5 ms·
Microsoft: Laptops with Snapdragon X Elite Will Be Faster Than M3 MacBook Air
- aaronbrethorst 3y agoAnd then you're stuck using Windows.
- znpy 3y agoqualcomm had demos of snapdragon elite x laptops running debian with 3d stuf going on. It's not released yet, why so much negativity?
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoPeople bond over shared negativity.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoI think that for many people they want to feel they made the best choice in what they purchased, so when someone says something else is better, they defensively try to shoot it down, so that they can remain feeling good about their decision. Occasionally I find people get surprised when I don’t engage in pointless “well my different (but largely equivalent) thing is actually better” debates. A lot of the “holy” wars are like this, iOS vs Android, Windows vs macOS vs Linux, tabs vs spaces, programming language/framework choices, etc Really, I’m happy for you to use what makes you happy and please let me do the same without it irrationally bugging you, even though it has no effect on you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kyriakos 3y agoReal reason is that most of HN crowd is biased for Apple.
- pc86 3y agoI came here to make a similar comment. I only have an M1 and I can't really think of anything I need it to be faster for. I've got a Windows 11 PC next to me right now that I only bought for gaming and I still find myself fighting with its incessant need to pipe literally every piece of data it can get its hands on up to Daddy Satya. Let's say by chance Snapdragon is everything MS says it will be and more. Who cares? If you're only using Windows for whatever reason, now you'll have a faster Windows. If you're not, "it's faster than M3" is not in and of itself any reason to use it.
- pompino 3y agoThe overwhelming majority of the world uses Windows to get stuff done.
- pquki4 3y agoAnother day, another HN user speaks as if Windows is the end of the world and cannot imagine other people using Windows. The reality is that even among developers, there are a ton of Windows users (for work or personal use). I don't know if there is an accurate number, but if we trust Stackoverflow survey, there are likely more people that use Windows than Mac for personal device. They are just not as loud and talking about this operating system is better than other options.
- madsbuch 3y agoDoes this mean we will soon see ARM based Linux Desktops?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tonymet 3y agoThey've been around for 7+ years with Raspberry Pi
- znpy 3y agoand chromebooks
- madsbuch 3y agoYou are both technically correct - the best form of correct. It seems like raspberry pi maxes out at 8GB of RAM, which effectively will not allow me to work. I also do not plan run Google's OS for chromebooks, and it seems like installing other OSs is a hassle on the chromebooks. In essence I want the specs of a MBP M3 Max with 128GB of ram, just running PopOS.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- robin_reala 3y agoRaspberryPI? If you mean ATX-factor then you can go and buy something like this Ampere Altra.[1] Probably better off putting Asahi Linux on a Mac Studio though, as the CPU upgradability is going to be limited regardless. [1] https://www.ipi.wiki/products/ampere-altra-developer-platform https://www.ipi.wiki/products/ampere-altra-developer-platfor...
- madsbuch 3y agoLaptops, sorry, not Desktops. And I would also want something that performs better than Raspberry Pie.
- scosman 3y agoMacBook Air level M3, not MacBook Pro. "Our best chip which isn't released yet is better than the competitors entry level model which is already in market" isn't that much of a brag.
- wlesieutre 3y agoNot to mention that the Air is fanless
- scosman 3y agoAnd that benchmark is running at 80w...
- pquki4 3y agoSure, it may not be very competitive, but given the context which is the performance and efficiency for x86 and previous Qualcomm CPUs, this would be a big leap. Even if it cannot match M-series Pro chips for a while, it could change the landscape quite a bit, because you know what, most people don't actually need or care about Pro level performance.
- giantrobot 3y agoThis has been Qualcomm's claim with each of the Snapdragon powered Surfaces Microsoft has released. Even then the claim is hedged about running specific benchmarks. Real world performance of these systems hasn't seemed to beat the compared to Apple systems.
- Dylan16807 3y agoI don't care who is the best, I care about having enough performance, and performance per dollar. And this is enough performance for many things. It's a useful thing to say (though how useful depends on battery life).
- multimoon 3y agoI wonder how much of this is raw performance and how much is windows is an unoptimized ad and tracking filled mess compared to MacOS.
- ProfessorLayton 3y agoI just bought a loaded M3 15" Air, and it's a fantastic laptop in nearly every way. While I don't notice much CPU performance difference from the M2 MBA it replaced (Had a 13" before, but decided I wanted something bigger), I don't want there to be an Intel situation with Apple, and have them get complacent. So this is great news, because competition should be fierce, and all of us will be the benefactors of that.
- invaliduser 3y agoThat's fine and I appreciate this progress, but right now performance is way below energy efficiency to me when choosing a laptop. My major question is, how long will the battery last between each charge. I just don't want to worry anymore about charging when travelling for a few hours.
- jwells89 3y agoI’ll echo that. Laptops have been “fast enough” for a long time, which is why I can break out an Core 2 Duo laptop from 2008 and still get a lot done with it, but somehow despite far better process nodes and battery tech, battery life is on average worse today than it was in 2014, which is just goofy.
- giantrobot 3y ago> but somehow despite far better process nodes and battery tech, battery life is on average worse today than it was in 2014, which is just goofy Not trying to make excuses for shitty laptop vendors but the CPU power usage is just a fraction of a laptop's power envelope. The GPU, RAM, controllers, storage, and display (including driver circuitry) all eat up power. Their usage is exacerbated if the OS can't sleep or otherwise throttle those components during times of low demand. Apple's pretty good about managing whole system power. It's gotten "easier" for them with Apple Silicon since everything is a SoC that they control. On x86 machines the vendor is just leveraging the components they get from Intel or AMD. The vendor's control is limited to what the drivers expose. Often times different components' behavior or stability can change with different power modes. Vendors will just lock the device to high power mode to avoid those pitfalls at the cost of battery life for the user.
