4 ms·
They can generally decline coverage for any reason, for what it's worth; they could cancel without aerial footage just on the hunch that you didn't replace your
by tptacek 3y ago
They can generally decline coverage for any reason, for what it's worth; they could cancel without aerial footage just on the hunch that you didn't replace your roof, or they could mass-mail their customers demanding proof of roof replacements.
(The article and other things I'm reading suggest that cancellations are because footage finds trampolines and pools --- in which case I don't even understand how anybody can have sympathy. It's fine to have insurance risks on your property! But disclose them!)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- everybodyknows 3y agoIt's interesting that insurers will spend money to discover this rather than rely on the pro forma clause that claims proceeding from an undisclosed risk are invalid. I'm guessing they calculate that a jury may not respect that part of the contract when confronted in court by grieving parents of an accident victim.
- ssl-3 3y agoHow is an unversed lay homeowner who is inexpert in the insurance industry (or perhaps even any industry) supposed to know what risks an insurer thinks are important? Their job, I think, is to accept the quote, pay the premiums, and to keep living life.
- tptacek 3y agoOn 1-3 occasions over the course of an insured's entire life, they'll be confronted with the paperwork for the insurance contract for the most expensive asset they'll ever buy. They should read it.
- Retric 3y agoAnd then remember all the relevant details for the next 30 years… It’s frankly unrealistic to expect most people to remember their home insurance asking about trampolines 15+ years ago.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat you're really saying is that it's unrealistic for buyers to know that trampolines are dangerous.
- Retric 3y agoBathtubs are dangerous, being dangerous isn’t the only criteria here.
- tptacek 3y agoOk, well, we've reached an argument that is dispositive for people who think trampolines are no more dangerous than bathtubs.
- thfuran 3y agoAnd for people who aren't deliberately missing the point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ssl-3 3y agoI don't see here where anyone has made any supposition that bathtubs are more dangerous than trampolines are, except for your own missive.
- Teever 3y agoWell now you've got me wondering. What does the data say? Which is more dangerous, trampolines or bathrooms? I've known a few people who have hurt themselves in the bathroom, but I dont know anyone who has hurt themselves on a trampoline.
- everybodyknows 3y ago> They should read it. Indeed. This is how I discovered that my own policy forbade me to own a dog belonging, even in part, to any of a long list of breeds: Pit Bull, Rottweiler, Cana Presario ... IIRC German Shepherd was on the list.
- ncallaway 3y agoI wasn’t actually confronted with the paperwork. When I purchased my house, the insurerer that was selected by my bank informed me (several times) that they were unable to provide the complete coverage details and contract until after the insurance contract was in place. Even then, it took me several calls and interactions to get them to send me the actual detailed insurance contract. They tried to fob me off several times with a brief summary document. I would be surprised, based on my experience, if people are actually confronted with the paperwork as you suggest. The default flow of my home purchase made it clear that my request to review the coverage contract was so far outside the norm that they weren’t really sure how to handle it.
- jajko 3y agoNo, you have been played. Signing a contract, any contract without previously seeing it... ask any lawyer how good of an idea is that. Its doesnt matter what mumbo jumbo they come up with, if you cave to peer pressure then accept the risks. Or vote with your wallet.
- ncallaway 3y agoI didn’t sign a contract without seeing it. I didn’t sign a contract with the homeowners insurance. The bank contracted with the homeowners insurance. How could I have signed a contract without seeing it? I wouldn’t have anything to sign! But none of that was my point. My point was—if asking to see the agreement was this far outside the norm, then how many people are actually confronted with the paperwork? My guess, based on my anecdotal experience, is not many.
- radlad 3y agoYou are entitled to find your own home insurance, you do not have to use the bank's choice.
- callalex 3y agoIs that really an option when there are another dozen people bidding on the house though? (I haven’t been through the home buying process yet)
- singleshot_ 3y agoThis is good advice. One wants to be sure that one is reading the entire policy. Key words here are "certified complete copy" and once someone at the insurance company who is authorized to do so certifies a copy as complete, you can be a little more sure you're dealing with the entire thing than the "copy that happened to be attached to someone's email." The first page or so will explain who the policyholder is, what is the effective date of the policy, and what forms constitute the insurance being provided. The rest of the policy is (usually) a set of forms approved by the state insurance commissioner that define, in particular, what is and is not being insured. Be aware that something that is very clearly defined on the first page of the first form is very frequently completely contradicted by something on the fifteenth page of the thirtieth form, which makes it very important to have the complete set. In general insurance law is such that you ought to be able to read the entire policy and make sense of it - no tricks. In practice there are some wrinkles and it's good to consult a professional but if you read the policy you will at least have some awareness of the coverage you can expect.
- alistairSH 3y agoI’m assuming the insurer would ask. How old is the roof? Do you have a pool? Etc.
- hattmall 3y agoIt's up to them to make their own risk assessments. There's a lot of press when claims get denied but it's not as common or as easy as complainants make it seem. Especially when it comes to roof replacements. That's been a heavily exploited point as well. Lots of shady operators chasing storms.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoAlso trees can have a lot of impact on your insurance rate, like if you have a neighbor's trees intruding into your property, remember that it is the property's owner responsibility and not the owner of the tree, so they could ding you for that. Or if they notice you are too close to a tree line in an area known for wild fires, etc...
- firesteelrain 3y agoSome insurance companies will allow trampolines -- at a cost. We had to get rid of ours because the cost and liability just wasnt worth it.
- nothercastle 3y agoMost people don’t declare then which is really stupid imo.
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoPerhaps they figure the risk is worth it compared to the increased premiums.
- mvc 3y agoSo in the richest country in the world parents can't let their kids play on trampolines because a neighbours kid having an accident on one would bankrupt their insurance company. Meanwhile, toddlers do active shooter drills like they are fire alarm drills. Totally logical country you got there with a perfectly reasonable approach to risk.
- firesteelrain 3y agoAh, yes, the great trampoline versus active shooter drill debate—a classic comparison in risk management. It's fascinating how we can meticulously calculate the liability of a backyard bounce while simultaneously normalizing lockdown drills for kindergarteners. It's like comparing apples to, well, something far less innocent than apples. But hey, who's to say which is more logical in the land of the free and the home of the brave, right?
- someguydave 3y agoYour child is much more likely to be injured on a trampoline than in a school shooting
- tekknik 3y agoHmm, when I was a kid while at my friends house I had a small statue fall on my head from a bookshelf. I still have the mark from it. My parents were informed, and with two of them nurses they decided to just watch me for concussion. My parents didn’t sue them, just chalked it up to accident. A friend of mine broke their arm on another friends giant trampoline. Again, no lawsuit. These days parents will sue their child’s best friends parents for something like that. So perhaps there’s something different with modern Americans that has made them more likely to piss on their neighbors? Unfortunately this is the normal ebb and flow of populations. And the stage the US is at we just have to wait for severe economic disaster to remind people what trauma is.