5 ms·
Why is it not a good thing if insurance is more accurately priced? Insurance isn't a redistribution mechanism. And dilapidated roofs aren't a social good. Munic
by tptacek 3y ago
Why is it not a good thing if insurance is more accurately priced? Insurance isn't a redistribution mechanism. And dilapidated roofs aren't a social good. Municipalities have actual redistribution schemes to make these kinds of repairs.
I'll note that there's nothing at all redistributive about sneaking a trampoline onto your property, too.
Further, I'll note that working class people also take pride in their houses and pay to keep them up, and they too are being asked to subsidize people who are getting rate breaks from false assessments.
Later
My municipality will make an interest-free loan of up to $25,000 to cover the kinds of property repairs we're discussing, if you're income-qualified (ie: not too rich to just pay to replace your own roof).
- drekipus 3y agoIsn't insurance entirely a redistribution mechanism?
- tptacek 3y agoNot in the sense evoked by customer purchasing power.
- compiler-guy 3y agoNo. It’s a risk pooling mechanism. If a group of ten people all have a one in one-thousand per year chance of a million-dollar loss each year, then their annual premium will be: 10 x 0.001 x $1,000,000 = $10,000 (plus some administrative overhead and assuming a very basic risk model) It has nothing to do with who is rich and who is poor or making anyone come out ahead of their own losses.
- potatolicious 3y ago> "If a group of ten people all have a one in one-thousand per year chance of a million-dollar loss each year" More importantly, each person in this group has a different chance of a million-dollar loss each year, and it's important if you're going to write a policy to get that chance as accurate as possible. Some members of the pool have a 1-in-1000 chance per year, others have a 1-in-10 chance. An efficient insurance market assess who has what risk, and offers premium commensurate with risk. If you're one of the 1-in-10 people you pay more. A risk pool combines resources to pay out for losses that are otherwise individually unaffordable by each member of the pool. It is explicitly not a mechanism - nor is the intent to - have members with wildly different risk exposure pay the same premium. In fact the only way it can sustainably function is if each member's risk level is accurately gauged to some level of precision. There are risk pools where the intent is to subsidize higher-risk members, where we believe that such subsidy is a social good - health insurance for example is one of those things. But I don't see a good argument that home insurance is, or should be, one of these types of risk pools.
- harimau777 3y agoWouldn't an efficient insurance market be worthless since the expected net payout for everyone insured would trend to zero?
- jfim 3y agoThe EV of insurance is negative, in the sense that the expected money that one can expect to get out of insurance is less than the premium. Insurance is for catastrophic losses. I don't pay for insurance to make a profit, I make it to avoid the large tail loss of having the house destroyed and having to pay the value of the mortgage to the bank.
- aqfamnzc 3y agoNo, it's still very valuable since I'll never have to pay out of pocket for that million-dollar incident. The point isn't to save money, it's to distribute the incident payments over a long term.
- dannyw 3y agoGenerally insurance premiums are invested into relatively safe assets, like bonds, which yield quite a bit right now.
- tptacek 3y agoThese kinds of questions are a little mind-binding. Insurance is a financial services business. If the net EV of insurance was positive, how could any insurer remain solvent?
- shpx 3y agoIf insurance was just about pooling risk, an insurer that had perfect information about the future would pool everyone into a one-man pool and charge everyone the price of their damage for the year +1 cent for itself. But that's not what would happen. You would still have insurance because what we really have is 8 billion people in the world (or 300 million in America or 10 million in your state or 1 million in your city or 500 in your neighborhood/village) and each person in that group of people derives some utility from other people in that group not having to pay full price for their broken roof, whether that's because when you go talk to your neighbor he's not complaining about his roof all day or because your neighbor is your doctor and you want him in the hospital instead of running around trying to fix his roof all day or sitting at home wet because he can't afford it. The total amount of that utility multiplied by how much money the entire group makes might be less or more than the price of roofs for everyone in that group. So it's both. You're trying to discover the network of people (or create/convince that network, sometimes by threat of violence in the case of government-mandated insurance) in whose interest it is to redistribute their wealth to a given person.
- Noumenon72 3y agoI invite you to start selling an insurance product whose sales pitch is "You will get some utility from this product paying for other people's roofs!" Is there some kind of theory of insurance they teach in business class where they explain this "discover the network" idea? It doesn't sound like the common definition of insurance at all. I believe the perfect information case you say wouldn't happen is exactly what would happen. The only reason we have insurance is that perfect information is impossible in a chaotic world.
