9 ms·
Fake AI law firms are sending fake DMCA threats to generate fake SEO gains
- tommiegannert 3y agoYou're now an "AI firm" because your website contains generated photos? sigh Words mean nothing. Headlines are just a set of keywords the content marketers want in there.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoSoon it will be fake AI law firms sending DMCA threats to fake AI posters to take fake AI content down before tgf fake AI end users see it. Then we can just pull the plug and go back to doing human stuff.
- teddyh 3y ago<https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dead_Internet_theory&oldid=1217201761 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dead_Internet_the...>
- DoItToMe81 3y agoMy friend was actually targeted by one of these. His registrar investigated the report and binned it. He wasn't even informed until they started to hit his Cloudflare account, which never acted on the report.
- gentleman11 3y agoThe root problem is that the legal system is completely inaccessible and non-existent to individuals or small companies. Even to medium companies. Only mega corps and law firms can afford to use the legal system. Even big tech often avoids it because of the expense, but if they do use it, they’re going to win, 99.9% of the time because of their war chests So, people are semi defenceless when these things come up, and you can really abuse people in pretty epic and unending ways
- olliej 3y agoThe issue is that defending this generally requires paying a lawyer, and filing fraudulent DMCA claims is free, and comes with no requirement to pay the legal fees of the recipient if the claim is false
- david_shi 3y agoAgreed. Increasing the predictability and transparency of these systems is crucial for a functional society
- RobotToaster 3y agoThat was my thought. A fake DMCA claim is fraud or at least perjury, but trying to actually bring a claim for that will be difficult for most people.
- lupire 3y agoThere's no legal threat here. It's all fake.
- icedchai 3y agoSadly, many folks will assume an "official" sounding message or call is actually legitimate. Especially if it's from someone calling themselves a lawyer. Next the AI law firms will be requesting payment in iTunes gift cards...
- ryandrake 3y agoI think there is a belief (right or wrong) among a lot of lay-people and non-lawyers that the legal system is an opaque minefield of "gotchas" where if you don't file form 27B/6 within 30 days, with a specific magical incantation X written on it, and then appear before a judge and speak magical incantation Y, then gotcha! you lose! So any time something looks even remotely official, people panic and wonder which minefield they are going to inadvertently step on, even by ignoring it.
- 3y ago
- lupire 3y agoThe article doesn't explain how the backlinks part of the scam works.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe linked original article does. https://www.404media.co/a-law-firm-of-ai-generated-lawyers-is-sending-fake-threats-as-an-seo-scam/ https://www.404media.co/a-law-firm-of-ai-generated-lawyers-i... > In this case, though, the email didn’t demand that the photo be taken down or specifically threaten a lawsuit. Instead, it demanded that Smith place a “visible and clickable link” beneath the photo in question to a website called “tech4gods” or the law firm would “take action.”
- leephillips 3y agoYes, it does: “the purported firm needed him to ‘add a credit to our client immediately’ through a link to Tech4Gods”.
- lupire 3y agoOh! I that was Spamglish for "make a payment (credit) by following a link to their website"
- vineyardmike 3y ago“Back links” are a critical part of SEO: if a lot of websites link to your website, then your website will rank higher. By mandating with “legal threat” that they link to a particular website, that website will rank higher.
- dudus 3y agoI just signed up for this genAI summit but the lack of social buzz and the profile of the organizers give me a strange feeling. https://genaisummit.ai/#/ https://genaisummit.ai/#/ I'm afraid this is might be a fake conference created by AI. Am I crazy? I paid $500 for tickets. I almost signed up for the booth. I'll have to start emailing speakers for confirmation because it's not passing the smell test.
- sajforbes 3y agoI'm a bit confused about your reasons for signing up, but it looks real to me. It could be with all the buzz around AI it really did see a large surge in interest. I'd be interested to hear from the founders and how they managed to grow so quickly.
