5 ms·
>This creates in effect a massive money transfer from the poor I'm always a little confused on exactly HOW this plays out. I could see someone with terrible c
by duxup 3y ago
>This creates in effect a massive money transfer from the poor
I'm always a little confused on exactly HOW this plays out. I could see someone with terrible credit being denied, but most cash back cards I use are hardly gated / limited to "rich folks only".
I feel like the reasons / the way it plays out are more complex than the results. And really if someone is poor, struggling to pay their card, that's a larger issue than the type of card they use.
I'm just not sure reward cards = "This creates in effect a massive money transfer from the poor" as simply as stated.
- whoisburbansky 3y agoIt plays out this way because anything anyone buys with a credit card, reward card or not, ends up costing 2-3% more than it would otherwise have, because of interchange fees. If you have a rewards card, the CC issuer turns around and gives you, say, half of that back (1% cashback on everything) and keeps the rest. It's kind of like a tax break that you only qualify for if your credit score is above a certain threshold, but you have to pay into regardless of income/credit score.
- woobar 3y ago> ends up costing 2-3% more than it would otherwise This is a very simplified view. Cash handling is not free. Fraud levels with cash are different. Overall attractiveness of a small but cash-only business is different.
- TheDong 3y agoThe alternative to credit cards that charge 2-3% fees shouldn't be cash, but rather debit cards with close to zero fees. Cash handling isn't free, but a digital transfer that doesn't have rewards is obviously cheaper than a credit card.
- chii 3y agoif the credit card merchant was able to extract 2-3% for using their network, what makes you think that a free debit card with low/zero cost wouldn't also be owned by the same credit card merchants and force the same fees to maintain their monopoly?
- dhosek 3y agoBecause right now debit card purchases don’t have a transaction fee while credit cards do. I just had two recent purchases where the vendor charged a 3% surcharge for credit cards but would do the transaction by debit card free.
- woobar 3y agoIt is an example that greed is everywhere. Not only among card issuers but also among merchants. The moment merchant find a socially accepted way to extract extra they will do it. Similar to tip screens on square terminals in all takeout places. Costs nothing to ask, generates some additional revenue.
- nkurz 3y agoBecause in the US we already have laws that cap the fees on most debit cards: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/plain-language/bus78-new-rules-electronic-payments-lower-costs-retailers.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/plain-language/bu... There's even a proposal to drop these fees even lower: https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-fed-set-revise-debit-card-fee-caps-pitting-banks-against-retailers-2023-10-25/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-fed-set-revise-debit-c... Europe has similar laws capping the fees on both credit cards and debit cards. We could do the same and it would work better for everyone except the credit card companies.
- woobar 3y agoDebit txs are not free. For big ($10B in assets) regulated issuers they are pretty low, but for everyone else they are close to 1.9% [1] https://usa.visa.com/content/dam/VCOM/download/merchants/visa-usa-interchange-reimbursement-fees.pdf https://usa.visa.com/content/dam/VCOM/download/merchants/vis...
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoDebit cards get arbitrarily rejected. Some gas stations won't process them. The IRS ID verification for Covid stimulus wouldn't work with debit.
- brewdad 3y agoThere is a reason every concert and sports venue near me has gone cashless. It's not because they enjoy giving away 2-3% of their revenues but rather those places aren't active every evening and tend to turn over employees quickly. Handling cash is expensive and risky in that environment.
- astura 3y agoIn a concert and sports venue concessions environment you're also prioritizing throughput much more than most businesses. Being cashless helps with throughput a lot - the employees don't have to wait for people to count their money, then recount it, and spend time making change.
- driscoll42 3y agoThere was a study by the Federal Reserve that came to the conclusion last year that rewards cards is basically a money transfer of ~$15 billion from poor to rich per year. Discussion on Hacker News about it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492502
- duxup 3y agoGotta be honest that I'm not reading 60 pages at this moment. But that reads like they're talking about the net effect measuring across FICO scores, but it's not clear that they're talking about the overall cause / if this is a case where some of the poor could in fact choose to use these cards. Being poor is complex, just not having time (two jobs, etc) often means they don't have time for a lot of things, including shopping for credit cards. I wonder if things like THAT are playing a part. I don't disagree with the math on the end result, I do think the reason is larger than just say rewards cards, and has to be approached careful.
- 11101010001100 3y agoIf these 'luxury' credit card companies wanted poor customers, you think they would have found them by now?
- bakhlawa 3y agoI think the Grandfather was making a different point. That because rewards cards = higher interchange fee for the merchant, this results in the merchant increasing fees on everyone (the payment networks prohibit charging a higher fee to only those paying with a credit card). >>>The money extracted by the credit card companies and Visa causes merchants to raise prices for everyone regardless of whether they have a rewards card or use a credit card at all. >>>This creates in effect a massive money transfer from the poor, who do not use rewards cards, to the rich consumers who do.
- duxup 3y agoThe pricing point is such complicated one too. Demand creates pricing changes, supply chains, etc... If say the poor used these cards at a higher volume, wouldn't they then to be passing on the changes to other poor?
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y agoPoor people, actual poor people who are just scraping by, usually have bad credit and cannot get credit cards.
- autoexec 3y agoPoor people can always get credit cards. They get constant offers for them. The catch is that they are terrible cards with fees and insane rates. The credit industry is perfectly happy to let everyone get into massive debit. They'll give them to anyone (https://www.mymoneydesign.com/nine-year-old-daughter-credit-card-offer/ https://www.mymoneydesign.com/nine-year-old-daughter-credit-...)
- supertrope 3y agoCredit cards for those with subprime credit often do not offer reward gimmicks and may even require a deposit and/or annual fee.
- neuronexmachina 3y agoThe median credit score for low-income Americans is 658 (US average is 714): https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-credit-score/ https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-credit-scor... It looks like a number of decent rewards cards require a credit score over 670.
- insane_dreamer 3y agobecause poor people, typically: - do not quality for high-rewards cards (which have higher credit score thresholds) - if not savvy, carry a balance because they can't afford to pay off the amount in full, are subject to higher interest rates because those are the cards they qualify for, and thereby pay much more than than well off consumers (increasing the transfer of wealth) - if savvy, realize that having a credit card costs them more than not, and stick to cash - are more likely to be receiving payment for services in cash themselves and will just spend that rather than depositing and using a CC (if they even have a bank account) (update: 4.5% of US households are unbanked; these are mostly from the lower quantile) https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html