- Too 3y agoThere are actually insurances that to some degree work proactively to reduce the risk of all its members in the pool. My home insurance offer free pest-control, because they know that if this is neglected, it will cost a lot more for them. Plus, it will be hard to prove that it was a cause of the home owners neglect. At the risk of getting political, (governmental) healthcare is another one, where regular checkups can save you thousands in repair. It might look like a subsidy but in the end it becomes a net-benefit for everyone in the pool.
- smodo 3y agoLol that’s precisely what it is. It redistributes the cost of accidents. Across all its members, paid forward. Just don’t get insurance and nothing of yours will pay for anything belonging to anybody else.
- tptacek 3y agoNo, it's not. The idea of a risk pool is that everyone's catastrophic risks cancel out, not that people who replace their roofs also chip in to cover hail and water damage for people who don't.
- shawndrost 3y agoIn fact, you are wrong; insurance in California is redistributive by regulatory design. Farmers (when operating in CA) must offer insurance X% of homeowners in a range of $Y-$Z, subsidizing those customers who are more expensive to Farmers. It's relevant to the story: Farmers is disallowed (for political reasons) from canceling accounts in Auburn due to actuarial climate updates; Farmers has new incentives to closely scrutinize home conditions and utilize any new datasets.
- loeg 3y agoThis quirk of California law (that insurers cannot factor in climate risk or anything other than trailing 20 year average costs) is why insurers are pulling out of the state; it isn't generally true of insurance.
- timr 3y agoIt also doesn't have anything explicitly to do with "actuarial climate updates" -- there have been a bunch of correlated losses recently (i.e. fires in 2017-2018) that mean that the insurers are losing money on people who live in certain high-risk places in California. Calling it "climate" just window dressing for local politics. California won't let them underwrite to accurately reflect the location risk, so they're pulling out instead. It's basically exactly what Tptacek said, only demonstrating it via the stupidity of California's law.
- rolandog 3y agoBecause everything is turned as a cash-grab by corporations and prices never go down.
- dgoldstein0 3y agoIn some states insurance rates are regulated. Definitely know they are in California. That said whether the regulators are effective in keeping costs down is a different issue. But my not-very-deep understanding is that risks are rising, e.g. large wildfires in the US West, and increased hurricane frequency and strength on the Gulf Coast, and the only way to deal with that for the insurers is to raise prices, or drop customers - sometimes to the point of abandoning the market altogether. This sounds like another piece in that trend.
- paulddraper 3y agoBut inflation is good TM
- WalterBright 3y agoYou've never seen anything on sale?
- sarchertech 3y agoI’m not arguing what insurance should be I’m merely talking about the end result of this technology. I guarantee you income is correlated with state of home repair. If insurance companies can more easily access state of repair, lower income individuals will end up paying more than they did previously. Regardless of whether that is fair, it is a change from the status quo, and it’s obvious why some people would consider that problematic.
- rvba 3y agoYou describe theory. In practice, the price will not drop for you at all, but will increase much for others, or they will be unable to get insurance. In fact your price will propably increase since more overhead needs to be allocated to fewer customers.
- mindslight 3y agoIt's incorrect to assume that more data points implies more accurate pricing, as we're talking about very limited very simplistic models. It's more plausible to envision those extra data points serving to confuse the market and make it less competitive, rather than actually helping to accurately price risk. Every new data point partitions the statistical population size into two smaller parts, each with their own larger variance (ie the insurance company's risk). The insurance company could statistically combine the risk from each partition into the same original, but it's more likely they'll focus on the higher independent risk figures and raise premiums an outsized amount to cover each individually. And this effect is going to be more pronounced the more lopsided the partition is, leading to similar monoculture incentives as we see in the mortgage/housing bubble. For example, I'd bet there's somewhat of a correlation between insurance claims and whether a house is painted beige. That is how rates can go up even when the extra data is fundamentally sound. But there can also be just enough extra information to be damning, but not enough to exonerate. For example after the "Do you have a trampoline" question, is there a follow up of "Do you let guests use it" ? Or perhaps a more formal "opt out of all liability coverage for the trampoline" ? Likely not. Then of course there are places where the model is irrelevant or even outright wrong, because the thing being singled out seems like it rocks the boat. Like the driver surveillance devices that penalize focused acceleration due to perceived association with racing, when it's much more likely that the driver is actually paying attention to driving. Or penalizing people for going over the posted speed limit, when it's actually safer to go the prevailing speed of the road.
