuinely don't get it
- gwbas1c 3y agoBecause every person deserves dignity, even if their circumstances were such that no one is mourning their death.
- layer8 3y agoThis really depends on whether you think that someone who is dead has the ability to care. In my opinion, funerals are for the living, for those left behind. And it’s those who don’t like the thought of non-attended funerals who organize this, and it’s really for them, not for the dead, whose lives are already over and done. Dignity is for those who can experience the dignity or lack thereof.
- keybored 3y agoDying alone is not undignified. Even though the article gracefully gives the “maybe they were a drug addict” as one of the examples.
- carlosjobim 3y ago[flagged]
- Scarblac 3y agoChurches aren't even in the story? These funerals are completely secular, and nobody from any church is showing up to them. Maybe churches should start doing this rather than leaving it to some poets.
- scop 3y ago> Acedia comes from the latin acedia, which itself comes from the Greek akedia, which translates as “lack of care”. Prior to the Christian era, ~the word denoted the act of not burying one’s dead. Thus it connotes a dehumanization~. Man buries his dead; animals do not. Nault: The Noonday Devil
- impish9208 3y agoThis reminded me of The Lonely Death of George Bell, a NYT article that delves into such deaths in NYC and how they’re handled. https://archive.is/e1v1r https://archive.is/e1v1r
- smearth 3y agoI imagine poetry as an often misanthropic and lonely hobby with virtually zero demand for it’s output. Whether written or spoken. Moreso now there are LLMs. If I die unrespected and socially isolated I like the thought of donating my body to medicine while providing a funeral for poets to crash and get their words out. It is an absurd concept, it would be nice if they connected socially before I died and provided the respect they are concerned about. But given the constraints of their own lives it is nice knowing my lonely death could provide social support to probably introverted intelligent thoughtful people who are likely at risk of social isolation themself. What is the purpose of a funeral is an interesting question. I think it is to help the living to socialise and forge ahead with a cohesive story of the deceased ‘s contribution to their own lives and to navigate the gap and hierarchy left in the modified social network. I’m guessing this process reduces grief and conflict as people feel loved and supported through the process. If you die alone you leave no gap. I think it’s brilliant that Poets seized this opportunity to get a reading in and strengthen their own social network. They are also attributing value and respect to life, no matter how meaningless, which is another positive. The futility and absurdity of the human condition is a beautiful thing we all wrestle with whether socially connected or not and I think this is the point they are getting across while having someone listen to their poetry.
- gnulinux 3y ago> I imagine poetry as an often misanthropic and lonely hobby with virtually zero demand for it’s output. Whether written or spoken. Moreso now there are LLMs. (1) In any big city in the US, you can easily find poetry workshops/meeting groups. I'm currently in one (Boston), we read each others' poetry and talk about poetry every week. It's absolutely ridiculous to think there is no demand for poetry, poetry is one of the -- if not the -- oldest art forms, I mean yeah there are people who read poetry even in 2024. My generic bookstore still has a poetry section where I pay $$$ to exchange for poetry books. There is even a dedicated poetry book shop in Harvard Sq (i.e. they exclusively sell poetry books) and they pay the same (expensive Boston) rent any other business pays. (2) LLMs write dogshit poetry. Comparing a "good" poem with a GPT-4 generated poem is like comparing "2001: Space Odyssey" and "The Room". Other than the fact that they're both arguably "movies" the quality difference is extremely obvious to people who are familiar with this art form.
- benou 3y agoIn a similar vein, the "Confrérie des Charitables de Saint-Éloi" was founded in Béthune (France) in 1188 during a plague epidemy and is still active today. Edit: spelling
- NoNameHaveI 3y agoPlease forgive my ignorance but who pays for these funerals? Here in the USA, funerals easily cost thousands of dollars, even without a casket or burial plot. To my knowledge, unclaimed remains end up in a mass grave with no fanfare. It’s nice that in the Netherlands, EVERYONE gets a little dignity at the end, no matter who they were.
- more_corn 3y agoThe dead don’t care. Funerals are for the living.
- space_oddity 3y agoSometimes I wonder what might happen to me. For some reason, it makes me feel sad