- fragmede 3y agoIt's listed on the Palace of Fine Arts page, so GPTDAO has booked the space for the event. Last year's event was at SCC, and had 1,500 people, so they're expecting 3,000, not 30,000. I'd email them to tell them about their typo, but it's real. https://www.palaceoffinearts.org/event/genai-summit https://www.palaceoffinearts.org/event/genai-summit
- samename 3y agoInstagram and Twitter links in footer don’t work… I’d do a chargeback with your credit card
- motoxpro 3y agoSame. This is the twitter link https://twitter.com/GPTDAOGLOBAL https://twitter.com/GPTDAOGLOBAL 30,000 attendees for a conference is MASSIVE. Like a GDC or SEMA or something. One of the biggest in the world. Unless it's happened before, then I have a hard time believing they just spun this up out of nowhere. Edit: Would also have more sponsors. 2k to sponsor that/get a booth is WAAAAAY to cheap. Edit2: Also one of the sessions is. "... text2video, text2audio, text2multimodal, text2richcontent" Sounds like a ChatGPT thing. Wild that they used, like you said, Ai, to generate an AI conference and genAI. Very meta
- nvy 3y agoThis is what A16Z's vaunted techno-optimism movement has produced. A more efficient way of scamming and generating disinformation. Hooray.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blobbers 3y agoThere are few truths; some say only one. Unfortunately there are many many ways to lie.
- antonvs 3y agoGood grief. I just looked that up. What a day to have eyes. I want a list of everyone who worked on that manifesto so I can put them on a list of "people to never interact with at any cost."
- camillomiller 3y agoWell it's just, like, the biggest VC in the world for investments and popularity? And yes, that is extremely sad.
- antonvs 3y agoI mean, the biggest firms are generally just shitshows of FOMO and so on. The second biggest, Sequoia, was all in on FTX and Sam Bankman-Fried right up until the collapse.
- mycologos 3y agoSequoia put out a PR piece about SBF [1] a few months before it all blew up, and it's pretty amazing, and has made it a lot easier for me to believe that VC partners are maybe not necessarily that smart: > [Sequoia partner Michelle] Bailhe remembers it the same way: “We had a great meeting with Sam, but the last question, which I remember Alfred asking, was, ‘So, everything you’re building is great, but what is your long-term vision for FTX?’” That’s when SBF told Sequoia about the so-called super-app: “I want FTX to be a place where you can do anything you want with your next dollar. You can buy bitcoin. You can send money in whatever currency to any friend anywhere in the world. You can buy a banana. You can do anything you want with your money from inside FTX.” Suddenly, the chat window on Sequoia’s side of the Zoom lights up with partners freaking out. “I LOVE THIS FOUNDER,” typed one partner. “I am a 10 out of 10,” pinged another. “YES!!!” exclaimed a third. What Sequoia was reacting to was the scale of SBF’s vision. It wasn’t a story about how we might use fintech in the future, or crypto, or a new kind of bank. It was a vision about the future of money itself—with a total addressable market of every person on the entire planet. “I sit ten feet from him, and I walked over, thinking, Oh, shit, that was really good,” remembers Arora. “And it turns out that that fucker was playing League of Legends through the entire meeting.” “We were incredibly impressed,” Bailhe says. “It was one of those your-hair-is-blown-back type of meetings.” There's plenty of other stuff in there. It's not just pumping up a promising bet that went bad, it's hagiography on a scale that is almost impossible to believe, approved by an organization that is really supposed to know better. [1] https://archive.ph/GQkCp https://archive.ph/GQkCp
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoI wonder if there's something common between crypto and AI leading to the cloud of grift and predation around the ecosystems and common uses of the respective technologies. Or if this is where society is at now and it will happen with any new technology regardless.
- visarga 3y ago> grift and predation around the ecosystems and common uses We have had web search for 25 years, it could surface any content out of billions of web pages. It's faster than LLMs and the content is written by humans. Why mention AI and crypto and not web search, it empowers people to make derivative works or to use information without compensation, isn't that a form of predation? Add Wikipedia too, it officially discourages any "original research", everything is derived, and most people just read the wiki without ever clicking on the references to the original contents. Wiki takes traffic away from those sources, can we say it is a grifter site? Alternatively, let's tone down the grifting logic. There is nothing LLMs know that search engines and wiki don't, they just save a determined person a couple of clicks and a bit of reading.
- nine_zeros 3y agoThere are enough people desperate enough that they will take unusual risks. Some of these people will become successful. Others are the suckers who will spend their lives chasing gold but never reach it.
- Intralexical 3y agoIf they're all taking "risks", then by definition the result is luck/random. So then what separates your "successful" from your "suckers"?
- nine_zeros 3y agoThe only difference between suckers and successful people is the outcome. If the outcome was truly meaningful for the individual, they were successful. Otherwise, they were just a sucker in other individual's games.