- tptacek 3y agoI didn't say anything about more data points. I'm talking about insurers being able to properly gauge whether existing customers are adhering to the terms of their policy, or whether they're free-riding off the premiums of their neighbors by defrauding the insurer.
- mindslight 3y agoBy "more data points" I meant questions like "Do you have a trampoline?". Read my comment again with that understanding. Elaborating on my second criticism - let's say someone has a trampoline but never has guests at their house. The insurance company asks about the first condition, but doesn't ask about the second condition. If the customer lies about having a trampoline, it's likely that they are actually still being subsidized by their neighbors as their overall risk of liability claims is much lower. And I've actually got to wonder if lying about having a trampoline is technically even fraud. Are home insurance companies legally obligated to pay/defend liability claims stemming from things you lied about? If not, then it would seem there is no fraud (unless you also lie for the claim) - the claim can just be denied, and liability coverage isn't relied upon by a mortgage.
- autoexec 3y ago> Why is it not a good thing if insurance is more accurately priced? Another poster here, Scoundreller, recently responded to one of my comments on another topic with this insight: > The funny thing about insurance is that as it becomes perfect at assessing risk, it becomes worthless. > Oh, you’re about to have a $x claim this year, your premium is $x + y% admin fee. > Just self insure and save yourself the y%. There's likely a point where the more accurately priced a policy is the less worthwhile that policy is to purchase, which really wouldn't be a good thing for the insurance industry. The use of aerial photography probably isn't enough to put them over that threshold, but the closer they get, the less attractive their offerings will be. Considering that the insurance companies mentioned in the article have billions in revenue and assets I'm not sure they have a compelling need to resort to this level of surveillance in order to make good money. None of them appear to be going broke due to rogue trampolines anyway.
- PurestGuava 3y agoThat argument is silly because it misunderstands what "risk" means both in an insurance context and in general. Yes, if you could 100% guarantee that someone was going to have a $Y valued claim, their premium would fairly be 100% of $Y at least in order to allow for their contribution to the risk pool. Problem is, you cannot 100% predict the future, and there is no model capable of doing so, nor will there likely ever be. Nor can you predict that any other insured risk might not materialise in the meantime. More to the point, it fundamentally misunderstands what insurance is and how it works, not least the commercial considerations involved. If there is a 100% risk of risk X materialising, the insurer won't rate your premium at the cost of risk X; it will simply exclude risk X from your policy and rate your premium based on all the other myriad risks that might arise that year in an attempt to win your business and collect premium for what, to them, is a better bet. This already happens, incidentally; travel insurance policies will exclude pre-existing conditions or recurrences of previous illnesses as a matter of course, because if someone (e.g.) has cancer, the odds of them needing to claim on their policy - and as such draw down from the pool more than they paid in premium - skyrocket.
- autoexec 3y ago
- Calavar 3y ago> Insurance isn't a redistribution mechanism That's exactly what insurance is. The whole premise is that they will dip into other people's payments to pay you if you ever encounter a covered issue. If insurance only ever paid you back some fraction X of your own contributions, why would you ever buy it? It would make infinitely more sense to deposit whatever you would have paid to insurance in a high yield savings account.
- tptacek 3y agoRead downthread for repeated explanations of how insurance works. You know you're in trouble when you profess shock that insurance has negative expected dollar value.
- Calavar 3y agoOn the contrary, I think using expected value to explain the value of insurance from the perspective of an insurance holder is a misunderstanding of insurance. People don't buy insurance to optimize the average case; they buy it to optimize the worst case. But an insurance policy that doesn't redistribute wealth has both negative expected value and negative value in the event of a payout. At which point it is just a personal rainy-day fund held in a savings account with a negative interest rate.
- tptacek 3y agoInsurance almost mathematically must be negative EV in dollar terms. It's positive EV in utility terms because of the declining marginal utility of a dollar. If it was dollarwise positive EV, every insurer would be insolvent. This is pretty basic? Like, it's an economics frequently asked question why buying an insurance policy isn't as irrational as playing the lottery, since both have negative dollar EV.
- Calavar 3y agoYou're moving away from the original question, which is does insurance redistribute wealth. If you get an insurance payout and that payout doesn't involve redistribution of wealth, then it means that the payout must come only from your premium payments, minus admin fees and profit margin. But that's not how insurance works. There are innumerable examples of people who received more in insurance payouts then they've ever paid in in premiums.