7 ms·
1.18k drawings of plant root systems
- futureshock 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FredPret 3y agoImagine how much digging went into drawing those pictures
- johnny_pearseed 3y agoIt's fairly amazing the amount of labor that went into projects in the past. Now as the value of someone's time went up, it feels not economically feasible to do these anymore.
- berkes 3y ago> economically feasible Luckily it's a University project. And economic feasibility does not apply. Or should not. Unfortunately some universities do take this into consideration, rather than just scientific value.
- walthamstow 3y agoNot to mention that half of the people doing the projects, at least in Britain, were rentier aristocrats who didn't need to work
- paganel 3y agoThe Baumol effect [1] all over again, I'm thinking about it more and more lately. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect
- w-ll 3y agoHow was this captured? I mean they are just drawing but they seem relativly new. I'd kinda guess they were lab grown with some sort of imaging on the 2 sides, but they are 2d drawings. Did they really dig them up and and map them out... Maybe water them with a fluorescent dye to get depth info... Super curious.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoThey're pen drawings, done by hand. Most of the history of Botany was done this way - Drawings by skilled artists, using life samples painstakingly removed from the soil, as was most of the history of biology and physiology. You can grow plants specifically for this purpose, using less dense soil so that you can more easily extract the root system without damaging it.
- Tempest1981 3y agoImagine the patience required, first to wait years until the roots are established, then painstakingly unearth them.
- yreg 3y agoWouldn't the soil density affect the root system?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pvaldes 3y agoYes. There aren't two root systems identical. I assume that this plants were cultured in a sandy or hydroponic mix. But the main goal is the generalization and to know how long roots can grow. For trees they wanted to know also if roots can grow up the hill against gravity (they do it all the time). This is useful to understand how stable is the structure and how useful to fix soil in place and fix erosion processes. The dune melon root is particularly funny. You can almost hear the root sniffing water right and left in the Namibian desert
- Faaak 3y agoYeah, the methodology here is bothering me. Did they really dig 4m+ deep? Must be really hard work, but impressive nevertheless. Maybe they did use some water spades to ease up the digging?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- parpfish 3y agoThe significant digits in that title a killing me. They’ve really gone out of their just to obscure the final digit. they should have just given the full number (1,18x) or rounded to the hundreds (1.2k)
- __turbobrew__ 3y ago1.18k is more characters than 1180. Who came up with this title?
- bookofjoe 3y agoBut not more characters than 1,180
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ai_slurp_bot 3y agoOriginally, there were 1030 drawings. So it was titled 1k. Then, 110 drawings were added. The title needed to change, so it was titled 1.1k. Then, 42 drawings were added. The title needed to change, so it was titled 1.18k. In 2 weeks, 6 more drawings will be added. The title will need to change, and this can be resubmitted as 1.188k.
- Loveaway 3y agoRIP my friend. Good thing you found the energy to warn us before dieing. By the way, your first sentence is missing a verb. Your second sentence is missing the word "way". Your third sentence should end with a period and the first word should be capitalized. I hope you can still use your last breaths to correct these mistakes. We must give our everything to avoid further casulties in future generations.
- holoduke 3y agoIs dieing a correct word? Should it not be dying? :)
- 3y ago
- triyambakam 3y agoFunny, 1.18k is more characters than 1180 and usually I think of using the k form for less approximate values, e.g. 1k
- Tempest1981 3y ago1.18k implies +/- 5, whereas 1180 implies exactly 1180. Maybe the count isn't precise, or is changing?
- throwup238 3y agoIf I remember my high school math “1180.” with the decimal implies exactly 1180 “1180” without the decimal implies only 3 significant digits.
- yreg 3y agoNever heard of such notation. For me ≈1180 would mean that it's not exactly 1180. But a better title would be something like “Over a thousand plant root system drawings”.
- iopq 3y agonobody adds the decimal digit to integers, though 1180 can be 4 significant digits if the count is precise
- throwup238 3y agoNobody really uses 1.18k outside of math, engineering, and scientific contexts either. A kagi or Google search for 1.18k in quotes returns this very HN thread and mostly a bunch of resistors, very few organic uses (some youtube videos about subscriber counts is all I see).
- permo-w 3y agowhere did you go to high school?
- 3y ago
- bri3k 3y agoUSDA Pomological Collection is another set if you want to see the fruiting bodies. https://search.nal.usda.gov/discovery/collectionDiscovery?vid=01NAL_INST:MAIN&collectionId=81279629860007426 https://search.nal.usda.gov/discovery/collectionDiscovery?vi...
