7 ms·
This is the entire text of the linked Bluesky post (which is part of several threads): > Looks like it a few domains, including thehandbasket.co, were mistaken
by Aurornis 3y ago
This is the entire text of the linked Bluesky post (which is part of several threads):
> Looks like it a few domains, including thehandbasket.co, were mistakenly classified as a phishing site, which has since been corrected as Andy mentioned. Unfortunately, at our scale, we get false positives on safety measures all the time. Apologies for the trouble.
False positive that was already corrected at the time is was posted on Bluesky and corrected long before it was posted here on HN.
This all happened and was fixed days ago, but people are still trying to post headlines that imply something more nefarious is still happening.
There is no story here, just journalists trying to stir up controversy and imply malice. Unfortunately this is a valid tactic for driving attention to small substacks and similar outlets who wouldn’t otherwise be noteworthy. Getting “banned” by Facebook is the most effective thing they could ask for to gain more exposure, as evidenced by the way this has shot to number 1 on Hacker News despite having been corrected days ago.
- barbazoo 3y ago> Unfortunately, at our scale, we get false positives on safety measures all the time. At this point, the “at our scale …” argument is such an arrogant excuse for doing damage all over the world. If I can’t ensure people are treated fairly, don’t get harassed, etc, maybe it’s not a viable business then. Stop offloading all kinds of externalities onto the public.
- root_axis 3y agoThe "doing damage all over the world" framing makes no sense here. Blocking a link on your own website is not an externality by definition.
- barbazoo 3y agoThink of Myanmar https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-facebooks-systems-promoted-violence-against-rohingya-meta-owes-reparations-new-report/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-faceb...
- lupire 3y agoSo, Facebook allowing content is bad, and Facebook not allowing content is also bad?
- 3np 3y agoWell, yeah. No entity should be in the centrally authoritative position that Meta alongside a handful of other companies is. Moderation and filtering needs to be decoupled from content hosting and authn/authz. This is a major part making me optimistic about bluesky/atproto.
- rightbyte 3y agoAre you implying that would be some kind of fallacy?
- krainboltgreene 3y agoIn most cases I would agree, but in this case they actually did do reputational damage. There are people asking the site owners why the site is considered insecure.
- root_axis 3y agoI didn't consider that aspect. I admit that does sound frustrating from the perspective of the site owner.
- hyperhopper 3y agoWhat are they supposed to do? Not have any automated filtering? Just shut down when the site gets too big. I'm not a fan of these privately owned social media platforms with no oversight, fairness, or recourse for the public, but people want corporate social media and I'm not sure what these giants are supposed to do or what people even want here.
- tomrod 3y ago> What are they supposed to do? Not have any automated filtering? Just shut down when the site gets too big[?] Maybe? It's not that crazy of an idea that if you can't serve your clients that you are put out of business?
- wbl 3y agoBut they do serve their clients. We don't shut down hospitals because one doctor misses a diagnosis.
- tjpnz 3y agoThe hospital is serving a public good.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> hospital is serving a public good Given hospitals are frequently privately owned, one could argue Facebook provides a public service in running a social media platform. Discriminating models based on public goodness is simply command-economy picking of winners and losers based on politicians’ limited knowledge and preferences.
- janalsncm 3y agoOne doctor missing a diagnosis doesn’t indicate a systemic issue with the hospital. A hospital which drove teenage girls into depression and suicide via an addictive product would rightfully be shut down.
- 3y ago
- jahewson 3y agoThis piece of “journalism” isn’t fair either though. Should we shut down CNN too?
- lupire 3y agoHow many people would follow links to that website if Facebook didn't exist? Fewer than of Facebook existed as accidentally banned them for one day.
- piva00 3y agoWe can't know since history has no ifs and we have no idea what else could have been in place of Facebook.
- jbverschoor 3y agoAt that scale, they have the resources to deal with it.
- mcswell 3y agoCan you say "clueless"? I didn't think so. What you're saying is that if something isn't perfect, it shouldn't exist at all. And guess what: Nothing is perfect.
- zazazache 3y agoWrong, first they blocked the Kansas Reflector but when they fixed that the “offending” column was still blocked. That column was reposted by someone else and their whole website was also blocked. There is controversy and malice
- Aurornis 3y agoThe quote in my post was verbatim copy and paste of the linked BlueSky post. If you have different information, perhaps post a valid source here rather than saying “wrong” and then injecting something else. I literally just copy and pasted the linked post text. The linked post is halfway through a BlueSky thread that has a screenshot of a part of a Twitter thread about a link to something else that I can’t click. Nothing screams “social media ragebait mill” like a long chain of unclickable screenshots to some ragebait take about some story that happened elsewhere.
- jrflowers 3y agoI think GP may have been responding to this > There is no story here, just journalists trying to stir up controversy and imply malice. Which was not a quote Assuming you’re not familiar with this story at all, here is some previous discussion of the numerous events in which the critical article was stopped from being shared on meta’s platform. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39945811 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39945811
- shortformblog 3y agoTell me, how does the same story, reposted in three different places, conveying criticism about the source of the blocking, lead to phishing issues on three different domains? It is clearly underplaying questionable behavior that has caused serious problems for a media outlet that were only fixed because this got attention.
- lupire 3y agoObviously because something in the content triggered the phishing filter.
- shortformblog 3y agoAnd what’s in the content that would trigger phishing? Among what you’ll find in the piece: - Criticism of Facebook’s ad policies and functions - Discussion of climate change issues - Links to Vox, government sources, and a bunch of PBS sites https://kansasreflector.com/2024/04/04/when-facebook-fails-local-media-matters-even-more-for-our-planets-future/ https://kansasreflector.com/2024/04/04/when-facebook-fails-l... This gets blocked, yet I see significantly spammier links on Facebook by accident. To me, the real issue is likely that their filters aren’t very good.
- cloverich 3y agoOr the problem is far more complex at their scale than you are considering, and ie simple content filtering is but a mere tiny signal amongst what qualifies links to be filtered.
- davidgerard 3y agoYou're not making an argument that makes Facebook look non-malicious here.
- davidgerard 3y agoso that's not the case - the Facebook guy was lying. At absolute best, he was making a much stronger claim than he confidently could. There's continued to be intermittent bans on the Kansas Reflector site, and there's even fresh bans on blog posts talking about the ban on the site. Also, the original KR post about Facebook still seems to be blocked from being posted on Facebook or Instagram. Someone is actively adding these URLs to the filter. There's this weird tendency to bend over backwards to assume Facebook, a company repeatedly convicted of doing malicious things, wouldn't do a malicious thing, and none of the excuses stand up to the facts for a second. Would a company run by a man who openly compares himself to Caesar Augustus try to silence its critics?