3 ms·
Mild disagree, though I can appreciate the sentiment. Why do developers want to publish and distribute on the App Store? As a dev myself, my anecdotal answer
by ben_w 3y ago
Mild disagree, though I can appreciate the sentiment.
Why do developers want to publish and distribute on the App Store?
As a dev myself, my anecdotal answer is: because I can make money doing so.
Why can I make money doing so? Because Apple built trust with the users, and because they developed the tools and technologies that made their OS worth paying significantly more for similar tech specs.
- withinboredom 3y ago> I can make money doing so. Not everyone is interested in making money.
- talldayo 3y agoIf the App Store wasn't the only place to download software on iPhone, you'd have more of a point. Instead, it doesn't matter what the relationship is between the user and Apple since there's only one option anyways. Apple wants to make the App Store look like Steam; at best, they're the built-in Microsoft store.
- ben_w 3y ago[flagged]
- lapcat 3y ago> I remember when the App Store didn't exist, and devs were begging for one. They weren't begging for an app store. They were begging for third-party native apps. The exact method of distribution of third-party apps is a different matter. From 1977 to 2007, all third-party apps on Apple platforms were independently distributed. (Some boxed software was sold in retail Apple Stores from 2001, but the software was not exclusive to Apple Stores.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- heavyset_go 3y agoNobody was begging for an app store lol
- makeitdouble 3y ago> Why do developers want to publish and distribute on the App Store? Because it's half of the market, and more depending on who you're targeting. I worked at a shop where we were asked for Blackberry apps alongside with iOS and android apps, not because they had strong feelings about BlackBerry, but because it was 3% of their market share and it was above their cutoff for support.
- staplers 3y agobecause they developed the tools and technologies that made their OS Not quite. They used quite a few FOSS to build their products then pulled the ladder up behind them. Remove the app store requirement and the market will indicate just how useful the app store monopoly is to the end user.
- ben_w 3y ago> They used quite a few FOSS to build their products then pulled the ladder up behind them Not only but also. > Remove the app store requirement and the market will indicate just how useful the app store monopoly is to the end user. Android suggests: fairly important, even though it could be replaced.
- arlcode 3y agoI can see where you are coming from and once we have meaningful competitive alternatives to the AppStore (so after whatever they try in the EU with the platform fee and related shenanigans is forced to switch to a sane model) we can make a judgement on that. Right now there is simply no way to know whether people are interested in the AppStore itself or simply selling to people who own iPhones (which is more likely but I may be wrong). If I were a high class furniture company and the developer building roughly half of the populations' homes could enforce that all furniture sold to their customers needs to be vetted and distributed by them, of course I would play by their rules and even sing their praise. Apples terms (all of them) are a direct result of their ability to stifle any competition on devices their customers paid them good money for. Nothing they do is problematic unless they are able to "my way or the highway" their rules on the hardware level. Apple dug too deeply and greedily and they woke up the sleeping regulatory giants which are now changing the rules.
- lwkl 3y agoWe have a direct comparison on the desktop be it Windows or macOS and it is definitely harder to sell software there. The App Store and Play Store buying software a lot easier and increased the size of the market. Similar to Steam for PC games. But I also think that Apple should probably give developers better conditions. As a customer of Apple I selfishly prefer Apple continuing to extract service revenue from developers. Because their shareholders expect growth and that has to come somewhere and I don’t want to pay for it.
- lapcat 3y ago> We have a direct comparison on the desktop be it Windows or macOS and it is definitely harder to sell software there. How so? On desktop, the race to the bottom hasn't hit as hard, and customers are more willing to pay sustainable prices for software.
- makeitdouble 3y ago> I don’t want to pay for it。 I don't get how you're not paying for it...assuming you're an iOS user, you bought apps and the devs passed on you the extra cost to pay Apple. Not counting for the ads you saw in the Store. You probably also bought extra space to backup your phone in iCloud, and as Apple is the only way for that. Litteraly anything you paid on the platform went first to Apple.
- stale2002 3y ago> Because Apple built trust with the users, and because they developed the tools and technologies Hey if those tools and technologies on the Apple App Store are so valuable, then Apple has nothing to worry about. Developers will just stay on that app store. If, instead, other competing options are better on some metrics than Apple's, then that is a situation where developers would move off of the app store. It seems like we will find out how valuable that app store really is soon, won't we?
- ben_w 3y agoTrust was also on that list, and that's absolutely a thing they can lose. So far as I can tell, "trust" is the only reason Apple has for their rules about sexual content.
- stale2002 3y ago> So far as I can tell, "trust" is the only reason Apple has for their rules about sexual content. Hey if Apple doesn't want sexual content on their app store, thats fine. But that isn't relevant to other app stores having that content.
- ben_w 3y agoThey also don't want it in social apps. Telegram and Discord don't have access to the same content on iOS vs. Android. I may be wrong (often am), but I can only model this as Apple thinking they have a reputation for being a "family friendly" platform and wishing to uphold that. If so, I can see how they might consider being forced to allow a competitor that doesn't care, harmful to their reputation. (Me? I think sex is fine and have a problem with realistic violence, and have been confused since I was 15 or so why films and TVs allow outright murder in kids' cartoons given how upset people get by even mere "wardrobe malfunctions").
- amelius 3y ago> Why can I make money doing so? Because Apple built trust with the users, and because they developed the tools and technologies that made their OS worth paying significantly more for similar tech specs. Nah. It's because developers put a lot of effort in making Apple's platform great for many users.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]