- badcarbine 3y ago[dead]
- olliej 3y agoAnother day another abuse built into the core of the DMCA. Seriously the fact that copyright violation has 10s of thousands if not millions in penalties, but fraudulent copyright claims don’t even cover legal costs is so gross. It’s right up there with “it’s a crime for you to create derivative work, but not for a VC funded ‘AI’ company to”
- spxneo 3y agohere's the thing and i had my share of arguments on twitter around this if your work is not generating $$$ its probably not worth anything to sue over all these artists are rightfully upset that Stability is making money off them by scraping their copyrighted content from Deviant Art or Tumblr but without significant revenues, you are at the mercy of eager class action attorneys who will take most of the winnings and are just as quick to settle for a 99% probability of cashing out. so it is a "crime" like it would be if you would run gameboy ROMs on emulator.js and sell advertisement. It won't even register on the politicians minds. Hollywood studio finding their work used to train LLMs? Well you saw how eager biden was taking down Megaupload. Money talks and your content if its not owned by a large studio and not raking in significant tax revenues, its probably worthless in the minds of the judge/jury/politicians
- olliej 3y agoThe penalty for IP theft is monetary, and the monetary penalties are independent on whether it creates value. Companies routinely sue people for distributing products they literally no longer sell, it does not matter. In the same way that when someone steals your tv, they don’t get to just return or pay for the TV if they’re caught. If an AI company is consuming your work, it definitionally has value, and they have no more right to it than you have to any of their property. Now if one of these companies is happy to let you take, use, and/or charge for their services without paying them then I’d wouldn’t consider them hypocritical thieves, but they don’t, so I don’t. It like all the “AI” trained on OSS software. That has value to you, literally the entire look t of licenses like the GPL is that that software has value, and you are in no way giving it away for free, and the license explicitly requires compensation.
- spxneo 3y agoseems like the biggest adopters of AI are spammers and criminals. Just like crypto
- anileated 3y agoML in various forms was used for different purposes for a while, but generative tools based on it got popular very recently. They probably have potential to create value (maybe more than crypto?), but if the core feature is to emulate a human you can see that many uses would be malicious.
- mianos 3y agoDoing a rudimentary search for some of the faces quickly shows some of them to be as real as the fairy godmother. I find the centre placement of "Max Evans" quite funny: https://generated.photos/faces/right-facing/adult/black-race/male https://generated.photos/faces/right-facing/adult/black-race...
- palmfacehn 3y agoThe automated threats from the 'legitimate' DMCA firms aren't much better. Typically they scrape and match by substring. As an example, if an unreleated PDF file's title/file name contained the name of a film as a substring and they'd send an DMCA complaint to the hosting provider.
- justinclift 3y agoOuch. Sounds like someone's impersonating law people. If the authorities decide to go after whoever did it, that could go pretty badly for the guilty party.
- CaptainFever 3y agoThis is more of an issue with copyright law and DMCA than AI.
- celestialcheese 3y agoThis is so common, and has been for a number of years. As an owner of a website with a lot of content published over the years, a copyright claim pops up with "settlement" offers between $200-$1k to make it go away. 50% of the time it's an outright scam like this. 45% it's legit, we pay the settlement, and a writer gets a reminder about citing images and copyright. 5% is the worst, where a photographer will have a open license like CC BY-NC, then a law firm will contact photographers with images licensed like that, and partner with them to send demand letters to businesses improperly using the open license and do the settlement shakedown. While technically in violation because we're a business with ad revenue, it's nefarious because it's exploiting nuances of open licenses and writers on schedule missing the NC part of the license review. We get it right most of the time, but mistakes happen. Feels dirty to leverage CC to make money doing copyright shakedowns.
- duskwuff 3y ago> 5% is the worst, where a photographer will have a open license like CC BY-NC Doesn't even have to be -NC. Creative Commons licenses require reusers to provide comprehensive[1] attribution when they reuse images. Some older versions of the license, like 2.0, also terminated immediately and permanently upon any breach of the license; copyright trolls have abused this to sue reusers who forgot to include some part of the required attribution. CC 4.0 provides the reuser a 30-day grace period to cure a violation. [1]: "the name of the creator and attribution parties, a copyright notice, a license notice, a disclaimer notice, and a link to the material", as well as the title of the work prior to 4.0 -- https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en#ref-appropriate-credit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en#ref-appr...
- celestialcheese 3y agoYup. Haven't had this specific type of complaint levied against us, not looking forward to that payout. And we do our best to comply with the letter of all the different open licenses, but it's hard as a small pub with a writing staff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 3y agoMoney is the root of all bullshit like this, right since the very first human civilization. The requirement of money as the core instrument of survival should be abolished. If people aren't raised thinking money is everything, maybe society as a whole will gradually chill out on scamming the f outta each other.
- Moore34 3y ago[dead]
- mkhkkkk 3y ago[flagged]