- bee_rider 3y agoDon’t worry, Microsoft will find plenty of new background processes to spin up. Users won’t be faced with the confusing task of finding useful applications to run on their lap warmers.
- tonymet 3y agoApple and third party developers were collectively much better prepared to transition to ARM, to the point that it was totally seamless. Developers were experienced with ARM on iOS, and Apple had a robust dual-binary & backward compatibility system to make sure all apps ran smoothly. I don't anticipate this level of compatibility with Arm on Windows. You're going to get your new machine, and many if not most of your apps won't run. The intel simulator performance will suffer. Sometimes the migration path needs even more investment than the end product.
- lvass 3y agoI think it's much easier to do if you're abandoning video games entirely, something that would make no sense for windows. The only reason I'd buy a non-amd64 PC is if it's better at running amd64 software than amd64 processors.
- jeroenhd 3y agoHaving seen what box64 can do on my phone, I don't think it'd be that terrible. The graphics intensive system calls are all native system library code. The CPU parts will run slower, of course, but if they can beat the M3, I don't think the result would be all that bad.
- tonymet 3y agoARM has tremendous efficiency benefits. I'd happily trade off top-line performance for 3x battery life and no fans
- jsheard 3y agoI'm more concerned about drivers than apps, because that's where you'll absolutely need native ARM builds rather than being able to fall back on emulation.
- tonymet 3y agoextremely good point. Also drivers can be even more disruptive. You have a scanner you use 1 / mo but for a critical business. Everything's great on your new Arm / Windows laptop and then you find out the 5 y/o scanner driver doesn't work. Your meeting is in the morning.
- paulmd 3y ago80W elite 10C cpu is faster than the passively-cooled 10W 4C CPU? you don't say
- mikestew 3y agoOf course, the headline doesn't answer the other half of this equation: power efficiency. (Because, yeah, AMD also makes a faster CPU, but you better bring a power adapter.) So a few paragraphs in we have: "MacBooks with Apple silicon also offer industry-leading performance-per-watt, while the Snapdragon X Elite will likely run hotter and require laptops with fans." MacBook Airs don't have fans.
- rmbyrro 3y agoThe headline obviously can't answer everything, otherwise it wouldn't be called a headline. The body does address power efficiency. > There are a few caveats here, including that (...) MacBooks with Apple silicon also offer industry-leading performance-per-watt, while the Snapdragon X Elite will likely run hotter and require laptops with fans.
- mikestew 3y agoI say this completely in jest, with a smile on my face: what, you could not be bothered to read my whole comment? You quoted exactly what I quoted. :-)
- wintorez 3y agoWould love to see the new Snapdragon in the next Oculus Quest.
- porcoda 3y agoI’m eager to see these. I bought a regular windows machine for the first time in decades to see how WSL works for my development work and have been pleased. My only gripe is the power efficiency compared to my Apple Silicon machine. If they can come anywhere near the Apple silicon devices in that dimension, I’m likely to switch over (which feels really weird after 26 years in Apple-land, but I’ve lost my patience with them over the last few MacOS versions).
- dangoodmanUT 3y agothe air? the one that's thermal throttled the second it's turned on? I'd be more interested if it was the m3 max
- insaneirish 3y agoSome computers that will exist in the future will be faster than some computers that exist today. Story at 11.
- alberth 3y agoTL;DR; - a competitors rumored future (not yet released) computer will be faster than Apple baseline chip from last year.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pompino 3y ago"Performance" is a marketing term and is meaningless without details. "Faster" means nothing without context. We need to know the exact workload, the peak performance numbers, the sustained performance numbers, the heat output, etc, etc. People who gloss over these details, probably aren't interested in choosing the right product for the application, but just selecting a "Good" product.
- faeriechangling 3y agoIt's about more than the speed of the chips, Apple is simply more capable and willing to commit harder to transitioning to ARM native than Microsoft is. Also as bad as MacOS is, Windows has aggressively been trashing their OS with adware to the extent that I have to assume Microsoft has lost confidence in the future of Windows and is attempting to cash in - and why would I invest my time into a platform the developer doesn't believe in? Also compared to say 10 years ago, the amount of software which I need Windows for has absolutely plummeted.
- Aerbil313 3y agoYet, Adobe Photoshop, that legacy business app from Windows 7 days and your new AAA title remains Windows-only. Overwhelming majority of people have just 1 (one) application which would prevent them from getting out of the worst backwards compatible application platform that is Windows. It’s really amusing.
- faeriechangling 3y agoNews to me that Photoshop is a Windows exclusive. As for legacy business apps, I’ve been part of more conversion/virtualization projects than you can shake a stick at and Microsoft itself has done stuff like .NET core since 2016. I haven’t seen people greenfielding windows exclusive native apps in years. It’s mostly gaming and old professional apps with 30 year old codebases where I still see Windows dominate and even THERE I see more availability on MacOS nowadays with cross platform development being the norm.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Some more discussion on actual article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39971753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39971753
- probably_jesus 3y ago[dead]
- akmarinov 3y agoIsn't the M4 right around the corner?