- florid 3y ago[dead]
- xpe 3y agoProject idea for someone sufficiently motivated: Some of the drawings show rhizomes in root systems, but I don't see a way to search for that.
- roland35 3y agoSomewhere an AI is pumping it's fists in excitement
- drusepth 3y agoI'm a human pumping my fists in excitement on AI's behalf
- fuck_google 3y ago[dead]
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoA massive effort led by Herr Dipl. -Ing Dr. Erwin Lichtenegger going from 1960 up till 2009 was what I looked at. Was interested for a while to get these into a 3D format but never got a reply from the library or the Pflanzensoziologisches Institute. I think these would look great animated and can only wonder what the good doctor would have achieved archiving with today's tools. Effort and dedication like that applied over time is a rare thing I am glad they are well preserved as works of art as much as science. Ps also the workbooks of Dr. Santiago Ramon y Cajal on brain neurons are museum quality pieces with some startling similarities to these roots from a distance.
- geek_at 3y agoShame that the book is over 200€
- martyvis 3y agoWhy 1.18k and not 1180?
- eimrine 3y ago1k18
- abdela 3y agoGreat way to view what is normally hidden, really makes me appreciate plants.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- KingOfCoders 3y agoAnd then people think root cause analysis means finding the one root cause.
- duckmysick 3y agoAbsolutely fascinating stuff, love it! If you're doing any kind of gardening, you can find the root system of many common plants and weeds. Some examples: - bindweed: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/193/rec/1 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/193/rec/1 the white meaty rhizomes go at about 10 cm but the actual roots can go much much deeper (2.2 meters in this example) - horsetail: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/753/rec/1 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/753/rec/1 also grows deep roots; extremely sturdy - resists many herbicides and can spread through spores. - goutweed: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1435/rec/1 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1435/rec/... dense network of thin roots - dandelion: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/676/rec/2 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/676/rec/2 this example has roots reaching 4.5 meters! - potato: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1014/rec/3 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1014/rec/... was looking for a tomato plant but found this instead (they are the same genus); you can see the tubers too. - carrot: https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1049/rec/4 https://images.wur.nl/digital/collection/coll13/id/1049/rec/... the edible taproot is not the only part
- benrutter 3y agoBejeezus how do I unsee the bindweed one!? No wonder it takes so much time to keep it at bay.
- snorkel 3y agoThe dandelion root is 450 cm?! That explains why pulling up the sprouts does nothing to prevent it from sprouting again.
- aszantu 3y agothey're amazing, you can make salad with lemon and salt, or fry in butter and eat with your steak. Also the roots are edible. And dandelion pulls nutrients for other plants from below, once the nutrients have been used up, the dandy will leave on its own.
- vanderZwan 3y ago
- theanonymousone 3y agoIs this available as a dataset?
- h3wallace 3y agoAs above, so below, as below so above
- tome 3y agoWow, these are astonishing. The trees have much shallower roots than I thought. I assumed they went down as deep as the tree is tall! And the smaller plants have much deeper roots than I thought.
- Lutger 3y agoAnd much wider that most people think. Generally the roots of trees are 1,5x to 2x the crown. Roots need oxygen, going more than a few meters down in the soil and conditions aren't very beneficial anymore. Most of the soil life (and nutrients) are in the top few inches.
- tome 3y agoYes, also wider! Do the smaller plants only look like they have longer roots because they're going to about the same absolute depth?
- Lutger 3y agoThese are amazing and very informative. There is an important caveat to consider: how roots actually grow depends a lot on the soil. Sand or clay, moisture and especially if and where there is compaction has a huge impact. A lot of root systems can't even penetrate heavily compacted soil, so you can imagine there is a lot of variability.
- subroutine 3y agoIn a way this reminds me of the neuron cell trace database from the Allen Brain Atlas... https://celltypes.brain-map.org/data https://celltypes.brain-map.org/data
- udev 3y agoToo bad it does not contain any of the grape (genus Vitis) varieties.
- animatethrow 3y agoHow were these drawings made? It seems the only accurate way would be to painstakingly excavate soil around the root systems a few tiny clumps at a time so as to record how the root system really is shaped prior to any disturbance. This would mean slowly observing the root system from shallower to deeper levels, then reconstructing the side views seen in the drawings. Growing the plants in some sort of 2D glass observation vessel in order to observe the roots from the side would cause the roots to grow more unusually than in nature. Very curious how these were done.
- olejorgenb 3y agoWish they the images was available at even higher resolution. The highest resolution is decent, but not close to fully sharp in the details.